Rookie wrote:Hey Martin and Andrew, i think you should change Nalod's user name to Vorohkorp

Awesome

Nets talk are welcome there but not here

Nalod wrote:

FrenchKnicks wrote:

mikesknicks wrote:This is a Knicks site why would the Net be relevant here at all?

+1

This is a Knicks subforum, there's an NBA subforum on this site as well. Nets talk are welcome there but not here, let's be clear about that because we've seen way too many OT / Nets talks on this part of the site.

I haven't seen the mods do much about off topic threads on the NY Knicks Forum, I just wish people here would respect that.

Cuz they play in the divison.

Why talk about any other teams for that matter if its a KNicks forum only?

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

Nalod wrote:

FrenchKnicks wrote:

mikesknicks wrote:This is a Knicks site why would the Net be relevant here at all?

+1

This is a Knicks subforum, there's an NBA subforum on this site as well. Nets talk are welcome there but not here, let's be clear about that because we've seen way too many OT / Nets talks on this part of the site.

I haven't seen the mods do much about off topic threads on the NY Knicks Forum, I just wish people here would respect that.

Cuz they play in the divison.

Why talk about any other teams for that matter if its a KNicks forum only?

I mean you could say this isn't a team USA forum. So all the talk about Melo's performance in that context is irrelevant too. You guys should chill out. If any threads here have a devastating impact I'm sure the mods will move them.

What frenchknicks said.

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

Nalod wrote:

FrenchKnicks wrote:

mikesknicks wrote:This is a Knicks site why would the Net be relevant here at all?

+1

This is a Knicks subforum, there's an NBA subforum on this site as well. Nets talk are welcome there but not here, let's be clear about that because we've seen way too many OT / Nets talks on this part of the site.

I haven't seen the mods do much about off topic threads on the NY Knicks Forum, I just wish people here would respect that.

Cuz they play in the divison.

Why talk about any other teams for that matter if its a KNicks forum only?

I mean you could say this isn't a team USA forum. So all the talk about Melo's performance in that context is irrelevant too. You guys should chill out. If any threads here have a devastating impact I'm sure the mods will move them.

What frenchknicks said.

So you too want to overrule the decisions of the mods?

Not sure but did they say to stop posting in the NBA Forum when you are talking about non knick stuff?

London Olympic Games
Server Upgrades
Official Free Agency Thread
Tyson Chandler Take on His Olympic Teammates
2012-2013 Power Ranking from Real GM
The Rise of Jeremy Lin
Open Letter to All
For Once I Wholeheartedly Agree with Charles Barkley
Melo Exploding at Olympics
Perfect Storm to Swing Casual Fans
Is Anyone Actually Watching Carmelo Represent the United States
Say "Good Morning" to: Ray Felton, Ronnie Brewer...
Replay of Argentina vs France: Pabloco vs (pretty much) NBA level competition
Starting SG

As might as well ask the mods to wipe out 80% of the threads in this subforum.

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

Nalod wrote:

FrenchKnicks wrote:

mikesknicks wrote:This is a Knicks site why would the Net be relevant here at all?

+1

This is a Knicks subforum, there's an NBA subforum on this site as well. Nets talk are welcome there but not here, let's be clear about that because we've seen way too many OT / Nets talks on this part of the site.

I haven't seen the mods do much about off topic threads on the NY Knicks Forum, I just wish people here would respect that.

Cuz they play in the divison.

Why talk about any other teams for that matter if its a KNicks forum only?

I mean you could say this isn't a team USA forum. So all the talk about Melo's performance in that context is irrelevant too. You guys should chill out. If any threads here have a devastating impact I'm sure the mods will move them.

What frenchknicks said.

So you too want to overrule the decisions of the mods?

Not sure but did they say to stop posting in the NBA Forum when you are talking about non knick stuff?

Not that I'm aware of but exactly what non-Knick stuff means is unclear. If you're talking about how the Nets will impact the Knicks, that's not non-Knick stuff. If you want to be very strict, very few of the threads on this forum are directly on the Knicks. It is odd that it is only the Nets threads that people are throwing hissy fits over. At the moment, these are the top threads (with ones in bold unambiguously referring directly to Knicks basketball):

London Olympic Games
Server Upgrades
Official Free Agency Thread
Tyson Chandler Take on His Olympic Teammates
2012-2013 Power Ranking from Real GM
The Rise of Jeremy Lin
Open Letter to All
For Once I Wholeheartedly Agree with Charles Barkley
Melo Exploding at Olympics
Perfect Storm to Swing Casual Fans
Is Anyone Actually Watching Carmelo Represent the United States
Say "Good Morning" to: Ray Felton, Ronnie Brewer...
Replay of Argentina vs France: Pabloco vs (pretty much) NBA level competition
Starting SG

As might as well ask the mods to wipe out 80% of the threads in this subforum.

Not necessary. If the topics are regarding current Knicks they stay. I think there is a gray rea where Lin and free agency come to play. I think other teams are a topic in game threads and for a short period of time after completing a trade with the Knicks ( I e the nuggets after the melo trade). I don't see how a site with a knick forum, other forum and an nba forum is a spot to discuss the nets. There are yankee, mets, ... Talk threads for other teams. My suggestion is that you start that thread in its appropriate place.

Bonn1997 wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:

Nalod wrote:

FrenchKnicks wrote:

mikesknicks wrote:This is a Knicks site why would the Net be relevant here at all?

+1

This is a Knicks subforum, there's an NBA subforum on this site as well. Nets talk are welcome there but not here, let's be clear about that because we've seen way too many OT / Nets talks on this part of the site.

I haven't seen the mods do much about off topic threads on the NY Knicks Forum, I just wish people here would respect that.

Cuz they play in the divison.

Why talk about any other teams for that matter if its a KNicks forum only?

I mean you could say this isn't a team USA forum. So all the talk about Melo's performance in that context is irrelevant too. You guys should chill out. If any threads here have a devastating impact I'm sure the mods will move them.

What frenchknicks said.

So you too want to overrule the decisions of the mods?

Not sure but did they say to stop posting in the NBA Forum when you are talking about non knick stuff?

Not that I'm aware of but exactly what non-Knick stuff means is unclear. If you're talking about how the Nets will impact the Knicks, that's not non-Knick stuff. If you want to be very strict, very few of the threads on this forum are directly on the Knicks. It is odd that it is only the Nets threads that people are throwing hissy fits over. At the moment, these are the top threads (with ones in bold unambiguously referring directly to Knicks basketball):

London Olympic Games
Server Upgrades
Official Free Agency Thread
Tyson Chandler Take on His Olympic Teammates
2012-2013 Power Ranking from Real GM
The Rise of Jeremy Lin
Open Letter to All
For Once I Wholeheartedly Agree with Charles Barkley
Melo Exploding at Olympics
Perfect Storm to Swing Casual Fans
Is Anyone Actually Watching Carmelo Represent the United States
Say "Good Morning" to: Ray Felton, Ronnie Brewer...
Replay of Argentina vs France: Pabloco vs (pretty much) NBA level competition
Starting SG

As might as well ask the mods to wipe out 80% of the threads in this subforum.

Not necessary. If the topics are regarding current Knicks they stay. I think there is a gray rea where Lin and free agency come to play. I think other teams are a topic in game threads and for a short period of time after completing a trade with the Knicks ( I e the nuggets after the melo trade). I don't see how a site with a knick forum, other forum and an nba forum is a spot to discuss the nets. There are yankee, mets, ... Talk threads for other teams. My suggestion is that you start that thread in its appropriate place.

So you're giving the forum unsolicited suggestions on how to post here?

smackeddog wrote:I think what my problem is with some of the Net talk, is that I suspect some fans are hedging their bets. I think they'll start off stating a mild interest in the Nets, and when the new season comes, if the Knicks stink it up and the Nets do well, these same people will jump ship- I just feel that people are just laying the ground work for a full switch with the 'nets are great' talk.I don't think this Knicks fan site should be assisting that. I can't stand Deron Williams, Lopez or the Kardashian. The Nets anti-Knick 'come join us' stuff has also been hacking me off.

For me it's like saying you're a Clipper and Laker fan, or even a Knicks and Heat fan. Rivals are rivals.

Of course you can support both teams, it's your own personal choice, but this is not a Nets board and I don't think we should be supporting people to jump ship- why not post about them in the other Nba topic forum on this site?

Well said Smackeddog! You've hit the nail right smack on its head. I've been trying to say the same things for about a week now and Nalod & Bonn1997 were calling for me (an ultimate knicks fan)to leave. They've also been pushing for me to be banned because I've expressed the same concerns.