OldFan wrote:I don't see Mello as a top five player.
Which of these trades do you think would favor the team getting Mello?
Lebron - Mello
Kobe - Mello
Wade - Mello
Durant - Mello
Howard - Mello
Paul - Mello
Nowitzki - Mello
Nash - Mello
D Williams - Mello
Amare - Mello

Excluding age/injury potential I would take the non Mello side of all those trades.

Excluding age and injury I would take a healthy T-Mac over most of those guys. What does that prove? Those guys arent avaialable, Melo is.

A prime T-Mac > Kobe

AnubisADL wrote:

OldFan wrote:I don't see Mello as a top five player.
Which of these trades do you think would favor the team getting Mello?
Lebron - Mello
Kobe - Mello
Wade - Mello
Durant - Mello
Howard - Mello
Paul - Mello
Nowitzki - Mello
Nash - Mello
D Williams - Mello
Amare - Mello

Excluding age/injury potential I would take the non Mello side of all those trades.

Excluding age and injury I would take a healthy T-Mac over most of those guys. What does that prove? Those guys arent avaialable, Melo is.

A prime T-Mac > Kobe

no f'g way. a prime t-mac was a regular season johnny with zero - count 'em zero - stones in the playoffs.

AnubisADL wrote:

Marv wrote:

AnubisADL wrote:

OldFan wrote:I don't see Mello as a top five player.
Which of these trades do you think would favor the team getting Mello?
Lebron - Mello
Kobe - Mello
Wade - Mello
Durant - Mello
Howard - Mello
Paul - Mello
Nowitzki - Mello
Nash - Mello
D Williams - Mello
Amare - Mello

Excluding age/injury potential I would take the non Mello side of all those trades.

Excluding age and injury I would take a healthy T-Mac over most of those guys. What does that prove? Those guys arent avaialable, Melo is.

A prime T-Mac > Kobe

no f'g way. a prime t-mac was a regular season johnny with zero - count 'em zero - stones in the playoffs.

Thanks to Grant Hill collecting dust on the bench while McGrady destroyed his body. I dont recall Kobe doing much without a second star.

his one year with yao at 80 games in hou resulted in the same, 1 and dun.

AnubisADL wrote:

OldFan wrote:I don't see Mello as a top five player.
Which of these trades do you think would favor the team getting Mello?
Lebron - Mello
Kobe - Mello
Wade - Mello
Durant - Mello
Howard - Mello
Paul - Mello
Nowitzki - Mello
Nash - Mello
D Williams - Mello
Amare - Mello

Excluding age/injury potential I would take the non Mello side of all those trades.

Excluding age and injury I would take a healthy T-Mac over most of those guys. What does that prove? Those guys arent avaialable, Melo is.

A prime T-Mac > Kobe

Doesn't prove anything. I just wanted to know what people thought of Mello relative to the players mentioned.