Anji wrote:

TMS wrote:

NYK3 wrote:So we have a chance to get THE BEST PG in the league and yet some of you are against it because we MIGHT have to give up Anthony Ewing, um I mean Randolph. UNBELIEVABLE

it really is unbelievable... after 2 years of futzing around on a hope & a prayer that we could sign Lebron this summer, you'd think Knick fans would welcome the idea of actually GETTING a superstar this time... yes, we got Amare, but history tells us you don't win championships w/o at least 1 more superstar on your team... & guys are hedging because they're afraid to give up Anthony Randolph... if we were giving up a young player for cap space, then i'd be fully in agreement here as being opposed to it, but this is a straight trade we're talking about... you actually know what you're getting, & what you're getting is the #1 PG in the game today at 25 years of age... wow... Anthony Randolph.

What about Gallo bird??? I think it's funny that he is rarely mentioned even though he is viewed to be a better prospect by most knick fans.............

in the case of Gallo, i think it's just that we've seen him more & we're more comfortable w/his abilities & how he would fit into this offense... if you bring in a ball facilitator to play off of Amare in the P&R, logically you would want someone on the perimeter who could knock down open J's... Gallo fits that bill perfectly... AR has his own unique skillset but he is more of a question mark IMO.

playa2 wrote:

BRIGGS wrote:Ill take John Wall 1. He's the only guy who will have championship caliber talent. there are some super guards in there great but I have a feeling that John Wall might become the best player in the game within 3 years.

You didn't take and make the personal survey in the 1st post so you didn't answer or rank all the pg's they put on the site.

Can you read man ?

...And to think Briggs was in a poster appreciation thread with you!

Cruel, baby, cruel.

SupremeCommander wrote:

Anji wrote:1.Chris Paul
2.Deron Williams
3.Steve Nash
4.Chauncey Billups
5.Derrick Rose
6.Rajon Rondo
7.Jason Kidd
8.Tony Parker
9.Russell Westbrook
10.Gilbert Arenas
11.Devin Harris
12.Baron Davis
13.Jameer Nelson
14.Brandon Jennings
15.Stephen Curry
16.Aaron Brooks
17.Jose Calderon
18.Andre Miller
19.Tyreke Evans
20.John Wall

I think cp3 is the best until I see other wise, but DW is a beast. Tyreke is a shooting guard Imo and Wall is a combo Guard rookie that hasn't played a game. A healthy Gilbert is probably in roses spot.

I think after Billups, most of the guards in this lead are mostly Athletic scorer types and less floor generals.

Other then Kid, Nelson, Calderon and Miller, the new guard type is a 15-20point & 5-8 assists Combo guard

I think DW and CP is a matter of preference... size or speed? Both are elite. I said Williams because I saw him play in fantastic seats in Houston and I swear, he saw the play develop seconds before I did. I'm not trying to give myself credit, what I'm saying is usually it's easier to see from a distance. I've seen Paul play too and his speed and quickness are out of this world... I just think Williams' size gives him the advantage in the postseason in half court sets

Yeah Williams is a beast, that's the best I can put it. Like a bull or a boar, he is physically better then any guard in the league. What he did to Denver was just pure bully tactics. He was unstoppable......... I still think Paul though is a better "point guard" and making his team better.