[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Are we contenders?
Author Thread
Childs2Dudley
Posts: 23906
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 1/25/2010
Member: #3051
USA
2/25/2011  7:35 PM
For a title? No.
"Our attitude toward life determines life's attitude towards us." - Earl Nightingale
AUTOADVERT
SupremeCommander
Posts: 34057
Alba Posts: 35
Joined: 4/28/2006
Member: #1127

2/25/2011  8:04 PM
The Knicks have two of the top ten players in the league. Depends how quickly they grow together. It will happen. Just curious if it happens this season. Melo and Billups are playing one game and the rest of the team the other way. They all need playing experience with each other.
DLeethal wrote: Lol Rick needs a safe space
SupremeCommander
Posts: 34057
Alba Posts: 35
Joined: 4/28/2006
Member: #1127

2/25/2011  8:07 PM    LAST EDITED: 2/25/2011  8:23 PM
anyone else surprised Balkman is in? wrong thread
DLeethal wrote: Lol Rick needs a safe space
JrZyHuStLa
Posts: 25677
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/5/2007
Member: #1241

2/25/2011  8:17 PM
AnubisADL wrote:Dam some of you make it seems like Amare and Carmelo are chopped liver. We got Billups to which will be BIG in the playoffs.

Don't mind them. These are the same people that wanted Gallo, Wilson, and Mosgov over Carmelo lol.

babyKnicks
Posts: 22486
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/31/2006
Member: #1191
USA
2/25/2011  8:55 PM
Absolutely. This year.
Let's go Knicks. That's amare
orangeblobman
Posts: 27269
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/1/2009
Member: #2539
Nauru
2/26/2011  2:25 AM
Fuck no. We were more of a contender before the trade than we are now.

Melo is Stephon Marbury/Al Harrington 2.0. Word is bond.

WE AIN'T NOWHERE WITH THIS BUM CHOKER IN CARMELO. GIVE ME STARKS'S 2-21 ANY DAY OVER THIS LACKLUSTER CLUSTEREFF.
knickstorrents
Posts: 21121
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/23/2010
Member: #3050
Hong Kong
2/26/2011  2:35 AM
loweyecue wrote:I agree with this. Amare and Melo are not people who will give consistent effort on defense, otherwise George Karl would have had an effect on Melo by now and whoever replaced MDA in PHX would have gotten more out of Amare defesively. But the argument is that we don't need STAT/Melo to be stellar on defense, we need them to be adequate.


My problem with the whole 'surround our two best players with defenders' is name me a championship team in the past 10 years where at least one of the two best players isn't also an excellent defender?

Lakers- Kobe (and Pau)
Heat- Wade (and Shaq in 2006)
Spurs- Duncan
Celtics- Garnett
Pistons- Billups (in 2004)

With our limited cap flexibility and no upside in skills due to lack of youth (players at 26 are not going to get better, let's face it) we are stuck with this team. Stuck. Unless Landry becomes even better, and we get some great waiver wire/D League pickups, we are not going anywhere past the 1st/2nd round.

Rose is not the answer.
Paladin55
Posts: 24321
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2008
Member: #2098

2/26/2011  3:43 AM
knickstorrents wrote:
loweyecue wrote:I agree with this. Amare and Melo are not people who will give consistent effort on defense, otherwise George Karl would have had an effect on Melo by now and whoever replaced MDA in PHX would have gotten more out of Amare defesively. But the argument is that we don't need STAT/Melo to be stellar on defense, we need them to be adequate.


My problem with the whole 'surround our two best players with defenders' is name me a championship team in the past 10 years where at least one of the two best players isn't also an excellent defender?

Lakers- Kobe (and Pau)
Heat- Wade (and Shaq in 2006)
Spurs- Duncan
Celtics- Garnett
Pistons- Billups (in 2004)

With our limited cap flexibility and no upside in skills due to lack of youth (players at 26 are not going to get better, let's face it) we are stuck with this team. Stuck. Unless Landry becomes even better, and we get some great waiver wire/D League pickups, we are not going anywhere past the 1st/2nd round.


I did one of my few threads on this and nobody came up with any teams that had two all offense/little or no defense type players like Amare and Melo who won a title.

This franchise has dug a hole, and it will take everything Donnie can do to get us out of it, that is if he is actually given the chance.

No man is happy without a delusion of some kind. Delusions are as necessary to our happiness as realities- C.N. Bovee
Paladin55
Posts: 24321
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2008
Member: #2098

2/26/2011  3:46 AM
AnubisADL wrote:
Paladin55 wrote:
loweyecue wrote:
AnubisADL wrote:
loweyecue wrote:Setting unrealistic expectations doesn't really help anyone but nay sayers. This thread is bogus.

We can beat Chicago, Orlando, or Atlanta in a 7 game series.

Amare and Carmelo would need to have monster games coupled with guys stepping up for us to beat Miami and Boston. Point is anything can happen in the playoffs. All we need to do is steal a game or 2 and your are in the ECF.

Carmelo and Amare both have jumpers which will be valuable in the playoffs. Plus we got the battle tested Billups running the point.

I think we can sneak into the finals.

Yes anything can happen. But if Carmelo and Amare don't have those monster games let's not come back here and spin that into MDA doesn't coach defense.

The basic problem regarding our D, is that except for Amare's shot blocking, he and Melo are poor defenders, and Billups has lost a step or two at his age.

I've said it before- being a good defender is more about heart and desire than it is about some magic instructions from some defensive guru coach.

Guys like Jordan, Clyde, Kobe, Wade, James, Pippin, Rodman, Ewing, etc., took it personally if you beat them on D, and this showed in their tenacity. I love the way Amare has come in and helped turn the team around, but his D is spotty at best, and like Melo, he is not the type that sweats getting beat on a play.

At best we may be the 4th best team in the East- most likely we are the 5th, unless Orlando's slide continues.

Carmelo and Amare have proven they can good defenders when they apply themselves. I dont think Carmelo's defense will be an issue in the playoffs.

Carmelo has never shown himself to be a consistent defender.

You might have waited a couple of weeks to do this thread.

No man is happy without a delusion of some kind. Delusions are as necessary to our happiness as realities- C.N. Bovee
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
2/26/2011  8:13 AM
Paladin55 wrote:
knickstorrents wrote:
loweyecue wrote:I agree with this. Amare and Melo are not people who will give consistent effort on defense, otherwise George Karl would have had an effect on Melo by now and whoever replaced MDA in PHX would have gotten more out of Amare defesively. But the argument is that we don't need STAT/Melo to be stellar on defense, we need them to be adequate.


My problem with the whole 'surround our two best players with defenders' is name me a championship team in the past 10 years where at least one of the two best players isn't also an excellent defender?

Lakers- Kobe (and Pau)
Heat- Wade (and Shaq in 2006)
Spurs- Duncan
Celtics- Garnett
Pistons- Billups (in 2004)

With our limited cap flexibility and no upside in skills due to lack of youth (players at 26 are not going to get better, let's face it) we are stuck with this team. Stuck. Unless Landry becomes even better, and we get some great waiver wire/D League pickups, we are not going anywhere past the 1st/2nd round.


I did one of my few threads on this and nobody came up with any teams that had two all offense/little or no defense type players like Amare and Melo who won a title.

This franchise has dug a hole, and it will take everything Donnie can do to get us out of it, that is if he is actually given the chance.

That might be giving him too much credit since he locked us into at least one of not both of the two players who you're complaining about for being all offense, no defense.

Paladin55
Posts: 24321
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2008
Member: #2098

2/26/2011  12:20 PM
Bonn1997 wrote:
Paladin55 wrote:
knickstorrents wrote:
loweyecue wrote:I agree with this. Amare and Melo are not people who will give consistent effort on defense, otherwise George Karl would have had an effect on Melo by now and whoever replaced MDA in PHX would have gotten more out of Amare defesively. But the argument is that we don't need STAT/Melo to be stellar on defense, we need them to be adequate.


My problem with the whole 'surround our two best players with defenders' is name me a championship team in the past 10 years where at least one of the two best players isn't also an excellent defender?

