Posted by bitty41:
I blame Shaq in the kobe feud. Early on Shaq gave Kobe a "this is my team sonny" talk and killed any chance of chemistry. They tried all the big brother crap after that but Shaq's ego was insurmountable, and he knows it, that's why his first order of business upon landing in Miami was to make friends with Wade, tell him he's the best player he's ever played with and it's Wade's team.
And this is a problem because? When your a dominating center in this league especially to the degree Shaq was in his prime ITS YOUR TEAM". Kobe get over yourself this isn't some "im okay your okay" where everyone should be accomdating to Kobe's feelings. If Kobe didn't like it play somewhere else remember this was the same guy who after just coming straight out of High School forced a trade because he did not want to play for the Hornets.
It's a problem because it cast the first stone that broke the team up. Shaq put his ego before the team creating a tension that loomed all the while. As you say, if Kobe didn't like it he could go somewhere else. Well, that's how it went down, so that's what's wrong with it. A dynasty broken. How many dynasties would exist if a team only has room for one star?
Shaq and Kobe weren't going to be winning anymore, Shaq wanted a big extension, Phil wanted one too, and Kobe was a free agent. Too much money was required all at the same time and it just wasn't worth it for such a dysfunctional situation.
I agree but I would have hitched my horse to Shaq and Phil. Let Kobe walk and go after someone else. In reality you could replace him with about 10 other guys and they still could have won 1 or 2 more Championships. Whereas Kobe any superstar with a half amount of sense would not want to play with this guy. Just look at his demeanor on the court yelling at teammates sometimes not even acknowledging them and godforbid you miss him on pass. Lets not forget the stunt he pulled during last year' series against the Suns just totally waving the white flag because he was pissed off at this teammates. Real smooth Kobita.
I would not have rode with Shaq. He'd already established himself as a destructive leader. Plus he's aging and I disagree he's a lock for contention at this point in his career.
Keep in mind, the Lakers got Odom by trading Shaq. Shaq wanted an exhorbitant extension but was not in a walk year (he was not a free agent) so if he wanted out, which he did when he knew an extension wasn't forthcoming, he had to be traded, which got value in return. But Kobe was an FA, and he would have simply walked to the other side of the area and played for the Clippers or the Suns, and the Lakers would have gotten nothing in return.
However poorly Kobe and Odom may mesh they still make the playoffs. But Shaq and Smush, with no Kobe or Odom, I don't think make playoffs. Going for old Shaq at 20M per year only to miss the playoffs would have been a collassal mistake. I'm not even sure Phil would have wanted to coach that, though the situation with the bosses daughter certainly muddies the waters.
For all Kobe's faults, I think he's a better leader at whatever his age is than Shaq was. If the Lakers draft someone as talented as Shaq or Kobe, will Kobe's first order of business be to alienate him? If he does then we can compare his leadership to Shaq's
Shaq I think is not the smartest guy nor do I think he's the most mature guy but bottom line is this when he's on your team (maybe not now since he's reaching retirement) it is going to be a serious threat in the playoffs. Whereas Kobita's leadership puts most of the faults on his teammates. Even these latest comments a great leader wouldn't even make these comments public they would just have a sit down with management and go from there but to publicly come out and say that basically your teammates suck where's the leadership in that?
btw
If the Lakers draft someone as talented as Shaq
Yea okay theres about a 1 and billion chances of anyone coming out thats near Shaq's level during his rookie season. No Mr. Cookie monster Andrew Bynum does not count.
Have you considered their chances of keeping Shaq and drafting a kobe and grooming him for Shaq in his limited window of time?
You like Shaq better than Kobe, I don't. That's cool, but for a myriad of reasons the Lakers felt as I do. But whatever trouble you see for the lakers now I think would have been considerably worse had they rode with Shaq and lost Kobe. That blank look on Shaq's face from the bench when he can't create for himself and the team is losing is more than most fans can bear. Imagine seeing that look 45 games a season while Kobe and Elton brand are hosting the conference finals in your arena.
[Edited by - blueseats on 05-05-2007 5:45 PM]