[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Playoff time!
Author Thread
Rookie
Posts: 27365
Alba Posts: 28
Joined: 10/15/2008
Member: #2274

5/19/2026  8:54 AM
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:If Wemby grows out his hair like Stephon Castle he will be ten feet tall

It's been said but this dude is an absolute freak. Was reading your message as he hit that deep-3. He just might be the GOAT in short-order

Why do the Knicks always have to come up against these all time great freak players when we are good…..MJ, Yao Ming…..

I do like Wemby’s edgy play compared to SGA’s foul baiting bs

AUTOADVERT
SergioNYK
Posts: 22978
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/8/2002
Member: #333
USA
5/19/2026  9:01 AM
Something went wrong if Wemby doesn't win 3-5 rings or more.
SergioNYK
Posts: 22978
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/8/2002
Member: #333
USA
5/19/2026  9:03 AM
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:If Wemby grows out his hair like Stephon Castle he will be ten feet tall

It's been said but this dude is an absolute freak. Was reading your message as he hit that deep-3. He just might be the GOAT in short-order

Guarantee he will eclipse LeBum and be in the conversation with MJ for best ever by this summer if he wins his first ring.

newyorknewyork
Posts: 30294
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #541
5/19/2026  9:08 AM
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

As a person with no extra special affinity for either Melo or Lin and can call the balls and strikes. Lin got hated on because he left the Knicks to sign with the Rockets. The doubling back for more money most likely did it. Hate he received was mostly coping due to giving fans that short term euphoria and then leaving. Melo has taken a lot more arrows than Lin ever has though. Case in point the shot he just took Philc1. Lin and Melo have never played a playoff game together, they played a grand total of 16 games together as Knicks. People speak like this was a Shaq & Kobe dynastic beef spanning 5 plus years whenever revisited lol.

KAT & Brunson took 2 full seasons, Thibs getting fired, and being down 2-1 in the playoffs vs the Hawks. For them to figure out how to play together in the most effective manor by comparison. And they are more efficient offensive players to begin with.

On a another note. Lin would be great for broadcasting and commentary for the NBA if he isn't already in some capacity. I could see it for him, he probably has great stories to tell given his unique NBA path as well as knowledge of the game.

We should also see Lin more within the Knicks alumni. Dolan is probably blocking due to still being pissed about Lin doubling back with the Rockets. But if he could forgive Sprewell for cursing him out and disrespecting him. He could bury that hatchet with Lin if that is even the case. Fans would love it and he would be good making his appearances, win-win.

https://vote.nba.com/en Vote for your Knicks.
Knixkik
Posts: 35796
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #11
USA
5/19/2026  10:18 AM
I’m glad the thunder and Spurs are in the west. It’s going to be so hard for west teams to break through against both of them the next 8-10 years. Wemby, Castle and Harper are going to be hell. And imagine if they eventually move Fox for an elite wing/ forward to add to the mix ? And okc has picks to do whatever they want. 2 scary teams.
martin
Posts: 80517
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
5/19/2026  10:50 AM
Knixkik wrote:I’m glad the thunder and Spurs are in the west. It’s going to be so hard for west teams to break through against both of them the next 8-10 years. Wemby, Castle and Harper are going to be hell. And imagine if they eventually move Fox for an elite wing/ forward to add to the mix ? And okc has picks to do whatever they want. 2 scary teams.

Right, and OKC has the problem of having too many good players and tons of upcoming picks.

They didn't play their #15 pick Sober from last year and for 2 years have not played their #12 pick Nickola Topic and they traded for TikTok Jesus Jared McCain. And they got #12 and #17 this year in a deep draft out to 20 or more

All they have to do is manage their excess assets and salary cap hell

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
Panos
Posts: 30633
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/6/2004
Member: #520
5/19/2026  12:03 PM
newyorknewyork wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

As a person with no extra special affinity for either Melo or Lin and can call the balls and strikes. Lin got hated on because he left the Knicks to sign with the Rockets. The doubling back for more money most likely did it. Hate he received was mostly coping due to giving fans that short term euphoria and then leaving. Melo has taken a lot more arrows than Lin ever has though. Case in point the shot he just took Philc1. Lin and Melo have never played a playoff game together, they played a grand total of 16 games together as Knicks. People speak like this was a Shaq & Kobe dynastic beef spanning 5 plus years whenever revisited lol.

KAT & Brunson took 2 full seasons, Thibs getting fired, and being down 2-1 in the playoffs vs the Hawks. For them to figure out how to play together in the most effective manor by comparison. And they are more efficient offensive players to begin with.

On a another note. Lin would be great for broadcasting and commentary for the NBA if he isn't already in some capacity. I could see it for him, he probably has great stories to tell given his unique NBA path as well as knowledge of the game.

We should also see Lin more within the Knicks alumni. Dolan is probably blocking due to still being pissed about Lin doubling back with the Rockets. But if he could forgive Sprewell for cursing him out and disrespecting him. He could bury that hatchet with Lin if that is even the case. Fans would love it and he would be good making his appearances, win-win.

Pretty fair and balanced take.

NardDogNation
Posts: 27810
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 5/7/2013
Member: #5555

5/19/2026  12:27 PM
Rookie wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:If Wemby grows out his hair like Stephon Castle he will be ten feet tall

It's been said but this dude is an absolute freak. Was reading your message as he hit that deep-3. He just might be the GOAT in short-order

Why do the Knicks always have to come up against these all time great freak players when we are good…..MJ, Yao Ming…..

I do like Wemby’s edgy play compared to SGA’s foul baiting bs

It's our cross to bear but I geniunely believe we'd beat SAS in a 7 games series this year. Maybe I'm delusional but I never felt what I'm feeling about this franchise and it's capabilities. I hope I'm not wrong.....because Wemby is here and I think that dude will have a stranglehold on the league until he gets hurt or retires.

NardDogNation
Posts: 27810
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 5/7/2013
Member: #5555

5/19/2026  12:28 PM
SergioNYK wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:If Wemby grows out his hair like Stephon Castle he will be ten feet tall

It's been said but this dude is an absolute freak. Was reading your message as he hit that deep-3. He just might be the GOAT in short-order

Guarantee he will eclipse LeBum and be in the conversation with MJ for best ever by this summer if he wins his first ring.

Maybe I'm being hyperbolic but I already think what he's doing has eclipsed peak-LeBron and overlaps alot with MJ. All he's missing are the rings and the rings will be coming if he stays healthy.

Nalod
Posts: 72205
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
5/19/2026  12:33 PM

From what I recall Melo said in response to Lin's contract it was an over pay.
It was. Lin never replicated his Knick performance and his injuries mounted on other teams. Recall he had meniscus issues and was the reason they did not play much besides Melo being injured. He missed the last 17 games and we did go on to make the playoffs bowing to Miami in 5 gams and he never dressed. Some thought he held out so he would not ruin his free agency. It would have been dumb for him to play and risk further injury and his pay day.

The comment pitted did divide the Melo Homers and the Haters. Seemed as if Melo was envious of Lin's rise to fame while injured.

As for Dolan being mad at him? Lets be real, Linsanty was awesome but Lin played in 35 games and started 25. Linsanity was a small window of time. He played in no playoff games for knicks. Spree played 351 games (50 less than his GS tenure) and 41 playoff games!

In Melo's tenure by comparsion we made the playoffs 3 of his 7 seasons and he played in 21 games. Most unfortunate his talent was rarely properly used. Melo as a 2nd option on a really good/Great team would have been awesome! At least it ended the starphuch era!

NardDogNation
Posts: 27810
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 5/7/2013
Member: #5555

5/19/2026  12:36 PM
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

That is definitely true. I suppose the first one through the door always gets the most hate. Yao had to deal with similar issues but the Lin-hate seemed so much worse. As much as certain aspects about him did irritate me (constantly talking about his faith), he seemed like a good, well-intentioned dude.

It's the Melo-Lin dynamic that bugged me. I'm still a huge Melo-fan/defender but could not understand why being one would preclude me from being a fan of the other. As big of a fan as I am of Lin, Jalen Brunson is the one who brought more joy to the franchise over the past 20-30 years. He's the Prince that was promised

NardDogNation
Posts: 27810
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 5/7/2013
Member: #5555

5/19/2026  12:39 PM
newyorknewyork wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

As a person with no extra special affinity for either Melo or Lin and can call the balls and strikes. Lin got hated on because he left the Knicks to sign with the Rockets. The doubling back for more money most likely did it. Hate he received was mostly coping due to giving fans that short term euphoria and then leaving. Melo has taken a lot more arrows than Lin ever has though. Case in point the shot he just took Philc1. Lin and Melo have never played a playoff game together, they played a grand total of 16 games together as Knicks. People speak like this was a Shaq & Kobe dynastic beef spanning 5 plus years whenever revisited lol.

KAT & Brunson took 2 full seasons, Thibs getting fired, and being down 2-1 in the playoffs vs the Hawks. For them to figure out how to play together in the most effective manor by comparison. And they are more efficient offensive players to begin with.

On a another note. Lin would be great for broadcasting and commentary for the NBA if he isn't already in some capacity. I could see it for him, he probably has great stories to tell given his unique NBA path as well as knowledge of the game.

We should also see Lin more within the Knicks alumni. Dolan is probably blocking due to still being pissed about Lin doubling back with the Rockets. But if he could forgive Sprewell for cursing him out and disrespecting him. He could bury that hatchet with Lin if that is even the case. Fans would love it and he would be good making his appearances, win-win.


All that might be true but the question still lingers....why the F didn't Dolan match HOU's offer? When you consider the bums we've given generational money to (e.g. Eddy Curry, Jerome James, Jared Jefferies, Shandon Anderson, Joakim Noah, etc), it made no sense especially when looking at the situation in hindsight. Pablo Prigioni was likely the best lead-guard for us during that era and that dude was already ~40 years old! The real villain here is Dolan; not Lin.

NardDogNation
Posts: 27810
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 5/7/2013
Member: #5555

5/19/2026  12:40 PM
Knixkik wrote:I’m glad the thunder and Spurs are in the west. It’s going to be so hard for west teams to break through against both of them the next 8-10 years. Wemby, Castle and Harper are going to be hell. And imagine if they eventually move Fox for an elite wing/ forward to add to the mix ? And okc has picks to do whatever they want. 2 scary teams.

The silver-lining is that those teams will beat each other to a pulp until the Finals, which gives us a window to secure a title or two

Nalod
Posts: 72205
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
5/19/2026  12:45 PM
One game and we gushing about him in the elite catagory already?
This is their first playoff run!
Toe to toe with defending champs is impressive and that was a hell of a game he played! No doubt his future is bright.
but....He has missed 65 games in his first 3 seasons.
Had a blood issue.
Was serious enough to bench him.
If he can stay on the court and turn into wilt he could find his way to Mt Rushmore!
If he don't break. He is Ralph Sampson but with greater understanding of his body and a team that gets it.
If he does get large, like WIlt did He appears to do the work to perhaps stay fluid. Wilt got big and while he got really strong, he lost the quickness. Wilt was a defensive force late in his career. Young Wilt and Wemby looks similar. Wilt was a track star and durable.

Not sure he can be stopped, but im not ready to hand him the keys. He has to prove durable.
He is the true unicorn potentially.

newyorknewyork
Posts: 30294
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #541
5/19/2026  4:48 PM
NardDogNation wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

As a person with no extra special affinity for either Melo or Lin and can call the balls and strikes. Lin got hated on because he left the Knicks to sign with the Rockets. The doubling back for more money most likely did it. Hate he received was mostly coping due to giving fans that short term euphoria and then leaving. Melo has taken a lot more arrows than Lin ever has though. Case in point the shot he just took Philc1. Lin and Melo have never played a playoff game together, they played a grand total of 16 games together as Knicks. People speak like this was a Shaq & Kobe dynastic beef spanning 5 plus years whenever revisited lol.

KAT & Brunson took 2 full seasons, Thibs getting fired, and being down 2-1 in the playoffs vs the Hawks. For them to figure out how to play together in the most effective manor by comparison. And they are more efficient offensive players to begin with.

On a another note. Lin would be great for broadcasting and commentary for the NBA if he isn't already in some capacity. I could see it for him, he probably has great stories to tell given his unique NBA path as well as knowledge of the game.

We should also see Lin more within the Knicks alumni. Dolan is probably blocking due to still being pissed about Lin doubling back with the Rockets. But if he could forgive Sprewell for cursing him out and disrespecting him. He could bury that hatchet with Lin if that is even the case. Fans would love it and he would be good making his appearances, win-win.


All that might be true but the question still lingers....why the F didn't Dolan match HOU's offer? When you consider the bums we've given generational money to (e.g. Eddy Curry, Jerome James, Jared Jefferies, Shandon Anderson, Joakim Noah, etc), it made no sense especially when looking at the situation in hindsight. Pablo Prigioni was likely the best lead-guard for us during that era and that dude was already ~40 years old! The real villain here is Dolan; not Lin.

I think from Dolan's view he was letting Lin set up the market to find out what teams were gonna offer financially, and he had every intention of matching. Dolan most likley felt he was operating out of good faith. At the same time, Knicks also didn't want to pay Lin a lot more than what the market was offering and wanted to see what teams would offer knowing they had the power to match any deal.

Dolan most likely felt slighted that Lin signed the poison pill contract and it put the Knicks in a bind finacially when that 3rd year kicked in. More so than just not wanting to pay him. Espeically since he was originally offered a deal that the Knicks had every intention of matching. The optics of him doubling back for the poison pill. Seemed to go against the agreement of the two sides working in good faith to give Lin a deal based on the market. In Dolan's eyes anyway.

All in all. Knicks did not foresee the poison pill and were caught with their pants down by the Rockets who had nothing to lose at the time with Morey running show. Peotic Justice that the Knicks are the team that probably ends his career as Pres for an org. Lin signed the deal that was most lucrative for him in that moment.

But if he could do it over again based on how his career unfolded. If he signs that original 4 year $28mil deal and the Knicks match. Maybe he ends up getting another 4 year deal when his contract ended at 28. Now hes with the Knicks for 9 years. Now his legacy is a career with the Knicks. Could of been a John Starks type of loved figure.

https://vote.nba.com/en Vote for your Knicks.
Chandler
Posts: 27053
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/26/2015
Member: #6197

5/19/2026  5:56 PM
FWIW I just saw a post article saying melo invited Lin on his podcast to clear up “bull****” being said about their relationship.

Couldnt help but think either Melos lurking or other forums/X are saying the same stuff we’ve been saying

Hope Lin ignores him

(5)(7)
BlueKnickers
Posts: 21380
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/13/2025
Member: #11677

5/20/2026  1:20 AM
newyorknewyork wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

As a person with no extra special affinity for either Melo or Lin and can call the balls and strikes. Lin got hated on because he left the Knicks to sign with the Rockets. The doubling back for more money most likely did it. Hate he received was mostly coping due to giving fans that short term euphoria and then leaving. Melo has taken a lot more arrows than Lin ever has though. Case in point the shot he just took Philc1. Lin and Melo have never played a playoff game together, they played a grand total of 16 games together as Knicks. People speak like this was a Shaq & Kobe dynastic beef spanning 5 plus years whenever revisited lol.

KAT & Brunson took 2 full seasons, Thibs getting fired, and being down 2-1 in the playoffs vs the Hawks. For them to figure out how to play together in the most effective manor by comparison. And they are more efficient offensive players to begin with.

On a another note. Lin would be great for broadcasting and commentary for the NBA if he isn't already in some capacity. I could see it for him, he probably has great stories to tell given his unique NBA path as well as knowledge of the game.

We should also see Lin more within the Knicks alumni. Dolan is probably blocking due to still being pissed about Lin doubling back with the Rockets. But if he could forgive Sprewell for cursing him out and disrespecting him. He could bury that hatchet with Lin if that is even the case. Fans would love it and he would be good making his appearances, win-win.


All that might be true but the question still lingers....why the F didn't Dolan match HOU's offer? When you consider the bums we've given generational money to (e.g. Eddy Curry, Jerome James, Jared Jefferies, Shandon Anderson, Joakim Noah, etc), it made no sense especially when looking at the situation in hindsight. Pablo Prigioni was likely the best lead-guard for us during that era and that dude was already ~40 years old! The real villain here is Dolan; not Lin.

I think from Dolan's view he was letting Lin set up the market to find out what teams were gonna offer financially, and he had every intention of matching. Dolan most likley felt he was operating out of good faith. At the same time, Knicks also didn't want to pay Lin a lot more than what the market was offering and wanted to see what teams would offer knowing they had the power to match any deal.

Dolan most likely felt slighted that Lin signed the poison pill contract and it put the Knicks in a bind finacially when that 3rd year kicked in. More so than just not wanting to pay him. Espeically since he was originally offered a deal that the Knicks had every intention of matching. The optics of him doubling back for the poison pill. Seemed to go against the agreement of the two sides working in good faith to give Lin a deal based on the market. In Dolan's eyes anyway.

All in all. Knicks did not foresee the poison pill and were caught with their pants down by the Rockets who had nothing to lose at the time with Morey running show. Peotic Justice that the Knicks are the team that probably ends his career as Pres for an org. Lin signed the deal that was most lucrative for him in that moment.

But if he could do it over again based on how his career unfolded. If he signs that original 4 year $28mil deal and the Knicks match. Maybe he ends up getting another 4 year deal when his contract ended at 28. Now hes with the Knicks for 9 years. Now his legacy is a career with the Knicks. Could of been a John Starks type of loved figure.

If you let a player take offers to set the market, then blaming the player for that doesn't make sense. Fans being angry at Lin for that when all Dolan had to do was offer him a fair contract also makes no sense.

My original point is there was a contingent of Melo fans who thought it was a Melo vs. Lin world and because they were Melo stans they were now somehow opposed to Lin. The rumors going around was Melo was jealous of Lin and maybe Melo's fans found that offensive, but whatever bug got up that subset of fans azzholes it was noxious behavior that sometimes overlapped with outright bigotry.

Blaming Lin for taking a poison pill deal is ludicrous when he just wanted a deal of some kind, because that's what undrafted players do when they hit a lucky streak in the NBA, they try to get paid like everyone else would. We could have signed him, but we didn't so when he set the market blaming it on Lin it absolutely insane.

Philc1
Posts: 29302
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 9/2/2020
Member: #8897

5/20/2026  9:20 AM
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

I don’t recall any Lin haters among Knicks fans.

Philc1
Posts: 29302
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 9/2/2020
Member: #8897

5/20/2026  9:24 AM
BlueKnickers wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

As a person with no extra special affinity for either Melo or Lin and can call the balls and strikes. Lin got hated on because he left the Knicks to sign with the Rockets. The doubling back for more money most likely did it. Hate he received was mostly coping due to giving fans that short term euphoria and then leaving. Melo has taken a lot more arrows than Lin ever has though. Case in point the shot he just took Philc1. Lin and Melo have never played a playoff game together, they played a grand total of 16 games together as Knicks. People speak like this was a Shaq & Kobe dynastic beef spanning 5 plus years whenever revisited lol.

KAT & Brunson took 2 full seasons, Thibs getting fired, and being down 2-1 in the playoffs vs the Hawks. For them to figure out how to play together in the most effective manor by comparison. And they are more efficient offensive players to begin with.

On a another note. Lin would be great for broadcasting and commentary for the NBA if he isn't already in some capacity. I could see it for him, he probably has great stories to tell given his unique NBA path as well as knowledge of the game.

We should also see Lin more within the Knicks alumni. Dolan is probably blocking due to still being pissed about Lin doubling back with the Rockets. But if he could forgive Sprewell for cursing him out and disrespecting him. He could bury that hatchet with Lin if that is even the case. Fans would love it and he would be good making his appearances, win-win.


All that might be true but the question still lingers....why the F didn't Dolan match HOU's offer? When you consider the bums we've given generational money to (e.g. Eddy Curry, Jerome James, Jared Jefferies, Shandon Anderson, Joakim Noah, etc), it made no sense especially when looking at the situation in hindsight. Pablo Prigioni was likely the best lead-guard for us during that era and that dude was already ~40 years old! The real villain here is Dolan; not Lin.

I think from Dolan's view he was letting Lin set up the market to find out what teams were gonna offer financially, and he had every intention of matching. Dolan most likley felt he was operating out of good faith. At the same time, Knicks also didn't want to pay Lin a lot more than what the market was offering and wanted to see what teams would offer knowing they had the power to match any deal.

Dolan most likely felt slighted that Lin signed the poison pill contract and it put the Knicks in a bind finacially when that 3rd year kicked in. More so than just not wanting to pay him. Espeically since he was originally offered a deal that the Knicks had every intention of matching. The optics of him doubling back for the poison pill. Seemed to go against the agreement of the two sides working in good faith to give Lin a deal based on the market. In Dolan's eyes anyway.

All in all. Knicks did not foresee the poison pill and were caught with their pants down by the Rockets who had nothing to lose at the time with Morey running show. Peotic Justice that the Knicks are the team that probably ends his career as Pres for an org. Lin signed the deal that was most lucrative for him in that moment.

But if he could do it over again based on how his career unfolded. If he signs that original 4 year $28mil deal and the Knicks match. Maybe he ends up getting another 4 year deal when his contract ended at 28. Now hes with the Knicks for 9 years. Now his legacy is a career with the Knicks. Could of been a John Starks type of loved figure.

If you let a player take offers to set the market, then blaming the player for that doesn't make sense. Fans being angry at Lin for that when all Dolan had to do was offer him a fair contract also makes no sense.

My original point is there was a contingent of Melo fans who thought it was a Melo vs. Lin world and because they were Melo stans they were now somehow opposed to Lin. The rumors going around was Melo was jealous of Lin and maybe Melo's fans found that offensive, but whatever bug got up that subset of fans azzholes it was noxious behavior that sometimes overlapped with outright bigotry.

Blaming Lin for taking a poison pill deal is ludicrous when he just wanted a deal of some kind, because that's what undrafted players do when they hit a lucky streak in the NBA, they try to get paid like everyone else would. We could have signed him, but we didn't so when he set the market blaming it on Lin it absolutely insane.

Knicks didn’t want to offer Lin a big contract because 1) they didn’t think he was that good 2) he didn’t get along with Melo and there was division in the locker room and 3) Kidd was available as UFA for way less years and guaranteed money. Felton was also available.

And to be fair they were right on all counts.

newyorknewyork
Posts: 30294
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #541
5/20/2026  9:38 AM
BlueKnickers wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
NardDogNation wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Lin is a Randle hater is what I got from this

Probably also a low key FU to Melo who was Randle before Randle.

Fair

I love Jeremy so much. Always will hold a warm place in my heart for him

Good commentary. On point

Is there room for me in this love-fest? I always liked Jeremy Lin and never understood the hate he got from the fan base. He's also clearly talented off the court as well. That dude should be apart of some network's half-time show.

The world is full of bigots who pretend the reason they hated Lin was not some kind of prejudice. In addition, many Lin haters in NYC were stupid Melo fans who felt it was necessary to take sides which was very telling. Nobody said you have to destroy Lin because you're a Melo fan, but I saw it happen too many times which made it clear it was some kind of cultish knee-jerk reaction. The way some people treated Lin was disgusting. He brought more joy to this franchise than any other player in 20 years and should be respected for it.

As a person with no extra special affinity for either Melo or Lin and can call the balls and strikes. Lin got hated on because he left the Knicks to sign with the Rockets. The doubling back for more money most likely did it. Hate he received was mostly coping due to giving fans that short term euphoria and then leaving. Melo has taken a lot more arrows than Lin ever has though. Case in point the shot he just took Philc1. Lin and Melo have never played a playoff game together, they played a grand total of 16 games together as Knicks. People speak like this was a Shaq & Kobe dynastic beef spanning 5 plus years whenever revisited lol.

KAT & Brunson took 2 full seasons, Thibs getting fired, and being down 2-1 in the playoffs vs the Hawks. For them to figure out how to play together in the most effective manor by comparison. And they are more efficient offensive players to begin with.

On a another note. Lin would be great for broadcasting and commentary for the NBA if he isn't already in some capacity. I could see it for him, he probably has great stories to tell given his unique NBA path as well as knowledge of the game.

We should also see Lin more within the Knicks alumni. Dolan is probably blocking due to still being pissed about Lin doubling back with the Rockets. But if he could forgive Sprewell for cursing him out and disrespecting him. He could bury that hatchet with Lin if that is even the case. Fans would love it and he would be good making his appearances, win-win.


All that might be true but the question still lingers....why the F didn't Dolan match HOU's offer? When you consider the bums we've given generational money to (e.g. Eddy Curry, Jerome James, Jared Jefferies, Shandon Anderson, Joakim Noah, etc), it made no sense especially when looking at the situation in hindsight. Pablo Prigioni was likely the best lead-guard for us during that era and that dude was already ~40 years old! The real villain here is Dolan; not Lin.

I think from Dolan's view he was letting Lin set up the market to find out what teams were gonna offer financially, and he had every intention of matching. Dolan most likley felt he was operating out of good faith. At the same time, Knicks also didn't want to pay Lin a lot more than what the market was offering and wanted to see what teams would offer knowing they had the power to match any deal.

Dolan most likely felt slighted that Lin signed the poison pill contract and it put the Knicks in a bind finacially when that 3rd year kicked in. More so than just not wanting to pay him. Espeically since he was originally offered a deal that the Knicks had every intention of matching. The optics of him doubling back for the poison pill. Seemed to go against the agreement of the two sides working in good faith to give Lin a deal based on the market. In Dolan's eyes anyway.

All in all. Knicks did not foresee the poison pill and were caught with their pants down by the Rockets who had nothing to lose at the time with Morey running show. Peotic Justice that the Knicks are the team that probably ends his career as Pres for an org. Lin signed the deal that was most lucrative for him in that moment.

But if he could do it over again based on how his career unfolded. If he signs that original 4 year $28mil deal and the Knicks match. Maybe he ends up getting another 4 year deal when his contract ended at 28. Now hes with the Knicks for 9 years. Now his legacy is a career with the Knicks. Could of been a John Starks type of loved figure.

If you let a player take offers to set the market, then blaming the player for that doesn't make sense. Fans being angry at Lin for that when all Dolan had to do was offer him a fair contract also makes no sense.

My original point is there was a contingent of Melo fans who thought it was a Melo vs. Lin world and because they were Melo stans they were now somehow opposed to Lin. The rumors going around was Melo was jealous of Lin and maybe Melo's fans found that offensive, but whatever bug got up that subset of fans azzholes it was noxious behavior that sometimes overlapped with outright bigotry.

Blaming Lin for taking a poison pill deal is ludicrous when he just wanted a deal of some kind, because that's what undrafted players do when they hit a lucky streak in the NBA, they try to get paid like everyone else would. We could have signed him, but we didn't so when he set the market blaming it on Lin it absolutely insane.

Knicks didn't know what a fair deal was based on 35 games, 25 starts for a 2nd year UDFA. There was no precedent for the Linsanity situation. They were hoping the market dictated that for them so they didn't outbid themselves. Lin was gonna get paid no matter what. Simply came down to how much and how many years.

Knicks believing that since they had the power to match: A it would probably scare teams away to begin with. As a team could lose out on other FAs chasing a player that will just be matched. B with the power to match they had full control either way. Dolan most likely wasn't the one to offer and negotiate contracts either. That would of been Glen Grunwald, with Dolan signing off on it. So either Glen presented this strategy to Dolan and he okayed it. Or Dolan presented it to Glen to put it to action. Rockets just so happen to be in position as a rebuilding team to be able to finesse. Knicks didn't account for it and got caught with their pants down. Rockets purposely offered a contract with the third year jump to $14.9mil because it purposely and severely put the Knicks in lux tax. This wasn't a normal contract where they just offered him 3 years $8mil per year with yearly increases. Rockets did what they had to do to make the Knicks hurt for matching. Dolan seemed to feel away with the optics of Lin doubling back for a contract like that as his reasoning to not matching. Have to wonder if the poison pill was the original offer from the Rockets if Dolan gives the okay to match. Rockets proceeded to package Lin with a first round draft pick to off load his salary before that $14.9mil kicked in on them themselves.

It's not about assigning blame. It's about the circumstances each side had to navigate during this time frame. People like to funnel all blame and create villains based on who they don't like. Then the opposite based on who they do.

As for Melo fans. Sure there were probably a group of unbearable fans. Is par for the course with polarizing players. Lin im sure had his share as well for his career. Problems usually stem from people needing to talk down about one person or player in order to prop up another. Just as many non Melo fans were saying Melo was holding Lin back and hating on him. I've heard Melo told Dolan that he wanted Lin out which is why Dolan never intended to match catering to Melo. Seemed more like people were projecting their own views on Melo to how Melo would view Lin.

https://vote.nba.com/en Vote for your Knicks.
Playoff time!

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy