[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Who is more qualified to coach the Knicks - Thibodeau or Fisher


Author Poll
Rookie
Posts: 7069
Joined: 10/15/2008
Member: #2274

Thibodeau has a solid resume and a reputation as a defensive minded coach who works his players hard in practice. It could also be mentioned that he has clashed with Chicago management.

Fisher's resume as a coach is still TBD. I am not sure what he brings to the table other then he played in the Triangle for Phil and has a reputation as a leader.

Another underachieving season with Fisher as head coach could mean the end of his tenure here. With Thibs still out there taking a break from coaching and his rep for turning things around quickly, things in NY could get hot come Feb or sooner. NY fans and media are not exactly known for their patience. I would expect the triangle offense and Fisher to come under fire pretty quickly if the Knicks stumble out of the gate. Phil has proven to be very loyal and patient, but what's going to happen when the fire Fisher chants start raining down from the rafters?

Thibodeau
Fisher
View Results


Page 2 of 2 Previous 1  2 
Topic LOCKED
Author Thread
blkexec
Posts: 28347
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/3/2004
Member: #748
8/8/2015  6:29 PM
CrushAlot wrote:
TripleThreat wrote:
Rookie wrote:doen"t Leon Rose/CAA represent both Thibs and Anthony?


CAA repped Mike Woodson and he got the smear job as well.

Given Thibs is white and Melo is black, wouldn't surprise me if Melo tried to angle the press that Thibs is harder on black players than white ones.

Why did Kobe Bryant stay silent when Phil Jackson came back to the Lakers after leaving and writing a book about Kobe Bryant as a giant POS? Because the book was out on Mamba, any excellent coach out there with choices would rather not deal with that kind of headache.

What coach wants to walk into a team with one of the worst owners in sports, a gutted team just barely floating above it's 17 wins the year before, having possibly one of the least talented overall rosters in the NBA, shades of Zeke looming around, and having a franchise player who you can't make do anything because Big Daddy Dolan will say leave him alone and let him do whatever he wants?

A coach with choices will want nothing to do with Melo.

A coach just wanting to be an NBA head coach and will coach anywhere? Sure. Plenty of those will say yes to the job.

What are you basing this on?

Why does everything have to be based on race? Thats the cop out lazy analysis of many people. The challenge is to look beyond race first, and just maybe there are other variables to consider. I personally rather have Thibs for this team. But I also rather have consistency. And Phil rather have someone he can dethrone or over shadow at any time. With Thibs, it's disrespectful. With Fisher, it's a teaching moment.

Born in Brooklyn, Raised in Queens, Lives in Maryland. The future is bright, I'm a Knicks fan for life!
AUTOADVERT
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
8/8/2015  7:27 PM
Right now this isn't about dark conspiracies or corporate scandal. We have a young coach going into his 2nd year with a new roster and a better idea of what the job is about. We need to just let this play it's natural course and see if coach and players can grow together and start to win. That's what this season will be about and not all the rumors and conspiracy talk. All of that is a foolish distraction and has no bearing on what Fish and the Players do.
dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
8/9/2015  1:20 AM
why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.
knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
8/9/2015  1:54 AM
dk7th wrote:why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.

Agree again. Nice.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
8/9/2015  2:16 AM    LAST EDITED: 8/9/2015  2:17 AM
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.

Agree again. Nice.

I think for the 1st time this is a franchise in Synch from the bottom to the top. We've got to allow this team to grow together. We've got a young coach and some young players to root for and they seem to fit for the most part. It's gonna be interesting to watch this group grow together.

Rookie
Posts: 27069
Alba Posts: 28
Joined: 10/15/2008
Member: #2274

8/9/2015  9:57 AM
dk7th wrote:why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.

Thibideau is on paid vacation. He probably has something in his contract with Chicago that says if he takes a new job for equal or more money, they don't have to pay him the balance of his contract. This is about next season. Thibs isn't taking a job in season. It's also about the heat that Fisher and the triangle will get if this team underachieves in this system. 52 or more in the loss column and this thread is relevant.

dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
8/9/2015  10:55 AM
Rookie wrote:
dk7th wrote:why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.

Thibideau is on paid vacation. He probably has something in his contract with Chicago that says if he takes a new job for equal or more money, they don't have to pay him the balance of his contract. This is about next season. Thibs isn't taking a job in season. It's also about the heat that Fisher and the triangle will get if this team underachieves in this system. 52 or more in the loss column and this thread is relevant.

never mind about the triangle... if you guesstimate simply by the win shares of the new players (from trades and free agency) over the players they have replaced that is around 8 more wins, perhaps ten. that's 25-27 wins right there.

therefore for your scenario it would mean that melo is uncooperative and disgruntled/injured PLUS grant and kris are bad.

knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
Rookie
Posts: 27069
Alba Posts: 28
Joined: 10/15/2008
Member: #2274

8/9/2015  11:25 AM
dk7th wrote:
Rookie wrote:
dk7th wrote:why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.

Thibideau is on paid vacation. He probably has something in his contract with Chicago that says if he takes a new job for equal or more money, they don't have to pay him the balance of his contract. This is about next season. Thibs isn't taking a job in season. It's also about the heat that Fisher and the triangle will get if this team underachieves in this system. 52 or more in the loss column and this thread is relevant.

never mind about the triangle... if you guesstimate simply by the win shares of the new players (from trades and free agency) over the players they have replaced that is around 8 more wins, perhaps ten. that's 25-27 wins right there.

therefore for your scenario it would mean that melo is uncooperative and disgruntled/injured PLUS grant and kris are bad.

In my scenario, if the team underachieves it's on the coach and the system. We know Fisher is a good leader, but is he a good coach? This team is good enough to be competitive. How Fisher manages crunch time where games are won and lost is on him. How many times have we seen him draw up a play coming out of a time out that none of the players can follow? Coming out of a timeout should result in a quality shot, not a shot clock violation, turnover or chaotic jacked shot. That's on Fisher. How he manages line ups, rotations and players minutes is also on the coach. Grant and KP's development is also on Fisher.

Fisher should get a free pass through Christmas, but after that, if the team underachieves, he is going to feel the heat from fans and the media. Thibs is a proven coach with a defensive mindset. Fisher is not yet since he didn't have a very good opportunity last season. This season there's no excuses. He also has the extra burden of proving the triangle is still a relevant offense in today's NBA. I wish him luck.

CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
8/9/2015  11:46 AM
Rookie wrote:
dk7th wrote:why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.

Thibideau is on paid vacation. He probably has something in his contract with Chicago that says if he takes a new job for equal or more money, they don't have to pay him the balance of his contract. This is about next season. Thibs isn't taking a job in season. It's also about the heat that Fisher and the triangle will get if this team underachieves in this system. 52 or more in the loss column and this thread is relevant.

He was on Mike and Mike a few times after he was let go. Maybe he works for espn and does some analysis or broadcasting for a year. He doesn't seem like the type to stay away from the bench for long.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
8/9/2015  11:53 AM
Rookie wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Rookie wrote:
dk7th wrote:why is this even a thread. thiboudeaux is not a practiced triangle coach and is not going to work seamlessly with jackson... get your foot off of fisher's neck and let him prove himself this season! maybe, as with the draft and free agent acquisitions, he too will make us feel encouraged. young coaches need a chance to develop just like players.

Thibideau is on paid vacation. He probably has something in his contract with Chicago that says if he takes a new job for equal or more money, they don't have to pay him the balance of his contract. This is about next season. Thibs isn't taking a job in season. It's also about the heat that Fisher and the triangle will get if this team underachieves in this system. 52 or more in the loss column and this thread is relevant.

never mind about the triangle... if you guesstimate simply by the win shares of the new players (from trades and free agency) over the players they have replaced that is around 8 more wins, perhaps ten. that's 25-27 wins right there.

therefore for your scenario it would mean that melo is uncooperative and disgruntled/injured PLUS grant and kris are bad.

In my scenario, if the team underachieves it's on the coach and the system. We know Fisher is a good leader, but is he a good coach? This team is good enough to be competitive. How Fisher manages crunch time where games are won and lost is on him. How many times have we seen him draw up a play coming out of a time out that none of the players can follow? Coming out of a timeout should result in a quality shot, not a shot clock violation, turnover or chaotic jacked shot. That's on Fisher. How he manages line ups, rotations and players minutes is also on the coach. Grant and KP's development is also on Fisher.

Fisher should get a free pass through Christmas, but after that, if the team underachieves, he is going to feel the heat from fans and the media. Thibs is a proven coach with a defensive mindset. Fisher is not yet since he didn't have a very good opportunity last season. This season there's no excuses. He also has the extra burden of proving the triangle is still a relevant offense in today's NBA. I wish him luck.

in a different situation i would say 30 games is more than enough to gauge a team but because the team is in rebuild mode i would give the coach more than 30 games to get. lets say they are 11-19 at christmas: you are saying the team goes 18-33 or worse the rest of the way then fisher should be canned.

knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
8/9/2015  12:12 PM
Fisher is on the right track IMO. He had a rough start to last season but found his footing after the trade. He's starting this year with a clearer understanding of what he needs to do. The changes he made starting last year actually made a positive difference and looked even better in Summer League.

This is a team full of players that actually want to be here now. Most of these guys are solid character guys who believe in Team and have shown that they are team players. That's going to make a HUGE difference in how they work and the effort they put into becoming a good team. There's more talent and talent that fits the style of ball they want to play.

Fisher didn't really have issues with drawing up plays or setting his lineups after the trade. Things settled down a lot as he worked in the new players. The team actually started to compete and wins some games. If he had a healthy Melo to close the year there's no way he loses as many games. Good health is always important and hopefully we catch a break this year compared to previous seasons.

arkrud
Posts: 32217
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 8/31/2005
Member: #995
USA
8/9/2015  10:37 PM
Fisher is a student of Phil.
He just finished his freshmen year.
3 more to go before graduation.
He can drop off too... but this will be his decision unless the school will be closed altogether by Dolan.
"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." Hamlet
TripleThreat
Posts: 23106
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/24/2012
Member: #3997

8/10/2015  8:49 AM
blkexec wrote:Why does everything have to be based on race? Thats the cop out lazy analysis of many people. The challenge is to look beyond race first, and just maybe there are other variables to consider.....


Is it a cop out?

LeBron James leaves Cleveland in what is seen as one of the most bizarre and self damaging marketing tactics in human history with "The Decision" and then after Dan Gilbert blasts him in the infamous "Comic Sans font letter", Jesse Jackson immediately goes public and accuses Gilbert of racism.

LeBron James, battered in the press over and over about The Decision, finally looking for any kind of daylight and rope, finally says, well the backlash is in part due to racism because he's black. After which Charles Barkley says LBJ is stupid, no one hates LBJ for being black ,they hate him for taking a big fat crap on his hometown in public in an embarrassing display of arrogance.

Donald Sterling, rightly, gets run over the rails. However no one wants to talk about earlier before Doc Rivers came to town that Chris Paul openly says he'd rather play for a black coach than a white one. What do you think would happen if Steve Nash said that?

Danny Ferry gets run over the coals and run out of town for comments with the Hawks, however Shaq gets fewer All Star votes than Yao Ming, then does a 'ching chong' mock speak on the radio to mock Yao Ming, and gets no suspension and no fine.

Kobe Bryant, in Colorado, battered and cornered for what he did, finally his lawyer comes out, seeing his endorsements burn and his client at risk for life in prison, at Kobe's behest, claims racism is a factor ( you know, not that ENTIRE RAPING SOMEONE THING AND THAT BEING A CRIME ISSUE)

Even outside of the NBA, Actor Isaiah Washington is accused of saying something negative about a gay castmate, in which finally, cornered and ripped apart by brutal and negative PR in gay friendly Hollywood and the liberal media, finally relents and claims racism is a factor in what he called a "witchhunt"

Take it to the bank. If Thibs was the Knicks coach, he would DEMAND CONSISTENCY, EFFORT AND PRODUCTION ON DEFENSE. He is a known defensive coach. Guess who has never shown real consistency , effort or production on defense? Melo. I can assure you, defense or lack of it would be a hot button issue between coach and player and Melo has never pulled punches about using the press to attack people on the Knicks, and that would include Thibs if Thibs was a Knick coach, to serve his own agenda.

Sorry dude, time and time again, when pushed into a corner because of issue of merit, black athletes and even celebrities consistently run to the race card to try to bail themselves out.

Then again, how much objectivity am I going to get about blacks in pro sports and the NBA using racism as a PR defense card from a guy who calls himself "blkexec" and compares himself to NBA veterans on the court constantly.

Thibs is a great coach. However he's a coach who will actually have choices when he decides to return to coaching. Coaches in that position have the leverage to not go to teams they know will be bad situations for them. Just like Coach K decided Kobe Bryant's pleas for him to coach the Lakers wasn't enough to leave his living God status at Duke for a toxic situation. Melo gets what Melo wants, even if it kills the team. Why would Thibs want to come here and deal with a player with an established Don't Try/Don't Care/Screw You attitude about defense, with regards to a known defensive coach? Its like having someone drink a gallon of gasoline and pissing in your campfire.

If Thibs and Melo were together on the same team, it would eventually be an all out war in the press. Thibs demanding Melo play real defense and Melo digging for anything, and yes including the vaunted race card, to try to obscure the fact that he's a one dimensional selfish chucker who cares more about being some CEO type than winning basketball games. Melo had no problem tweeting and talking to the press about being "hoodwinked" and hating the Knicks draft, you think he will hesitate to claim racism if he's under media fire for his absolute disgrace of what he calls defensive play?

nyk4ever
Posts: 41010
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 1/12/2005
Member: #848
USA
8/10/2015  9:33 AM
i wish i was qualified enough to lock this thread.
"OMG - did we just go on a two-trade-wining-streak?" -SupremeCommander
ChuckBuck
Posts: 28851
Alba Posts: 11
Joined: 1/3/2012
Member: #3806
USA
8/10/2015  9:41 AM
I like Thibs as a defensive mind, but not as a head coach.

Winning record in Chicago and all, but he just runs his players into the ground. Rose always hurt, Noah, pretty much all his key guys always missed alot of time.

A coach like Thibs would ruin young KP. Let Fisher continue the rebuild, it's only his 2nd season.

holfresh
Posts: 38679
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/14/2006
Member: #1081

8/10/2015  10:00 AM    LAST EDITED: 8/10/2015  11:29 AM
TripleThreat wrote:
blkexec wrote:Why does everything have to be based on race? Thats the cop out lazy analysis of many people. The challenge is to look beyond race first, and just maybe there are other variables to consider.....


Is it a cop out?

LeBron James leaves Cleveland in what is seen as one of the most bizarre and self damaging marketing tactics in human history with "The Decision" and then after Dan Gilbert blasts him in the infamous "Comic Sans font letter", Jesse Jackson immediately goes public and accuses Gilbert of racism.

LeBron James, battered in the press over and over about The Decision, finally looking for any kind of daylight and rope, finally says, well the backlash is in part due to racism because he's black. After which Charles Barkley says LBJ is stupid, no one hates LBJ for being black ,they hate him for taking a big fat crap on his hometown in public in an embarrassing display of arrogance.

Donald Sterling, rightly, gets run over the rails. However no one wants to talk about earlier before Doc Rivers came to town that Chris Paul openly says he'd rather play for a black coach than a white one. What do you think would happen if Steve Nash said that?

Danny Ferry gets run over the coals and run out of town for comments with the Hawks, however Shaq gets fewer All Star votes than Yao Ming, then does a 'ching chong' mock speak on the radio to mock Yao Ming, and gets no suspension and no fine.

Kobe Bryant, in Colorado, battered and cornered for what he did, finally his lawyer comes out, seeing his endorsements burn and his client at risk for life in prison, at Kobe's behest, claims racism is a factor ( you know, not that ENTIRE RAPING SOMEONE THING AND THAT BEING A CRIME ISSUE)

Even outside of the NBA, Actor Isaiah Washington is accused of saying something negative about a gay castmate, in which finally, cornered and ripped apart by brutal and negative PR in gay friendly Hollywood and the liberal media, finally relents and claims racism is a factor in what he called a "witchhunt"

Take it to the bank. If Thibs was the Knicks coach, he would DEMAND CONSISTENCY, EFFORT AND PRODUCTION ON DEFENSE. He is a known defensive coach. Guess who has never shown real consistency , effort or production on defense? Melo. I can assure you, defense or lack of it would be a hot button issue between coach and player and Melo has never pulled punches about using the press to attack people on the Knicks, and that would include Thibs if Thibs was a Knick coach, to serve his own agenda.

Sorry dude, time and time again, when pushed into a corner because of issue of merit, black athletes and even celebrities consistently run to the race card to try to bail themselves out.

Then again, how much objectivity am I going to get about blacks in pro sports and the NBA using racism as a PR defense card from a guy who calls himself "blkexec" and compares himself to NBA veterans on the court constantly.

Thibs is a great coach. However he's a coach who will actually have choices when he decides to return to coaching. Coaches in that position have the leverage to not go to teams they know will be bad situations for them. Just like Coach K decided Kobe Bryant's pleas for him to coach the Lakers wasn't enough to leave his living God status at Duke for a toxic situation. Melo gets what Melo wants, even if it kills the team. Why would Thibs want to come here and deal with a player with an established Don't Try/Don't Care/Screw You attitude about defense, with regards to a known defensive coach? Its like having someone drink a gallon of gasoline and pissing in your campfire.

If Thibs and Melo were together on the same team, it would eventually be an all out war in the press. Thibs demanding Melo play real defense and Melo digging for anything, and yes including the vaunted race card, to try to obscure the fact that he's a one dimensional selfish chucker who cares more about being some CEO type than winning basketball games. Melo had no problem tweeting and talking to the press about being "hoodwinked" and hating the Knicks draft, you think he will hesitate to claim racism if he's under media fire for his absolute disgrace of what he calls defensive play?

I could probably go through the cases why some blacks may get away with some of the things they say based on their experiences, as opposed to why some whites won't..It's not equal and fair..But ignoring all that..Just like whites as a whole don't want to get accused of racism because of the actions of a few, I'm sure you can appreciate the apprehension of most here when you try to prescribe a particular predictable outcome to an entire race or people based on the actions of a few..Can you or does your deep thought allow such engagement??

martin
Posts: 76516
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
8/10/2015  11:31 AM
TripleThreat wrote:
blkexec wrote:Why does everything have to be based on race? Thats the cop out lazy analysis of many people. The challenge is to look beyond race first, and just maybe there are other variables to consider.....


Is it a cop out?

LeBron James leaves Cleveland in what is seen as one of the most bizarre and self damaging marketing tactics in human history with "The Decision" and then after Dan Gilbert blasts him in the infamous "Comic Sans font letter", Jesse Jackson immediately goes public and accuses Gilbert of racism.

LeBron James, battered in the press over and over about The Decision, finally looking for any kind of daylight and rope, finally says, well the backlash is in part due to racism because he's black. After which Charles Barkley says LBJ is stupid, no one hates LBJ for being black ,they hate him for taking a big fat crap on his hometown in public in an embarrassing display of arrogance.

Donald Sterling, rightly, gets run over the rails. However no one wants to talk about earlier before Doc Rivers came to town that Chris Paul openly says he'd rather play for a black coach than a white one. What do you think would happen if Steve Nash said that?

Danny Ferry gets run over the coals and run out of town for comments with the Hawks, however Shaq gets fewer All Star votes than Yao Ming, then does a 'ching chong' mock speak on the radio to mock Yao Ming, and gets no suspension and no fine.

Kobe Bryant, in Colorado, battered and cornered for what he did, finally his lawyer comes out, seeing his endorsements burn and his client at risk for life in prison, at Kobe's behest, claims racism is a factor ( you know, not that ENTIRE RAPING SOMEONE THING AND THAT BEING A CRIME ISSUE)

Even outside of the NBA, Actor Isaiah Washington is accused of saying something negative about a gay castmate, in which finally, cornered and ripped apart by brutal and negative PR in gay friendly Hollywood and the liberal media, finally relents and claims racism is a factor in what he called a "witchhunt"

Take it to the bank. If Thibs was the Knicks coach, he would DEMAND CONSISTENCY, EFFORT AND PRODUCTION ON DEFENSE. He is a known defensive coach. Guess who has never shown real consistency , effort or production on defense? Melo. I can assure you, defense or lack of it would be a hot button issue between coach and player and Melo has never pulled punches about using the press to attack people on the Knicks, and that would include Thibs if Thibs was a Knick coach, to serve his own agenda.

Sorry dude, time and time again, when pushed into a corner because of issue of merit, black athletes and even celebrities consistently run to the race card to try to bail themselves out.

Then again, how much objectivity am I going to get about blacks in pro sports and the NBA using racism as a PR defense card from a guy who calls himself "blkexec" and compares himself to NBA veterans on the court constantly.

Thibs is a great coach. However he's a coach who will actually have choices when he decides to return to coaching. Coaches in that position have the leverage to not go to teams they know will be bad situations for them. Just like Coach K decided Kobe Bryant's pleas for him to coach the Lakers wasn't enough to leave his living God status at Duke for a toxic situation. Melo gets what Melo wants, even if it kills the team. Why would Thibs want to come here and deal with a player with an established Don't Try/Don't Care/Screw You attitude about defense, with regards to a known defensive coach? Its like having someone drink a gallon of gasoline and pissing in your campfire.

If Thibs and Melo were together on the same team, it would eventually be an all out war in the press. Thibs demanding Melo play real defense and Melo digging for anything, and yes including the vaunted race card, to try to obscure the fact that he's a one dimensional selfish chucker who cares more about being some CEO type than winning basketball games. Melo had no problem tweeting and talking to the press about being "hoodwinked" and hating the Knicks draft, you think he will hesitate to claim racism if he's under media fire for his absolute disgrace of what he calls defensive play?

No way dude, this is an awful post on so many different levels. You and only you have brought racism into a topic that lacked it and then took it to a new level.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
Page 2 of 2 Previous 1  2 
Topic LOCKED
Who is more qualified to coach the Knicks - Thibodeau or Fisher

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy