[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Playoff GameThread #5: Knicks @ Detroit, 730pm TNT MSG 4/29
Author Thread
VDesai
Posts: 41625
Alba Posts: 44
Joined: 10/28/2003
Member: #477
USA
4/30/2025  8:16 AM
The Knicks best lineup probably involves having OG and Mitch out at the same time. They force turnovers, can defend pick and roll. I'm wondering if they need less of KAT, not more.

Deuce shooting 27% from the field, 25% from 3 and 50% from the FT line.

AUTOADVERT
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27661
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

4/30/2025  8:22 AM
Also, need to give Shamet some run. Deuce has lost his shot. Shamet was hot going into playoffs. As was Payne.
'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
Chandler
Posts: 26450
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/26/2015
Member: #6197

4/30/2025  8:35 AM
VDesai wrote:The Knicks best lineup probably involves having OG and Mitch out at the same time. They force turnovers, can defend pick and roll. I'm wondering if they need less of KAT, not more.

Deuce shooting 27% from the field, 25% from 3 and 50% from the FT line.

KAT is our best shooter and probably best passer. We have Zero plays for hi , unless a trailing three counts as such. He is not the issue

Thank goodness Mitch showed some life but his turnovers killed us as did his foul shooting. He is not the answer to our problems at least at Kats expense.

(5)(7)
nycericanguy
Posts: 21420
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/20/2023
Member: #9127

4/30/2025  8:46 AM
Too many good passers and high IQ players for so much reliance on ISO.

Mitch showing his worth last night though. 13 & 11, and 8 OREB in just 23 min is crazy.

I underestimated Ihart big time because even if you swapped him out 1 for 1 with KAT, we are probably better.

nycericanguy
Posts: 21420
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/20/2023
Member: #9127

4/30/2025  8:53 AM
I've been a die hard Thibs supporter through and through, he's been great, but I can see the logic that maybe this is as far as he takes us and we need someone else to maximize this roster.

KAT just doesn't do it for me, great shooter and scorer but defense and IQ are lacking. And his emotional outbursts on every play are very Randle-esque. I find myself feeling more comfortable with Mitch out there, knowing he'll at least defend the rim and give us 2nd chance OPS.

VDesai
Posts: 41625
Alba Posts: 44
Joined: 10/28/2003
Member: #477
USA
4/30/2025  8:55 AM
Chandler wrote:
VDesai wrote:The Knicks best lineup probably involves having OG and Mitch out at the same time. They force turnovers, can defend pick and roll. I'm wondering if they need less of KAT, not more.

Deuce shooting 27% from the field, 25% from 3 and 50% from the FT line.

KAT is our best shooter and probably best passer. We have Zero plays for hi , unless a trailing three counts as such. He is not the issue

Thank goodness Mitch showed some life but his turnovers killed us as did his foul shooting. He is not the answer to our problems at least at Kats expense.


He was really bad on both ends yesterday. 5/14 shooting, couldn't guard the pick and roll for ****, and was absolutely dominated on the Glass. Duren literally snatches the ball from his hands or pushes him away every time. He is averaging less than 0.5 offensive rebounds this series and only 9 rebounds overall (more than 3 few rebounds than the regular season). He has been outhustled by Duren the whole series and that advantage for the Pistons was only negated when Mitch was out there on the floor.

KAT obviously needs to play and play well for us to win. His offensive game was off last night and his defense was worse. He was brutal in the 3rd quarter in a bunch of these games.

nycericanguy
Posts: 21420
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/20/2023
Member: #9127

4/30/2025  8:58 AM    LAST EDITED: 4/30/2025  8:59 AM
VDesai wrote:
Chandler wrote:
VDesai wrote:The Knicks best lineup probably involves having OG and Mitch out at the same time. They force turnovers, can defend pick and roll. I'm wondering if they need less of KAT, not more.

Deuce shooting 27% from the field, 25% from 3 and 50% from the FT line.

KAT is our best shooter and probably best passer. We have Zero plays for hi , unless a trailing three counts as such. He is not the issue

Thank goodness Mitch showed some life but his turnovers killed us as did his foul shooting. He is not the answer to our problems at least at Kats expense.


He was really bad on both ends yesterday. 5/14 shooting, couldn't guard the pick and roll for ****, and was absolutely dominated on the Glass. Duren literally snatches the ball from his hands or pushes him away every time. He is averaging less than 0.5 offensive rebounds this series and only 9 rebounds overall (more than 3 few rebounds than the regular season). He has been outhustled by Duren the whole series and that advantage for the Pistons was only negated when Mitch was out there on the floor.

KAT obviously needs to play and play well for us to win. His offensive game was off last night and his defense was worse. He was brutal in the 3rd quarter in a bunch of these games.

the difference between KAT and Mitch on the Offensive boards is STAGGERING and seeing Mitch last night was a huge reminder. Granted, some of that is that Mitch is in the paint more, but KAT really just doesn't get after the offensive boards.

KAT in35mpg averaged only 2.9 OREB this season, Mitch's last full season he averaged 4.6 in just 25mpG!

Ihart was also a beast on the OREB.

we've lost not only defense and rim protection, but we are losing those extra possessions too.

I always said injuries aside, KP was a better, more impactful player and BOS got him for pennies.

Chandler
Posts: 26450
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/26/2015
Member: #6197

4/30/2025  9:14 AM    LAST EDITED: 4/30/2025  9:16 AM
VDesai wrote:
Chandler wrote:
VDesai wrote:The Knicks best lineup probably involves having OG and Mitch out at the same time. They force turnovers, can defend pick and roll. I'm wondering if they need less of KAT, not more.

Deuce shooting 27% from the field, 25% from 3 and 50% from the FT line.

KAT is our best shooter and probably best passer. We have Zero plays for hi , unless a trailing three counts as such. He is not the issue

Thank goodness Mitch showed some life but his turnovers killed us as did his foul shooting. He is not the answer to our problems at least at Kats expense.


He was really bad on both ends yesterday. 5/14 shooting, couldn't guard the pick and roll for ****, and was absolutely dominated on the Glass. Duren literally snatches the ball from his hands or pushes him away every time. He is averaging less than 0.5 offensive rebounds this series and only 9 rebounds overall (more than 3 few rebounds than the regular season). He has been outhustled by Duren the whole series and that advantage for the Pistons was only negated when Mitch was out there on the floor.

KAT obviously needs to play and play well for us to win. His offensive game was off last night and his defense was worse. He was brutal in the 3rd quarter in a bunch of these games.

You can't expect a lot of offensive rebounds from a guy playing near the three point line. Similarly, it's easy to overstate Mitch's contribution to rebounding especially when his job on offense is to hang near the rim and try and get offensive rebounds.

To me, the reality is Mitch or Precious should be guarding Duren. Leave KAT on Harris, and get KAT involved earlier and more often.

KATs value is on offense and it's being waaaay under utilized. if you're going to fault him on D, then you should fault Mitch on Offense (4-7 from FTs, TOs, stone hands; we don't even lob to him at this point)

(5)(7)
VDesai
Posts: 41625
Alba Posts: 44
Joined: 10/28/2003
Member: #477
USA
4/30/2025  9:18 AM
Chandler wrote:
VDesai wrote:
Chandler wrote:
VDesai wrote:The Knicks best lineup probably involves having OG and Mitch out at the same time. They force turnovers, can defend pick and roll. I'm wondering if they need less of KAT, not more.

Deuce shooting 27% from the field, 25% from 3 and 50% from the FT line.

KAT is our best shooter and probably best passer. We have Zero plays for hi , unless a trailing three counts as such. He is not the issue

Thank goodness Mitch showed some life but his turnovers killed us as did his foul shooting. He is not the answer to our problems at least at Kats expense.


He was really bad on both ends yesterday. 5/14 shooting, couldn't guard the pick and roll for ****, and was absolutely dominated on the Glass. Duren literally snatches the ball from his hands or pushes him away every time. He is averaging less than 0.5 offensive rebounds this series and only 9 rebounds overall (more than 3 few rebounds than the regular season). He has been outhustled by Duren the whole series and that advantage for the Pistons was only negated when Mitch was out there on the floor.

KAT obviously needs to play and play well for us to win. His offensive game was off last night and his defense was worse. He was brutal in the 3rd quarter in a bunch of these games.

You can't expect a lot of offensive rebounds from a guy playing near the three point line. Similarly, it's easy to overstate Mitch's contribution to rebounding especially when his job on offense is to hang near the rim and try and get offensive rebounds.

To me, the reality is Mitch or Precious should be guarding Duren. Leave KAT on Harris, and get KAT involved earlier and more often.

KATs value is on offense and it's being waaaay under utilized. if you're going to fault him on D, then you should fault Mitch on Offense (4-7 from FTs, TOs, stone hands; we don't even lob to him at this point)


He's averaging 2/3 fewer offensive rebounds than his season average and 1/4 total rebounds vs. his season average. He is underperforming.

martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  9:18 AM
Yes

DLeethal wrote:Bridges complete inability to carry offense for stretches while being guarded by Hardaway and Shroeder is just pathetic
Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  9:21 AM
VDesai wrote:Worst play of the game was Mikal's utter bonehead pass to Mitch from like 40 feet away in a tie game. In what world is that a good play? We had a chance to grab some momentum and create a lead.

We have been way too bad on fast breaks

I don't understand ANY Knicks player who things a pass to Mitch that isn't an alley opp or DHO type play is worthwhile. And yet they keep doing it.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
martin
Posts: 74846
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
4/30/2025  9:24 AM
LivingLegend wrote:
Chandler wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:Disgusting game - so many unforced TO’s, dumb fouls and just putrid offense and defense at key times.

Can Brunson or Deuce stop a paper bag? Schroeder killing us at key points and Jalen can’t even step up for a spilt second and slow Cade down off high screen.

Once again Kat literally ignored all night on offensive end —- I don’t recall a single pass from Brunson to Towns.

Shitty offense and Thibs is useless standing on sideline watching this turd burger offense.


this is the story of the game. KAT is our best shooter, not Jalen. Jalen has had pretty good defenders on him. DUren and Harris are not good defenders. SO what's our game plan? Stand around and watch Jalen???

Freaking ridiculous. This is really, really dumb, selfish, egotistical basketball. Simplify the game.

It’s just too easy for us to get into the hero Brunson ball.

Best minutes of entire season were the game 4 1st quarter minute where we were flying around and ball was moving - that lasted ~1 quarter and it;s been gone ever since.

I don’t think Jalen is selfish but more so it’s how he operates—— I wish he’d move the ball more.

Jalen, when he is guarded heavily, seems like the old Charles Barkley or Melo of post play. Holds the ball for a long while (or takes time dribbling ball up court), pounds the post defense, and then reacts with < 5 seconds on clock.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
VDesai
Posts: 41625
Alba Posts: 44
Joined: 10/28/2003
Member: #477
USA
4/30/2025  9:27 AM
The only flaw in Mitch last night was the Knicks thinking he was iHart in the way they were passing it to him like he's an offensive hub. Unfortunately his hands keep getting progressively worse.

He was an absolute force last night. The way he defends and rebounds definitely shakes the Pistons. He's the one player who comes in who's physicality exceeds what the Pistons are giving you. Energy level was way better last night - guess he got over his illness. He was probably giving Bickerstaff flashbacks from the Cavs series.

SergioNYK
Posts: 22387
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/8/2002
Member: #333
USA
4/30/2025  9:28 AM
This was one of those losses that really makes you rethink and ask yourself why am I a fan cause even at almost 43 years old, I take these losses extremely hard and personal. Anyone else like this?

I hated everything about this game. Extremely beyond words disappointed in this team for how they came out flat and once again got killed in the 3rd quarter. The zebras were awful like always. How do you call a foul on OG tying his sneakers? But that's not why we lost. We allowed that bum Ausar Thompson, who plays like Jared Jeffries, to score 22 points all on dunks. Everything about this game sucked except for Mitch, who was great and played his heart out, and OG's defense. They came ready to play.

Same cannot be said for the rest of the team. And it starts with Thibs. We weren't ready to play. We came out like it was a game in mid January and not like it was a pivotal game five at home with a chance to advance. There was no sense of urgency and the turnovers were the proof. First play of the game was a shot clock violation. Knew right there what was coming. 6 total turnovers in that first quarter! Inexcusable!

Thibs has a bad game. I'm not calling for him to be fired but that's now two really badly coached games in this series. The offense looked putrid and much like it did in game two where KAT just stands there and does nothing. What happened to getting him the ball and finding him for threes? KAT only took 5 total shots in the second half! I DO NOT GET IT!

