Posted by Pharzeone:
Posted by Rich:
Although I always take what is said about a team's draft intentions with a huge grain of salt, I view drafting Bynum as an acid test for Isiah. If he doesn't draft him we know that he is merely another shill for Dolan, just in it for the paycheck, exactly like Layden.
How in the hell do you make a conclusion like that. Suppose Bynum sucks it up in workouts.
Rich in this thread has a very narrow viewpoint. You cannot limit yourself to only one player, especially one that we know so little about, and conclude that if that one player isn't drafted, the GM failed the "acid test." I'd take a very different view. If Bynum looks good, then yes, definitely draft him. However, if he looks bad and looks like he's not only younger than other players available but also is not going to amount to as much as them and is another Kwame Brown, Eddy Curry, etc, then drafting him just to please critics like Rich would be a failure.