[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Philosophically - rebuilding or just regular building?
Author Thread
Nalod
Posts: 71363
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
11/7/2014  2:45 PM
"Organic Tanking".......If it sucks, let it be and use the draft.

If you trade your picks and what you get in return MAKES YOU WORSE, then your phuched.
(EDDY, Starbury)

I don't prescribe to "artificial Tanking" which is losing on purpose. That serves no good.
Losing can teach you great lessons that you can learn from.

AUTOADVERT
knickknack
Posts: 20054
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/17/2014
Member: #5891

11/7/2014  2:56 PM
Splat wrote:
nixluva wrote:
TripleThreat wrote:
nixluva wrote:I personally don't really think the draft is such a high % path to success.


Why don't we put an end to this happy horse **** right now? Yes, let's do that.


Golden State Warriors

Steph Curry - drafted
Klay Thompson - drafted
Andrew Bogut - via trade, but acquired by giving up Monta Ellis, meaning a great job of mining the 2nd round of the draft for a high value asset at the time
Igoudala - Only able to get to the Warriors because they gave up draft picks for Utah to eat contracts. Utah's valuation of those picks (i.e. their view that the draft would lead them to better success) allowed that trade to happen.
Draymond Green - drafted

Chicago Bulls

Joachim Noah - drafted
Derrick Rose - drafted
Taj Gibson - drafted
Jimmy Butler - drafted and a gem of a late first round pick
Nice young talent in Mirotic and McBuckets ( the Knicks would KILL to have guys like this on the roster) - drafted

OKC Thunder
Kevin Durant - drafted
Russell Westbrook - drafted
Serge Ibaka - drafted
Steven Adams - drafted
Perry Jones ( doing a nice job filling in with injuries) - drafted
Reggie Jackson - drafted ( a nice late first round value)

LA Clippers

Blake Griffin - drafted
DeAndre Jordan - drafted
Chris Paul - In trade, but trade was leveraged with biggest piece, Eric Gordon, then a high value shooting guard at the time, was a drafted player

Cleveland Cavaliers

LeBron James - originally drafted, came back ( cap space cleared was only possible using draft assets to dump contracts)
Kevin Love - trade, but only after using high value drafted assets in Wiggins and Bennett to get him
Kyrie Irving - drafted
Dion Waiters - drafted
Tristan Thompson - drafted
Anderson Varejo - drafted ( despite injurie, a hell of a value for a 2nd rounder)

SA Spurs

Tim Duncan - drafted
Tony Parker - drafted ( high value grab not at the top of the draft)
Manu Ginobili - drafted
Tiago Splitter - drafted ( late first rounder)
Kawhi Leonard - draft day trade for George Hill ( Hill was a developed late first rounder)

Some super high draft picks, but a lot of these teams, much of their core was digging for value in the draft even outside the top of the draft. Guys like Reggie Jackson, Varejao, DeAndre Jordan, Jimmy Butler, Draymond Green. All guys who would be STARTERS for the Knicks today.

In almost every case, these teams, current contenders, are build around the draft or gotten key assets through trades from high value draft assets or developed draft assets. Almost all have a player who was a high value grab later in the draft.

Even if the Knicks didn't have super high draft picks and just did the heavy mining in the late first round and 2nd that some of these teams did, they'd be in an infinitely better position.

The draft doesn't work for you if YOU ARE A BAD ORGANIZATION AND HAVE A BAD FRONT OFFICE. Yet you keep clamoring how amazing Zen Master is, how he's a leader of men, how he's changing the entire Knicks landscape, yet you seem to think a roster he tried to almost entirely dump this past offseason is full of hidden gold.

The Knicks have coughed up so many draft assets in the last decade that they don't EVEN GIVE THEMSELVES A CHANCE TO SEE IF IT MIGHT WORK FOR THEM.

I'm not trying to say you can't build thru the draft. I said high % meaning that most teams that try to do it that way aren't as successful as the few you're posting. It's the reason I said what I said. It's not a high % success rate. How many teams are there in the NBA and you point to a precious few that were able to build thru the draft and become contenders. If I listed the teams that have tried and failed over the years it's a longer list. So it's not "happy horse..." It's reality.

Now I'm not saying it made sense to surrender assets as badly as this franchise has. The thing is that the basic premise most are suggesting is to lose badly and hope a great player is there and we actually get lucky bounces of lottery balls. It has to be recognized that this may not work as expected and you could be in the lottery for many years without success.

I'm being totally fair here, but what did you just refute?

Pretty much the best current or recent long-standing best franchises are what TT cited.

In other words, they have the weight of success supporting their basic assertion that committing to the draft is the route to success.

Are you countering that there is a proven better way? No, you are not. All you are trying to infer is they have no statistical weight to their assertions, yet how is it that the teams they cited are the winners of the bulk of recent NBA championships?

Yeah, you're just wrong.

Um lets analyze that more closely:
that bulls team"s number of championships = zero
that cavaliers team's number of championships = zero
that warriors team's number of championships = zero
that thunder team's number of championships = zero
Clippers dnt really count cause if so the knicks leveraged draft picks to get Melo so they'd be in this group too, either way they still have zero rings as well
that leaves only the spurs which is only enough evidence to support the theory that the key to win championships is to move your team to San Antonio Texas and just wait.

trust the kristaps-cess!
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
11/7/2014  4:17 PM
I know that it can take time to build a winner after drafting players, but just this small sample of time doesn't show a great direct correlation between the draft and Titles from a percentage stand point. What you see is that YES you want to draft a great player but overall those types of players like Duncan, Kobe, Dirk or Lebron are few and far between and often the team that actually drafts that great player doesn't reap the reward of a title themselves. It seems to me that if the Knicks were in the draft seriously there were few players they could've gotten that would guarantee a title. A better team perhaps, but the end goal is very elusive.

We went from Jordan, Hakeem, Duncan, Shaq, Kobe and Lebron. With a little Dirk and KG thrown in there. Durant made a cameo as did Dwight Howard. It's just really hard to put together the right mix.

First Overall Selections, Year-by-Year
Year Lg Team First Pick College
2014 NBA Cleveland Cavaliers Andrew Wiggins University of Kansas
2013 NBA Cleveland Cavaliers Anthony Bennett University of Nevada, Las Vegas
2012 NBA New Orleans Hornets Anthony Davis University of Kentucky
2011 NBA Cleveland Cavaliers Kyrie Irving Duke University
2010 NBA Washington Wizards John Wall University of Kentucky
2009 NBA Los Angeles Clippers Blake Griffin University of Oklahoma
2008 NBA Chicago Bulls Derrick Rose University of Memphis
2007 NBA Portland Trail Blazers Greg Oden Ohio State University
2006 NBA Toronto Raptors Andrea Bargnani
2005 NBA Milwaukee Bucks Andrew Bogut University of Utah
2004 NBA Orlando Magic Dwight Howard
2003 NBA Cleveland Cavaliers LeBron James
2002 NBA Houston Rockets Yao Ming
2001 NBA Washington Wizards Kwame Brown
2000 NBA New Jersey Nets Kenyon Martin University of Cincinnati
1999 NBA Chicago Bulls Elton Brand Duke University
1998 NBA Los Angeles Clippers Michael Olowokandi University of the Pacific
1997 NBA San Antonio Spurs Tim Duncan Wake Forest University
1996 NBA Philadelphia 76ers Allen Iverson Georgetown University
1995 NBA Golden State Warriors Joe Smith University of Maryland
1994 NBA Milwaukee Bucks Glenn Robinson Purdue University
1993 NBA Orlando Magic Chris Webber University of Michigan
1992 NBA Orlando Magic Shaquille O'Neal Louisiana State University

Year	Western champion	Result	Eastern champion	
2014 San Antonio Spurs 4–1 Miami Heat
2013 San Antonio Spurs 3–4 Miami Heat
2012 Oklahoma City Thunder 1–4 Miami Heat
2011 Dallas Mavericks 4–2 Miami Heat
2010 Los Angeles Lakers 4–3 Boston Celtics
2009 Los Angeles Lakers 4–1 Orlando Magic
2008 Los Angeles Lakers 2–4 Boston Celtics
2007 San Antonio Spurs 4–0 Cleveland Cavaliers
2006 Dallas Mavericks 2–4 Miami Heat
2005 San Antonio Spurs 4–3 Detroit Pistons
2004 Los Angeles Lakers 1–4 Detroit Pistons
2003 San Antonio Spurs 4–2 New Jersey Nets
2002 Los Angeles Lakers 4–0 New Jersey Nets
2001 Los Angeles Lakers 4–1 Philadelphia 76ers
2000 Los Angeles Lakers 4–2 Indiana Pacers
1999 San Antonio Spurs 4–1 New York Knicks
1998 Utah Jazzdagger 2–4 Chicago Bulls
1997 Utah Jazz 2–4 Chicago Bulls
Philosophically - rebuilding or just regular building?

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy