Posted by islesfan:
Balkman got a DNP-CD
None of last year's rookies started and all got fewer minutes than usual.
If Larry Brown had done that, some of you would have vilified him for it.
Are we building for the future or are we looking to win games with Jerome James getting more minutes than he deserves?
i think there's two sides of the coin. lb did some crazy stuff last year...that i supported. why? b/c i knew the culture here and i knew lb was a prick but his way got results...and most importantly, winning results. so i let alot of stuff he did slide b/c i thought it would be a 5 year plan and lb had to break a few (in our case a TON) of eggs to get going.
alot of people didn't like his methods and didn't understand them. but i feel many didn't take into account the atmosphere of the team, the market, the culture of the organization which starts from the owner on down, and the pressures of gm'ing and coaching in nyc. lb was forcing change. i didn't care about the lineups or any of that BS. i only cared about the direction we were trying to go in over the next 5 years and the culture that was to be developed here. but that didn't fly with alot of folks here and the most important folk in dolan.
so now you have isiah, who the players like, and who, both he and the organization, is operating as if last year was completely lb's fault. everything is right with the team and the organization and the guy that tried to change things was wrong. and why shouldn't they think that? he's the outsider trying to fix a well oiled machine (in their eyes). he is used to winning and is used to well built organizations over his past 4 stops (spurs, indy, philly, and detroit). so when he walks into the knicks, he doesn't like what he sees so he tries to change it. was he right? we'll never know but 30 years of history dictates that he is.
anyway, back to isiah. in reality, ANY coach that came in this year would've been better than the 23 win benchmark some are using. the clusterfcuk of lineups, rotations, etc. these kids could develop and become decent players...but will we ever go anywhere significant? will we get past the 1st or 2nd round of the playoffs? are we trying to build a title team? will the same culture that's been permeating here for 7 years continue and hold us back? we know now that dolan and co. are afraid of change. they like things done their way regardless of wins or losses (i.e layden here for 4 years, sather for 7). so winning a title is not a top priority. so if that's the case, how much pressure is there on a GM to win BIG rather than to just win a little to keep his owners happy?
we'll see how this plays out over the long haul. some fans have made up their mind that we're not headed down the righteous path of title building. i am one of them. i have seen how all title teams before this one have been built. i have seen the major components needed to win (franchise player, frontcourt defense, heady guard play). and i see us not having any of those pieces. it's very tough to do, but we are ignoring all methods taken before. some like to give a guy like isiah credit for being aggressive and doing some unconventional things, especially with the hand he was dealt. i'm in the other camp thinking that his unconvential methods, althoughy sexy, ultimately will not take us where we want to go. so, to me, we're going to be stuck at some point, in a similar position of the pacers, trying to figure out whether to blow it up again or keep making recycling/lateral moves like the trade they just made for murphy + dunleavy.
i guess i can sit back and enjoy the ride or i can come on these boards and speak my mind. whatever, win or lose, i still get the same amount of enjoyment following them.
ok, i just ranted like an idiot and my thoughts were kind of all over the place. i need to get me some food.