Vmart wrote:

fishmike wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

if you do this would you then use THjr in a trade for Lowry? Keep Shump, add Jimmer, use THjr and parts to get Lowry. Move JR to the SL and bring Jimmer off the bench

No way I trade Hardaway for Lowry. I'd keep THJ this guy is will be one of the best three point shooters of all time by the time he is finished playing the game. His game will expand over time. I'm not sold on Lowry beside his new contract is almost guaranteed to never match his production. From this year.

Nalod wrote:

Clean wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

fishmike wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

if you do this would you then use THjr in a trade for Lowry? Keep Shump, add Jimmer, use THjr and parts to get Lowry. Move JR to the SL and bring Jimmer off the bench

absolutely down withat scenario, i think toronto might just bite too..

No way to trading Tim. He is 1 or two summers away from becoming a Ray Allen type player. He just needs to put in work in the offseason.

Or Shump type. Never know.

He won't be a Shump type. He already has more game than Shump.

fishmike wrote:

Vmart wrote:

fishmike wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

if you do this would you then use THjr in a trade for Lowry? Keep Shump, add Jimmer, use THjr and parts to get Lowry. Move JR to the SL and bring Jimmer off the bench

No way I trade Hardaway for Lowry. I'd keep THJ this guy is will be one of the best three point shooters of all time by the time he is finished playing the game. His game will expand over time. I'm not sold on Lowry beside his new contract is almost guaranteed to never match his production. From this year.

he's a shooter... we can one anywhere... draft or dleague or FA

He is not just a shooter he is a slasher/fast break finisher something the Knicks have very little of.

SupremeCommander wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

I like this. Makes sense. I don't want the Knicks to move Tim. I think the Knicks need to avoid getting fleeced in a Lowry trade. The guy is having a great year but he is a free agent, has struggled with coaches and has been injury prone.

I think the Knicks need to make a couple of deals. I don't think a big trade like Lowry makes too much sense. The Knicks are out of options and digging themselves into a corner when they're 10+ games below 500 in the ****tiest Eastern Conference I can remember is beyond stupid. I really, really like Lowry but I would prefer maintaining what little flexibilit the franchise has left

I agree. This isn't an easy fix and teams want what is right with the Knicks. Getting jimmer for beno is a no risk move that could work out nicely.

SupremeCommander wrote:

Nalod wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:

fishmike wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

if you do this would you then use THjr in a trade for Lowry? Keep Shump, add Jimmer, use THjr and parts to get Lowry. Move JR to the SL and bring Jimmer off the bench

I'd consider that if Melo had an extension in place... the only young asset that the Knicks have and will have next year would be THJ. I'm not about to proclaim that he's a lock to be a 10 time all star but giving him up for another guy w/o a contract makes me uneasy

I will say that

Lowry
Jimmer
JR
Melo
Chandler

actually sounds like an NBA team

YOu putting Jimmer at the 2?

If you make the move that fish suggested, I have no idea who else to put at the two. If you don't make the move for Lowry I think the lineup looks like

Jimmer
THJ
JR
Melo
Chandler

gunsnewing wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:

Nalod wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:

fishmike wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

if you do this would you then use THjr in a trade for Lowry? Keep Shump, add Jimmer, use THjr and parts to get Lowry. Move JR to the SL and bring Jimmer off the bench

I'd consider that if Melo had an extension in place... the only young asset that the Knicks have and will have next year would be THJ. I'm not about to proclaim that he's a lock to be a 10 time all star but giving him up for another guy w/o a contract makes me uneasy

I will say that

Lowry
Jimmer
JR
Melo
Chandler

actually sounds like an NBA team

YOu putting Jimmer at the 2?

If you make the move that fish suggested, I have no idea who else to put at the two. If you don't make the move for Lowry I think the lineup looks like

Jimmer
THJ
JR
Melo
Chandler

one of the worst defenses ever assembled

two things:

1 - so I guess that's better than one of the worst backcourts ever assembled
2 - I don't really like the line-up but now that I know you don't like it, I know it's much better than I thought

SupremeCommander wrote:

gunsnewing wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:

Nalod wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:

fishmike wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

if you do this would you then use THjr in a trade for Lowry? Keep Shump, add Jimmer, use THjr and parts to get Lowry. Move JR to the SL and bring Jimmer off the bench

I'd consider that if Melo had an extension in place... the only young asset that the Knicks have and will have next year would be THJ. I'm not about to proclaim that he's a lock to be a 10 time all star but giving him up for another guy w/o a contract makes me uneasy

I will say that

Lowry
Jimmer
JR
Melo
Chandler

actually sounds like an NBA team

YOu putting Jimmer at the 2?

If you make the move that fish suggested, I have no idea who else to put at the two. If you don't make the move for Lowry I think the lineup looks like

Jimmer
THJ
JR
Melo
Chandler

one of the worst defenses ever assembled

two things:

1 - so I guess that's better than one of the worst backcourts ever assembled
2 - I don't really like the line-up but now that I know you don't like it, I know it's much better than I thought

I know everyone is giddy for change. I'm just saying be careful what you wish for. Patch up work never works for us

fishmike wrote:

Vmart wrote:

fishmike wrote:

SupremeCommander wrote:Beno to the Wiz, second to the Kings, Jimmer to NY

it makes so much sense it will never happen

if you do this would you then use THjr in a trade for Lowry? Keep Shump, add Jimmer, use THjr and parts to get Lowry. Move JR to the SL and bring Jimmer off the bench

No way I trade Hardaway for Lowry. I'd keep THJ this guy is will be one of the best three point shooters of all time by the time he is finished playing the game. His game will expand over time. I'm not sold on Lowry beside his new contract is almost guaranteed to never match his production. From this year.

he's a shooter... we can one anywhere... draft or dleague or FA

Not as high on Jimmer as some are. I tend to agree that we could go get something comparable in the D-league right now (Seth Curry for instance) and keep the pick. This kid Curry might have better PG ability, a better handle and a better off-the-dribble game by comparison.

gunsnewing wrote:

VCoug wrote:But remember, those two 2nd rounders we traded for Barganani have no value

Exactly people get all giddy over these trades and then panic when he the team actually gets worse with no assets and picks to improve

It's like some of you became Knicks fans yesterday. Come on we should know better by now

Knicks can't take back salary for picks like the cavs or other teams. They moved second rounders to create more cap space for 2015. Grunwald couldn't change the cap situation so that the Knicks were players and under the cap for this deadline. The Knicks being capped out isn't a new thing. Making moves with second rounders to improve that situation is bad?