MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:At the end of the day i think Lin and Melo can figure out how to dominate together and translate it into wins. I think it is Stoudemire that has really become a problem because he doesn't play defense and creates and inbalance in this system.

LOL.

Gtfo.

Please explain your response...

I wouldn't know where to start.

So you don't think they are capable of playing together at all? Or you don't think Melo is a good player? Or don't think Lin is? Or think Stoudemire is a great player? Try explaining and see what comes out.

Clearly you're trying to be funny and are just a typical overreacting knicks fan. Being a melo hater doesn't prove anything. This is why people make fun of knicks fans. This isn't a video game.

I mean, when you ask me a question like that you're effectively spitting on my entire body of work on this forum.

Sorry i don't specifically pay attention to your posts. You can say what you want about Melo right now, and most of it may be true, but at the end of the day in order to win in the playoffs you need someone who can take over the game. Our roster without Melo gets to the playoffs and loses right now. With Melo you have a fighting chance when you get there.

I think that's a stupid excuse Melo jockers use to justify his wackness.

Melo murdered this team two times already in his first calendar year here.

First, he demanded, like a bitch, a trade that took something like 8 players off this team.

Then, he came back and destroyed the the team that went 8-1, with two of those 8 wins coming against Serious Top Dogs in the West.

Melo sucks as a basketball player.

He is struggling, but clearly you never watched Melo before this season.

He's not struggling, he's strangling. He's strangling this team to death.

I can partially agree with you, but you really think it's all on him? If that is the case, he hasn held Denver back every year he was there.

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:At the end of the day i think Lin and Melo can figure out how to dominate together and translate it into wins. I think it is Stoudemire that has really become a problem because he doesn't play defense and creates and inbalance in this system.

LOL.

Gtfo.

Please explain your response...

I wouldn't know where to start.

So you don't think they are capable of playing together at all? Or you don't think Melo is a good player? Or don't think Lin is? Or think Stoudemire is a great player? Try explaining and see what comes out.

Clearly you're trying to be funny and are just a typical overreacting knicks fan. Being a melo hater doesn't prove anything. This is why people make fun of knicks fans. This isn't a video game.

I mean, when you ask me a question like that you're effectively spitting on my entire body of work on this forum.

Sorry i don't specifically pay attention to your posts. You can say what you want about Melo right now, and most of it may be true, but at the end of the day in order to win in the playoffs you need someone who can take over the game. Our roster without Melo gets to the playoffs and loses right now. With Melo you have a fighting chance when you get there.

I think that's a stupid excuse Melo jockers use to justify his wackness.

Melo murdered this team two times already in his first calendar year here.

First, he demanded, like a bitch, a trade that took something like 8 players off this team.

Then, he came back and destroyed the the team that went 8-1, with two of those 8 wins coming against Serious Top Dogs in the West.

Melo sucks as a basketball player.

He is struggling, but clearly you never watched Melo before this season.

He's not struggling, he's strangling. He's strangling this team to death.

I can partially agree with you, but you really think it's all on him? If that is the case, he hasn held Denver back every year he was there.

My position has always been that MDA and Melo cannot work together successfully.

Dolan has to choose one or the other.

I prefer MDA and the fun style of play he brings. When Melo was out, we got a chance to see what MDA can do with a team that buys into his system.

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:At the end of the day i think Lin and Melo can figure out how to dominate together and translate it into wins. I think it is Stoudemire that has really become a problem because he doesn't play defense and creates and inbalance in this system.

LOL.

Gtfo.

Please explain your response...

I wouldn't know where to start.

So you don't think they are capable of playing together at all? Or you don't think Melo is a good player? Or don't think Lin is? Or think Stoudemire is a great player? Try explaining and see what comes out.

Clearly you're trying to be funny and are just a typical overreacting knicks fan. Being a melo hater doesn't prove anything. This is why people make fun of knicks fans. This isn't a video game.

I mean, when you ask me a question like that you're effectively spitting on my entire body of work on this forum.

Sorry i don't specifically pay attention to your posts. You can say what you want about Melo right now, and most of it may be true, but at the end of the day in order to win in the playoffs you need someone who can take over the game. Our roster without Melo gets to the playoffs and loses right now. With Melo you have a fighting chance when you get there.

I think that's a stupid excuse Melo jockers use to justify his wackness.

Melo murdered this team two times already in his first calendar year here.

First, he demanded, like a bitch, a trade that took something like 8 players off this team.

Then, he came back and destroyed the the team that went 8-1, with two of those 8 wins coming against Serious Top Dogs in the West.

Melo sucks as a basketball player.

He is struggling, but clearly you never watched Melo before this season.

He's not struggling, he's strangling. He's strangling this team to death.

I can partially agree with you, but you really think it's all on him? If that is the case, he hasn held Denver back every year he was there.

My position has always been that MDA and Melo cannot work together successfully.

Dolan has to choose one or the other.

I prefer MDA and the fun style of play he brings. When Melo was out, we got a chance to see what MDA can do with a team that buys into his system.

I think Melo is a bad fit in this offense only because of where he is being fit in the offense. He was very effective playing PF for Mike in the Olympics. Look at where he operates and is successful. Put him at PF in between Chandler and either Novak or Harrellson with Lin and Shumpert in the backcourt and see what a difference it makes. Stoudemire causes the issues because he struggles to play with Chandler and Melo in this offense. He is playing with 2 mid range and inside operators. It clogs the paint. You put Melo, Lin, and Chander on the floor together with 2 effective perimeter players and it makes a huge difference for everyone.

I think he is a bad fit because his personality doesn't mesh well with the other guys. I think it's something that is outside of the realm of X's and O's.

He is talented enough to figure things out in basketball sense, but I don't think he is able to figure them out from an interpersonal sense.

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

Knixkik wrote:At the end of the day i think Lin and Melo can figure out how to dominate together and translate it into wins. I think it is Stoudemire that has really become a problem because he doesn't play defense and creates and inbalance in this system.

LOL.

Gtfo.

Please explain your response...

I wouldn't know where to start.

So you don't think they are capable of playing together at all? Or you don't think Melo is a good player? Or don't think Lin is? Or think Stoudemire is a great player? Try explaining and see what comes out.

Clearly you're trying to be funny and are just a typical overreacting knicks fan. Being a melo hater doesn't prove anything. This is why people make fun of knicks fans. This isn't a video game.

I mean, when you ask me a question like that you're effectively spitting on my entire body of work on this forum.

Sorry i don't specifically pay attention to your posts. You can say what you want about Melo right now, and most of it may be true, but at the end of the day in order to win in the playoffs you need someone who can take over the game. Our roster without Melo gets to the playoffs and loses right now. With Melo you have a fighting chance when you get there.

I think that's a stupid excuse Melo jockers use to justify his wackness.

Melo murdered this team two times already in his first calendar year here.

First, he demanded, like a bitch, a trade that took something like 8 players off this team.

Then, he came back and destroyed the the team that went 8-1, with two of those 8 wins coming against Serious Top Dogs in the West.

Melo sucks as a basketball player.

He is struggling, but clearly you never watched Melo before this season.

He's not struggling, he's strangling. He's strangling this team to death.

I can partially agree with you, but you really think it's all on him? If that is the case, he hasn held Denver back every year he was there.

My position has always been that MDA and Melo cannot work together successfully.

Dolan has to choose one or the other.

I prefer MDA and the fun style of play he brings. When Melo was out, we got a chance to see what MDA can do with a team that buys into his system.

I think Melo is a bad fit in this offense only because of where he is being fit in the offense. He was very effective playing PF for Mike in the Olympics. Look at where he operates and is successful. Put him at PF in between Chandler and either Novak or Harrellson with Lin and Shumpert in the backcourt and see what a difference it makes. Stoudemire causes the issues because he struggles to play with Chandler and Melo in this offense. He is playing with 2 mid range and inside operators. It clogs the paint. You put Melo, Lin, and Chander on the floor together with 2 effective perimeter players and it makes a huge difference for everyone.

I think he is a bad fit because his personality doesn't mesh well with the other guys. I think it's something that is outside of the realm of X's and O's.

He is talented enough to figure things out in basketball sense, but I don't think he is able to figure them out from an interpersonal sense.

If that is the case then it's a separate issue. I think he will figure it all out. Again to reiterate, i think Lin, Melo, and Chandler have potential as a core with the right supporting cast. With everything that Chandler does, i just don't think Stoudemire fits well anymore.

Absolutely not.

God bless you.

crzymdups wrote:Carmelo and Amar'e have never meshed on the floor. I think it has to be one or the other.

They messed pretty well last year late in the season and in the playoffs before Amare hurt his back. Was it all Billups I doubt it. The pressure of playing in NY clearly gets to these guys. You need special kinda players to handle NY

I wouldn't mind keeping Melo around to be our finisher for 10 minutes a game, but that isn't realistic.

I'm glad I have league pass, I don't have to stay up late to watch this crap and can watch the games in just over an hour now. Much less emotional and I have the memories of that 8-1 stretch when we were playing as a team.

MarburyAnd1Crossover wrote:

HugeKnick4 wrote:Billups was Big.

I think Billups went a long way to mask chemistry problems last season, and we still only went .500 after the trade.

We were 2 games above .500 before the trade and finished the season 2 games above .500. I wouldn't say anyone really meshed since the trade, at any point.

I think team has good peaces but to make this specific peaces a TEAM will be very difficult task and will take a long time.
I doubt is up to this task and Dolan and NY fan base will have enough patience for this kind of process.

I don't understand how with a week of practice time, and a PG to run Mike's system, that they look as dysfunctional as ever?

I think I would trade Melo for Gasol and worry about how I play three bigs or make a follow up trade later.

Great talent, but its just not working, and I'm not sure it really can work.

Problem is, you need the "right" stars. And this is New York, which means it MUST work immediately, or else heads must roll.

The core problem with our beloved Knicks is patience. The post-Lin(sanity) roster is still learning and will require the month of March to sort it out. JR Smith just got through customs and Josh Harrellson needs to be reminded he is not Steve Novak. Amar'e needs to watch tapes of Gus Johnson. It was refreshing to watch him get tangled up with Dejuan Blair.

Carmelo needs to play like Paul Pierce. He has the same edge and skill set, just not the same mojo.

Iman Shumpert needs a jump shot and Landry Fields needs to keep going hard to the rack.

It takes time... and a good brawl does not hurt either.

misterearl wrote:This is a replay of the classic, "you need stars to win" conundrum.

Problem is, you need the "right" stars. And this is New York, which means it MUST work immediately, or else heads must roll.

The core problem with our beloved Knicks is patience. The post-Lin(sanity) roster is still learning and will require the month of March to sort it out. JR Smith just got through customs and Josh Harrellson needs to be reminded he is not Steve Novak. Amar'e needs to watch tapes of Gus Johnson. It was refreshing to watch him get tangled up with Dejuan Blair.

Carmelo needs to play like Paul Pierce. He has the same edge and skill set, just not the same mojo.

Iman Shumpert needs a jump shot and Landry Fields needs to keep going hard to the rack.

It takes time... and a good brawl does not hurt either.

knicks could use a good brawl. they have more pieces than they've had since 1999.

but the deal is, it takes a while to mesh when there are that many different pieces.

we have a bunch of guys who are used to being the #1 option - not used to getting theirs in the flow. it takes time to learn to get it in the flow. the offense will come.

my issue is that i don't think the defense will ever work with amar'e and melo on the floor together.

as for the kind of star new york needs, may i present tyson chandler and iman shumpert and jeremy lin - team first guys with more than one dimension to their game. melo's got too much marbury in him.