[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Playoff GameThread #5: Knicks @ Detroit, 730pm TNT MSG 4/29
Author Thread
nycericanguy
Posts: 21420
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/20/2023
Member: #9127

4/30/2025  12:08 PM
lets be fair DET is a really good team. We would have steamrolled MIA or MIL without Dame.
AUTOADVERT
Clean
Posts: 30226
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
4/30/2025  12:21 PM    LAST EDITED: 4/30/2025  12:23 PM


Thibs is clueles on offense. Take Brunson out the whole game we struggle to score 70 in this series. Its why regular season does not matter. Teams take away options in the playoffs. Only good coaches can adapt. Thibs is not that. He is just lucky Brunson is as good as he is at creating his own shots because Thibs ain't going to help anyone get easy shots.

martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  12:29 PM
BigDaddyG wrote:
martin wrote:I think there was a play during the 2nd quarter where Mitch set a pick for Jalen. Jalen got a smidge of space to pass the ball back to Mitch as if Mitch were rolling to the basket, but he didn't. He wasn't even looking and kinda turned around to move out of the area.

How does an above average IQ basketball player like Jalen even conceivably make that pass to Mitch? It's something that hasn't happened in years.

Like WTF Clutch Player of the Year.

Fatigue and pain can alter your decision making I guess. Jalen is going through it, despite what Detroit fans tell you. No excuse for Jalen going in with blinders on, but it is something to consider. Also, as mentioned above, Jalen isn't a natural playmaker.

Yeah, for me, I'm not there for the fatigue and pain thing on decision making. It's a golden rule and Jalen been playing with Mitch for 3 years and KNOWS Mitch is rusty AF

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  12:34 PM    LAST EDITED: 4/30/2025  12:38 PM
Clean wrote:


Thibs is clueles on offense. Take Brunson out the whole game we struggle to score 70 in this series. Its why regular season does not matter. Teams take away options in the playoffs. Only good coaches can adapt. Thibs is not that. He is just lucky Brunson is as good as he is at creating his own shots because Thibs ain't going to help anyone get easy shots.

Who is the player that you can turn into an offensive engine that can get easy baskets for other players?

Deuce and Mikal and OG are not them. So who is it that Thibs is sprinkling the fairy dust on that can do this thing?

I don't get that part. Cam? Or is it the assumption that a coaching system by itself can just overcome lack of ball handling and passing.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  12:40 PM
Detroit shot 42%, 28% from downtown, missed 10 FT's, in MSG, and still won.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
BigDaddyG
Posts: 39450
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 1/22/2010
Member: #3049

4/30/2025  12:49 PM
martin wrote:
Clean wrote:


Thibs is clueles on offense. Take Brunson out the whole game we struggle to score 70 in this series. Its why regular season does not matter. Teams take away options in the playoffs. Only good coaches can adapt. Thibs is not that. He is just lucky Brunson is as good as he is at creating his own shots because Thibs ain't going to help anyone get easy shots.

Who is the player that you can turn into an offensive engine that can get easy baskets for other players?

Deuce and Mikal and OG are not them. So who is it that Thibs is sprinkling the fairy dust on that can do this thing?

I don't get that part. Cam? Or is it the assumption that a coaching system by itself can just overcome lack of ball handling and passing.

That's what system's are for. I'm not saying go back to the triangle, but you do need to have something place that's creates shots outside of an iso. The ball movement simply isn't where it needs to be. I understand trusting your players, but you also need to be able to put a steady hand on them.

Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right. - The Tick
Clean
Posts: 30226
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
4/30/2025  12:52 PM
martin wrote:
Clean wrote:


Thibs is clueles on offense. Take Brunson out the whole game we struggle to score 70 in this series. Its why regular season does not matter. Teams take away options in the playoffs. Only good coaches can adapt. Thibs is not that. He is just lucky Brunson is as good as he is at creating his own shots because Thibs ain't going to help anyone get easy shots.

Who is the player that you can turn into an offensive engine that can get easy baskets for other players?

Deuce and Mikal and OG are not them. So who is it that Thibs is sprinkling the fairy dust on that can do this thing?

I don't get that part. Cam? Or is it the assumption that a coaching system by itself can just overcome lack of ball handling and passing.

You are misunderstanding his point. He is saying that you can't turn the players into that. You have to put them in the best postion to utilize their gifts. He is agreeing with you and wondering why Thibs was not calling plays to get these players to use their gifts instead of just giving them the ball to ISO.

EwingsGlass
Posts: 27274
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 4/29/2005
Member: #893
USA
4/30/2025  12:53 PM
martin wrote:
BigDaddyG wrote:
martin wrote:I think there was a play during the 2nd quarter where Mitch set a pick for Jalen. Jalen got a smidge of space to pass the ball back to Mitch as if Mitch were rolling to the basket, but he didn't. He wasn't even looking and kinda turned around to move out of the area.

How does an above average IQ basketball player like Jalen even conceivably make that pass to Mitch? It's something that hasn't happened in years.

Like WTF Clutch Player of the Year.

Fatigue and pain can alter your decision making I guess. Jalen is going through it, despite what Detroit fans tell you. No excuse for Jalen going in with blinders on, but it is something to consider. Also, as mentioned above, Jalen isn't a natural playmaker.

Yeah, for me, I'm not there for the fatigue and pain thing on decision making. It's a golden rule and Jalen been playing with Mitch for 3 years and KNOWS Mitch is rusty AF

Brunson had a bad game. Off night. 7/10 from the FT line is kind of telling. A mediocre night from Brunson would have been enough to eek out a win. The "not a natural playmaker" comment may be semantics, but he looks for his shot first, not that he can't make plays.

I don't like the Knicks offense style. The shot selections. The over-dribbling. If they make it through this series, I am skeptical of what the Boston series will look like. This team is not ready for this playoffs. They are playing a soft, inefficient style and letting the refs bail them out.

“Speak softly and carry a big stick” - KAT
Clean
Posts: 30226
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
4/30/2025  12:58 PM
Listen to Caitlin explain what a good coach does. I been saying this for years. Thibs does not put players in positions where they and the team as a whole can be successful. No I am not talking about regular season. I am talking about in the playoffs. No one cares for the regular season. The playoffs is when teams take away options. When you have to make adjustments and move players around to be successful. Thibs is not able to do that. That is why he was always known as a great floor raiser but he will cap how good you can be because of his limitations.
Clean
Posts: 30226
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
4/30/2025  1:51 PM
Clean wrote:
martin wrote:
Clean wrote:


Thibs is clueles on offense. Take Brunson out the whole game we struggle to score 70 in this series. Its why regular season does not matter. Teams take away options in the playoffs. Only good coaches can adapt. Thibs is not that. He is just lucky Brunson is as good as he is at creating his own shots because Thibs ain't going to help anyone get easy shots.

Who is the player that you can turn into an offensive engine that can get easy baskets for other players?

Deuce and Mikal and OG are not them. So who is it that Thibs is sprinkling the fairy dust on that can do this thing?

I don't get that part. Cam? Or is it the assumption that a coaching system by itself can just overcome lack of ball handling and passing.

You are misunderstanding his point. He is saying that you can't turn the players into that. You have to put them in the best postion to utilize their gifts. He is agreeing with you and wondering why Thibs was not calling plays to get these players to use their gifts instead of just giving them the ball to ISO.

martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  2:39 PM
This seem right?

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27661
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

4/30/2025  3:13 PM
Clean wrote:Listen to Caitlin explain what a good coach does. I been saying this for years. Thibs does not put players in positions where they and the team as a whole can be successful. No I am not talking about regular season. I am talking about in the playoffs. No one cares for the regular season. The playoffs is when teams take away options. When you have to make adjustments and move players around to be successful. Thibs is not able to do that. That is why he was always known as a great floor raiser but he will cap how good you can be because of his limitations.

Are you saying we should get Caitlin to coach the Knicks?

Raise your hand if anyone maybe just maybe thinks the roster we have is not capable of winning a chip yet?
If you think this roster is complete then absolutely you start blaming the coach.

However, I think we still have to improve our bench.
Need to add a physical PF.
Get JB to see the floor better and not play hero ball.
Het a $50m elite player who can CREATE and take over a game.

Not saying we are a bad team.
We are a tough opponent and have highly skilled players.
May go deep if all players get hot.
But if you thought we were complete enough to blow out a tough young team and sweep the first round, you may have been miscalculated our deficiencies.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
Clean
Posts: 30226
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
4/30/2025  3:16 PM
martin wrote:This seem right?


If I went to the games I would not be as loud as last year. I am just not feeling the team this season. So I understand why the fans might not feel the same as in the past.
Clean
Posts: 30226
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
4/30/2025  3:39 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
Clean wrote:Listen to Caitlin explain what a good coach does. I been saying this for years. Thibs does not put players in positions where they and the team as a whole can be successful. No I am not talking about regular season. I am talking about in the playoffs. No one cares for the regular season. The playoffs is when teams take away options. When you have to make adjustments and move players around to be successful. Thibs is not able to do that. That is why he was always known as a great floor raiser but he will cap how good you can be because of his limitations.

Are you saying we should get Caitlin to coach the Knicks?

Raise your hand if anyone maybe just maybe thinks the roster we have is not capable of winning a chip yet?
If you think this roster is complete then absolutely you start blaming the coach.

However, I think we still have to improve our bench.
Need to add a physical PF.
Get JB to see the floor better and not play hero ball.
Het a $50m elite player who can CREATE and take over a game.

Not saying we are a bad team.
We are a tough opponent and have highly skilled players.
May go deep if all players get hot.
But if you thought we were complete enough to blow out a tough young team and sweep the first round, you may have been miscalculated our deficiencies.

Since you are having trouble understanding what I am talking about let me try it this way. I don't feel like this taking all day so I am sticking to offense to make my point and to make it as simple as possible. What we are talking about has nothing to do with how good the roster is. The goal for a good to great coach is to put the team and players in the best position to succeed. Everyone knows the players make or miss the shots. You are not breaking any news here.

How you can tell a good coach from the rest is the quality of shots he gets those players. How you can tell a great coach from the rest is the quality of shots he gets those players after teams gameplan to take his first few options away. Thibs is a good coach. He got us to have the very best offense in the history of the league for a few. The problem came once teams made the first adjustment. They put a big on Hart and that allowed them to pack the paint and double anything. They are willing to live with Hart shooting the ball. After that adjustment it was checkmate against Thibs. It's been months and he has not been able to counter it. The ability to adjust and still put your players and teams in positions to succeed is what seperates the good coaches from the great coaches. So I don't care if the players make or miss a shot. What quality of shot did Thibs get for those players in the important thing when evaluating a coach. Talent can carry a coach very far. Look at Doc Rivers.

Clean
Posts: 30226
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
4/30/2025  3:54 PM
Chandler
Posts: 26450
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/26/2015
Member: #6197

4/30/2025  4:13 PM
LivingLegend wrote:
nycericanguy wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
nycericanguy wrote:Too many good passers and high IQ players for so much reliance on ISO.

Mitch showing his worth last night though. 13 & 11, and 8 OREB in just 23 min is crazy.

I underestimated Ihart big time because even if you swapped him out 1 for 1 with KAT, we are probably better.

Prior to last night in 4 games Mitch was averaging 5 boards, 2 points and 0.5 blocks ---- we are not better with Mitch vs Kat.

Play them both and sit Josh on the bench.

in what? 14mpg?... Defense and rim protection is the biggest thing.

KAT is soft unfortunately.

I've seen zero softness from Kat in these playoffs - if anything Kat has been forgotten on offense.

He basically has to create 100% on his own or squeeze off 25 footers before his defender is in his grill.

Kat sucked in regular season defensively --- thought he's been decent this series.

Issue has been high screen roll leading to top speed attacks by Cade that Kat has to contest leaving Duren open and cutters like Thompson wide open.

Defensive guru Thibs has not figured out how to hide Jalen.

My suggestion is to put Jalen on less athletic guys. Thompson is doing the only thing he can do on offense and we're making it easier by putting least athletic defender on him. I'd rather see JB on Hardaway or Beasley or even Harris if JB feels stout enough to hold ground.

(5)(7)
Chandler
Posts: 26450
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/26/2015
Member: #6197

4/30/2025  4:20 PM
EwingsGlass wrote:
martin wrote:
BigDaddyG wrote:
martin wrote:I think there was a play during the 2nd quarter where Mitch set a pick for Jalen. Jalen got a smidge of space to pass the ball back to Mitch as if Mitch were rolling to the basket, but he didn't. He wasn't even looking and kinda turned around to move out of the area.

How does an above average IQ basketball player like Jalen even conceivably make that pass to Mitch? It's something that hasn't happened in years.

Like WTF Clutch Player of the Year.

Fatigue and pain can alter your decision making I guess. Jalen is going through it, despite what Detroit fans tell you. No excuse for Jalen going in with blinders on, but it is something to consider. Also, as mentioned above, Jalen isn't a natural playmaker.

Yeah, for me, I'm not there for the fatigue and pain thing on decision making. It's a golden rule and Jalen been playing with Mitch for 3 years and KNOWS Mitch is rusty AF

Brunson had a bad game. Off night. 7/10 from the FT line is kind of telling. A mediocre night from Brunson would have been enough to eek out a win. The "not a natural playmaker" comment may be semantics, but he looks for his shot first, not that he can't make plays.

I don't like the Knicks offense style. The shot selections. The over-dribbling. If they make it through this series, I am skeptical of what the Boston series will look like. This team is not ready for this playoffs. They are playing a soft, inefficient style and letting the refs bail them out.

why not run it through KAT up top. Spreadw things out. He can see over the defense. Gives space for guys to cut, and if the guy sags he shoots

the issue isn't Jalen looking for his shot. the issue is he's doing that and holding the ball far too looooong

I also think if we defend and rebound better and get running a lot of things will self rectify

now everyone is tight. And we are running our offense on a very short shot clock by the time you account for full court pressure and his slow pace once he's over half court. way too predictable. defense is already organized etc.

(5)(7)
nycericanguy
Posts: 21420
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/20/2023
Member: #9127

4/30/2025  5:03 PM    LAST EDITED: 4/30/2025  5:03 PM
ultimately knicks will be fine and win this in 6, BOS was tested too by a worse team, it's not a horrible thing. but I don't think these players are being maximized and I'm not sure a team can win with KAT at the 5.
martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  7:08 PM
Clean wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
Clean wrote:Listen to Caitlin explain what a good coach does. I been saying this for years. Thibs does not put players in positions where they and the team as a whole can be successful. No I am not talking about regular season. I am talking about in the playoffs. No one cares for the regular season. The playoffs is when teams take away options. When you have to make adjustments and move players around to be successful. Thibs is not able to do that. That is why he was always known as a great floor raiser but he will cap how good you can be because of his limitations.

Are you saying we should get Caitlin to coach the Knicks?

Raise your hand if anyone maybe just maybe thinks the roster we have is not capable of winning a chip yet?
If you think this roster is complete then absolutely you start blaming the coach.

However, I think we still have to improve our bench.
Need to add a physical PF.
Get JB to see the floor better and not play hero ball.
Het a $50m elite player who can CREATE and take over a game.

Not saying we are a bad team.
We are a tough opponent and have highly skilled players.
May go deep if all players get hot.
But if you thought we were complete enough to blow out a tough young team and sweep the first round, you may have been miscalculated our deficiencies.

