smackeddog wrote:Not sure about Allan Houston being ranked higher than Sprewell in the ESPN one, I agree more with Nalod having them closer together. Much as I liked both of them, Houston could become annoyingly passive sometimes and disappear. Sprewell always brought the passion though. Hmm, it's tough though deciding which was better- they were complete opposites, always got the impression they didn't like each other.

Allan was here longer and played more games. Spree was a better player but I go by what is done in the uniform.

Could flip them around really. Its close.

Nalod wrote:

GodNa7ion wrote:Melo wins a series or 2 plus All-NBA 2nd team at least and scoring title and he moves into the top 10, if he does all that and gets an MVP then top 5, he gets the MVP plus all that he's #1

So in order for Carmelo to be the #1 Knick he needs

1 Ring plus Finals MVP
1 MVP
All NBA 1st Team- 1 time
All NBA 2nd Team- 2-3 times
1 scoring title
Multiple Playoff Series wins
a 50 Point game

*note*-has to beat LBJ in a series as well

One Season MVP and one ring with finals MVP and he is top 5.

Career Knicks with bling are royalty. Mercenary Knicks need to match those to be considered.

Hey ChuckBuck, care to elaborate? Or is my historical content to detailed for comprehension? Not enough Starphuch for a contemparary homer?

Nah, I'll let you have your glory. You're always right.