Posted by fishmike:

your right... that is silly. Ewing was a top 50 NBA player of all time, and he played both ends of the court. Did you know that the game is played on both ends? This isnt football where you only play to one goal.

you guys arent watching when you talk about how great Eddy is. The numbers dont lie.


Ewing? Even RVHoss isnt dumb enough to compare Eddy to Ewing.

Ewing anchored the Knick defense FIRST. He was the hoya destroya. He averaged 3-4 blocks a game. He was also one of the best rebounders (especially defensive) rebounders in the game. You didnt get 2nd chances with Ewing in the game. With Eddy in the game you get dunks on offensive rebounds.

So how do you define best player? Is it potential? production?

Right now Lee is the most productive player, because when he's in the line up the Knicks outscore their opponents.

That doesnt happen with Eddy on the floor. Sorry this truth is so disturbing

I think this is what the most important thing is. I think the player that makes the most impact on the game is Lee, when he's in the game, good thing happen all over the court.

The problem that lies in this Topic is that in the thread title Bonn asked who is the Knicks best player and in the poll question he asked who has the most impact. I think there is a huge difference between the 2.

Curry. You think anybody would say Lee is better then Allen/Redd/Bibby/Arena??? Same principle, Curry pretty much does what those guys do...................... your hate clouds your jugdement.

tough choice between Lee & Curry... i'd have to say D Lee since the team looks instantaneously better everytime he comes into the games... it's like night & day... though Curry's vast improvement on the offensive end has really helped this team during times when they were struggling to get points otherwise... just dump it into the big guy & let him do his thing, much in the same way we would see w/Ewing back in the day (obviously not to as great an extent just yet).