Brunson had probably his worst game as a Knick. It happens. He's human. I'm very disappointed but he's our guy so I will always have his back. I still would've liked to see him play with more urgency and fire. He just wasn't sharp at all with his passes and had a poor floor game. And that ankle keeps rolling which is getting really annoying. Either he has the worst luck ever or that sneaker company needs to be sued.

Bridges got going in the 4th quarter but I hated his game overall. He's just too relaxed out there and at times it doesn't even seem like he wants to be out there. I'm sick of Beasley and everyone clowning him and he doesn't retaliate. Again, I'm not asking for a brawl or for him to be Draymond Green but come on man! Stop getting trolled and punked!

As for Thibs not calling a timeout to get both Brunson and Hart back in, it was a dumb decision but I kind of understand it wanting to keep one more timeout. We could've just fouled Thompson to stop the clock and get them back in. It was 97-95 Detroit when they came out with about 3 minutes left and it became 103-97 with 27 secs left when they came back so it ended up costing us the game. But with 100% honesty I cannot 100% for sure say we would've won if they didn't come out. Detroit was the better team last night and this series is slowly proving we are pretty evenly matched and that's disappointing. A play here and there or a foul here and there and we honestly could've been eliminated at this point.

Panos
Posts: 29882
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/6/2004
Member: #520
4/30/2025  9:34 AM
I've been so grateful to have JB and his talents on this team. That said, it really has been egregious how much he's not been a general, and only going for his. Nevermind pick-and-rolls, can we do some drive and kick? I mean I saw nothing resembling an offense yesterday. The whole fourth quarter was just Brunson going for his. You can say that was because no one else was in a flow, but why is that? Because there was no flow to the offense the whole game what-so-ever. It was wholly unpleasant to watch, even when they were winning.
DLeethal
Posts: 22072
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/19/2023
Member: #9126

4/30/2025  9:39 AM
VDesai wrote:The only flaw in Mitch last night was the Knicks thinking he was iHart in the way they were passing it to him like he's an offensive hub. Unfortunately his hands keep getting progressively worse.

He was an absolute force last night. The way he defends and rebounds definitely shakes the Pistons. He's the one player who comes in who's physicality exceeds what the Pistons are giving you. Energy level was way better last night - guess he got over his illness. He was probably giving Bickerstaff flashbacks from the Cavs series.

I blame his teammates. Mikal seems like he's the biggest culprit and it seems he's too eager to play hot potato and pass the ball to a worse scorer in a worse position rather than sack up and try to score on a small guard.

Panos
Posts: 29882
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/6/2004
Member: #520
4/30/2025  9:41 AM
Also, why does every team have a sniper off the bench that can come in an light us up, but we've got nothing? Shamet was scoring at the end of the season, can he get a shot when no one else can throw it in the ocean???
SergioNYK
Posts: 22387
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/8/2002
Member: #333
USA
4/30/2025  9:45 AM
Panos wrote:Also, why does every team have a sniper off the bench that can come in an light us up, but we've got nothing? Shamet was scoring at the end of the season, can he get a shot when no one else can throw it in the ocean???


Problem is in the few minutes Shamet has gotten in this series he's been awful at both ends. I would still give him another chance but we desperately need to add that sniper/scorer off the bench. And Deuce isn't it.

LivingLegend
Posts: 24758
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 8/13/2007
Member: #1645

4/30/2025  9:46 AM
Chandler wrote:KAT needs to touch the ball a whole lot more. If not to shoot then pass

And we need to up the pace. Tho spins on ball pressure is giving pistons the extra couple of seconds to find their men, communicate etc. need to create some pressure

We went from early season where Kat was being used nicely - catch/shoot, catch/pass and catch/drive.

Now virtually 75% of his offense is catch/hold, put head down, hold some more and then drive into contested drive.

It's not the drive -- it's that it'd not happening quickly off the catch (too much holding the ball).

LivingLegend
Posts: 24758
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 8/13/2007
Member: #1645

4/30/2025  9:48 AM
DLeethal wrote:

Jesus - if that might work why is he suggesting that to the press and not the locker room.

Sounds so weak.

Playoff GameThread #5: Knicks @ Detroit, 730pm TNT MSG 4/29

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy