gunsnewing wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:

gunsnewing wrote:2nd round exit clearly. We will be chasing miami & boston. If brooklyn ever gets dwight its over. We would then be battling for the 7,8th seed

And shumpert will bring us to teh finals i guess?

He is a piece of the puzzle for a decade long run not a quickie and then we are back to square one

martin wrote:

Jmpasq wrote:Nash couldnt win in his prime with Amare ,Joe Johnson and Marion core. They had better role players as well. How is he going to win now at 37

argument holds up about the same as: Kobe couldn't win in his prime with Shaq, Karl Malone, Gary Payton, etc

Nash played with those guys once? And JJ was poked in the eye and hip check etc?

Knicks role players will be: Tyson, Lin, JR Smith, Novak, JJ2. And let's also hope Shump.

I doubt very much if we sign Nash and he comes in at about 10 mil, we will be willing to match what will be offered to Lin if those numbers are correct..

holfresh wrote:

martin wrote:

Jmpasq wrote:Nash couldnt win in his prime with Amare ,Joe Johnson and Marion core. They had better role players as well. How is he going to win now at 37

argument holds up about the same as: Kobe couldn't win in his prime with Shaq, Karl Malone, Gary Payton, etc

Nash played with those guys once? And JJ was poked in the eye and hip check etc?

Knicks role players will be: Tyson, Lin, JR Smith, Novak, JJ2. And let's also hope Shump.

I doubt very much if we sign Nash and he comes in at about 10 mil, we will be willing to match what will be offered to Lin if those numbers are correct..

why the heck not? you just don't let that guy walk, from a player perspective or from a $$$ to MSG perspective.

martin wrote:

holfresh wrote:

martin wrote:

Jmpasq wrote:Nash couldnt win in his prime with Amare ,Joe Johnson and Marion core. They had better role players as well. How is he going to win now at 37

argument holds up about the same as: Kobe couldn't win in his prime with Shaq, Karl Malone, Gary Payton, etc

Nash played with those guys once? And JJ was poked in the eye and hip check etc?

Knicks role players will be: Tyson, Lin, JR Smith, Novak, JJ2. And let's also hope Shump.

I doubt very much if we sign Nash and he comes in at about 10 mil, we will be willing to match what will be offered to Lin if those numbers are correct..

why the heck not? you just don't let that guy walk, from a player perspective or from a $$$ to MSG perspective.

I guess we will see what Lin's true value is to MSG giving the fact that more likely Lin's and Nash's contract will push us over the luxury tax threshold..Resigning JR and Novak as well..We will see..