[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Why is Randle still our primary Ball handler
Author Thread
martin
Posts: 76085
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
11/2/2021  6:21 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
AUTOADVERT
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
11/2/2021  7:13 PM    LAST EDITED: 11/2/2021  7:20 PM
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels

ES
EwingsGlass
Posts: 27466
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 4/29/2005
Member: #893
USA
11/2/2021  7:32 PM
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

For the last time (I hope). The Knicks utilize team rebounding. This results in other team members getting easier rebounds rather than Mitch Robinson. His lack of official defensive rebounds is not reflective of his effect on the game.

He leads the league in BoxOuts per game.
https://www.nba.com/stats/players/box-outs/?sort=BOX_OUTS&dir=1

Notwithstanding this fact, the man is still top 10 (9) in offensive rebounds per game where he is able to attack the rebound more freely.
https://www.nba.com/stats/players/traditional/?sort=OREB&dir=-1

His blocks are down and he still looks a step slow while adjusting to this weight and recovery from injury, but the effort stats are there.

You know I gonna spin wit it
BigDaddyG
Posts: 39792
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 1/22/2010
Member: #3049

11/2/2021  7:39 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels


Mitch is averaging nearly a double, double at about 30 mins a game. He's also averaging 2.5 blocks a game. This is from his updated stats on bball reference. He's not the greatest rebounder, but he ain't below average. Really, it's too early in the season to be doing this, but Mitch has improved as a passer as well. His assist rate has seen an uptick.You saw how RJ was able to leverage Mitch's gravity with alley oops with drives as well. His spacing isn't poor on the pick and roll because some always needs to keep a body on him. And he's still working himself back in shape. Also, you can't mention the Knicks record without Mitch and not mention the Knicks record with D Rose. Rose's tear on offense kinda happened around the same time Mitch went down.
Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right. - The Tick
EwingsGlass
Posts: 27466
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 4/29/2005
Member: #893
USA
11/2/2021  7:44 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels

https://www.nba.com/stats/players/defense/?sort=DEF_RATING&dir=1&CF=MIN*GE*20&Season=2021-22&SeasonType=Regular%20Season

This is DefRtg sorted by players playing more than 20 minutes. The Knicks starting lineup as a whole aren’t doing great at getting stops. But if you look at the starting 5, Randle and Robinson are the best DefRtg players on the team.

Kemba is the big outlier giving up 118 pts per 100 possessions.


Compare that to the same sort from 20-21

https://www.nba.com/stats/players/defense/?sort=DEF_RATING&dir=-1&CF=MIN*GE*20&Season=2020-21&SeasonType=Regular%20Season

All the Knicks were better at defense last year, and Robinson (106) was better than Noel (108.5)

Short answer is that the Knicks need their new lineup to tighten up its defense. But there is nothing to suggest that Robinson is the reason. That’s anecdotal at best and not supported by numbers or facts.

You know I gonna spin wit it
martin
Posts: 76085
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
11/2/2021  7:45 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels

Mitch is one of the more twitch fast centers in the league and probably the fastest up and down the court for C's. I don't know what you are seeing.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
Kemet
Posts: 22087
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/23/2015
Member: #6148

11/3/2021  1:01 AM
Every time Randle dribble-dribble the ball down court our offense become a half-court offense, because our opponent are back set up on defense, the clock is running the more Randle dribble to the FT line, our ball movement is usually one or two teammates if Randle don't shoot the ball. The problem has been Randle passing to a moving teammate, or cutter to the basket leads to a turn-over. The Raptors team had 8 turnovers however, Randle & Barrett combine had 7 turn-overs. The Raptors play-maker VanVleet has been averaging 3 turnovers a game without Lowry. Playing us for 37 min VanVleet average 1 turnover. We applied no defensive pressure on the Raptors PG, and he made us look like bums throughout the 2nd half.
And Randle forgot he's a PF on defense, AO scored 36 pts on Randle without sweating.
MitchRob is an above the rim player that should be scoring in double-digits every game with Randle handling the rock.
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
11/3/2021  8:02 AM
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels

Mitch is one of the more twitch fast centers in the league and probably the fastest up and down the court for C's. I don't know what you are seeing.

HoopsHype had him as the 4th slowest Center in the NBA last season, I didn't believe it at first, but right before he got hurt i started paying close attention to him and I notice he was always the last guy down court on both ends.

ES
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
11/3/2021  8:08 AM
Kemet wrote:Every time Randle dribble-dribble the ball down court our offense become a half-court offense, because our opponent are back set up on defense, the clock is running the more Randle dribble to the FT line, our ball movement is usually one or two teammates if Randle don't shoot the ball. The problem has been Randle passing to a moving teammate, or cutter to the basket leads to a turn-over. The Raptors team had 8 turnovers however, Randle & Barrett combine had 7 turn-overs. The Raptors play-maker VanVleet has been averaging 3 turnovers a game without Lowry. Playing us for 37 min VanVleet average 1 turnover. We applied no defensive pressure on the Raptors PG, and he made us look like bums throughout the 2nd half.
And Randle forgot he's a PF on defense, AO scored 36 pts on Randle without sweating.
MitchRob is an above the rim player that should be scoring in double-digits every game with Randle handling the rock.

AO is listed as a SG/SF, he's essentially a wing player and Randle is not. Randle doesn't have the speed either to rotate to the perimeter when the ball swings out to the perimeter.

Like i said earlier in the thread, when teams are play small ball we don't counter, when we did (the last preseason game with obi and randle) we came back from 12 down in 4 minutes.

ES
martin
Posts: 76085
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
11/3/2021  8:10 AM
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels

Mitch is one of the more twitch fast centers in the league and probably the fastest up and down the court for C's. I don't know what you are seeing.

HoopsHype had him as the 4th slowest Center in the NBA last season, I didn't believe it at first, but right before he got hurt i started paying close attention to him and I notice he was always the last guy down court on both ends.

LAST season? When the Knicks purposely slowed the game down cause they didn't have the personal to run? Or a PG in first unit to push ball? That old, irrelevant stat?

Bro, if you want to make a point and have a link to some website that keeps track of things and want to share that, it would be step 1 to actually starting to make a point

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
11/3/2021  8:12 AM
EwingsGlass wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels

https://www.nba.com/stats/players/defense/?sort=DEF_RATING&dir=1&CF=MIN*GE*20&Season=2021-22&SeasonType=Regular%20Season

This is DefRtg sorted by players playing more than 20 minutes. The Knicks starting lineup as a whole aren’t doing great at getting stops. But if you look at the starting 5, Randle and Robinson are the best DefRtg players on the team.

Kemba is the big outlier giving up 118 pts per 100 possessions.


Compare that to the same sort from 20-21

https://www.nba.com/stats/players/defense/?sort=DEF_RATING&dir=-1&CF=MIN*GE*20&Season=2020-21&SeasonType=Regular%20Season

All the Knicks were better at defense last year, and Robinson (106) was better than Noel (108.5)

Short answer is that the Knicks need their new lineup to tighten up its defense. But there is nothing to suggest that Robinson is the reason. That’s anecdotal at best and not supported by numbers or facts.

The lost of Payton and Bullock on the defensive side is definitely evident. On the flip side we are definitely scoring more points.

ES
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
11/3/2021  8:20 AM
BigDaddyG wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels


Mitch is averaging nearly a double, double at about 30 mins a game. He's also averaging 2.5 blocks a game. This is from his updated stats on bball reference. He's not the greatest rebounder, but he ain't below average. Really, it's too early in the season to be doing this, but Mitch has improved as a passer as well. His assist rate has seen an uptick.You saw how RJ was able to leverage Mitch's gravity with alley oops with drives as well. His spacing isn't poor on the pick and roll because some always needs to keep a body on him. And he's still working himself back in shape. Also, you can't mention the Knicks record without Mitch and not mention the Knicks record with D Rose. Rose's tear on offense kinda happened around the same time Mitch went down.

He has a totally of 8 blocks on the season, 3 of those came in 1 game.

How can he block shots when teams are shooting more and more 3's, Fast breaks are leading to more open 3's than layups.

I forgot what game i was watching the other day, But the 2 teams combine for just 5 TWO point attempts in the entire 2nd quarter.

ES
BigDaddyG
Posts: 39792
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 1/22/2010
Member: #3049

11/3/2021  12:04 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
BigDaddyG wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels


Mitch is averaging nearly a double, double at about 30 mins a game. He's also averaging 2.5 blocks a game. This is from his updated stats on bball reference. He's not the greatest rebounder, but he ain't below average. Really, it's too early in the season to be doing this, but Mitch has improved as a passer as well. His assist rate has seen an uptick.You saw how RJ was able to leverage Mitch's gravity with alley oops with drives as well. His spacing isn't poor on the pick and roll because some always needs to keep a body on him. And he's still working himself back in shape. Also, you can't mention the Knicks record without Mitch and not mention the Knicks record with D Rose. Rose's tear on offense kinda happened around the same time Mitch went down.

He has a totally of 8 blocks on the season, 3 of those came in 1 game.

How can he block shots when teams are shooting more and more 3's, Fast breaks are leading to more open 3's than layups.

I forgot what game i was watching the other day, But the 2 teams combine for just 5 TWO point attempts in the entire 2nd quarter.


My bad, I was looking at their projected stats, not their actual stats. Still, it's too early, to read anything into it. What are opponents shooting at the rim when he's in the game? What's the point differential when he's on the court? Those are the stats that really tell us what Mitch means to the defense, not just blocks.
Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right. - The Tick
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
11/3/2021  2:49 PM
BigDaddyG wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
BigDaddyG wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
martin wrote:Mitch playing with Randle has nothing to do with Randle's poor shot choice or his hero ball, iso mentality. Not the turnovers either.

You want a spacer at the 5, go find one, not many out there, and not many out there who can defend at the level Mitch does. And defense is one of Knicks' weaknesses right now

Dude, if you don't realize we are a slower team with randle as a ball handler and mitch as a center, your nuts...Neither one of them are fast players. Randle gets that rebound he's trotting up the court, not sprinting, same with mitch.

The defense is suffering because teams are swinging the ball and shooting 3's and playing small ball, and we are countering that with a slow line up that can't recover in time.

You want know why mitch is avg 1 block, because teams are more perimeter centric.

You saw it yourself last night were we traded 3 point baskets like a layup drill, and you see it in from every team

Yeah I still don't get your point. When Randle brings the ball up the court slowly, it has nothing to do with Mitch. You should detach one from the other.

When Randle plays poorly, it has nothing to do with Mitch.


I personally think both of them play too many minutes with a squad this deep.

Mitch is tied for 25th in rebound playing 30 min per game, and blocking just 1 shot

Randle doesn't need to play 37/40 minutes a night..when you have OBI, or can even go with a line up of

Mitch
RJ
Fournier
burks
Rose

Randle
obie
burks
IQ
Kemba

Randle
Rj
Fornier
Kemba
Rose

There's so many ways to use this talent IMO to speed the pace on both ends

you keep bringing up blocks like it's the only way to gauge defense. Mitch is turning into a very good defensive center, he intimidates/alters shots and players coming near where he could be.

Dude has zero preseason and has been rehabbing since like March.

And yet he got better IMHO. First start of season where it doesn't take him like 5-10 games to realize he shouldn't foul a dude and he is patrolling quite nicely.

But Martin The fact is mitch is a very limited skilled player who should be getting limited minutes. For all of the things he can't do, the only thing your able to come back with is he plays defense..

He can't pass, but he plays defense
he can't shoot, but he plays defense
He's slow, but he plays defense
Below avg rebonder for his size and athletic ability, but he plays defense
poor FT shooter, but he plays defense
some how ends up on the floor(while we cringe hoping he gets up) more than any player on the court.
He has poor spacing on PnR, but he play's defense

we were 18-23 when Mitch went down last yr (5 games under 500), once he went down, Randle blew up and we finish 10 games over 500

He is a solid 22 min per night player nothing more, he's grabbing his shorts anything after, and he certainly isn't chasing no guards and wings off the 3 point line, he's not an energy guy for more than 10 minutes.

The knicks could have offer Mitch an extension weeks ago....why haven't they?

I'm going to say this over and over again, HE IS NOT A GOOD FIT NEXT TO RANDLE. I'm not saying he's the sole reason randle is struggling, but he plays a part because of the spacing.

If he so good defensively why have we NOSE DIVE in defensive rating this yr...His IQ is nowhere near Noels


Mitch is averaging nearly a double, double at about 30 mins a game. He's also averaging 2.5 blocks a game. This is from his updated stats on bball reference. He's not the greatest rebounder, but he ain't below average. Really, it's too early in the season to be doing this, but Mitch has improved as a passer as well. His assist rate has seen an uptick.You saw how RJ was able to leverage Mitch's gravity with alley oops with drives as well. His spacing isn't poor on the pick and roll because some always needs to keep a body on him. And he's still working himself back in shape. Also, you can't mention the Knicks record without Mitch and not mention the Knicks record with D Rose. Rose's tear on offense kinda happened around the same time Mitch went down.

He has a totally of 8 blocks on the season, 3 of those came in 1 game.

How can he block shots when teams are shooting more and more 3's, Fast breaks are leading to more open 3's than layups.

I forgot what game i was watching the other day, But the 2 teams combine for just 5 TWO point attempts in the entire 2nd quarter.


My bad, I was looking at their projected stats, not their actual stats. Still, it's too early, to read anything into it. What are opponents shooting at the rim when he's in the game? What's the point differential when he's on the court? Those are the stats that really tell us what Mitch means to the defense, not just blocks.

I'm not sure of any of the other stats, my point is he's a limited player that should not be getting 30 minutes, especially when teams play small. There's no way we should be getting out rebounded by a bunch of wing players on the raptors, I mean Cole Anthony grab 16 boards, that happens because they are long rebounds off of miss perimeter shots, and once they grab those boards they are off and running.

watch him carefully tonight and you'll see.

Keep in my mind I think he's a solid player we should keep at a low cost..I just don't agree with him starting..Thats THIBS with his hard on for RIM protection

ES
Philc1
Posts: 28301
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 9/2/2020
Member: #8897

11/3/2021  10:35 PM
I was saying we needed to trade him last summer for a package


I told ya so

jskinny35
Posts: 21580
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/27/2005
Member: #928
USA
11/4/2021  1:53 AM
Philc1 wrote:I was saying we needed to trade him last summer for a package


I told ya so

You'll have to get in line for that one :)

Why is Randle still our primary Ball handler

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy