[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Please Donnie, no more savior schemes & 2012 plans... just keep amassing assets
Author Thread
EwingsGlass
Posts: 27517
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 4/29/2005
Member: #893
USA
7/13/2010  11:35 AM
Clearly the Jeffries trade did not clear all $37M in cap space. It cleared about $10M. We had room for 1.5 Max free agents since the Crawford/ZBO trades. With cap holds in consideration, the extra $10M in cap space allow us to sign a max free agent without renouncing our rights to David Lee. Could we have pulled it off without the trade? I think it is too close to call (the difference is in the thousands not millions of dollars). Nobody should be saying the TMAC trade was the biggest trade victory in the history of the Knicks-- all I am saying is it added to flexibility which allowed us to make a series of moves this offseason and have the ability to offer two max contracts (and get rejected by a number of FAs).
You know I gonna spin wit it
AUTOADVERT
martin
Posts: 76337
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
7/13/2010  11:36 AM
TMS wrote:
martin wrote:
MS wrote:I don't know about the value of the TMAC trade. Don Nelson is the guy we should be thanking. He time and time again proves he is clueless with talent evaluation. He did it with CWebb and I think has done it with AR. I think the stars aligned just right for us not to lose Lee and have a great package we shouldn't have gotten. Sometimes it works that way, I'm glad we finaly got a little luck. Like Johnson getting overpaid. The Knicks were going full force on that one. Again sometimes it comes down to luck.

you don't have one without the other. Nobody taking on Jefferies at this time of year. TMac allowed us to be in position for Don Nelson maneuver.

how do you figure? we had the cap space to make a non-equitable monetary trade w/o making the T-Mac deal... first we were able to sign Amare because of the T-Mac trade, now we were able to trade Lee for AR because of the T-Mac deal... i suppose any player we get from now on was all made possible by the T-Mac trade? if Melo signs here in 2011, people will be arguing that the T-Mac trade made that possible... come on.

blah blah, refer to the many other threads about the numbers. I am talking about the full Amare acquisition+GSW trade. One or the other but not both without JJ and Hill going.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
TMS
Posts: 60684
Alba Posts: 617
Joined: 5/11/2004
Member: #674
USA
7/13/2010  11:36 AM
Paladin55 wrote:The team that Walsh has put together as of today is probably the most interesting one in terms of its mix of older (but not really old) talent, younger talent, and talented role players, that we have had for years

i agree w/u on that... this roster has more balance than any one we've had for the past several years... we finally have some shotblockers up front, we finally have a real PG, we finally have a stud player we can build around & some good young talent around him... i can't complain at all about the end product at this point... just wish we had been able to hold onto the rights to our next 2 picks, but hopefully we learn a lesson from our mistakes instead of repeating them again... just need to be smart from here on out & stop throwing away young talent & future picks for a hope & a prayer at landing a big fish in free agency... having tradeable assets is a much better way to go about trying to land that big fish... teams rarely go wrong by amassing good young talent.

After 7 years & 40K+ posts, banned by martin for calling Nalod a 'moron'. Awesome.
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
7/13/2010  11:38 AM
The TMac trade is like a religious argument at this point. What's important is that DONNIE thought it was necessary and in the end we had not only enough to make all the moves he made but some cap left over. DW has really made a great effort to balance the roster which makes it clear he's built a team and not just collecting for some future move. This is a good young roster full of upside.

The big diff from previous yrs is that we're solid up the middle. Felt and Amare is a MAJOR upgrade and will give us consistency from game to game.

TMS
Posts: 60684
Alba Posts: 617
Joined: 5/11/2004
Member: #674
USA
7/13/2010  11:46 AM
martin wrote:
TMS wrote:
martin wrote:
MS wrote:I don't know about the value of the TMAC trade. Don Nelson is the guy we should be thanking. He time and time again proves he is clueless with talent evaluation. He did it with CWebb and I think has done it with AR. I think the stars aligned just right for us not to lose Lee and have a great package we shouldn't have gotten. Sometimes it works that way, I'm glad we finaly got a little luck. Like Johnson getting overpaid. The Knicks were going full force on that one. Again sometimes it comes down to luck.

you don't have one without the other. Nobody taking on Jefferies at this time of year. TMac allowed us to be in position for Don Nelson maneuver.

how do you figure? we had the cap space to make a non-equitable monetary trade w/o making the T-Mac deal... first we were able to sign Amare because of the T-Mac trade, now we were able to trade Lee for AR because of the T-Mac deal... i suppose any player we get from now on was all made possible by the T-Mac trade? if Melo signs here in 2011, people will be arguing that the T-Mac trade made that possible... come on.

blah blah, refer to the many other threads about the numbers. I am talking about the full Amare acquisition+GSW trade. One or the other but not both without JJ and Hill going.

keep on spinning... even if we add Fishlips & J Hill's salaries back on this roster, we're still $2M under the cap... but oh, we would have missed out on Ray Felton... who the hell cares?

After 7 years & 40K+ posts, banned by martin for calling Nalod a 'moron'. Awesome.
alau53
Posts: 20324
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2006
Member: #1147

7/13/2010  11:49 AM    LAST EDITED: 7/13/2010  11:55 AM
TMS wrote:
martin wrote:
MS wrote:I don't know about the value of the TMAC trade. Don Nelson is the guy we should be thanking. He time and time again proves he is clueless with talent evaluation. He did it with CWebb and I think has done it with AR. I think the stars aligned just right for us not to lose Lee and have a great package we shouldn't have gotten. Sometimes it works that way, I'm glad we finaly got a little luck. Like Johnson getting overpaid. The Knicks were going full force on that one. Again sometimes it comes down to luck.

you don't have one without the other. Nobody taking on Jefferies at this time of year. TMac allowed us to be in position for Don Nelson maneuver.

how do you figure? we had the cap space to make a non-equitable monetary trade w/o making the T-Mac deal... first we were able to sign Amare because of the T-Mac trade, now we were able to trade Lee for AR because of the T-Mac deal... i suppose any player we get from now on was all made possible by the T-Mac trade? if Melo signs here in 2011, people will be arguing that the T-Mac trade made that possible... come on.

have always agreed with you tms and continue to do so..it is our belief that if we didnt make the tmac trade we'd have the same team as constituted today plus valuable assets in j hill, our own 2011 draft pick instead of a possible lower houston pick, our 2012 draft pick, and an expiring jeffries contract..and if we needed to clear cap space to sign felton we would have been able to trade hill for a future 1st rd pick...im not saying jordan hill is or is going to be a good player but u have to agree that having him is an asset and would have given donnie more flexibility baby

fishmike
Posts: 53858
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
7/13/2010  11:51 AM
nixluva wrote:The TMac trade is like a religious argument at this point. What's important is that DONNIE thought it was necessary and in the end we had not only enough to make all the moves he made but some cap left over. DW has really made a great effort to balance the roster which makes it clear he's built a team and not just collecting for some future move. This is a good young roster full of upside.

The big diff from previous yrs is that we're solid up the middle. Felt and Amare is a MAJOR upgrade and will give us consistency from game to game.

I mean thats it... its all about finding the right parts. People hold onto that trade for what? Jordan Hill? If anything that trade speaks volumes about what a good GM Walsh is. Every GM makes mistakes. Walsh made a mistake w/ Hill. It was a bad choice and the wrong choice. So he purged it along w/ a top 5 protected pick, cleared about another $9mm in cap space and turned that into better players that better fit our system.

The whole roster is rebuild with size, skill and youth and 2-way players that fit into the coaches style of play. The TMac trade was part of what made that happen, along w/ the Zach trade, Crawford trade, etc.

You can focus on that, or you can focus on Anthony Robertson or Jordan Hill. Rockets (swap) are looking like a lottery team right now. We are better and deeper than them and the other pick is top 5 protected.

My favorite is when people talk about 3-4 draft picks we gave up. I count one... but hey, we all know I am on the slow side

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
TMS
Posts: 60684
Alba Posts: 617
Joined: 5/11/2004
Member: #674
USA
7/13/2010  12:05 PM    LAST EDITED: 7/13/2010  12:09 PM
alau53 wrote:
TMS wrote:
martin wrote:
MS wrote:I don't know about the value of the TMAC trade. Don Nelson is the guy we should be thanking. He time and time again proves he is clueless with talent evaluation. He did it with CWebb and I think has done it with AR. I think the stars aligned just right for us not to lose Lee and have a great package we shouldn't have gotten. Sometimes it works that way, I'm glad we finaly got a little luck. Like Johnson getting overpaid. The Knicks were going full force on that one. Again sometimes it comes down to luck.

you don't have one without the other. Nobody taking on Jefferies at this time of year. TMac allowed us to be in position for Don Nelson maneuver.

how do you figure? we had the cap space to make a non-equitable monetary trade w/o making the T-Mac deal... first we were able to sign Amare because of the T-Mac trade, now we were able to trade Lee for AR because of the T-Mac deal... i suppose any player we get from now on was all made possible by the T-Mac trade? if Melo signs here in 2011, people will be arguing that the T-Mac trade made that possible... come on.

have always agreed with you tms and continue to do so..it is our belief that if we didnt make the tmac trade we'd have the same team as constituted today plus valuable assets in j hill, our own 2011 draft pick instead of a possible lower houston pick, our 2012 draft pick, and an expiring jeffries contract..and if we needed to clear cap space to sign felton we would have been able to trade hill for a future 1st rd pick...im not saying jordan hill is or is going to be a good player but u have to agree that having him is an asset and would have given donnie more flexibility baby

i don't understand why it's so hard for people to just admit Donnie made a mistake by giving away assets for a glimmer of a chance at signing Lebron this summer... it's like they've grown so used to lambasting anyone who had anything critical to say about that highly questionable move for the past few months they just refuse to acknowledge anyone for having been justified in doubting the move from the very beginning.

anyway, the point of this thread isn't to argue the T-Mac trade for the 100000th time... it's to map out a reasonable plan for the future now that we have the cap flexibility & the young assets to finally build a real team... no more giving away assets for a 1 in a million shot at banging Adriana Lima... build up the core, develop the young talent & see what develops from there.

After 7 years & 40K+ posts, banned by martin for calling Nalod a 'moron'. Awesome.
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
7/13/2010  12:25 PM
TMS wrote:
alau53 wrote:
TMS wrote:
martin wrote:
MS wrote:I don't know about the value of the TMAC trade. Don Nelson is the guy we should be thanking. He time and time again proves he is clueless with talent evaluation. He did it with CWebb and I think has done it with AR. I think the stars aligned just right for us not to lose Lee and have a great package we shouldn't have gotten. Sometimes it works that way, I'm glad we finaly got a little luck. Like Johnson getting overpaid. The Knicks were going full force on that one. Again sometimes it comes down to luck.

you don't have one without the other. Nobody taking on Jefferies at this time of year. TMac allowed us to be in position for Don Nelson maneuver.

how do you figure? we had the cap space to make a non-equitable monetary trade w/o making the T-Mac deal... first we were able to sign Amare because of the T-Mac trade, now we were able to trade Lee for AR because of the T-Mac deal... i suppose any player we get from now on was all made possible by the T-Mac trade? if Melo signs here in 2011, people will be arguing that the T-Mac trade made that possible... come on.

have always agreed with you tms and continue to do so..it is our belief that if we didnt make the tmac trade we'd have the same team as constituted today plus valuable assets in j hill, our own 2011 draft pick instead of a possible lower houston pick, our 2012 draft pick, and an expiring jeffries contract..and if we needed to clear cap space to sign felton we would have been able to trade hill for a future 1st rd pick...im not saying jordan hill is or is going to be a good player but u have to agree that having him is an asset and would have given donnie more flexibility baby

i don't understand why it's so hard for people to just admit Donnie made a mistake by giving away assets for a glimmer of a chance at signing Lebron this summer... it's like they've grown so used to lambasting anyone who had anything critical to say about that highly questionable move for the past few months they just refuse to acknowledge anyone for having been justified in doubting the move from the very beginning.

anyway, the point of this thread isn't to argue the T-Mac trade for the 100000th time... it's to map out a reasonable plan for the future now that we have the cap flexibility & the young assets to finally build a real team... no more giving away assets for a 1 in a million shot at banging Adriana Lima... build up the core, develop the young talent & see what develops from there.


Just cuz you don't want the shot at Lima doesn't mean it's dumb to take a shot! You don't know that maybe she has a bad break up and is real emotional thus ready to get with you on the rebound

While I was laying next to her I wouldn't be thinking about the crap I gave up or how risky it may have seemed. I'd be smilin as I smell her hair with her head on my chest.

TMS
Posts: 60684
Alba Posts: 617
Joined: 5/11/2004
Member: #674
USA
7/13/2010  12:27 PM
nixluva wrote:
TMS wrote:
alau53 wrote:
TMS wrote:
martin wrote:
MS wrote:I don't know about the value of the TMAC trade. Don Nelson is the guy we should be thanking. He time and time again proves he is clueless with talent evaluation. He did it with CWebb and I think has done it with AR. I think the stars aligned just right for us not to lose Lee and have a great package we shouldn't have gotten. Sometimes it works that way, I'm glad we finaly got a little luck. Like Johnson getting overpaid. The Knicks were going full force on that one. Again sometimes it comes down to luck.

you don't have one without the other. Nobody taking on Jefferies at this time of year. TMac allowed us to be in position for Don Nelson maneuver.

how do you figure? we had the cap space to make a non-equitable monetary trade w/o making the T-Mac deal... first we were able to sign Amare because of the T-Mac trade, now we were able to trade Lee for AR because of the T-Mac deal... i suppose any player we get from now on was all made possible by the T-Mac trade? if Melo signs here in 2011, people will be arguing that the T-Mac trade made that possible... come on.

have always agreed with you tms and continue to do so..it is our belief that if we didnt make the tmac trade we'd have the same team as constituted today plus valuable assets in j hill, our own 2011 draft pick instead of a possible lower houston pick, our 2012 draft pick, and an expiring jeffries contract..and if we needed to clear cap space to sign felton we would have been able to trade hill for a future 1st rd pick...im not saying jordan hill is or is going to be a good player but u have to agree that having him is an asset and would have given donnie more flexibility baby

i don't understand why it's so hard for people to just admit Donnie made a mistake by giving away assets for a glimmer of a chance at signing Lebron this summer... it's like they've grown so used to lambasting anyone who had anything critical to say about that highly questionable move for the past few months they just refuse to acknowledge anyone for having been justified in doubting the move from the very beginning.

anyway, the point of this thread isn't to argue the T-Mac trade for the 100000th time... it's to map out a reasonable plan for the future now that we have the cap flexibility & the young assets to finally build a real team... no more giving away assets for a 1 in a million shot at banging Adriana Lima... build up the core, develop the young talent & see what develops from there.


Just cuz you don't want the shot at Lima doesn't mean it's dumb to take a shot! You don't know that maybe she has a bad break up and is real emotional thus ready to get with you on the rebound

While I was laying next to her I wouldn't be thinking about the crap I gave up or how risky it may have seemed. I'd be smilin as I smell her hair with her head on my chest.

the closest you'd get to laying next to Adriana Lima & smelling her hair is spreading out a Victoria's Secret catalog on your bed & spritzing some perfume on it... pretty much as close we came to landing Lebron this summer.

After 7 years & 40K+ posts, banned by martin for calling Nalod a 'moron'. Awesome.
EwingsGlass
Posts: 27517
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 4/29/2005
Member: #893
USA
7/13/2010  12:39 PM
You guys need to get more action.
You know I gonna spin wit it
martin
Posts: 76337
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
7/13/2010  12:45 PM
EwingsGlass wrote:You guys need to get more action.

LOL

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
Paladin55
Posts: 24321
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2008
Member: #2098

7/13/2010  1:16 PM
TMS wrote:
nixluva wrote:

Just cuz you don't want the shot at Lima doesn't mean it's dumb to take a shot! You don't know that maybe she has a bad break up and is real emotional thus ready to get with you on the rebound

While I was laying next to her I wouldn't be thinking about the crap I gave up or how risky it may have seemed. I'd be smilin as I smell her hair with her head on my chest.

the closest you'd get to laying next to Adriana Lima & smelling her hair is spreading out a Victoria's Secret catalog on your bed & spritzing some perfume on it... pretty much as close we came to landing Lebron this summer.

If we had made the trade being talked about a couple of years ago, and picked up Darko and Marko Jaric, people around here would have at least had a chance of brushing up against her at the Garden, but rubbing up against her butt while you try to get by her to your seat is about as close as you would get to someone like her.

No man is happy without a delusion of some kind. Delusions are as necessary to our happiness as realities- C.N. Bovee
93BUICK
Posts: 22281
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 10/6/2006
Member: #1175
USA
7/13/2010  1:20 PM
I'm ok with having Felton instead of JJ2 and Jordan Hill. I like the team as it is and it will be easy for me to root for, and everyone is fairly young. I'm ok with how it worked out and I'm glad LeBron isn't going to be in the NY papers everyday. I'm fine w all of it.
If you are still following the team and reading sites like this, there is nothing, short of your own demise, that is going to throw you off this train.
Nalod
Posts: 71247
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
7/13/2010  1:26 PM
IN the end things smooth themselves out. WE never know the true values of trades but instead need to look at the body of work.

The sign and trade Lee for Golden state was a great deal and could be a steal of AR turns to be the real deal. IN fact so much that one completed piece could be all that is needed. Or, He becomes a huge trade chip!

Having young talent gets you in prime players.

I think waht donnie is saying is no more starphuching but if a opportunity arises we are ABLE.

Win win!!!!

The franchise has been rebooted.

misterearl
Posts: 38786
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/16/2004
Member: #799
USA
7/13/2010  1:51 PM
Donnie On Donnie

“When you finish this, don’t go out and say a name and then for two years or one year, we’re all focused on that one name,” Walsh said. “The guys I’m bringing in here now are meant to come here and stay here. In other words, they’re the kinds of players that you want even if you did have the cap flexibility to go out and get another player, so it isn’t like everyone should be looking over their shoulders. I think the days of just basically making deals for cap space, for the most part, are over.”

once a knick always a knick
TMS
Posts: 60684
Alba Posts: 617
Joined: 5/11/2004
Member: #674
USA
7/13/2010  4:38 PM
Nalod wrote:Having young talent gets you in prime players.

that's how i feel... that's our best road towards getting this franchise back to where we want it to be.

After 7 years & 40K+ posts, banned by martin for calling Nalod a 'moron'. Awesome.
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
7/13/2010  4:48 PM
It's clear that Donnie was more prepared for Lebron not coming than any thought. He's been saying for years that it wasn't just about Lebron. He proved it after "The Decision" and it's a blessing in disguise. The expectations are lower for the kids, but they have the kind of talent to easily exceed those expectations. Plus it's not all on one guy, so much that if that guy gets hurt we're screwed.

I like the idea of watching this young team come together and I think the overall talent level is pretty good. We still don't have the identifiable star on the perimeter that you usually associate with title contenders, but we're more like Orlando. A team with an All Star or 2 and a bunch of good players that fit well.

alau53
Posts: 20324
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/6/2006
Member: #1147

7/13/2010  9:04 PM
now we'll have something to look forward to after the yankees win #28 and the jets and jints start the season off 6-1 and 5-2 respectfully
Please Donnie, no more savior schemes & 2012 plans... just keep amassing assets

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy