[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

ot - colangelo expected to win exec of the year
Author Thread
islesfan
Posts: 9999
Alba Posts: 37
Joined: 7/19/2004
Member: #712
5/14/2007  2:02 PM
Remember that question about who else would be available to come to the Knicks, if they had gotten rid of Isiah, and could have done a better job?
If it didn’t work in Phoenix with Nash and Stoutamire... it’s just not a winning formula. It’s an entertaining formula, but not a winning one. - Derek Harper talking about D'Antoni's System
AUTOADVERT
Nalod
Posts: 72408
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
5/14/2007  2:04 PM
No doubt Marion does some wonderful things but if they don't win this year Sarver is not going over the cap to keep it together.

and if you don't win it then its obvious changes need to be made.

I don't have the imagination with Marion and all those picks what the team can accomplish is reworking SOME of the pieces.

I have read they could trade Amare for Oden and rebuild. Its possible this team if not this year could ever win it and its better to retool on the fly when your at such a high level.

I did not say rebuild, just retool. Interesting prospects.
Nalod
Posts: 72408
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
5/14/2007  2:04 PM
No doubt Marion does some wonderful things but if they don't win this year Sarver is not going over the cap to keep it together.

and if you don't win it then its obvious changes need to be made.

I don't have the imagination with Marion and all those picks what the team can accomplish is reworking SOME of the pieces.

I have read they could trade Amare for Oden and rebuild. Its possible this team if not this year could ever win it and its better to retool on the fly when your at such a high level.

I did not say rebuild, just retool. Interesting prospects.
TrueBlue
Posts: 29144
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 9/20/2006
Member: #1172

5/14/2007  2:07 PM
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by Solace:

Marion is considerably better than Deng. I like Deng, but Marion is a complete stud. With Marion, the Suns likely will win a few championships before it's said and done. Without him, nope.

Like Bonn said, his playoff stats are equivalent. I would trade Curry and Lee to get Marion and consider that we'd have highly improved the Knicks, for example.

Yeah, if the Suns were a 39 win rebuilding team, the Deng/Marion trade would make sense because of the age differences. But the Suns are a perennial contender. They can't afford to downgrade from Marion to Deng. (And Deng is a very good player; he's just not at Marion's level.)


Hmmmmmmmm let's see how far off Deng is from Marion

Deng 22yrs of age salary $3,320,338
06-07 Chi 82gms 37.5min 7.7-14.9fga .517fg% 0.0-0.1(3)pta .143(3)pt% 3.4-4.4fta .777ft% 1.2stls 0.6blks 1.9TO's 2.0PF 1.8ORB 5.3DRB 7.1REB 2.5ast 18.8pts

Marion 29yrs of age salary $16,440,000
06-07 Pho 80gms 37.6min 7.0-13.4fga .524fg% 1.0-3.1(3)pta .317(3)pt% 2.5-3.1fta .810ft% 2.0stls 1.5blks 1.4TO's 2.7PF 2.2ORB 7.7DRB 9.8REB 1.7ast 17.5pts


Marion is the better defender but not by a whole lot. Deng is the better offensive player inside the arc. Marion shoots a higher% but he's playing with Nash. Meanwhile Deng is shooting just as high a % doing most of his damage with a midrange game. If you look at Deng's career stats he's steadily improving across the board. Meanwhile Marion has peaked. Then when you factor in age and salary it would be a no brainer for me to do this trade. Of course other things need to be involved to make it work but I'd do it.


[Edited by - TrueBlue on 05-14-2007 1:09 PM]
LMFAO @ the Bio [url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephon_Marbury[/url]
TrueBlue
Posts: 29144
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 9/20/2006
Member: #1172

5/14/2007  2:12 PM
Posted by BlueSeats:

I think Marion does for the Suns what a healthy K-Mart did for the Nets (toughness, rebounds, defense, intangiables, swagger, easy dunks, etc).

The Nets are worse with Vince than with Mart.

Now if the Suns could get Joe Johnson back...

While that may be true the Suns went pretty far in the playoffs last yr with Marion having one of his most horrible performances ever meanwhile Diaw, Bell, and Barbosa were cutting it up. That's why Marion was on the trade table this off-season in hopes of them landing Rashard Lewis. Playoffs should be about elevating your game from regular season, most great players do that. They don't stay the same. Marion is a good player but the time is ripe to trade him. Just don't make a stupid trade if you do.
LMFAO @ the Bio [url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephon_Marbury[/url]
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
5/14/2007  2:13 PM
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by Solace:

Marion is considerably better than Deng. I like Deng, but Marion is a complete stud. With Marion, the Suns likely will win a few championships before it's said and done. Without him, nope.

Like Bonn said, his playoff stats are equivalent. I would trade Curry and Lee to get Marion and consider that we'd have highly improved the Knicks, for example.

Yeah, if the Suns were a 39 win rebuilding team, the Deng/Marion trade would make sense because of the age differences. But the Suns are a perennial contender. They can't afford to downgrade from Marion to Deng. (And Deng is a very good player; he's just not at Marion's level.)


Hmmmmmmmm let's see how far off Deng is from Marion

Deng 22yrs of age salary $3,320,338
06-07 Chi 82gms 37.5min 7.7-14.9fga .517fg% 0.0-0.1(3)pta .143(3)pt% 3.4-4.4fta .777ft% 1.2stls 0.6blks 1.9TO's 2.0PF 1.8ORB 5.3DRB 7.1REB 2.5ast 18.8pts

Marion 29yrs of age salary $16,440,000
06-07 Pho 80gms 37.6min 7.0-13.4fga .524fg% 1.0-3.1(3)pta .317(3)pt% 2.5-3.1fta .810ft% 2.0stls 1.5blks 1.4TO's 2.7PF 2.2ORB 7.7DRB 9.8REB 1.7ast 17.5pts


Marion is the better defender but not by a whole lot. Deng is the better offensive player inside the arc. Marion shoots a higher% but he's playing with Nash. Meanwhile Deng is shooting just as high a % doing most of his damage with a midrange game. If you look at Deng's career stats he's steadily improving across the board. Meanwhile Marion has peaked. Then when you factor in age and salary it would be a no brainer for me to do this trade. Of course other things need to be involved to make it work but I'd do it.


[Edited by - TrueBlue on 05-14-2007 1:09 PM]

Deng is 3 rbs, 1 stl, and 1 block lower than Marion. Meanwhile, Marion averages the same number of points as Deng *without ever having calls played for him* and plays better defense than Deng as you indicated. All these differences combined are not minor.
TrueBlue
Posts: 29144
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 9/20/2006
Member: #1172

5/14/2007  2:21 PM
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by Solace:

Marion is considerably better than Deng. I like Deng, but Marion is a complete stud. With Marion, the Suns likely will win a few championships before it's said and done. Without him, nope.

Like Bonn said, his playoff stats are equivalent. I would trade Curry and Lee to get Marion and consider that we'd have highly improved the Knicks, for example.

Yeah, if the Suns were a 39 win rebuilding team, the Deng/Marion trade would make sense because of the age differences. But the Suns are a perennial contender. They can't afford to downgrade from Marion to Deng. (And Deng is a very good player; he's just not at Marion's level.)


Hmmmmmmmm let's see how far off Deng is from Marion

Deng 22yrs of age salary $3,320,338
06-07 Chi 82gms 37.5min 7.7-14.9fga .517fg% 0.0-0.1(3)pta .143(3)pt% 3.4-4.4fta .777ft% 1.2stls 0.6blks 1.9TO's 2.0PF 1.8ORB 5.3DRB 7.1REB 2.5ast 18.8pts

Marion 29yrs of age salary $16,440,000
06-07 Pho 80gms 37.6min 7.0-13.4fga .524fg% 1.0-3.1(3)pta .317(3)pt% 2.5-3.1fta .810ft% 2.0stls 1.5blks 1.4TO's 2.7PF 2.2ORB 7.7DRB 9.8REB 1.7ast 17.5pts


Marion is the better defender but not by a whole lot. Deng is the better offensive player inside the arc. Marion shoots a higher% but he's playing with Nash. Meanwhile Deng is shooting just as high a % doing most of his damage with a midrange game. If you look at Deng's career stats he's steadily improving across the board. Meanwhile Marion has peaked. Then when you factor in age and salary it would be a no brainer for me to do this trade. Of course other things need to be involved to make it work but I'd do it.


[Edited by - TrueBlue on 05-14-2007 1:09 PM]

Deng is 3 rbs, 1 stl, and 1 block lower than Marion. Meanwhile, Marion averages the same number of points as Deng *without ever having calls played for him* and plays better defense than Deng as you indicated. All these differences combined are not minor.



And neither is $3mil vs $16.5mil, neither is 22yrs of age vs 29yrs of age. I'm giving Deng upside potential in that he's capable of providing very close to what Marion has given. Let's be honest how much longer do they need to keep him around, he's given them his best. If Deng played with Nash his numbers go up easily and it's not like Deng lacks athleticism to complement their open court game.
LMFAO @ the Bio [url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephon_Marbury[/url]
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
5/14/2007  2:24 PM
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by Solace:

Marion is considerably better than Deng. I like Deng, but Marion is a complete stud. With Marion, the Suns likely will win a few championships before it's said and done. Without him, nope.

Like Bonn said, his playoff stats are equivalent. I would trade Curry and Lee to get Marion and consider that we'd have highly improved the Knicks, for example.

Yeah, if the Suns were a 39 win rebuilding team, the Deng/Marion trade would make sense because of the age differences. But the Suns are a perennial contender. They can't afford to downgrade from Marion to Deng. (And Deng is a very good player; he's just not at Marion's level.)


Hmmmmmmmm let's see how far off Deng is from Marion

Deng 22yrs of age salary $3,320,338
06-07 Chi 82gms 37.5min 7.7-14.9fga .517fg% 0.0-0.1(3)pta .143(3)pt% 3.4-4.4fta .777ft% 1.2stls 0.6blks 1.9TO's 2.0PF 1.8ORB 5.3DRB 7.1REB 2.5ast 18.8pts

Marion 29yrs of age salary $16,440,000
06-07 Pho 80gms 37.6min 7.0-13.4fga .524fg% 1.0-3.1(3)pta .317(3)pt% 2.5-3.1fta .810ft% 2.0stls 1.5blks 1.4TO's 2.7PF 2.2ORB 7.7DRB 9.8REB 1.7ast 17.5pts


Marion is the better defender but not by a whole lot. Deng is the better offensive player inside the arc. Marion shoots a higher% but he's playing with Nash. Meanwhile Deng is shooting just as high a % doing most of his damage with a midrange game. If you look at Deng's career stats he's steadily improving across the board. Meanwhile Marion has peaked. Then when you factor in age and salary it would be a no brainer for me to do this trade. Of course other things need to be involved to make it work but I'd do it.


[Edited by - TrueBlue on 05-14-2007 1:09 PM]

Deng is 3 rbs, 1 stl, and 1 block lower than Marion. Meanwhile, Marion averages the same number of points as Deng *without ever having calls played for him* and plays better defense than Deng as you indicated. All these differences combined are not minor.



And neither is $3mil vs $16.5mil, neither is 22yrs of age vs 29yrs of age. I'm giving Deng upside potential in that he's capable of providing very close to what Marion has given. Let's be honest how much longer do they need to keep him around, he's given them his best. If Deng played with Nash his numbers go up easily and it's not like Deng lacks athleticism to complement their open court game.
Then he'll be making $16.5 soon too

TrueBlue
Posts: 29144
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 9/20/2006
Member: #1172

5/14/2007  2:32 PM
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by Solace:

Marion is considerably better than Deng. I like Deng, but Marion is a complete stud. With Marion, the Suns likely will win a few championships before it's said and done. Without him, nope.

Like Bonn said, his playoff stats are equivalent. I would trade Curry and Lee to get Marion and consider that we'd have highly improved the Knicks, for example.

Yeah, if the Suns were a 39 win rebuilding team, the Deng/Marion trade would make sense because of the age differences. But the Suns are a perennial contender. They can't afford to downgrade from Marion to Deng. (And Deng is a very good player; he's just not at Marion's level.)


Hmmmmmmmm let's see how far off Deng is from Marion

Deng 22yrs of age salary $3,320,338
06-07 Chi 82gms 37.5min 7.7-14.9fga .517fg% 0.0-0.1(3)pta .143(3)pt% 3.4-4.4fta .777ft% 1.2stls 0.6blks 1.9TO's 2.0PF 1.8ORB 5.3DRB 7.1REB 2.5ast 18.8pts

Marion 29yrs of age salary $16,440,000
06-07 Pho 80gms 37.6min 7.0-13.4fga .524fg% 1.0-3.1(3)pta .317(3)pt% 2.5-3.1fta .810ft% 2.0stls 1.5blks 1.4TO's 2.7PF 2.2ORB 7.7DRB 9.8REB 1.7ast 17.5pts


Marion is the better defender but not by a whole lot. Deng is the better offensive player inside the arc. Marion shoots a higher% but he's playing with Nash. Meanwhile Deng is shooting just as high a % doing most of his damage with a midrange game. If you look at Deng's career stats he's steadily improving across the board. Meanwhile Marion has peaked. Then when you factor in age and salary it would be a no brainer for me to do this trade. Of course other things need to be involved to make it work but I'd do it.


[Edited by - TrueBlue on 05-14-2007 1:09 PM]

Deng is 3 rbs, 1 stl, and 1 block lower than Marion. Meanwhile, Marion averages the same number of points as Deng *without ever having calls played for him* and plays better defense than Deng as you indicated. All these differences combined are not minor.



And neither is $3mil vs $16.5mil, neither is 22yrs of age vs 29yrs of age. I'm giving Deng upside potential in that he's capable of providing very close to what Marion has given. Let's be honest how much longer do they need to keep him around, he's given them his best. If Deng played with Nash his numbers go up easily and it's not like Deng lacks athleticism to complement their open court game.
Then he'll be making $16.5 soon too


Not necessarily at least not right away when he gets a new deal. His first yr salary will be somewhere around $10-12mil.
LMFAO @ the Bio [url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephon_Marbury[/url]
TheGame
Posts: 26657
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/15/2006
Member: #1154
USA
5/14/2007  3:28 PM
Trading Marion might make some sense if they don't get to the finals. Like some else said, they could draft Brewer with their own pick, and then they could trade Marion to a team with a 5-9 pick and probably get Conley to be PG of the future. They also should be able to get a decent player in return in addition to the pick. They would clear a bunch of cap room and make their team younger.

It really all depends on whether the owner wants to spend the money over the next 2-3 years to make a run at a championship. If you are not going to spend, then you might as well trade Marion while his value is high and you can get alot for him.
Trust the Process
Solace
Posts: 30002
Alba Posts: 20
Joined: 10/30/2003
Member: #479
USA
5/14/2007  3:47 PM
Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.
Wishing everyone well. I enjoyed posting here for a while, but as I matured I realized this forum isn't for me. We all evolve. Thanks for the memories everyone.
playa2
Posts: 34922
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 5/15/2003
Member: #407

5/14/2007  3:49 PM
Posted by djsunyc:
Posted by playa2:

Colangelo would have never gone to Toronto, unless David "the don" Stern guaranteed him the #1 pick overall to pick Italy's Andrais Barganni.

Colangelo went ahead and made two huge moves by looking overseas, signing European free agent forward Jorge Garbajosa and shooting guard/small forward Anthony Parker, an American who starred with the Maccabi Tel Aviv team.

Stern ok'ed it just to bring friendly european ball to the NBA where europeans feel at home in a city as INTERNATIONALLY flavored as Toronto is.

bargnani would not have gone #1 if anybody else had the pick. the raptors only jumped from #4 to #1. it's not like they were late lottery.

That's my point,Toronto had a rep of an organization that didn't care about winning anything so Stern had to guarantee Toronto would have the chance to draft Barganni whether it was 4th or #1.

So in order for Colangelo to agree and come and resurrect the franchise in Canada (brave the cold winters) now known as the European invasion, Stern had to set up a team in the league that the players would fit right in to the city makeup.
Did you know Toronto has a vast amount of Italians living there(perfect draw).


[Edited by - playa2 on 14-05-2007 15:50]
JAMES DOLAN on Isiah : He's a good friend of mine and of the organization and I will continue to solicit his views. He will always have strong ties to me and the team.
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
5/14/2007  3:57 PM
Posted by Solace:

Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.
The Suns have three first round picks including one at #4. They're not far away from a championship (if they don't win it this year) and they have some awesome trade assets with those three picks, which wouldn't even involve compromising their core players. Or they could draft a young stud who's ready to contribute now at #4.

[Edited by - bonn1997 on 05-14-2007 3:58 PM]
TheGame
Posts: 26657
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/15/2006
Member: #1154
USA
5/14/2007  3:59 PM
Posted by Solace:

Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.

I certainly was not trying to suggest that the Suns should trade Marion. I think he is one of the best and most underrated players in the league. I am just commenting that if their owner does not want to spend the money to make another run at a championship, Marion might make the most sense as someone to trade because you can pretty much rebuild your whole team by trading him.
Trust the Process
TrueBlue
Posts: 29144
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 9/20/2006
Member: #1172

5/14/2007  4:18 PM
Posted by Solace:

Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.


Deng will be considerably paid less than Marion even 2 yrs from now with a pay raise. Look Marion is a regular season stud everyone knows this. But he has peaked as a player and his salary continues to escalate. The Suns have been in championship contention for 3yrs now it won't last forever so instead of letting the bottom just fall out for no reason at all trade one of your best assets to trim payroll, help the rebuild process, while taking a chance at possibly remaining highly competitive. No one will want Marion once he's past 30 as much as they may want him now. Besides he's been on the trade block already it's not like this is some shocking idea or something.

[Edited by - TrueBlue on 05-14-2007 3:26 PM]
LMFAO @ the Bio [url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephon_Marbury[/url]
Solace
Posts: 30002
Alba Posts: 20
Joined: 10/30/2003
Member: #479
USA
5/14/2007  4:22 PM
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Solace:

Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.


Deng will be considerably paid less than Marion even 2 yrs from now witha pay raise. Look Marion is a regular season stud everyone knows this. But he has peaked as a player and his salary continues to escalate. The Suns have been in championship contention for 3yrs now it won't last forever so instead of letting the bottom just fall out for no reason at all trade one of your best assets to trim payroll, help the rebuild process, while taking a chance at possibly remaining highly competitive. No one will want Marion once he's past 30 as much as they may want him now. Besides he's been on the trade block already it's not like this is some shocking idea or something.

I doubt he's been on the trade block before. I think that was garbage rumors from garbage journalists.

As I said in my previous post, if you're considering trading Marion, you probably should consider trading at least Nash, as well, since Nash won't win a title without Marion, you might as well get value for Nash while he's at his peak.

But again, difference of opinion, but the Suns are the best team in the league in the eyes of many and have a very good shot at 1-3 titles in the next few seasons. Breaking things up might make some long term or financial sense, but if the ultimate goal is a title, you don't trade Marion. Marion, Nash and Stoudamire is your best shot at a title. Break up that group and your chances decrease (aside from getting a top 5 player in return for one of them).
Wishing everyone well. I enjoyed posting here for a while, but as I matured I realized this forum isn't for me. We all evolve. Thanks for the memories everyone.
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
5/14/2007  4:33 PM
Posted by Solace:
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Solace:

Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.


Deng will be considerably paid less than Marion even 2 yrs from now witha pay raise. Look Marion is a regular season stud everyone knows this. But he has peaked as a player and his salary continues to escalate. The Suns have been in championship contention for 3yrs now it won't last forever so instead of letting the bottom just fall out for no reason at all trade one of your best assets to trim payroll, help the rebuild process, while taking a chance at possibly remaining highly competitive. No one will want Marion once he's past 30 as much as they may want him now. Besides he's been on the trade block already it's not like this is some shocking idea or something.

I doubt he's been on the trade block before. I think that was garbage rumors from garbage journalists.

As I said in my previous post, if you're considering trading Marion, you probably should consider trading at least Nash, as well, since Nash won't win a title without Marion, you might as well get value for Nash while he's at his peak.

But again, difference of opinion, but the Suns are the best team in the league in the eyes of many and have a very good shot at 1-3 titles in the next few seasons. Breaking things up might make some long term or financial sense, but if the ultimate goal is a title, you don't trade Marion. Marion, Nash and Stoudamire is your best shot at a title. Break up that group and your chances decrease (aside from getting a top 5 player in return for one of them).
Maybe if they had no more assets and no ways to improve and we're stuck where they, it would make sense to break things up. But that's far from the case. Marion is an extremely effective player and the Suns have outstanding assets to use to get whatever players they need this offseason.

I mean, Nash is paid a huge amount and he's as good as he's going to get too. Why not trade him?
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
5/14/2007  4:34 PM
Posted by Bonn1997:
Posted by Solace:
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Solace:

Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.


Deng will be considerably paid less than Marion even 2 yrs from now witha pay raise. Look Marion is a regular season stud everyone knows this. But he has peaked as a player and his salary continues to escalate. The Suns have been in championship contention for 3yrs now it won't last forever so instead of letting the bottom just fall out for no reason at all trade one of your best assets to trim payroll, help the rebuild process, while taking a chance at possibly remaining highly competitive. No one will want Marion once he's past 30 as much as they may want him now. Besides he's been on the trade block already it's not like this is some shocking idea or something.

I doubt he's been on the trade block before. I think that was garbage rumors from garbage journalists.

As I said in my previous post, if you're considering trading Marion, you probably should consider trading at least Nash, as well, since Nash won't win a title without Marion, you might as well get value for Nash while he's at his peak.

But again, difference of opinion, but the Suns are the best team in the league in the eyes of many and have a very good shot at 1-3 titles in the next few seasons. Breaking things up might make some long term or financial sense, but if the ultimate goal is a title, you don't trade Marion. Marion, Nash and Stoudamire is your best shot at a title. Break up that group and your chances decrease (aside from getting a top 5 player in return for one of them).
Maybe if they had no more assets and no ways to improve and we're stuck where they, it would make sense to break things up. But that's far from the case. Marion is an extremely effective player and the Suns have outstanding assets to use to get whatever players they need this offseason.

I mean, Nash is paid a huge amount and he's as good as he's going to get too. Why not trade him?
Man, it's weird to debate with a sane person! I miss this! All I've been doing lately is arguing with the Curry loving group.
TrueBlue
Posts: 29144
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 9/20/2006
Member: #1172

5/14/2007  4:40 PM
Posted by Solace:
Posted by TrueBlue:
Posted by Solace:

Wow, I can't believe how underrated Marion is on this board. Sure, you could trade Marion, but why? The Suns are extremely close to a championship. If you trade a player for whom you have no hope of getting someone better in return for, you're making it more difficult to win a championship. The money I understand, but as Bonn said, Deng has to get paid too... and Marion is plain better. Those stats show that Deng is good, but Marion is better by a VERY significant margin.

Now rebuilding if you're the Suns is interesting, but you'd have to question that decision. If you want to indulge it, you're talking about trading Marion, Nash and Stoudamire. And if they make those trades, they don't get back equal value. Every team wants to get the level the Suns are at... so they should go for it and try to win some titles. IMHO, they are the best team in the NBA.


Deng will be considerably paid less than Marion even 2 yrs from now witha pay raise. Look Marion is a regular season stud everyone knows this. But he has peaked as a player and his salary continues to escalate. The Suns have been in championship contention for 3yrs now it won't last forever so instead of letting the bottom just fall out for no reason at all trade one of your best assets to trim payroll, help the rebuild process, while taking a chance at possibly remaining highly competitive. No one will want Marion once he's past 30 as much as they may want him now. Besides he's been on the trade block already it's not like this is some shocking idea or something.

I doubt he's been on the trade block before. I think that was garbage rumors from garbage journalists.


As I said in my previous post, if you're considering trading Marion, you probably should consider trading at least Nash, as well, since Nash won't win a title without Marion, you might as well get value for Nash while he's at his peak.

But again, difference of opinion, but the Suns are the best team in the league in the eyes of many and have a very good shot at 1-3 titles in the next few seasons. Breaking things up might make some long term or financial sense, but if the ultimate goal is a title, you don't trade Marion. Marion, Nash and Stoudamire is your best shot at a title. Break up that group and your chances decrease (aside from getting a top 5 player in return for one of them).



Jonathan Givony is a pretty reliable source and this rumor sounded more than legit
Word on the Street: Suns, Sonics Closing in on Deal? (Update:12:55 AM)

by: Jonathan Givony - President
June 24, 2006
Multiple sources told DraftExpress today that the Phoenix Suns and Seattle Supersonics are working on a potential blockbuster trade. The Sonics have implied to numerous people over the past 48 hours that “something is going to go down,” white another source in Seattle told us that the Supersonics are “getting very close” to finalizing a trade.

While the exact details of the trade are still unknown, numerous names have been mentioned as key components. The main ones are Shawn Marion and Rashard Lewis, who would be exchanged along with the team’s first round draft choices (#10 for #27). Other pieces that are being discussed include Leandro Barbosa and Danny Fortson.

Seattle is interested in moving Rashard Lewis due to the fact that they believe he will opt out of his contract next summer and will end up losing him for nothing. With so many concerns about the future of the franchise in Seattle, the best way to put fans in the seats is certainly to start winning more games, which is the primary motive of this trade.

Phoenix’s motive is to avoid the luxury tax for next season, which they are dangerously close to, and still keep the team as competitive as they are now. The Suns still have to extend Boris Diaw for 5 years and anywhere from 45-55 million dollars, which would put them well above the luxury tax threshold. With Leandro Barbosa looking for a contract starting in the 7-8 million dollar range, and Steve Nash, Amare Stoudemire and Shawn Marion making max or near max dollars, keeping their core together past next season does not appear to be very likely. Instead, the Suns can save quite a bit of money in the long term by taking on Rashard Lewis’ more affordable deal and securing an immediate contributor (such as Rodney Carney or Ronnie Brewer) on a cheap 4 year rookie contract. Lewis makes over 5 million dollars less than Marion.

Danny Fortson would be used as filler to make the trade work under the cap. He is an ending contract next year and could either give the Suns more toughness, rebounding and depth, be used as trade bait, or bought out of his contract. That depends on whether or not he can resolve his differences with Jerry Colangelo, whom he sued for defamation in 2004 for calling him a “thug” in the media after breaking Zarko Cabarkapa’s wrist in a game between Dallas and Phoenix.


Now Dantoni came out and shot the rumors down but when doing so he said they were fielding calls on Marion and it wasn't a coincidence that they were looking at a bunch of sf on the draft board at the time of last yr's draft. According to that Seattle/Phx rumor the bottom fell out because players weren't available at the draft positions to make the trades.


Here's an article from Sporting News that speaks on this very subject which makes the idea suitable for discussion and serious consideration.

If the Suns are to stay together, they must win it all
April 13, 2007

Certainly, Dallas has its share of pressure heading into the postseason. Blowing a lead of 2-0 in the Finals will do that to a team, especially when there's the added bonus of having blown a 13-point fourth-quarter lead that would have put the team up, 3-0. But step back and look at the numbers. Seems to me that no team is entering the playoffs with a greater pressure to win than Phoenix. No matter what happens in the playoffs, next year's Mavericks are likely to look a lot like this year's Mavericks. That's not necessarily the case for the Suns.

Just check out the Suns' books. Phoenix is already paying three players eight-figure salaries: Shawn Marion, Amare Stoudemire and Steve Nash. The Suns are fortunate that the eight-figure contracts they pay all belong to All-Stars -- that's not usually the case around the league. But those contracts are just the first layer of a bigger problem. Because of extensions handed out last summer, Phoenix will give big raises to Boris Diaw and Leandro Barbosa next year, from just over $3 million combined to well over $14 million combined.

Suns owner Robert Sarver has expressed his desire to keep the team out of range of the league's dollar-for-dollar luxury tax threshold. Last offseason, Phoenix was so dead-set on avoiding the luxury tax that it gave away two first-round picks. But, without significant alterations, the Suns are headed for an $80 million payroll, which is well over the tax threshold (which is about $65 million this year and should go up a bit next year).

A while back, I asked coach and GM Mike D'Antoni about whether this is a must-win situation for Phoenix, because this team as we know it might not be together much longer. "I know what you're getting at," D'Antoni said. "But that's not necessarily the case. We could have problems with the tax, I know, and like every team, we want to avoid that tax.

"But our owner wants to win a championship. And, you know, once you win a championship, who knows? There's more incentive to spend more. You can be a little looser with the checkbook once you've won a championship."

True, but that still seems to mean that this is a must-win championship for the Suns, to keep this team together. It sounds like Sarver would be willing to sit down and write a tax check only if he were looking at the Larry O'Brien trophy while he was writing. Make no mistake, there is not a lot of fat that can be trimmed to get the Suns under the tax threshold. So when we say keeping this team together, we're talking about the well-paid Nash-Stoudemire-Marion core.

Of course, it won't be the first time that Marion's name has come up in trade rumors. He was a target last summer, until the team made it clear that he would not be traded. But that was likely putting off the inevitable. The Suns, obviously, cannot trade Nash, because he is the hub of this wacky wheel of an offense. They can't trade Stoudemire, because you simply do not trade 24-year-old All-Star power forwards with freakish athleticism. The team will, no doubt, try to move Kurt Thomas -- who has one year left on his contract -- but the $8 million Thomas is to make next year isn't enough to solve Phoenix's tax problem and would be only a very short-term fix.

That's why it's always Marion, who has two years at $33 million left on his contract, who is left to bear the brunt of the trade rumors. Marion is one of the game's best players, of course, an incredible rebounder and great defender on the wing, but he's also more replaceable than Nash and Stoudemire. The Suns can fill in for Marion by trade, plug Boris Diaw into his spot and/or draft a player like Florida's Corey Brewer. Stoudemire can pick up some of the scoring and rebounding slack. That's not a perfect fix, but the team probably would not suffer a tremendous drop-off with that sort of lineup.

A replacement for Marion is still a replacement, and thus a blow to this team. But it's just impossible to see how else this team, from a payroll standpoint, is going to work next year. Unless, of course, they win it all now.

[Edited by - TrueBlue on 05-14-2007 3:42 PM]
LMFAO @ the Bio [url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephon_Marbury[/url]
Solace
Posts: 30002
Alba Posts: 20
Joined: 10/30/2003
Member: #479
USA
5/14/2007  5:04 PM
Perhaps, TrueBlue. I don't trust any journalist when it comes to trade rumors. It seems like nowadays a 'good' journalist is one who only makes up half of what he writes. The article above seemed very speculative, as most do.

I still don't buy it because the logical sense isn't there. And of course the proof is in the pudding, whether they looked to trade Marion or not, he's still a Sun. So, either teams weren't offering market value or the Suns weren't looking to trade him. Fair conclusion, yes? If the Suns were looking to trade him, they should've succeeded, I believe... I mean, what team wouldn't want Marion and be willing to offer a lot to get him? If they were desperate to unload salary, I'm sure he'd be a Knick, worst case. Isiah's always there to give up every expiring in the world and six #1's for Marion. The Suns could've found a taker if they wanted Marion traded.
Wishing everyone well. I enjoyed posting here for a while, but as I matured I realized this forum isn't for me. We all evolve. Thanks for the memories everyone.
ot - colangelo expected to win exec of the year

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy