| Author | Thread |
|
dk7th
Posts: 30006 Alba Posts: 1 Joined: 5/14/2012 Member: #4228 USA |
fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." thanks for the link. it's a pre-draft workout exchange which happened on june 22nd. anyway, a firestorm ensued, forcing melo to get defensive and backtrack, clarify and deny... just like he has done before. happily, kp has far exceeded everyone's expectations, and has been the catalyst for the team in general. all i asked for was a link. it's content is anecdotal evidence, no more and no less valid than anything else that gets out there, including the alleged displeasure that melo voiced. why gratuitously spew your garbage? knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
|
| AUTOADVERT |
|
fishmike
Posts: 53902 Alba Posts: 1 Joined: 7/19/2002 Member: #298 USA |
dk7th wrote:why spew my garbage? Because its NOT garbage. That would be what others spew. A quote from directly from a GM is NOT "anecdotal evidence" but IS more valuable that an unnamed source from a tabloid. Please I need one of your reminders how smart you are... now would be a good time.fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." Melo retracted the statement? Link please? "winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
|
|
GustavBahler
Posts: 42864 Alba Posts: 15 Joined: 7/12/2010 Member: #3186 |
Mission Accomplished.
|
|
Knickoftime
Posts: 24159 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 1/13/2011 Member: #3370 |
dk7th wrote:fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." "firestorm"? Really? We need a new way of describing offseason 'stories' like these. That it got attention did not mean it had any meaning. We now know (and some of us did at the time) it was meaningless and had no ramifications. |
|
dk7th
Posts: 30006 Alba Posts: 1 Joined: 5/14/2012 Member: #4228 USA |
fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:why spew my garbage? Because its NOT garbage. That would be what others spew. A quote from directly from a GM is NOT "anecdotal evidence" but IS more valuable that an unnamed source from a tabloid. Please I need one of your reminders how smart you are... now would be a good time.fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." i asked for a link. you provided one; you could have stopped there. but instead you decide to start an argument, speaking to me disrespectfully and hurling one insult after another. we have not had a cross word all season, so again i ask why the gratuitous aggression? knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
|
|
WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 6/28/2014 Member: #5843 |
fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." Had read the Mills/Melo stuff when the original article came out. Would have more significant if Melo had looked at Mills and said "What the F'...You kidding me Mills!" You shouldn't think that SAS and Berman were the only guys discussing Anthony's reactions after the draft. I remember Begely, or perhaps Isola (a fan of KP) on ESPN radio saying he had two sources. I've said this before- the issue was not Carmelo's reaction- he had the right to be pissed off- the real issue has to do with the guys who hang with the players letting info get out, and it could have been on Melo's side or Hardaway's. Whatever the reason...Anthony had some kind of change of heart over the summer, and all of us are benefiting from it. The Herring Tweets are good stuff to consider (I'm just taking the text), and go hand in hand as a follow-up to the Melo/Mills conversation:
Players grow and change all the time...not many examples like the stuff we're seeing with Anthony, though. Almost looking like Lebron these days,...except for the method acting flopping. I think the KP "discovery" inspired him but Anthony has been a different guy in many ways, from the Puerto Rico getaway to a more active leadership role on the court, and some of the best D he's EVER played in the NBA. Some of the stuff we're talking about is probably best left for discussion after the season, when we can assess everything the team has been through. We are not even at the halfway mark for the season, and things can still change...good or bad. I give my ideas in this type of thread, but I almost feel that I'm going to jinx the team by being too optimistic about what I'm seeing. Have Hahn on the radio right now- at this very moment he's introducing an upcoming segment by saying that something is starting to turn for the Knicks. I tend to agree with him, and believe that something good is going on and will continue, and believe that discussing and understanding WHY this team is changing is interesting to do, but I'm surprised at all the snipes being made by UK members at each other. Got to keep the good karma going. EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
|
|
martin
Posts: 80097 Alba Posts: 108 Joined: 7/24/2001 Member: #2 USA |
dk7th wrote:fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." the link that Fish posted was directly from Mills. Mills quoting himself, not some source close to Melo like in the example you tried to compare it to. And you didn't ask for a link, you demanded it in a way that suggests you don't believe and were put off by it. And spewing of gratuitous garbage? Read your own posts before you use a phrase like that. Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
|
|
fishmike
Posts: 53902 Alba Posts: 1 Joined: 7/19/2002 Member: #298 USA |
dk7th wrote:agression? Disrespect? Nice try. Go back and read my words again... sarcasm yes. Insults? Is there some part of this back and forth I am missing on? No.. insulting was wasting our time with your Melo is a cancer rambling all summer (while he was organizing private workouts with Knick players unkown to you). Insulting is suggesting the info you were working with was solid, when in fact it was as anecdotal as can be.fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:why spew my garbage? Because its NOT garbage. That would be what others spew. A quote from directly from a GM is NOT "anecdotal evidence" but IS more valuable that an unnamed source from a tabloid. Please I need one of your reminders how smart you are... now would be a good time.fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." Not sure I see the disrespect. Did you spout a ton of Melo-garbage based on tabloid anecdotal reports this summer? Yes you did. Were you dead wrong? Well the truth has surfaced has it not? What is telling is that you are more interested in damage control like with your anecdotal comment than simply saying you were wrong about this player. "winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
|
|
WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 6/28/2014 Member: #5843 |
martin wrote:dk7th wrote:fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." This the the Reality TV era...I think many are expecting everything to be recorded and available on TV or the internet. I've gotten the feeling that many around here don't respect the reporters and columnists they don't agree with...and question their veracity as reporters of the truth. I've said a number of times that reporters have much to lose if they are proven to have supplied inaccurate details for a story. Folks don't seem to believe me, though. I believed the reported comments coming from the Anthony camp after the draft, as well as the Mills/Melo conversation. Have the ring of truth for me, and there is no reason why both cannot be seen as truthful. Hard to choose the truth you want to believe and discard the truth which makes you uncomfortable.
EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
|
|
PresIke
Posts: 27671 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 7/26/2001 Member: #33 USA |
dacash wrote:wow, we winning and cant get along. calm down be happy knicks doing great things, a thread about pop giving kp6 praise gets turned into an argument, lol damn It's always been this way with the fans. Even before this forum was created on the NY Times Forum folks used to argue about JVG and how he was holding the offense back (Camby, Free Spree!), some arguing we should have blown it up and traded everyone (Houston, Spree, etc.) because we would never really win with them, and how we relied on the "black hole" Ewing-centered offense. "Good Riddance" was the NY Post back page: http://nypost.com/2000/08/22/good-riddance-to-that-menacing-scowl/ Forum Po Po and #33 for a reason...
|
|
Knickoftime
Posts: 24159 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 1/13/2011 Member: #3370 |
ChuckBuck wrote:KP is the catalyst for the 2015-2016 Knicks. Pop is stating the obvious, and he rarely throws praise around. Besides maybe his own players Duncan and Kawhi, he rarely sends a bouquet of flowers anyone's way. Never sent any adulation Melo's way for sure his whole career. http://nypost.com/2016/01/10/2-reasons-why-its-ok-to-talk-knicks-and-playoff-race/ Friday in his post-game, Pop called Melo a "Hall of Fame" player. Okay, start dancing. You Knicks fans should get a clue. Be grateful KP inspired Melo to change his losing ways! It's not Fish, it's not Phil...it's simple peer pressure!!!!! Sometimes you need a young buck nipping at your heels threatening to steal your spotlight away to get inspired to better oneself. You sound insecure and desperate. |
|
newyorker4ever
Posts: 26515 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 5/19/2014 Member: #5816 |
fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." Well i guess he'll think twice next time he wants to call you out for a link....LOL |
|
newyorker4ever
Posts: 26515 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 5/19/2014 Member: #5816 |
fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:agression? Disrespect? Nice try. Go back and read my words again... sarcasm yes. Insults? Is there some part of this back and forth I am missing on? No.. insulting was wasting our time with your Melo is a cancer rambling all summer (while he was organizing private workouts with Knick players unkown to you). Insulting is suggesting the info you were working with was solid, when in fact it was as anecdotal as can be.fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:why spew my garbage? Because its NOT garbage. That would be what others spew. A quote from directly from a GM is NOT "anecdotal evidence" but IS more valuable that an unnamed source from a tabloid. Please I need one of your reminders how smart you are... now would be a good time.fishmike wrote:dk7th wrote:http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/id/14262815/after-lost-decade-knicks-find-right-pathfishmike wrote:nyknickzingis wrote:I think Melo was PISSED when they drafted KP. He was thinking "Project". He wanted someone more for now. Then when he actually saw what KP was capable of in workouts, a bright light went up in his head. He realized Phil knew what he was doing. Remember, Melo's friends have been traded recently. JR Smith, Shump and Hardaway all guys Melo loved. All sent packing by Phil. In a way Melo was thinking, maybe I'm not in the plans. As much as he denied saying that stuff after the draft that was reported, I think something was definitely said that his people leaked to the media.respectfully disagree... for one thing we learned that Melo pretty knew the Knicks were drafting KP. He attended KP's workout with Mills and asked him if he thought there was a chance the Knicks take him. Mills said "if he is there expect we DO take him." From what i've seen of this debate you're having with dk7th i think you should drop the mic and walk of the stage. He called you out and in return you showed him what he was calling you out about and now he's a little upset that you were able to show him what he demanded from you and now he's even more upset and is now saying you disrespected him when he started it. Drop the mic. |