Since you are having trouble understanding what I am talking about let me try it this way. I don't feel like this taking all day so I am sticking to offense to make my point and to make it as simple as possible. What we are talking about has nothing to do with how good the roster is. The goal for a good to great coach is to put the team and players in the best position to succeed. Everyone knows the players make or miss the shots. You are not breaking any news here.

How you can tell a good coach from the rest is the quality of shots he gets those players. How you can tell a great coach from the rest is the quality of shots he gets those players after teams gameplan to take his first few options away. Thibs is a good coach. He got us to have the very best offense in the history of the league for a few. The problem came once teams made the first adjustment. They put a big on Hart and that allowed them to pack the paint and double anything. They are willing to live with Hart shooting the ball. After that adjustment it was checkmate against Thibs. It's been months and he has not been able to counter it. The ability to adjust and still put your players and teams in positions to succeed is what seperates the good coaches from the great coaches. So I don't care if the players make or miss a shot. What quality of shot did Thibs get for those players in the important thing when evaluating a coach. Talent can carry a coach very far. Look at Doc Rivers.

Point blank hard to out coach this. While Brunson is shooting 43% overall, 34% from downtown.

I don’t have stats to show us how wide open or not those shots were compared to other teams. Maybe you can point those out?

Knicks seem to be missing a ton.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27661
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

4/30/2025  8:59 PM    LAST EDITED: 4/30/2025  9:02 PM
Clean wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
Clean wrote:Listen to Caitlin explain what a good coach does. I been saying this for years. Thibs does not put players in positions where they and the team as a whole can be successful. No I am not talking about regular season. I am talking about in the playoffs. No one cares for the regular season. The playoffs is when teams take away options. When you have to make adjustments and move players around to be successful. Thibs is not able to do that. That is why he was always known as a great floor raiser but he will cap how good you can be because of his limitations.

Are you saying we should get Caitlin to coach the Knicks?

Raise your hand if anyone maybe just maybe thinks the roster we have is not capable of winning a chip yet?
If you think this roster is complete then absolutely you start blaming the coach.

However, I think we still have to improve our bench.
Need to add a physical PF.
Get JB to see the floor better and not play hero ball.
Het a $50m elite player who can CREATE and take over a game.

Not saying we are a bad team.
We are a tough opponent and have highly skilled players.
May go deep if all players get hot.
But if you thought we were complete enough to blow out a tough young team and sweep the first round, you may have been miscalculated our deficiencies.

Since you are having trouble understanding what I am talking about let me try it this way. I don't feel like this taking all day so I am sticking to offense to make my point and to make it as simple as possible. What we are talking about has nothing to do with how good the roster is. The goal for a good to great coach is to put the team and players in the best position to succeed. Everyone knows the players make or miss the shots. You are not breaking any news here.

How you can tell a good coach from the rest is the quality of shots he gets those players. How you can tell a great coach from the rest is the quality of shots he gets those players after teams gameplan to take his first few options away. Thibs is a good coach. He got us to have the very best offense in the history of the league for a few. The problem came once teams made the first adjustment. They put a big on Hart and that allowed them to pack the paint and double anything. They are willing to live with Hart shooting the ball. After that adjustment it was checkmate against Thibs. It's been months and he has not been able to counter it. The ability to adjust and still put your players and teams in positions to succeed is what seperates the good coaches from the great coaches. So I don't care if the players make or miss a shot. What quality of shot did Thibs get for those players in the important thing when evaluating a coach. Talent can carry a coach very far. Look at Doc Rivers.


Everything you said above makes no sense.
Especially when you are saying all that when talking about a game where your top two players shot 9-30.

And your whole
Post is to say that So a good coach is one who gets players quality shots??
Nah. Think A good coach does ONE thing. WIN!!!!
FYI, what Knicks shoot at the foul line? Was that because of Thibs not getting them a better shot?

As for adjustments, don’t know how many playoff series you have watched but coaches make adjustments game by game. Which usually results in a back and forth battle.
Enjoy the battle and hope our guys start making shots.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
Playoff GameThread #5: Knicks @ Detroit, 730pm TNT MSG 4/29

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy