I like a lot of the takes here, some I disagree with. We basically traded out Burks and Noel for Brunson and Hartenstein, two guys above our timeline for two guys right smack in the middle. Hopefully with limited roster turnover, the Knicks defense can be solid from day one.
Fournier really turned it around as the season continued. I really question the wisdom of trading one of the top 5 3 point shooters in the league. Hopefully, having a high usage PG will open up the floor for a lot of our guys. Running pick and rolls with Robinson and Brunson to start our offensive sets should create better shot opportunities for RJ and Randle. There's a big difference between initiating the offense and running the second or third actions after defenses have been forced to rotate. All 4 of the projected starters have been willing passers during their career, I think that unselfishness will be the key to a strong season.
Between RJ Randle and Brunson I don't really see the need to go all in on a star. These guys are all hitting their prime so it's likely they still have room for improvement.
I don't think Obi and Grimes should get more playing time over Randle and Fournier. What the Knicks need is stability and veterans are better at getting it done every night. We still have two seasons of IQ and Obi on rookie contracts, as long as they continue to get court time I don't see the rush to give guys more minutes than they can handle.
The strength of this team is it's depth. I think depth was the biggest issue in the playoffs and the problem with super teams. Pretty sure Milwaukee wins again if Middleton doesn't go down.
That being said, injuries should be viewed as part of the game rather than fluke occurrences. You can go down the line of playoff teams that were hurt by their lack of depth. Boston with and without Robert Williams was two totally different teams. Boston improved their depth by adding injury prone Gallinari and Brogdon. Great players but it will be a big question of where they will be at next Spring.
Thibs has consistently preached the same basic philosophy since day one. The front office has provided a 15 player roster that can get it done. The team didn't give up at any point last season which says a lot about where Thibs has them mentally. Those pessimistic going forward really need to consider that even with Burks playing out of position, the Knicks were still a .500 team. We would have made the playoffs without Rose getting injured and if Kemba was given a shorter leash. The future is brighter for the Knicks than any time since Ewing's draft.