EnySpree wrote:

Splat wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

EnySpree wrote:To be fair, we do have lou amundson, galloway, Alexey shved to tip or hat to. Lance Thomas and Shane Larkin too to an extent. Besides then and Bargnani the rest of the squad suck.

To be fair?? If you offered all those players for Whiteside alone, Miami would just laugh at you.

And to be fair, the only acknowledgment Riley needs is that he acquired said players. How they were developed or by whom means nothing. The only decisive factor is who they end up with. Riley acquires better role players AT A GOOD PRICE consistently. We do not.

Then GTFO and become miami heat fans.

Phil has been here about a year in a historically losing franchise. He has yet to get his feet wet trying to get where Riley is. The heat historically is a winning franchise. All of the winning was fine in riles watch ever since he drafted wade....we will get our wade this year hopefully.

That kind response is why you are the one and only EnvyStar. You go girl!

BRIGGS wrote:I don't know how many people have watched miami bug they also have an undrafted d league guard named tyler Johnson and he's been spectacular in multiple games. Also yanked Henry walker who has helped the team but Johnson really looks really good.Phil is on the clock here. We should be a team making pulls like this all year.We fixated on Galloway and while he's been ok not anywhere near the class of player of Whiteside or Johnson.

He also gave 30 year old Bosh a 5 year max, and is about to give 29 year old Dragic a $20mil a year max, having already given up 2 first rounders for him. The kind of stuff Phil would get killed for.

Splat wrote:

EnySpree wrote:

Splat wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

EnySpree wrote:To be fair, we do have lou amundson, galloway, Alexey shved to tip or hat to. Lance Thomas and Shane Larkin too to an extent. Besides then and Bargnani the rest of the squad suck.

To be fair?? If you offered all those players for Whiteside alone, Miami would just laugh at you.

And to be fair, the only acknowledgment Riley needs is that he acquired said players. How they were developed or by whom means nothing. The only decisive factor is who they end up with. Riley acquires better role players AT A GOOD PRICE consistently. We do not.

Then GTFO and become miami heat fans.

Phil has been here about a year in a historically losing franchise. He has yet to get his feet wet trying to get where Riley is. The heat historically is a winning franchise. All of the winning was fine in riles watch ever since he drafted wade....we will get our wade this year hopefully.

That kind response is why you are the one and only EnvyStar. You go girl!

You can read it how you like but it's like shut up about another team already. Just go to a miami heat forum and be free.

I'm sick of you guys complaining all the damn time. Phil can't correct the whole last 15 years. He just got here. When we start winning, we'll get more opportunities to get better. We have money and a top pick coming. We're at the beginning stages towards getting better.

I want to enjoy this process. Not listen to you guys talk about other teams and how we ate so hopeless.

It's like you guys are some lames at the bar watching other guys bag up all the chic and you are just watching talking about if I had on my good shoes, or could lose your beer gut you could get a girl one day.

yellowboy90 wrote:WHy is a rookie GM being compared to one with years of experience?

It's like yelling at a newborn because they still live with their parents. Saying they'll never be **** in life because they can't talk or walk. Then comparing them to a college professor. Only thing that separates them is time. The infants potential is limitless

knickscity wrote:

yellowboy90 wrote:WHy is a rookie GM being compared to one with years of experience?

I thought the 11 rings and his natural ability to judge talent would automatically transfer to his position? Now he's a rookie. Amazing when some of us said that from the beginning cats went ballistic.

But yeah comparing to Riley IS perfectly fair. Riley when he took over the Heat overhauled a roster and brought in real talent in that first year. Phil....nope.

Phil is untouchable. For some, questioning his abilities as a GM is like spitting on the Cross. I sniffed out Phil early on. He's up against sharp GM's who are carving him up like mincemeat. But he has 11 rings. He's so very Zen. When Phil shows he doesn't have a plan, his acolytes say that is the plan. It's all so very convenient.

EnySpree wrote:

Splat wrote:

EnySpree wrote:

Splat wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

EnySpree wrote:To be fair, we do have lou amundson, galloway, Alexey shved to tip or hat to. Lance Thomas and Shane Larkin too to an extent. Besides then and Bargnani the rest of the squad suck.

To be fair?? If you offered all those players for Whiteside alone, Miami would just laugh at you.

And to be fair, the only acknowledgment Riley needs is that he acquired said players. How they were developed or by whom means nothing. The only decisive factor is who they end up with. Riley acquires better role players AT A GOOD PRICE consistently. We do not.

Then GTFO and become miami heat fans.

Phil has been here about a year in a historically losing franchise. He has yet to get his feet wet trying to get where Riley is. The heat historically is a winning franchise. All of the winning was fine in riles watch ever since he drafted wade....we will get our wade this year hopefully.

That kind response is why you are the one and only EnvyStar. You go girl!

You can read it how you like but it's like shut up about another team already. Just go to a miami heat forum and be free.

I'm sick of you guys complaining all the damn time. Phil can't correct the whole last 15 years. He just got here. When we start winning, we'll get more opportunities to get better. We have money and a top pick coming. We're at the beginning stages towards getting better.

I want to enjoy this process. Not listen to you guys talk about other teams and how we ate so hopeless.

It's like you guys are some lames at the bar watching other guys bag up all the chic and you are just watching talking about if I had on my good shoes, or could lose your beer gut you could get a girl one day.

It's you dudes making all the excuses for Phil, you guys are really the annoying ones. Phil has 100% admitted his faults and y'all still defend him like he's the pope. I suspect when Phil fails during the offseason and he will fail again, you cats will be still making excuses for him.

knickscity wrote:

smackeddog wrote:

mreinman wrote:

smackeddog wrote:

BRIGGS wrote:I don't know how many people have watched miami bug they also have an undrafted d league guard named tyler Johnson and he's been spectacular in multiple games. Also yanked Henry walker who has helped the team but Johnson really looks really good.Phil is on the clock here. We should be a team making pulls like this all year.We fixated on Galloway and while he's been ok not anywhere near the class of player of Whiteside or Johnson.

He also gave 30 year old Bosh a 5 year max, and is about to give 29 year old Dragic a $20mil a year max, having already given up 2 first rounders for him. The kind of stuff Phil would get killed for.

right. perhaps phil should win us a couple of rings or even games before he gets away with bonehead moves.

Oh come on, if Phil's big moves this offseason were signing Bosh and Dragic to 5year Max contracts, and trading 2 first rounders to do so, you all would be calling for his head. Riley does it and he's a genious.

Riley has had some great moments as a GM, but he doesn't always get it right- Juwan Howard, Brian Grant, etc.

No GM is perfect, but citing a few miscues dont offset the marvelous work he has done. Just wondering though, do you think signing Juwan Howard was a bad move? Dude made min salary to be a locker room presence.

I'm talking about the $100mil contract he signed Howard to back in 1997 (or around then)- got rescued by stern who ruled the contract illegal after the Bullets fans started crying about it.

skeng wrote:

knickscity wrote:

skeng wrote:I just hope Phil can continue to keep Jimmy D from sticking his sausage fingers in the phucking basketball decisions. To me that's a NYK GM job well done.

You may wanna thank the dude that told Dolan to sign him and keep up with his band. The only reason why Dolan hasnt gotten involved is because he's out to show the Knicks woes arent exclusively because of him. Once Phil fails, you wont be able to blame Dolan for it.

Thats always been his goal from day one, but fans seem to be gaga over a dude thats won in a different facet that they currently are in. Phil cannot cash in the rings for exec experience. Dolan hired Phil to get the fan heat off himself, when actually he should have hired a younger more innovative guy who would have put the Knicks on a real rebuild, not an old guy who doesnt have the time to truly rebuild.

Blame or not, I'm happy with Dolan being involved as little as possible.

The way I see it, we are rebuilding, culturally aswell. I'm not gonna debate the Melo signing, but I wouldn't be surprised if a younger, innovative GM would do the same as Phil. I don't think Phil has been completely horrendous and I don't think anyone expected us to have a competitive/meaningful season, so the losing/tanking is welcomed imo.

I think he should at least have next season and possibly the one after to prove himself. I mean, aren't we all clamoring for some continuity up in this bish?

If Phil flubs the off-season, there won't be another season of goodwill left in the tank. Regardless of our individual opinions on his performance so far, this is it. He gets things wrong now, he'll never recover.