jrodmc wrote:

toodarkmark wrote:Wow that people say yes to this. A'mare signed with us when we were nothing, put us on his back and carried us into the playoffs, had people chanting MVP mid season. And you would just straight up trade him for a guy who has never said he wanted to be here, who may not be a better player. This board sometimes shows me why fans are just always Grass is Greener and never appreciating how good they got it. No wonder Patrick Ewing was disgusted by this fan base at times in his career.

As you can see by the majority of replies, most posters in here would trade their own infants, zygotes, hoons, girlfriends, wives and mothers for whatever's winning in the last and next 5 minutes.
This thread should be included in the stupid frontrunners forum, along with the "WE NEED CRAWFORD BACK" and "ZBO's BETTER THAN TWO STATS" posts.
STAT carried a bunch of rooks and 2 1/2 tier players to the playoffs, and survived getting Melo'd mid-year. One can see that a fan base slowly begins to reflect the constant stream of mung media it ingests. I'm glad I don't watch TV or listen to the radio or read the faggoty anti-NY rags that infuse this area.

Or look at porn.

Sendclosk.

Me love you long time.

To me, the question is would you throw in something else of value -- say Landry or TD. I'd still say "yes", assuming, of course, that Dwight would sign an extension. Howard is a beast. Top defensive player in the game at most important defensive position, excellent rebounder, and a very good, if limited, offensive player. You cannot have Howard on your team and be below average on defense -- he's that good.

knickstorrents wrote:Why don't you reword the poll to say "would you do a lopsided trade in favor of your team?"

What a lame poll

Not really.

Amare helps spread the floor with his jump shot. Without him Melo would have to deal with more of the scoring load.

Also without his athleticism Dwight Howard would be pretty terrible. So you need to factor that in.

martin wrote:

AnubisADL wrote:

knickstorrents wrote:Why don't you reword the poll to say "would you do a lopsided trade in favor of your team?"

What a lame poll

Not really.

Amare helps spread the floor with his jump shot. Without him Melo would have to deal with more of the scoring load.

Also without his athleticism Dwight Howard would be pretty terrible. So you need to factor that in.

What kind of misguided logic is this. Holy crap.

Amare with no hops can still shoot jumpers. Dwight Howard with no hops is useless.

It would be cold blooded to trade STAT after he revived this team, so I'm thankful we don't have to put ourselves in this dilemma, but I would have a hard time turning down Superman.

Hypotheticals aside, I'm pumped to see what this Amar'e/Melo led team can do after a full training camp and (hopefully) some holes at PG and C are filled.

knicks1248 wrote:Somebody explain to me when did DH develope a jump shot..his situation here will be no better then it was in orl..as long as mike is the coach...

You need a bonifde perimeter player like kobe or jordan to play with a bigman that can score beyond 5 ft..surrounding him around shooters obviously doesn't wwork

Howard has never played with a player the caliber of Carmelo Anthony in his career.

knicks1248 wrote:

Childs2Dudley wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:Somebody explain to me when did DH develope a jump shot..his situation here will be no better then it was in orl..as long as mike is the coach...

You need a bonifde perimeter player like kobe or jordan to play with a bigman that can score beyond 5 ft..surrounding him around shooters obviously doesn't wwork

Howard has never played with a player the caliber of Carmelo Anthony in his career.

Carmelo is not really a bonifide perimeter player, which is part of the reason him and stat didn't just click like clock.. Im not saying it can't work, but it's going to take a very good pg to put it together.

I don't even think there's any young PG that can handle playing with 2 super stars like amare and melo, it's tough trying to balance ball distribution to 2 super stars, and still be aggresive.

I love Amar'e, but I honestly think Melo and Howard works better than Melo and Stat because Howard is a more defensive minded player that thrives on rebounding, shot blocking, and is willing to do the dirty work in the paint to help his team. Amar'e is strictly an offensive talent that has yet to make a commitment to rebounding for a player with his size and athleticism. Melo and Dhow is a serious 1-2 punch with offense and defense.