Lakers- Kobe (and Pau)
Heat- Wade (and Shaq in 2006)
Spurs- Duncan
Celtics- Garnett
Pistons- Billups (in 2004)

With our limited cap flexibility and no upside in skills due to lack of youth (players at 26 are not going to get better, let's face it) we are stuck with this team. Stuck. Unless Landry becomes even better, and we get some great waiver wire/D League pickups, we are not going anywhere past the 1st/2nd round.


I did one of my few threads on this and nobody came up with any teams that had two all offense/little or no defense type players like Amare and Melo who won a title.

This franchise has dug a hole, and it will take everything Donnie can do to get us out of it, that is if he is actually given the chance.

That might be giving him too much credit since he locked us into at least one of not both of the two players who you're complaining about for being all offense, no defense.

I'm in the camp which thinks Walsh did not want to give up Gallo or Mosguv. We gave up nothing to get Amare except cap space.

The crux of the matter is that we took away 4 of the better defenders on a team that was already challenged defensively because of the lack of a big man.

Easy to compensate for 1 defensive liability...not so easy when you have 2 in your starting 5.

Amare has his moments on D, especially as a shot blocker, but he has gaps in his attention span and does not seem to have the ability to be consistently tough in 1/1 situations. Melo is another case altogether.

The simple fact is that they are fundamentally similar in what they bring to the table on offense and defense, and we are seeing issues on both ends of the court which may, or may not be repairable.

Back in the days of old, the Knicks got rid of Bellamy and Komives so Reed and Frazier could do their respective things without hindrance. The lane became open for Reed, and Clyde was given the reins on offense.

We made the reverse of that trade- we cleared out guys who could compliment Amare, got rid of the player who might someday be our stopper in the middle, got a guy more likely to compete for the ball with Amare and a PG, who while still crafty, is not going to give us the energy we had in Felton.

I'm much happier with Billups than I am with Melo. Hopefully this changes, but no matter how folks look at things, this franchise still has major issues, and they may get worse if the new CBA is not crafted the right way.

No man is happy without a delusion of some kind. Delusions are as necessary to our happiness as realities- C.N. Bovee
BlueSeats
Posts: 27272
Alba Posts: 41
Joined: 11/6/2005
Member: #1024

2/26/2011  12:35 PM
Paladin55 wrote:
knickstorrents wrote:
loweyecue wrote:I agree with this. Amare and Melo are not people who will give consistent effort on defense, otherwise George Karl would have had an effect on Melo by now and whoever replaced MDA in PHX would have gotten more out of Amare defesively. But the argument is that we don't need STAT/Melo to be stellar on defense, we need them to be adequate.


My problem with the whole 'surround our two best players with defenders' is name me a championship team in the past 10 years where at least one of the two best players isn't also an excellent defender?

Lakers- Kobe (and Pau)
Heat- Wade (and Shaq in 2006)
Spurs- Duncan
Celtics- Garnett
Pistons- Billups (in 2004)

With our limited cap flexibility and no upside in skills due to lack of youth (players at 26 are not going to get better, let's face it) we are stuck with this team. Stuck. Unless Landry becomes even better, and we get some great waiver wire/D League pickups, we are not going anywhere past the 1st/2nd round.


I did one of my few threads on this and nobody came up with any teams that had two all offense/little or no defense type players like Amare and Melo who won a title.

This franchise has dug a hole, and it will take everything Donnie can do to get us out of it, that is if he is actually given the chance.


Magic/Worthy/Divac

I gave a few examples of pairs where only one of the two were good defenders.

Take a situation like Isiah/Dumars. Dumars was the better defender but better than Amare? Amare's raised his D and isn't all that bad now. He'd be a lot better if he had a hint of help in the frontcourt.

Paladin55
Posts: 24321
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2008
Member: #2098

2/26/2011  1:46 PM
BlueSeats wrote:
Paladin55 wrote:
knickstorrents wrote:
loweyecue wrote:I agree with this. Amare and Melo are not people who will give consistent effort on defense, otherwise George Karl would have had an effect on Melo by now and whoever replaced MDA in PHX would have gotten more out of Amare defesively. But the argument is that we don't need STAT/Melo to be stellar on defense, we need them to be adequate.


My problem with the whole 'surround our two best players with defenders' is name me a championship team in the past 10 years where at least one of the two best players isn't also an excellent defender?

Lakers- Kobe (and Pau)
Heat- Wade (and Shaq in 2006)
Spurs- Duncan
Celtics- Garnett
Pistons- Billups (in 2004)

With our limited cap flexibility and no upside in skills due to lack of youth (players at 26 are not going to get better, let's face it) we are stuck with this team. Stuck. Unless Landry becomes even better, and we get some great waiver wire/D League pickups, we are not going anywhere past the 1st/2nd round.


I did one of my few threads on this and nobody came up with any teams that had two all offense/little or no defense type players like Amare and Melo who won a title.

This franchise has dug a hole, and it will take everything Donnie can do to get us out of it, that is if he is actually given the chance.


Magic/Worthy/Divac

I gave a few examples of pairs where only one of the two were good defenders.

Take a situation like Isiah/Dumars. Dumars was the better defender but better than Amare? Amare's raised his D and isn't all that bad now. He'd be a lot better if he had a hint of help in the frontcourt.

Melo is the help in the front court.

Thomas and Dumars were not bad on D, and I seem to recall that Dumars did a good job with Jordan. That was also a team with length and guys willing to get dirty when they had to. Rodman, Salley, Mahorn, Edwards, Laimbeer, etc- ring a bell?

Did Magic/Worthy/Divac win a title? Worthy was not a terrible defender, and Magic put in the effort on D. Divac could block some shots, but he was not a star at the time, and never averaged over 16 PPG in his career. He was a classic Euro player- and never seemed to be a me first guy, from what I can remember.

By the way, the Laker team that lost in the finals to Chicago was the [b]second best defensive team in the league regarding points, and Divac was no real star at the time. You might also look at their roster, especially the length.


No. Player Pos Ht Wt Birth Date Exp
35 Tony Brown F-G 6-6 185 July 29, 1960 5
41 Elden Campbell C 6-11 215 July 23, 1968 R
12 Vlade Divac C 7-1 243 February 3,1968 1
10 Larry Drew G 6-1 170 April 2, 1958 9
45 A.C. Green F-C 6-9 220 October 4, 1963 5
32 Magic Johnson G-F 6-8 215 August 14, 1959 11
14 Sam Perkins F-C 6-9 235 June 14, 1961 6
4 Byron Scott G 6-3 195 March 28, 1961 7
34 Tony Smith G 6-3 185 June 14, 1968 R
20 Terry Teagle F-G 6-5 195 April 10, 1960 8
30 Irving Thomas F 6-8 225 January 2, 1966 R
43 Mychal Thompson C-F 6-10 226 January 30,1955 11
42 James Worthy F 6-9 225 February 27,1961 8

Once again, I would say that we are in a hole as a franchise with two star who will need a lot of help if the Knicks are to even reach the conference finals.

Hope I'm wrong.

No man is happy without a delusion of some kind. Delusions are as necessary to our happiness as realities- C.N. Bovee
BlueSeats
Posts: 27272
Alba Posts: 41
Joined: 11/6/2005
Member: #1024

2/26/2011  2:21 PM    LAST EDITED: 2/26/2011  2:24 PM
Paladin55 wrote:Thomas and Dumars were not bad on D, and I seem to recall that Dumars did a good job with Jordan. That was also a team with length and guys willing to get dirty when they had to. Rodman, Salley, Mahorn, Edwards, Laimbeer, etc- ring a bell?

Great defensive team, but I thought your point was about the two stars.


Did Magic/Worthy/Divac win a title? Worthy was not a terrible defender, and Magic put in the effort on D. Divac could block some shots, but he was not a star at the time, and never averaged over 16 PPG in his career. He was a classic Euro player- and never seemed to be a me first guy, from what I can remember.

My mistake, I was thinking they won the title in '91, but they "merely" got to the finals and lost to the Bulls.

Magic and Worthy were very average defenders, no better than Amare, and no better than Melo in that playoffs matchup against Kobe. You simply can not in good conscience say they fit the rule you are trying to espouse.

By the way, the Laker team that lost in the finals to Chicago was the [b]second best defensive team in the league regarding points, and Divac was no real star at the time. You might also look at their roster, especially the length.

No. Player Pos Ht Wt Birth Date Exp
35 Tony Brown F-G 6-6 185 July 29, 1960 5
41 Elden Campbell C 6-11 215 July 23, 1968 R
12 Vlade Divac C 7-1 243 February 3,1968 1
10 Larry Drew G 6-1 170 April 2, 1958 9
45 A.C. Green F-C 6-9 220 October 4, 1963 5
32 Magic Johnson G-F 6-8 215 August 14, 1959 11
14 Sam Perkins F-C 6-9 235 June 14, 1961 6
4 Byron Scott G 6-3 195 March 28, 1961 7
34 Tony Smith G 6-3 185 June 14, 1968 R
20 Terry Teagle F-G 6-5 195 April 10, 1960 8
30 Irving Thomas F 6-8 225 January 2, 1966 R
43 Mychal Thompson C-F 6-10 226 January 30,1955 11
42 James Worthy F 6-9 225 February 27,1961 8

Once again, I would say that we are in a hole as a franchise with two star who will need a lot of help if the Knicks are to even reach the conference finals.

Hope I'm wrong.

I don't dispute your premise of TEAM defense. I thought this was about the team's two best players.

This raises the point of whether D' is the right coach for these two players. He has to be willing to play centers, rebounders and wing stoppers. Has to have half-court scenarios and plans for late game stops. The thing that gives me hope is that I think Melo is better in late game, half-court scenarios than what we had prior. But it will be a tough load to carry for him because if the old team lost it was on the team, or D', whereas now when Melo misses a last shot it's going to be all on him. But that's the weight $20M/yr players should and must bear.

BTW, Bird was not a great defender either, but he was extremely opportunistic. These guys will have to be at least as good as him. I'm certainly not arguing anyone on this team can afford to be lazy.

Ultimately, we were a ~.500 team. All this talk about a championships is premature. Right now it's about trying to be good. Then damn good. Then contenders.

markvmc
Posts: 21996
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/6/2008
Member: #1797

2/26/2011  7:01 PM
The best thing about the Melo trade is that we now have a piece we can trade straight up for Dwight Howard or CP3.
CashMoney
Posts: 23145
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 1/15/2011
Member: #3374
USA
2/26/2011  8:17 PM
Not contenders yet but are really close. Just need a few more pieces and watch out.......
Blue & Orange 4 Life!
Paladin55
Posts: 24321
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2008
Member: #2098

2/26/2011  10:08 PM
markvmc wrote:The best thing about the Melo trade is that we now have a piece we can trade straight up for Dwight Howard or CP3.

Do you think that is something even being considered by anyone in the organization?

Interesting to speculate on, but it would mean that this trade was a failure, since the trade was not made with this in mind.

No man is happy without a delusion of some kind. Delusions are as necessary to our happiness as realities- C.N. Bovee
knickstorrents
Posts: 21121
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/23/2010
Member: #3050
Hong Kong
2/26/2011  10:21 PM
If we can trade Melo for Paul or Howard let's do this immediately please
Rose is not the answer.
loweyecue
Posts: 27468
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 11/20/2005
Member: #1037

2/27/2011  12:05 AM    LAST EDITED: 2/27/2011  12:13 AM
Before the Pistons no one had won it all without a proven megastar on the team
Before Kobe-Shaq no one ever won it all w/o at least one of the main cogs being someone they drafyed themselves
Just because something hasn't been done before doesn't mean it will not happen.

You guys consider Chicago a contender? Rose and Boozer are both below average defenders.

TKF on Melo ::....he is a punk, a jerk, a self absorbed out of shape, self aggrandizing, unprofessional, volume chucking coach killing playoff loser!!
markvmc
Posts: 21996
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/6/2008
Member: #1797

2/27/2011  10:08 AM
Paladin55 wrote:
markvmc wrote:The best thing about the Melo trade is that we now have a piece we can trade straight up for Dwight Howard or CP3.

Do you think that is something even being considered by anyone in the organization?

Interesting to speculate on, but it would mean that this trade was a failure, since the trade was not made with this in mind.

No, I don't think anyone is considering this. But if we're not substantially better than .500 next season, it might be something to consider.

Are we contenders?

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy