[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Um, from the WTF department, Grunwald out as Knicks GM
Author Thread
holfresh
Posts: 38679
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/14/2006
Member: #1081

9/28/2013  10:15 PM
MaTT4281 wrote:
holfresh wrote:The outrage over Grunwald's ouster is a little curious to me...Grunwald did an OK job, not necessary a great job...Dolan has every right to be a little unsure about Grunwald especially going into 2014/15 season..Novak's contract was a head scratcher..4 years close to 4 mil per, really???...3 years to JKidd and Camby??...KMart should have been here long ahead of Kurt Thomas, a no brainer...I mean come on guys...JR did us a solid by taking 2 mil last year...Without JR last year, it would have been a far different season...I'm not endorsing what Dolan did, but let's not make Grunwald out to be Jerry West...

I'll agree Grunwald didn't do a great job, mostly because he didn't have the flexibility to do anything truly substantial. Novak and Camby were gambles that didn't pan out, but were more or less rectified in the Bargnani trade. Kurt was part of the Raymond Felton trade, and Kmart was a signing late in the season when no one else had decided to offer him a contract, not seeing the connection. Basically, as I believe martin stated...he didn't **** up. Small, solid moves in addition to the pre-established foundation, got us to where we're at. Tyson, even though I have my doubts going forward with him, was a strong move. Enough to at least put my confidence in the man going forward, which is more than we've had in the past decade.

I wouldn't cast the Tyson move as a strong one given that it may have cost us a run at CP3(tho a long shot)...Forgot Kurt was part of the Felton trade but we could have cut Kurt and brought in KMart at the min a lot earlier...KMart was out there a long time..We got lucky getting him...Not screwing up is not a reason to go forward...He may have your confidence but having Dolan's confidence is a tad more important...Who knows what was actually going on behind the scenes at MSG and who was making the calls on signings and trades...SAS said the H20 is the guy doing most if not all the leg(phone calls) work...Grunwald hasn't really wowed me with anything he has done...He was OK..I won't waste time crying about this...

AUTOADVERT
holfresh
Posts: 38679
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/14/2006
Member: #1081

9/28/2013  10:25 PM
dk7th wrote:
holfresh wrote:The outrage over Grunwald's ouster is a little curious to me...Grunwald did an OK job, not necessary a great job...Dolan has every right to be a little unsure about Grunwald especially going into 2014/15 season..Novak's contract was a head scratcher..4 years close to 4 mil per, really???...3 years to JKidd and Camby??...KMart should have been here long ahead of Kurt Thomas, a no brainer...I mean come on guys...JR did us a solid by taking 2 mil last year...Without JR last year, it would have been a far different season...I'm not endorsing what Dolan did, but let's not make Grunwald out to be Jerry West...

it's the ethos, the culture, the overarching trajectory, that disgusts, not the event itself. turnover is a sign of sickness, instability a sign of ineptitude, underachieving is an inevitability.

I don't know about all that...NY is a tough place to work in any sporting arena...Dolan spends his money to put a product on the court...Thats all I can ask for...I don't also expect to have my favorite players, coaches and GM in place too...I don't get disappointed as much...

CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
9/28/2013  10:40 PM
skeng wrote:
markvmc wrote:This is the kind of crap that makes me wonder why I bother with this team.

My thoughts exactly! Stupid nostalgic ties keeping me around.. I hate that I actually care

This caused me to lose a lot of passion for the team. I imagine it will come back but I thought maybe the Knicks were beyond the dysfunction of the Isiah years and headed in the right direction. It isn't just about Grunwald being unjustly fired it is about a big step back in the mental health of the owner in regards to the team. The flavor of the month approach in regards to acquiring players keeps the Knicks on the back page. As many have suggested, sometimes the owner does things that make you think his sole motivation is for headlines.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
9/28/2013  10:48 PM
On a side note I think those hoping for building the 'right way; can take a break for Mill's tenure. He was in ny before and other teams have the likes of Aldridge and Noah because of the way the Knicks decided to build their team back then.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
toad
Posts: 20210
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/14/2012
Member: #4338

9/28/2013  11:47 PM
CrushAlot wrote:On a side note I think those hoping for building the 'right way; can take a break for Mill's tenure. He was in ny before and other teams have the likes of Aldridge and Noah because of the way the Knicks decided to build their team back then.

It's never going to happen with Dolan. The guy is a big fat spoilt brat throwing tantrums. It didn't happen quickly enough with Grunwald while the Nets were making splashy trades; so, out goes he GM. I kinda agree with him that this direction wasn't going anywhere, but Mills is just going to step up the star phucking, not lay a real foundation.

knickstorrents
Posts: 21121
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/23/2010
Member: #3050
Hong Kong
9/29/2013  12:02 AM
As I said before, the team is a revolving door at all levels except ownership. It's very difficult to be a fan.
Rose is not the answer.
MaTT4281
Posts: 34909
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #538
USA
9/29/2013  12:25 AM
holfresh wrote:
MaTT4281 wrote:
holfresh wrote:The outrage over Grunwald's ouster is a little curious to me...Grunwald did an OK job, not necessary a great job...Dolan has every right to be a little unsure about Grunwald especially going into 2014/15 season..Novak's contract was a head scratcher..4 years close to 4 mil per, really???...3 years to JKidd and Camby??...KMart should have been here long ahead of Kurt Thomas, a no brainer...I mean come on guys...JR did us a solid by taking 2 mil last year...Without JR last year, it would have been a far different season...I'm not endorsing what Dolan did, but let's not make Grunwald out to be Jerry West...

I'll agree Grunwald didn't do a great job, mostly because he didn't have the flexibility to do anything truly substantial. Novak and Camby were gambles that didn't pan out, but were more or less rectified in the Bargnani trade. Kurt was part of the Raymond Felton trade, and Kmart was a signing late in the season when no one else had decided to offer him a contract, not seeing the connection. Basically, as I believe martin stated...he didn't **** up. Small, solid moves in addition to the pre-established foundation, got us to where we're at. Tyson, even though I have my doubts going forward with him, was a strong move. Enough to at least put my confidence in the man going forward, which is more than we've had in the past decade.

I wouldn't cast the Tyson move as a strong one given that it may have cost us a run at CP3(tho a long shot)...Forgot Kurt was part of the Felton trade but we could have cut Kurt and brought in KMart at the min a lot earlier...KMart was out there a long time..We got lucky getting him...Not screwing up is not a reason to go forward...He may have your confidence but having Dolan's confidence is a tad more important...Who knows what was actually going on behind the scenes at MSG and who was making the calls on signings and trades...SAS said the H20 is the guy doing most if not all the leg(phone calls) work...Grunwald hasn't really wowed me with anything he has done...He was OK..I won't waste time crying about this...

I list Tyson only because it is really the one significant move Grunwald was able to make. Given that the team was still considered a joke defensively at that point, to come out and create the capspace to sign the DPOY is worthy of credit. Unfortunately the sudden change in philosophy came right after Walsh decided to bring Billups back for that final year (exactly why you should give a GM the entirety of an offseason to move the team in the direction of his or her choosing).

I thought KMart looked good in LA and absolutely should have had a contract to start the season, but he obviously gave teams a reason to pause. I don't know if it was because he was demanding too much or what, but Grunwald is the guy that finally got the deal done. Tough to complain when 30 out of 30 teams agree.

I hadn't heard anything about Houston's role, but I really hope that's accurate. The last lines are fair, but you have to understand fan concern over dumping a guy who at least proved adequate in a position the franchise has been abysmal at for a decade plus. I'll give Mills the benefit of the doubt (as I always do with this franchise...and as has certainly bitten me in the ass before). Fortunately for any doubts I may have, I don't see the roster shifting too much over the next two seasons.

CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
9/29/2013  12:41 AM
MaTT4281 wrote:
holfresh wrote:
MaTT4281 wrote:
holfresh wrote:The outrage over Grunwald's ouster is a little curious to me...Grunwald did an OK job, not necessary a great job...Dolan has every right to be a little unsure about Grunwald especially going into 2014/15 season..Novak's contract was a head scratcher..4 years close to 4 mil per, really???...3 years to JKidd and Camby??...KMart should have been here long ahead of Kurt Thomas, a no brainer...I mean come on guys...JR did us a solid by taking 2 mil last year...Without JR last year, it would have been a far different season...I'm not endorsing what Dolan did, but let's not make Grunwald out to be Jerry West...

I'll agree Grunwald didn't do a great job, mostly because he didn't have the flexibility to do anything truly substantial. Novak and Camby were gambles that didn't pan out, but were more or less rectified in the Bargnani trade. Kurt was part of the Raymond Felton trade, and Kmart was a signing late in the season when no one else had decided to offer him a contract, not seeing the connection. Basically, as I believe martin stated...he didn't **** up. Small, solid moves in addition to the pre-established foundation, got us to where we're at. Tyson, even though I have my doubts going forward with him, was a strong move. Enough to at least put my confidence in the man going forward, which is more than we've had in the past decade.

I wouldn't cast the Tyson move as a strong one given that it may have cost us a run at CP3(tho a long shot)...Forgot Kurt was part of the Felton trade but we could have cut Kurt and brought in KMart at the min a lot earlier...KMart was out there a long time..We got lucky getting him...Not screwing up is not a reason to go forward...He may have your confidence but having Dolan's confidence is a tad more important...Who knows what was actually going on behind the scenes at MSG and who was making the calls on signings and trades...SAS said the H20 is the guy doing most if not all the leg(phone calls) work...Grunwald hasn't really wowed me with anything he has done...He was OK..I won't waste time crying about this...

I list Tyson only because it is really the one significant move Grunwald was able to make. Given that the team was still considered a joke defensively at that point, to come out and create the capspace to sign the DPOY is worthy of credit. Unfortunately the sudden change in philosophy came right after Walsh decided to bring Billups back for that final year (exactly why you should give a GM the entirety of an offseason to move the team in the direction of his or her choosing).

I thought KMart looked good in LA and absolutely should have had a contract to start the season, but he obviously gave teams a reason to pause. I don't know if it was because he was demanding too much or what, but Grunwald is the guy that finally got the deal done. Tough to complain when 30 out of 30 teams agree.

I hadn't heard anything about Houston's role, but I really hope that's accurate. The last lines are fair, but you have to understand fan concern over dumping a guy who at least proved adequate in a position the franchise has been abysmal at for a decade plus. I'll give Mills the benefit of the doubt (as I always do with this franchise...and as has certainly bitten me in the ass before). Fortunately for any doubts I may have, I don't see the roster shifting too much over the next two seasons.

I actually think the reason teams pause with KMart is because he had micro fracture surgery on both knees. He played great when he started out for the Knicks but broke down and then came back and while effective wasn't the same guy. He also is 35. Ideally KMart plays 15 minutes a night and maybe sits out back to backs so you can up his minutes in the playoffs. KMart was forced into a starters role when Flu went down. I think that happens again. I also think similar to Amare, a guy like KMart is wired to go all out and not hold back. That is great if you are young and healthy but neither guy is.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
JamesKPolk
Posts: 21204
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/15/2012
Member: #4093

9/29/2013  4:06 AM    LAST EDITED: 9/29/2013  4:07 AM
holfresh wrote:The outrage over Grunwald's ouster is a little curious to me...Grunwald did an OK job, not necessary a great job...Dolan has every right to be a little unsure about Grunwald especially going into 2014/15 season..Novak's contract was a head scratcher..4 years close to 4 mil per, really???...3 years to JKidd and Camby??...KMart should have been here long ahead of Kurt Thomas, a no brainer...I mean come on guys...JR did us a solid by taking 2 mil last year...Without JR last year, it would have been a far different season...I'm not endorsing what Dolan did, but let's not make Grunwald out to be Jerry West...

Yet you were talking up the Grunwald/Woodson pairing as the new Jerry West/Phil Jackson during the season. And here we are. Still the ultra-Dolan apologist I see. Good for you. At least you never fail to stick to your ideals. Even if they are misplaced ideals.

Nobody cares about mediocre Grunwald. It's the re-hiring of an awful executive from an awful era of Knicks basketball for absolutely no reason at the most random time that's the problem. But what do you care? You would be supporting an Isiah Thomas hire if it were to happen. You like to go against the grain. You like to cheer for things that don't help at all, just on the off chance that it will work and you can pat yourself on the back. But you'll be waiting a long time for that as long as you support James Dolan.

"Peace, plenty, and contentment reign throughout our borders, and our beloved country presents a sublime moral spectacle to the world." - James K Polk
Markji
Posts: 22753
Alba Posts: -4
Joined: 9/14/2007
Member: #1673
USA
9/29/2013  6:32 AM
Papabear wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Papabear wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
knickscity wrote:
smackeddog wrote:If Isola's piece is true and Dolan didn't think we improved enough over the summer, what the heck did he want Grunnie to do. We had a late 1st rounder, no second round pick, no cap space, one tiny MMLE, no ability to sign and trade, and every extra dollar of salary we aquirred would lead to a massive tax bill. Guess Dolan was the moron who demanded we try and get Monta Ellis.

dolan isnt a rational person, he wont think like that, what he will do is get pissed that the Nets are getting a ton of praise while the Knicks are being dismissed.

thats enough for Dolan to react.

isn't dolan the same fellow who brokered a trade for carmelo anthony, gutting the team of valuable assets, and hamstringing the team financially for the ensuing campaigns? and now we hear that melo is agitating for change or he walks? let's tally up the collateral damage:

fields
gallinari
chandler
mozgov
stat
walsh
d'antoni
lin
grunwald

on tap is shumpert.


Damage caused by who? Dolan (I hope you're not talking about Melo)? A lot of those things you either can't blame on them or actually turned out well for us.

dolan is always the source of the bad, ultimately. but you can't say with a straight face, given http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1789193-knicks-front-office-shakeup-grunwald-out-mills-in-and-melo-in-the-middle#comments that melo is merely an innocent victim here, having no ability to catalyze anything.

or can you? in my opinion dolan and melo are made for each other, they enable each others considerable weaknesses. where they are destruction cannot be far off.

have you ever heard of "malignant narcissism" or "malignant narcissists?" 'cause that is what has been going down here. a classic case in fact, plain as day.

marbury same
thomas same
mills likely the same


Look, I'm not denying that Melo has some influence within the organization. Probably every franchise player does. However, I dont believe he orchestrated firing Grunwald in this situation. This was Dolan getting his buddy back into MSG. Nothing to do with Melo, in my opinion.

Papabear Says

You ever wonder why some of these guys are still Knicks fans?? They hate the management they hate the star players or even the team. So why are they here. Every thing that's wrong with this team is Melo's fault. It's sick. And they repeat the same damn thing over and over again. Dolan owns this team whether we like it or not. It ain't changing. So its best for them to move to another team that they like and is willing to root for and that is any team who ain't the Knicks.


You're hardly the most positive poster here. I find it puzzling that you think you've figured out the cut-off beyond which criticism indicates that you're not a real fan.

Papabear Says

At least I'm a Knicks Fan! And I go to games and enjoy MSG. What about you?? I'm positive about the Knicks. Here is my problem, some of you have nothing but anger and hate and its all Melo's fault. Hey Bonn Bonn its Dolan's money it's Dolan's cash. Bonn Bonn I repeat it's Dolan's and you are just a half tail negative poster with the twin brothers who are about nothing but doom and gloom. Maybe when you hit the big lottery you might have enough to buy a little piece of the Knicks Franchise which is the richest in the NBA. So no one cares about you and the twins doom and gloom. As for me I'm going to at least 10 Knicks games this season and guess what?? I'm gonna have a great time.


PapaBear, I agree with you on being positive about the Knicks. I always am at this point....at the beginning of the season. Why not be positive. Enjoy life. Enjoy last season's 54 wins and this upcoming season.

I hate Dolan's firing of Grunwald. I liked Grunwald. I like Melo. I 1/2 dislike Dolan; the half that meddles in the running of the team with his super, napoleanic ego. But I do like the fact that he is not cheap and spends large amounts of money, to at least try, to make the Knicks winners. He may not make the wisest moves, but he does open up the wallet.

If winning the Championship is the only thing that would make a fan happy, then only 3.33% of the NBA fans will ever be happy in any season. But, like PapaBear, I too enjoy the Knicks, especially when they win 54 games. We have a good team. Enjoy it.

The difference between fiction and reality? Fiction has to make sense. Tom Clancy - author
JamesKPolk
Posts: 21204
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/15/2012
Member: #4093

9/29/2013  6:40 AM
Papabear has been doing that troll mantra for years. The "I'm a better fan than you" shtick got tired and old during the Isiah era, Papabear. Continuing it now is just sad. But not as sad as referring to yourself in third person with every single post you make.

People here are attempting to separate management from the team when the moves management makes directly affects the team. You cannot separate these two things. They're one in the same. The moves management makes become the end result of the product you see on the basketball court every night. They are the brains behind the operation. That's like blaming the PR guy for the spin. The PR guys (in this case, the players) are simply a product of the executives who run the organization.

People are entitled to their optimism but not to the point where you're insulting my intelligence. By trying to rationalize Dolan's moves you are insulting my intelligence. Either you don't see Dolan in the same light as others do or you do but chose to be, in your words, 'optimistic' about his moves.

What, if anything, has given you this need for optimism? And how exactly am I supposed to react to someone praising Dolan when I know in my heart that he is awful? Are you telling me you don't get upset with anything in life? You're the most laid back, carefree individual on this planet? You will let people step on your emotions and just keep going forward with no reason to say anything?

I don't know how you can come on here and say you will never complain about the Knicks. That's as bad as the people who complain all the time. You lose credibility when you refuse to point out a negative about the team. There is no grand prize for being positive about everything all the time.

I follow this team. It's my favorite team. And when someone is hurting my team - just like if someone was hurting someone I loved - I will get angry. What would you do? Look the other way and give the man a cookie? To each his own, I guess. But I fail to see how being one extreme (always positive) is better than another extreme (always negative). Any extreme is bad and not healthy.

"Peace, plenty, and contentment reign throughout our borders, and our beloved country presents a sublime moral spectacle to the world." - James K Polk
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
9/29/2013  9:19 AM
Markji wrote:
Papabear wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Papabear wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
knickscity wrote:
smackeddog wrote:If Isola's piece is true and Dolan didn't think we improved enough over the summer, what the heck did he want Grunnie to do. We had a late 1st rounder, no second round pick, no cap space, one tiny MMLE, no ability to sign and trade, and every extra dollar of salary we aquirred would lead to a massive tax bill. Guess Dolan was the moron who demanded we try and get Monta Ellis.

dolan isnt a rational person, he wont think like that, what he will do is get pissed that the Nets are getting a ton of praise while the Knicks are being dismissed.

thats enough for Dolan to react.

isn't dolan the same fellow who brokered a trade for carmelo anthony, gutting the team of valuable assets, and hamstringing the team financially for the ensuing campaigns? and now we hear that melo is agitating for change or he walks? let's tally up the collateral damage:

fields
gallinari
chandler
mozgov
stat
walsh
d'antoni
lin
grunwald

on tap is shumpert.


Damage caused by who? Dolan (I hope you're not talking about Melo)? A lot of those things you either can't blame on them or actually turned out well for us.

dolan is always the source of the bad, ultimately. but you can't say with a straight face, given http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1789193-knicks-front-office-shakeup-grunwald-out-mills-in-and-melo-in-the-middle#comments that melo is merely an innocent victim here, having no ability to catalyze anything.

or can you? in my opinion dolan and melo are made for each other, they enable each others considerable weaknesses. where they are destruction cannot be far off.

have you ever heard of "malignant narcissism" or "malignant narcissists?" 'cause that is what has been going down here. a classic case in fact, plain as day.

marbury same
thomas same
mills likely the same


Look, I'm not denying that Melo has some influence within the organization. Probably every franchise player does. However, I dont believe he orchestrated firing Grunwald in this situation. This was Dolan getting his buddy back into MSG. Nothing to do with Melo, in my opinion.

Papabear Says

You ever wonder why some of these guys are still Knicks fans?? They hate the management they hate the star players or even the team. So why are they here. Every thing that's wrong with this team is Melo's fault. It's sick. And they repeat the same damn thing over and over again. Dolan owns this team whether we like it or not. It ain't changing. So its best for them to move to another team that they like and is willing to root for and that is any team who ain't the Knicks.


You're hardly the most positive poster here. I find it puzzling that you think you've figured out the cut-off beyond which criticism indicates that you're not a real fan.

Papabear Says

At least I'm a Knicks Fan! And I go to games and enjoy MSG. What about you?? I'm positive about the Knicks. Here is my problem, some of you have nothing but anger and hate and its all Melo's fault. Hey Bonn Bonn its Dolan's money it's Dolan's cash. Bonn Bonn I repeat it's Dolan's and you are just a half tail negative poster with the twin brothers who are about nothing but doom and gloom. Maybe when you hit the big lottery you might have enough to buy a little piece of the Knicks Franchise which is the richest in the NBA. So no one cares about you and the twins doom and gloom. As for me I'm going to at least 10 Knicks games this season and guess what?? I'm gonna have a great time.


PapaBear, I agree with you on being positive about the Knicks. I always am at this point....at the beginning of the season. Why not be positive. Enjoy life. Enjoy last season's 54 wins and this upcoming season.

I hate Dolan's firing of Grunwald. I liked Grunwald. I like Melo. I 1/2 dislike Dolan; the half that meddles in the running of the team with his super, napoleanic ego. But I do like the fact that he is not cheap and spends large amounts of money, to at least try, to make the Knicks winners. He may not make the wisest moves, but he does open up the wallet.

If winning the Championship is the only thing that would make a fan happy, then only 3.33% of the NBA fans will ever be happy in any season. But, like PapaBear, I too enjoy the Knicks, especially when they win 54 games. We have a good team. Enjoy it.

There's a big difference between winning one playoff series a decade and winning a championship every year. You can be upset with the former without demanding the latter.

Markji
Posts: 22753
Alba Posts: -4
Joined: 9/14/2007
Member: #1673
USA
9/29/2013  10:11 AM
Bonn1997 wrote:
Markji wrote:
Papabear wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Papabear wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
knickscity wrote:
smackeddog wrote:If Isola's piece is true and Dolan didn't think we improved enough over the summer, what the heck did he want Grunnie to do. We had a late 1st rounder, no second round pick, no cap space, one tiny MMLE, no ability to sign and trade, and every extra dollar of salary we aquirred would lead to a massive tax bill. Guess Dolan was the moron who demanded we try and get Monta Ellis.

dolan isnt a rational person, he wont think like that, what he will do is get pissed that the Nets are getting a ton of praise while the Knicks are being dismissed.

thats enough for Dolan to react.

isn't dolan the same fellow who brokered a trade for carmelo anthony, gutting the team of valuable assets, and hamstringing the team financially for the ensuing campaigns? and now we hear that melo is agitating for change or he walks? let's tally up the collateral damage:

fields
gallinari
chandler
mozgov
stat
walsh
d'antoni
lin
grunwald

on tap is shumpert.


Damage caused by who? Dolan (I hope you're not talking about Melo)? A lot of those things you either can't blame on them or actually turned out well for us.

dolan is always the source of the bad, ultimately. but you can't say with a straight face, given http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1789193-knicks-front-office-shakeup-grunwald-out-mills-in-and-melo-in-the-middle#comments that melo is merely an innocent victim here, having no ability to catalyze anything.

or can you? in my opinion dolan and melo are made for each other, they enable each others considerable weaknesses. where they are destruction cannot be far off.

have you ever heard of "malignant narcissism" or "malignant narcissists?" 'cause that is what has been going down here. a classic case in fact, plain as day.

marbury same
thomas same
mills likely the same


Look, I'm not denying that Melo has some influence within the organization. Probably every franchise player does. However, I dont believe he orchestrated firing Grunwald in this situation. This was Dolan getting his buddy back into MSG. Nothing to do with Melo, in my opinion.

Papabear Says

You ever wonder why some of these guys are still Knicks fans?? They hate the management they hate the star players or even the team. So why are they here. Every thing that's wrong with this team is Melo's fault. It's sick. And they repeat the same damn thing over and over again. Dolan owns this team whether we like it or not. It ain't changing. So its best for them to move to another team that they like and is willing to root for and that is any team who ain't the Knicks.


You're hardly the most positive poster here. I find it puzzling that you think you've figured out the cut-off beyond which criticism indicates that you're not a real fan.

Papabear Says

At least I'm a Knicks Fan! And I go to games and enjoy MSG. What about you?? I'm positive about the Knicks. Here is my problem, some of you have nothing but anger and hate and its all Melo's fault. Hey Bonn Bonn its Dolan's money it's Dolan's cash. Bonn Bonn I repeat it's Dolan's and you are just a half tail negative poster with the twin brothers who are about nothing but doom and gloom. Maybe when you hit the big lottery you might have enough to buy a little piece of the Knicks Franchise which is the richest in the NBA. So no one cares about you and the twins doom and gloom. As for me I'm going to at least 10 Knicks games this season and guess what?? I'm gonna have a great time.


PapaBear, I agree with you on being positive about the Knicks. I always am at this point....at the beginning of the season. Why not be positive. Enjoy life. Enjoy last season's 54 wins and this upcoming season.

I hate Dolan's firing of Grunwald. I liked Grunwald. I like Melo. I 1/2 dislike Dolan; the half that meddles in the running of the team with his super, napoleanic ego. But I do like the fact that he is not cheap and spends large amounts of money, to at least try, to make the Knicks winners. He may not make the wisest moves, but he does open up the wallet.

If winning the Championship is the only thing that would make a fan happy, then only 3.33% of the NBA fans will ever be happy in any season. But, like PapaBear, I too enjoy the Knicks, especially when they win 54 games. We have a good team. Enjoy it.

There's a big difference between winning one playoff series a decade and winning a championship every year. You can be upset with the former without demanding the latter.


I agree with that. Being upset is OK. Bitching about it is OK. But then at some point, one has to move on. I'm putting my attention on the team. And praying that Dolan doesn't force any more crazy moves.
The difference between fiction and reality? Fiction has to make sense. Tom Clancy - author
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
9/29/2013  10:18 AM
Markji wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Markji wrote:
Papabear wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Papabear wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
knickscity wrote:
smackeddog wrote:If Isola's piece is true and Dolan didn't think we improved enough over the summer, what the heck did he want Grunnie to do. We had a late 1st rounder, no second round pick, no cap space, one tiny MMLE, no ability to sign and trade, and every extra dollar of salary we aquirred would lead to a massive tax bill. Guess Dolan was the moron who demanded we try and get Monta Ellis.

dolan isnt a rational person, he wont think like that, what he will do is get pissed that the Nets are getting a ton of praise while the Knicks are being dismissed.

thats enough for Dolan to react.

isn't dolan the same fellow who brokered a trade for carmelo anthony, gutting the team of valuable assets, and hamstringing the team financially for the ensuing campaigns? and now we hear that melo is agitating for change or he walks? let's tally up the collateral damage:

fields
gallinari
chandler
mozgov
stat
walsh
d'antoni
lin
grunwald

on tap is shumpert.


Damage caused by who? Dolan (I hope you're not talking about Melo)? A lot of those things you either can't blame on them or actually turned out well for us.

dolan is always the source of the bad, ultimately. but you can't say with a straight face, given http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1789193-knicks-front-office-shakeup-grunwald-out-mills-in-and-melo-in-the-middle#comments that melo is merely an innocent victim here, having no ability to catalyze anything.

or can you? in my opinion dolan and melo are made for each other, they enable each others considerable weaknesses. where they are destruction cannot be far off.

have you ever heard of "malignant narcissism" or "malignant narcissists?" 'cause that is what has been going down here. a classic case in fact, plain as day.

marbury same
thomas same
mills likely the same


Look, I'm not denying that Melo has some influence within the organization. Probably every franchise player does. However, I dont believe he orchestrated firing Grunwald in this situation. This was Dolan getting his buddy back into MSG. Nothing to do with Melo, in my opinion.

Papabear Says

You ever wonder why some of these guys are still Knicks fans?? They hate the management they hate the star players or even the team. So why are they here. Every thing that's wrong with this team is Melo's fault. It's sick. And they repeat the same damn thing over and over again. Dolan owns this team whether we like it or not. It ain't changing. So its best for them to move to another team that they like and is willing to root for and that is any team who ain't the Knicks.


You're hardly the most positive poster here. I find it puzzling that you think you've figured out the cut-off beyond which criticism indicates that you're not a real fan.

Papabear Says

At least I'm a Knicks Fan! And I go to games and enjoy MSG. What about you?? I'm positive about the Knicks. Here is my problem, some of you have nothing but anger and hate and its all Melo's fault. Hey Bonn Bonn its Dolan's money it's Dolan's cash. Bonn Bonn I repeat it's Dolan's and you are just a half tail negative poster with the twin brothers who are about nothing but doom and gloom. Maybe when you hit the big lottery you might have enough to buy a little piece of the Knicks Franchise which is the richest in the NBA. So no one cares about you and the twins doom and gloom. As for me I'm going to at least 10 Knicks games this season and guess what?? I'm gonna have a great time.


PapaBear, I agree with you on being positive about the Knicks. I always am at this point....at the beginning of the season. Why not be positive. Enjoy life. Enjoy last season's 54 wins and this upcoming season.

I hate Dolan's firing of Grunwald. I liked Grunwald. I like Melo. I 1/2 dislike Dolan; the half that meddles in the running of the team with his super, napoleanic ego. But I do like the fact that he is not cheap and spends large amounts of money, to at least try, to make the Knicks winners. He may not make the wisest moves, but he does open up the wallet.

If winning the Championship is the only thing that would make a fan happy, then only 3.33% of the NBA fans will ever be happy in any season. But, like PapaBear, I too enjoy the Knicks, especially when they win 54 games. We have a good team. Enjoy it.

There's a big difference between winning one playoff series a decade and winning a championship every year. You can be upset with the former without demanding the latter.


I agree with that. Being upset is OK. Bitching about it is OK. But then at some point, one has to move on. I'm putting my attention on the team. And praying that Dolan doesn't force any more crazy moves.

OK, fair enough. I thought you were going down the "I'm better than you" papabear route.

Markji
Posts: 22753
Alba Posts: -4
Joined: 9/14/2007
Member: #1673
USA
9/29/2013  10:59 AM
Bonn1997 wrote:
Markji wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Markji wrote:
Papabear wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Papabear wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
knickscity wrote:
smackeddog wrote:If Isola's piece is true and Dolan didn't think we improved enough over the summer, what the heck did he want Grunnie to do. We had a late 1st rounder, no second round pick, no cap space, one tiny MMLE, no ability to sign and trade, and every extra dollar of salary we aquirred would lead to a massive tax bill. Guess Dolan was the moron who demanded we try and get Monta Ellis.

dolan isnt a rational person, he wont think like that, what he will do is get pissed that the Nets are getting a ton of praise while the Knicks are being dismissed.

thats enough for Dolan to react.

isn't dolan the same fellow who brokered a trade for carmelo anthony, gutting the team of valuable assets, and hamstringing the team financially for the ensuing campaigns? and now we hear that melo is agitating for change or he walks? let's tally up the collateral damage:

fields
gallinari
chandler
mozgov
stat
walsh
d'antoni
lin
grunwald

on tap is shumpert.


Damage caused by who? Dolan (I hope you're not talking about Melo)? A lot of those things you either can't blame on them or actually turned out well for us.

dolan is always the source of the bad, ultimately. but you can't say with a straight face, given http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1789193-knicks-front-office-shakeup-grunwald-out-mills-in-and-melo-in-the-middle#comments that melo is merely an innocent victim here, having no ability to catalyze anything.

or can you? in my opinion dolan and melo are made for each other, they enable each others considerable weaknesses. where they are destruction cannot be far off.

have you ever heard of "malignant narcissism" or "malignant narcissists?" 'cause that is what has been going down here. a classic case in fact, plain as day.

marbury same
thomas same
mills likely the same


Look, I'm not denying that Melo has some influence within the organization. Probably every franchise player does. However, I dont believe he orchestrated firing Grunwald in this situation. This was Dolan getting his buddy back into MSG. Nothing to do with Melo, in my opinion.

Papabear Says

You ever wonder why some of these guys are still Knicks fans?? They hate the management they hate the star players or even the team. So why are they here. Every thing that's wrong with this team is Melo's fault. It's sick. And they repeat the same damn thing over and over again. Dolan owns this team whether we like it or not. It ain't changing. So its best for them to move to another team that they like and is willing to root for and that is any team who ain't the Knicks.


You're hardly the most positive poster here. I find it puzzling that you think you've figured out the cut-off beyond which criticism indicates that you're not a real fan.

Papabear Says

At least I'm a Knicks Fan! And I go to games and enjoy MSG. What about you?? I'm positive about the Knicks. Here is my problem, some of you have nothing but anger and hate and its all Melo's fault. Hey Bonn Bonn its Dolan's money it's Dolan's cash. Bonn Bonn I repeat it's Dolan's and you are just a half tail negative poster with the twin brothers who are about nothing but doom and gloom. Maybe when you hit the big lottery you might have enough to buy a little piece of the Knicks Franchise which is the richest in the NBA. So no one cares about you and the twins doom and gloom. As for me I'm going to at least 10 Knicks games this season and guess what?? I'm gonna have a great time.


PapaBear, I agree with you on being positive about the Knicks. I always am at this point....at the beginning of the season. Why not be positive. Enjoy life. Enjoy last season's 54 wins and this upcoming season.

I hate Dolan's firing of Grunwald. I liked Grunwald. I like Melo. I 1/2 dislike Dolan; the half that meddles in the running of the team with his super, napoleanic ego. But I do like the fact that he is not cheap and spends large amounts of money, to at least try, to make the Knicks winners. He may not make the wisest moves, but he does open up the wallet.

If winning the Championship is the only thing that would make a fan happy, then only 3.33% of the NBA fans will ever be happy in any season. But, like PapaBear, I too enjoy the Knicks, especially when they win 54 games. We have a good team. Enjoy it.

There's a big difference between winning one playoff series a decade and winning a championship every year. You can be upset with the former without demanding the latter.


I agree with that. Being upset is OK. Bitching about it is OK. But then at some point, one has to move on. I'm putting my attention on the team. And praying that Dolan doesn't force any more crazy moves.

OK, fair enough. I thought you were going down the "I'm better than you" papabear route.


No. I bitched and moaned in a few posts about this in this thread and in the Steve Mills thread. Dolan's action truly sucked. But I've been a fan of the Knicks for over 50 years. I still root for the team.

I don't think PapaBear was referring to you as much as some others.

The difference between fiction and reality? Fiction has to make sense. Tom Clancy - author
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
9/29/2013  11:16 AM
Markji wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Markji wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Markji wrote:
Papabear wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
Papabear wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TeamBall wrote:
dk7th wrote:
knickscity wrote:
smackeddog wrote:If Isola's piece is true and Dolan didn't think we improved enough over the summer, what the heck did he want Grunnie to do. We had a late 1st rounder, no second round pick, no cap space, one tiny MMLE, no ability to sign and trade, and every extra dollar of salary we aquirred would lead to a massive tax bill. Guess Dolan was the moron who demanded we try and get Monta Ellis.

dolan isnt a rational person, he wont think like that, what he will do is get pissed that the Nets are getting a ton of praise while the Knicks are being dismissed.

thats enough for Dolan to react.

isn't dolan the same fellow who brokered a trade for carmelo anthony, gutting the team of valuable assets, and hamstringing the team financially for the ensuing campaigns? and now we hear that melo is agitating for change or he walks? let's tally up the collateral damage:

fields
gallinari
chandler
mozgov
stat
walsh
d'antoni
lin
grunwald

on tap is shumpert.


Damage caused by who? Dolan (I hope you're not talking about Melo)? A lot of those things you either can't blame on them or actually turned out well for us.

dolan is always the source of the bad, ultimately. but you can't say with a straight face, given http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1789193-knicks-front-office-shakeup-grunwald-out-mills-in-and-melo-in-the-middle#comments that melo is merely an innocent victim here, having no ability to catalyze anything.

or can you? in my opinion dolan and melo are made for each other, they enable each others considerable weaknesses. where they are destruction cannot be far off.

have you ever heard of "malignant narcissism" or "malignant narcissists?" 'cause that is what has been going down here. a classic case in fact, plain as day.

marbury same
thomas same
mills likely the same


Look, I'm not denying that Melo has some influence within the organization. Probably every franchise player does. However, I dont believe he orchestrated firing Grunwald in this situation. This was Dolan getting his buddy back into MSG. Nothing to do with Melo, in my opinion.

Papabear Says

You ever wonder why some of these guys are still Knicks fans?? They hate the management they hate the star players or even the team. So why are they here. Every thing that's wrong with this team is Melo's fault. It's sick. And they repeat the same damn thing over and over again. Dolan owns this team whether we like it or not. It ain't changing. So its best for them to move to another team that they like and is willing to root for and that is any team who ain't the Knicks.


You're hardly the most positive poster here. I find it puzzling that you think you've figured out the cut-off beyond which criticism indicates that you're not a real fan.

Papabear Says

At least I'm a Knicks Fan! And I go to games and enjoy MSG. What about you?? I'm positive about the Knicks. Here is my problem, some of you have nothing but anger and hate and its all Melo's fault. Hey Bonn Bonn its Dolan's money it's Dolan's cash. Bonn Bonn I repeat it's Dolan's and you are just a half tail negative poster with the twin brothers who are about nothing but doom and gloom. Maybe when you hit the big lottery you might have enough to buy a little piece of the Knicks Franchise which is the richest in the NBA. So no one cares about you and the twins doom and gloom. As for me I'm going to at least 10 Knicks games this season and guess what?? I'm gonna have a great time.


PapaBear, I agree with you on being positive about the Knicks. I always am at this point....at the beginning of the season. Why not be positive. Enjoy life. Enjoy last season's 54 wins and this upcoming season.

I hate Dolan's firing of Grunwald. I liked Grunwald. I like Melo. I 1/2 dislike Dolan; the half that meddles in the running of the team with his super, napoleanic ego. But I do like the fact that he is not cheap and spends large amounts of money, to at least try, to make the Knicks winners. He may not make the wisest moves, but he does open up the wallet.

If winning the Championship is the only thing that would make a fan happy, then only 3.33% of the NBA fans will ever be happy in any season. But, like PapaBear, I too enjoy the Knicks, especially when they win 54 games. We have a good team. Enjoy it.

There's a big difference between winning one playoff series a decade and winning a championship every year. You can be upset with the former without demanding the latter.


I agree with that. Being upset is OK. Bitching about it is OK. But then at some point, one has to move on. I'm putting my attention on the team. And praying that Dolan doesn't force any more crazy moves.

OK, fair enough. I thought you were going down the "I'm better than you" papabear route.


No. I bitched and moaned in a few posts about this in this thread and in the Steve Mills thread. Dolan's action truly sucked. But I've been a fan of the Knicks for over 50 years. I still root for the team.

I don't think PapaBear was referring to you as much as some others.


Yeah, I know that but I still think it takes the forum in a bad direction when people start making "I'm better than you" posts.
knickscity
Posts: 24533
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/2/2012
Member: #4241
USA
9/29/2013  11:27 AM
How do you explain being listed by name?
holfresh
Posts: 38679
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/14/2006
Member: #1081

9/29/2013  11:31 AM
MaTT4281 wrote:
holfresh wrote:
MaTT4281 wrote:
holfresh wrote:The outrage over Grunwald's ouster is a little curious to me...Grunwald did an OK job, not necessary a great job...Dolan has every right to be a little unsure about Grunwald especially going into 2014/15 season..Novak's contract was a head scratcher..4 years close to 4 mil per, really???...3 years to JKidd and Camby??...KMart should have been here long ahead of Kurt Thomas, a no brainer...I mean come on guys...JR did us a solid by taking 2 mil last year...Without JR last year, it would have been a far different season...I'm not endorsing what Dolan did, but let's not make Grunwald out to be Jerry West...

I'll agree Grunwald didn't do a great job, mostly because he didn't have the flexibility to do anything truly substantial. Novak and Camby were gambles that didn't pan out, but were more or less rectified in the Bargnani trade. Kurt was part of the Raymond Felton trade, and Kmart was a signing late in the season when no one else had decided to offer him a contract, not seeing the connection. Basically, as I believe martin stated...he didn't **** up. Small, solid moves in addition to the pre-established foundation, got us to where we're at. Tyson, even though I have my doubts going forward with him, was a strong move. Enough to at least put my confidence in the man going forward, which is more than we've had in the past decade.

I wouldn't cast the Tyson move as a strong one given that it may have cost us a run at CP3(tho a long shot)...Forgot Kurt was part of the Felton trade but we could have cut Kurt and brought in KMart at the min a lot earlier...KMart was out there a long time..We got lucky getting him...Not screwing up is not a reason to go forward...He may have your confidence but having Dolan's confidence is a tad more important...Who knows what was actually going on behind the scenes at MSG and who was making the calls on signings and trades...SAS said the H20 is the guy doing most if not all the leg(phone calls) work...Grunwald hasn't really wowed me with anything he has done...He was OK..I won't waste time crying about this...

I list Tyson only because it is really the one significant move Grunwald was able to make. Given that the team was still considered a joke defensively at that point, to come out and create the capspace to sign the DPOY is worthy of credit. Unfortunately the sudden change in philosophy came right after Walsh decided to bring Billups back for that final year (exactly why you should give a GM the entirety of an offseason to move the team in the direction of his or her choosing).

I thought KMart looked good in LA and absolutely should have had a contract to start the season, but he obviously gave teams a reason to pause. I don't know if it was because he was demanding too much or what, but Grunwald is the guy that finally got the deal done. Tough to complain when 30 out of 30 teams agree.

I hadn't heard anything about Houston's role, but I really hope that's accurate. The last lines are fair, but you have to understand fan concern over dumping a guy who at least proved adequate in a position the franchise has been abysmal at for a decade plus. I'll give Mills the benefit of the doubt (as I always do with this franchise...and as has certainly bitten me in the ass before). Fortunately for any doubts I may have, I don't see the roster shifting too much over the next two seasons.

I think we are going to disagree on a few things here..Tyson should not have won DPOY that year...Bron led an insane defensive display in Miami on his way to a first Championship after losing to Dallas in the Finals...Serge Ibaka was another guy having a great defensive year ahead of Tyson...DYOP is a curious award, I really don't know how it's voted on...Last year's winner, Marc Gasol, isn't even the best defender on his team...Donnie demanded total autonomous control of the Knicks after Dolan went after Melo..Left up to Donnie, MDA would still be here..Another argument for another day...But Tyson did make us better defensively, it's unfortunate that he doesn't bring it every game, he takes nights off...

My bet is Mills is here to be a front guy/media guy/finance guy helping H20 step into the role over the next year...Chris Copeland's comments on move was interesting...He said that Grunwald was a "nice guy" and he hate to see that happen to him..He also said that this is great for H20 and he is one of the great basketball minds he has met...He thinks H20 will do a great job...Grunwald's small dealings with Novak and Kidd gave me pause...I'm not sure how he handles a big deal like Melo or the next big free agent...Maybe thats Dolan's concern, who knows...

holfresh
Posts: 38679
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/14/2006
Member: #1081

9/29/2013  11:35 AM
JamesKPolk wrote:
holfresh wrote:The outrage over Grunwald's ouster is a little curious to me...Grunwald did an OK job, not necessary a great job...Dolan has every right to be a little unsure about Grunwald especially going into 2014/15 season..Novak's contract was a head scratcher..4 years close to 4 mil per, really???...3 years to JKidd and Camby??...KMart should have been here long ahead of Kurt Thomas, a no brainer...I mean come on guys...JR did us a solid by taking 2 mil last year...Without JR last year, it would have been a far different season...I'm not endorsing what Dolan did, but let's not make Grunwald out to be Jerry West...

Yet you were talking up the Grunwald/Woodson pairing as the new Jerry West/Phil Jackson during the season. And here we are. Still the ultra-Dolan apologist I see. Good for you. At least you never fail to stick to your ideals. Even if they are misplaced ideals.

Nobody cares about mediocre Grunwald. It's the re-hiring of an awful executive from an awful era of Knicks basketball for absolutely no reason at the most random time that's the problem. But what do you care? You would be supporting an Isiah Thomas hire if it were to happen. You like to go against the grain. You like to cheer for things that don't help at all, just on the off chance that it will work and you can pat yourself on the back. But you'll be waiting a long time for that as long as you support James Dolan.

Really??..Why don't I remember that...I do remember support Woodson because he went 18-6 and supported him after the Knicks were playing .500 after Felton got hurt during the season...A lot of guys here was asking for him to be fired...If that equates Jerry West/ Phil Jackson pairing in your eyes, how am I the one with misplaced ideals??..

smackeddog
Posts: 38391
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/30/2005
Member: #883
9/29/2013  11:40 AM    LAST EDITED: 9/29/2013  11:41 AM
Interesting interview with Grunnie himself (ha- sticking it to Dolan by doing an interview!):

http://www.sportsnet.ca/590/prime-time-sports/

Scroll down to Sept 26th, it's around the 18min mark of the audio.

He said he knew Dolan was unhappy about something, but didn't quite understand why. Sounds like a nice guy who's just been screwed, but is trying to be positive about it.

Um, from the WTF department, Grunwald out as Knicks GM

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy