I'll judge D'Antoni based on next year. If all our wildest dreams come true, and Lebron is here, then Mike needs to deliver. If he doesn't, he'll be fired in time.
If our nightmares come true, and this plan doesn't amount to more than a mid-pack playoff team with no superstar headlining, he'll be fired in a few years.
And if they win it all next year with Lebron, a lot of people will say Mike is a god, while some will say that he's a lucky s.o.b..
This year watching the Knicks is like observing a bunch of people with the flu while they wait to see a doctor. It's hard to judge how they'll look when they're healed, and it's easy to note that they currently look like crap.