Posted by Bonn1997:
I think if Isiah called her a bitch, that's awful. I don't have a problem with him saying it was "less offensive" for a black to call a black that name. He was giving his honest opinion and he even acknowledged it was an opinion he felt uncomfortable with. (I think he said something along the lines of he was "sorry to say" he felt that way.) It was poor judgment to say this publicly, though. You should deal with your own issues in private. The "less offensive" comment is not criminal by any means though!
I agree with this but never would have said that publicly. Some things are not for everyoe to know, and become divisive.
I think with the Imus thing, and people making the comparison, they are missing some very important things:
1. Imus was on National TV (kids could have heard what he said, millions of people heard it)
2. Imus is a respected guy by many politicians and listeners, he is a tastemaker, he influences people in terms of how to frame current events and who to vote for, what book to buy, he is someone to be taken seriously (at times).
3. Isiah is a basketbal coach, he plays an administrative role in a bball team, no one cares what he says or thinks about things.
4. What Imus said was both sexist and racist, while what Isiah said was sexist. Because of the history of this country, racism is a much bigger deal than sexism is.
6. The desire to have someone held accountable the way Imus was, showcases a vindictiveness that has its roots elsewhere. The folks who get amped about comparing this (or anything) to Imus aren't feminist's who champion women's rights, so where exactly does the motivation come from? How is it that now we have all of these guys taking a position on sexism as if they were members of NOW (National Organization for Women)? Does anybody want to take a stab at why this is so?
But lastly, Imus lost his job as a result of several things not just one. Its not like he said it and then he gets fired. Political pressure was applied, and his sponsors did not want to be associated with the controversy (as always happens) and they pulled out. Also many coworkers (on MSNBC) of his spoke out either in favor of them releasing him, or other coworkers who were his friends remained silent. All of this added pressure to the general public shock and outrage. Race is a hot button issue. Which is what makes what Isiah said so incredibly dumb, although I totally understand where hes coming from.
Let me put it like this: If Isiah worked for a show that was held afloat by sponsors, and women's organizations came out against him with force, and friends and coworkers were silent or called for his ouster, things would just like they were for Imus.
Now for context you guys should read this article, its really really good from TIME (they end up making many of the points I made):
http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1609490-4,00.html
Imus argued repeatedly that his critics should consider the "context" of his larger life...what determines who can make what jokes is the context of their work: the tone of their acts, the personas they present, the vehicles they create for their work.
That context is not as kind to Imus. He comes out of the shock jock tradition, but all shock jocks are not created equal. If Opie & Anthony or Mancow had made the "nappy-headed" comment, it wouldn't have been a blip because future Presidents do not do cable-news interviews with Opie & Anthony and Mancow.
and I think thats the critical part. He is held to a higher standard because he is at a higher position with more privaleges and more overall legitimacy than others in his field. Isiah Thomas, isnt even in his stratosphere in terms of importance on any level.