[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Kobe talks about Melo
Author Thread
Hersports85
Posts: 20391
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/19/2012
Member: #4397

12/13/2012  5:27 PM
Then answer this, if he would have waited .. how do we give Gallo and chandler their extension and still be able to have Tyson Chandler, Kidd, and Jr Smith. Who I would rather have right now. I'm just wondering.
AUTOADVERT
dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
12/13/2012  5:43 PM
Hersports85 wrote:This is a business. Get over it. Carmelo did what was best for him and his family, which any MAN should do. That comes first, I don't care what anyone says. With the lock out a lot was uncertain, and for him to have an extension and his contract in place was important. We didn't have to sign him!!!! Go and get someone else. He wanted his contract situation to be done with whether it was with Nets or whomever, but the Knicks was the first choice.

wrong. an ETHICAL MAN would not have done what he did. and spare me the pathetic "family" angle WTF is that?!? the dude would have still made 85 million and you have no conception of how much that is, nor does he. it was pride not pragmatism. rest assured he doesn't understand "order of magnitude." but you do, right? "we didn't have to sign him"? again wrong. WALSH didn't have to sign him but DOLAN did-- but not for reasons of winning.

in business you define success by earnings. but in sports business success means WINNING. dolan doesn't understand this and carmelo didn't care. how convenient to talk "money" as business and only afterwards talk winning. both dolan and melo share false values. apparently some alleged "true knick fans" share those false values. i don't like hypocrites but that won't stop others from admiring hypocrites.

knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
DAntoniMustGo
Posts: 20003
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/27/2012
Member: #3873

12/13/2012  5:44 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/13/2012  5:46 PM
Wonder if certain Gallinari fanboys would be so down on Melo's numbers and impact on the #1 seed in the Eastern Conference if it were their prized Gallo who was putting up the same numbers and impact.

It's been great not having to read TKF's shtick on RealGM.

ChuckBuck
Posts: 28851
Alba Posts: 11
Joined: 1/3/2012
Member: #3806
USA
12/13/2012  5:51 PM
dk7th wrote:
ChuckBuck wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TheloniusMonk wrote:Never thought I'd see the day that Knick "fans" root against the guy who is a main piece in leading them Knicks to success. It's baffling. Bets being made with the beter hoping that the Knick player DOESN'T get MVP of the NBA? Once upon a time stuff like that didn't happen around this proud city. This board either. These days, the prisoners are running the jail. It's weird. What happened here? Maybe these types of things bother me more than some others. Is everyone here from NY? Sometimes I get the feeling that the opinions I'm hearing are from that of a person from Tennessee somewhere, who happens to be a Knick "fan" but far from a New Yorker. Not saying every Knicks fan has to be from NYC but there is a pride that's missing with some. That diehard, ride or die, win-lose-or draw type thing. I don't know man....

you are rooting for a dude who forced his way here primarily for money-- showing contempt for success and winning, heedless of the team that was being built here and with players had already endeared themselves to the fanbase. he had a willing partner for this transaction in the owner who has been nothing but a knuckle-dragging loser his whole tenure, caring only about putting fans in seats and treating the fanbase with a superlative amount of cynicism and contempt for years and years and years.

so while he is starting to succeed a little bit, it will always come at a price... for he has justly earned the contempt of those fans who saw what he did as contemptuous. in life you get back what you give, or what goes around comes around.

you want his detractors to shut up? WIN THE FUCKING TITLE IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS

Leave the past behind, my friend. What's done is done.

You'll feel better trust me.

immanuel kant in the late 18th century posited that time is a projection of the mind having no bearing on actual existence. einstein corroborated this 100 years later by showing that reality is a web of space/time, ie that time is inextricably bound to space, and, again, not a phenomenon existing unto itself.

what am i getting at? the past is always with us whether we choose to acknowledge it or not, and is impossible to leave behind.

carmelo is playing with a TON of baggage and it isn't up to me to help him carry it.

What does his past have to do with this current crop of players?

He's never played with a guy like Jason Kidd before(sorry Chauncey). Let Melo and Knicks play now do the talking.

Leave the baggage behind, it's unhealthy to drum up the past. Everyone deserves a clean slate.

tkf
Posts: 36487
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 8/13/2001
Member: #87
12/13/2012  6:17 PM
dk7th wrote:
ChuckBuck wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TheloniusMonk wrote:Never thought I'd see the day that Knick "fans" root against the guy who is a main piece in leading them Knicks to success. It's baffling. Bets being made with the beter hoping that the Knick player DOESN'T get MVP of the NBA? Once upon a time stuff like that didn't happen around this proud city. This board either. These days, the prisoners are running the jail. It's weird. What happened here? Maybe these types of things bother me more than some others. Is everyone here from NY? Sometimes I get the feeling that the opinions I'm hearing are from that of a person from Tennessee somewhere, who happens to be a Knick "fan" but far from a New Yorker. Not saying every Knicks fan has to be from NYC but there is a pride that's missing with some. That diehard, ride or die, win-lose-or draw type thing. I don't know man....

you are rooting for a dude who forced his way here primarily for money-- showing contempt for success and winning, heedless of the team that was being built here and with players had already endeared themselves to the fanbase. he had a willing partner for this transaction in the owner who has been nothing but a knuckle-dragging loser his whole tenure, caring only about putting fans in seats and treating the fanbase with a superlative amount of cynicism and contempt for years and years and years.

so while he is starting to succeed a little bit, it will always come at a price... for he has justly earned the contempt of those fans who saw what he did as contemptuous. in life you get back what you give, or what goes around comes around.

you want his detractors to shut up? WIN THE FUCKING TITLE IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS

Leave the past behind, my friend. What's done is done.

You'll feel better trust me.

immanuel kant in the late 18th century posited that time is a projection of the mind having no bearing on actual existence. einstein corroborated this 100 years later by showing that reality is a web of space/time, ie that time is inextricably bound to space, and, again, not a phenomenon existing unto itself.

what am i getting at? the past is always with us whether we choose to acknowledge it or not, and is impossible to leave behind.

carmelo is playing with a TON of baggage and it isn't up to me to help him carry it.

good stuff dk..

Anyone who sits around and waits for the lottery to better themselves, either in real life or in sports, Is a Loser............... TKF
tkf
Posts: 36487
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 8/13/2001
Member: #87
12/13/2012  6:23 PM
dk7th wrote:
Hersports85 wrote:This is a business. Get over it. Carmelo did what was best for him and his family, which any MAN should do. That comes first, I don't care what anyone says. With the lock out a lot was uncertain, and for him to have an extension and his contract in place was important. We didn't have to sign him!!!! Go and get someone else. He wanted his contract situation to be done with whether it was with Nets or whomever, but the Knicks was the first choice.

wrong. an ETHICAL MAN would not have done what he did. and spare me the pathetic "family" angle WTF is that?!? the dude would have still made 85 million and you have no conception of how much that is, nor does he. it was pride not pragmatism. rest assured he doesn't understand "order of magnitude." but you do, right? "we didn't have to sign him"? again wrong. WALSH didn't have to sign him but DOLAN did-- but not for reasons of winning.

in business you define success by earnings. but in sports business success means WINNING. dolan doesn't understand this and carmelo didn't care. how convenient to talk "money" as business and only afterwards talk winning. both dolan and melo share false values. apparently some alleged "true knick fans" share those false values. i don't like hypocrites but that won't stop others from admiring hypocrites.

what is even worse is that most fans knew that carmelo coming here the way he did would strip the team of a lot of talent.. yet at the end of next year, their excuse was.... He had no help... go figure...

I am with you here, I am tired of the pathetic "family" angle.. not one nba player, from the stars down to the last man on the bench should have problems taking care of their families on NBA salaries.. It is ridiculous when I hear people use that angle...

Anyone who sits around and waits for the lottery to better themselves, either in real life or in sports, Is a Loser............... TKF
tkf
Posts: 36487
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 8/13/2001
Member: #87
12/13/2012  6:24 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/13/2012  6:27 PM
DAntoniMustGo wrote:Wonder if certain Gallinari fanboys would be so down on Melo's numbers and impact on the #1 seed in the Eastern Conference if it were their prized Gallo who was putting up the same numbers and impact.

It's been great not having to read TKF's shtick on RealGM.

so why are you here, again why troll the board, who is talking about gallo here?

It's been great not having to read TKF's shtick on RealGM.

i am sure yall are having a blast over there... smh, funny thing is, there are quite a few who would not agree with you.. and I have proof.....

Anyone who sits around and waits for the lottery to better themselves, either in real life or in sports, Is a Loser............... TKF
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
12/13/2012  6:25 PM
dk7th wrote:
TheloniusMonk wrote:Never thought I'd see the day that Knick "fans" root against the guy who is a main piece in leading them Knicks to success. It's baffling. Bets being made with the beter hoping that the Knick player DOESN'T get MVP of the NBA? Once upon a time stuff like that didn't happen around this proud city. This board either. These days, the prisoners are running the jail. It's weird. What happened here? Maybe these types of things bother me more than some others. Is everyone here from NY? Sometimes I get the feeling that the opinions I'm hearing are from that of a person from Tennessee somewhere, who happens to be a Knick "fan" but far from a New Yorker. Not saying every Knicks fan has to be from NYC but there is a pride that's missing with some. That diehard, ride or die, win-lose-or draw type thing. I don't know man....

you are rooting for a dude who forced his way here primarily for money-- showing contempt for success and winning, heedless of the team that was being built here and with players had already endeared themselves to the fanbase. he had a willing partner for this transaction in the owner who has been nothing but a knuckle-dragging loser his whole tenure, caring only about putting fans in seats and treating the fanbase with a superlative amount of cynicism and contempt for years and years and years.

so while he is starting to succeed a little bit, it will always come at a price... for he has justly earned the contempt of those fans who saw what he did as contemptuous. in life you get back what you give, or what goes around comes around.

you want his detractors to shut up? WIN THE FUCKING TITLE IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS

I couldn't disagree more. Melo wanted out of Denver. With a lockout looming and owners threatening to take back players rights and restrict free agency he pushed to be traded. He would not have stayed in Denver past the trade deadline if the Knicks didn't make the move to get him. Most likely he would be a Net. The Nuggets were not going to wait and get nothing for him. This argumement that Anthony was going to wait for a new cba before getting a contract makes no sense. Expecting the Nuggets to take nothing for Melo so the Knicks could keep their team makes no sense. The previous summer teams like Cleveland and Toronto got destroyed by free agency. Don't you think DEnver would move him to prevent that. Come on now. You can't create fantasy scenarios that never would have happened and criticize a guy because you are not based in reality.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
12/13/2012  6:56 PM
DAntoniMustGo wrote:Wonder if certain Gallinari fanboys would be so down on Melo's numbers and impact on the #1 seed in the Eastern Conference if it were their prized Gallo who was putting up the same numbers and impact.

It's been great not having to read TKF's shtick on RealGM.

my guess is that you only became a knick fan when carmelo anthony came here, am i right? because that is exactly what you are conveying with this post. what was your username on realgm? mine has remained the same, and intentionally.

knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA
12/13/2012  7:05 PM
Boy this MVP discussion really took a turn for the worst
cooch2584
Posts: 21586
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/28/2006
Member: #1187

12/13/2012  7:15 PM
ChuckBuck wrote:
dk7th wrote:
ChuckBuck wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TheloniusMonk wrote:Never thought I'd see the day that Knick "fans" root against the guy who is a main piece in leading them Knicks to success. It's baffling. Bets being made with the beter hoping that the Knick player DOESN'T get MVP of the NBA? Once upon a time stuff like that didn't happen around this proud city. This board either. These days, the prisoners are running the jail. It's weird. What happened here? Maybe these types of things bother me more than some others. Is everyone here from NY? Sometimes I get the feeling that the opinions I'm hearing are from that of a person from Tennessee somewhere, who happens to be a Knick "fan" but far from a New Yorker. Not saying every Knicks fan has to be from NYC but there is a pride that's missing with some. That diehard, ride or die, win-lose-or draw type thing. I don't know man....

you are rooting for a dude who forced his way here primarily for money-- showing contempt for success and winning, heedless of the team that was being built here and with players had already endeared themselves to the fanbase. he had a willing partner for this transaction in the owner who has been nothing but a knuckle-dragging loser his whole tenure, caring only about putting fans in seats and treating the fanbase with a superlative amount of cynicism and contempt for years and years and years.

so while he is starting to succeed a little bit, it will always come at a price... for he has justly earned the contempt of those fans who saw what he did as contemptuous. in life you get back what you give, or what goes around comes around.

you want his detractors to shut up? WIN THE FUCKING TITLE IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS

Leave the past behind, my friend. What's done is done.

You'll feel better trust me.

immanuel kant in the late 18th century posited that time is a projection of the mind having no bearing on actual existence. einstein corroborated this 100 years later by showing that reality is a web of space/time, ie that time is inextricably bound to space, and, again, not a phenomenon existing unto itself.

what am i getting at? the past is always with us whether we choose to acknowledge it or not, and is impossible to leave behind.

carmelo is playing with a TON of baggage and it isn't up to me to help him carry it.

What does his past have to do with this current crop of players?

He's never played with a guy like Jason Kidd before(sorry Chauncey). Let Melo and Knicks play now do the talking.

Leave the baggage behind, it's unhealthy to drum up the past. Everyone deserves a clean slate.

It must be a once a day thing with dk and tk to bring up Melo bashing. When the rest of the NBA sites,Espn sites etc.. are saying that Melo is MVP material and when hes WAY up on the list for All Star Ballots seems like SOMEONE(TK AND DK) are just trolling to make themselves seem important. Honestly tk and dk cut the crap because you have nothing intelligent to say. I hope both of you have NBAtv and just go watch gallo, and the nuggs and put both hands down your pants and make your happy face.

cooch2584
Posts: 21586
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/28/2006
Member: #1187

12/13/2012  7:18 PM
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TheloniusMonk wrote:Never thought I'd see the day that Knick "fans" root against the guy who is a main piece in leading them Knicks to success. It's baffling. Bets being made with the beter hoping that the Knick player DOESN'T get MVP of the NBA? Once upon a time stuff like that didn't happen around this proud city. This board either. These days, the prisoners are running the jail. It's weird. What happened here? Maybe these types of things bother me more than some others. Is everyone here from NY? Sometimes I get the feeling that the opinions I'm hearing are from that of a person from Tennessee somewhere, who happens to be a Knick "fan" but far from a New Yorker. Not saying every Knicks fan has to be from NYC but there is a pride that's missing with some. That diehard, ride or die, win-lose-or draw type thing. I don't know man....

you are rooting for a dude who forced his way here primarily for money-- showing contempt for success and winning, heedless of the team that was being built here and with players had already endeared themselves to the fanbase. he had a willing partner for this transaction in the owner who has been nothing but a knuckle-dragging loser his whole tenure, caring only about putting fans in seats and treating the fanbase with a superlative amount of cynicism and contempt for years and years and years.

so while he is starting to succeed a little bit, it will always come at a price... for he has justly earned the contempt of those fans who saw what he did as contemptuous. in life you get back what you give, or what goes around comes around.

you want his detractors to shut up? WIN THE FUCKING TITLE IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS

I couldn't disagree more. Melo wanted out of Denver. With a lockout looming and owners threatening to take back players rights and restrict free agency he pushed to be traded. He would not have stayed in Denver past the trade deadline if the Knicks didn't make the move to get him. Most likely he would be a Net. The Nuggets were not going to wait and get nothing for him. This argumement that Anthony was going to wait for a new cba before getting a contract makes no sense. Expecting the Nuggets to take nothing for Melo so the Knicks could keep their team makes no sense. The previous summer teams like Cleveland and Toronto got destroyed by free agency. Don't you think DEnver would move him to prevent that. Come on now. You can't create fantasy scenarios that never would have happened and criticize a guy because you are not based in reality.

And dk I really dont like the fact that you must use the F word. Very Immature

cooch2584
Posts: 21586
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/28/2006
Member: #1187

12/13/2012  7:26 PM
cooch2584 wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
TheloniusMonk wrote:Never thought I'd see the day that Knick "fans" root against the guy who is a main piece in leading them Knicks to success. It's baffling. Bets being made with the beter hoping that the Knick player DOESN'T get MVP of the NBA? Once upon a time stuff like that didn't happen around this proud city. This board either. These days, the prisoners are running the jail. It's weird. What happened here? Maybe these types of things bother me more than some others. Is everyone here from NY? Sometimes I get the feeling that the opinions I'm hearing are from that of a person from Tennessee somewhere, who happens to be a Knick "fan" but far from a New Yorker. Not saying every Knicks fan has to be from NYC but there is a pride that's missing with some. That diehard, ride or die, win-lose-or draw type thing. I don't know man....

you are rooting for a dude who forced his way here primarily for money-- showing contempt for success and winning, heedless of the team that was being built here and with players had already endeared themselves to the fanbase. he had a willing partner for this transaction in the owner who has been nothing but a knuckle-dragging loser his whole tenure, caring only about putting fans in seats and treating the fanbase with a superlative amount of cynicism and contempt for years and years and years.

so while he is starting to succeed a little bit, it will always come at a price... for he has justly earned the contempt of those fans who saw what he did as contemptuous. in life you get back what you give, or what goes around comes around.

you want his detractors to shut up? WIN THE FUCKING TITLE IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS

I couldn't disagree more. Melo wanted out of Denver. With a lockout looming and owners threatening to take back players rights and restrict free agency he pushed to be traded. He would not have stayed in Denver past the trade deadline if the Knicks didn't make the move to get him. Most likely he would be a Net. The Nuggets were not going to wait and get nothing for him. This argumement that Anthony was going to wait for a new cba before getting a contract makes no sense. Expecting the Nuggets to take nothing for Melo so the Knicks could keep their team makes no sense. The previous summer teams like Cleveland and Toronto got destroyed by free agency. Don't you think DEnver would move him to prevent that. Come on now. You can't create fantasy scenarios that never would have happened and criticize a guy because you are not based in reality.

And dk I really dont like the fact that you must use the F word. Very Immature

Why is it ok for dk and tk to make assumptions and tell us how Melo was thinking and what Nuggs Mgt was thinking,when he rips up posters for just enjoying this ride.Is it ok for tk and dk to make these assumptions and scenearios when they are doing it just for the sake of arguing? Nothing tk and dk is based on FACT,only on ASSumptions. THIS MAKES NO SENSE.

cooch2584
Posts: 21586
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/28/2006
Member: #1187

12/13/2012  7:34 PM
Now Im gonna go watch OUR KNICKS KICK SOME LAKERS ASS AND LOVE every minute of it.
dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
12/13/2012  7:55 PM
gunsnewing wrote:Boy this MVP discussion really took a turn for the worst

from what i have learned from others here, apparently the standard is merely being the "best" player on the team with the best record. by that dubious standard he most certainly is in the running for mvp, although there is a great deal of doubt what that has to do with being the most valuable player. since the team relies on jason kidd so much, an argument can be made that kidd's presence takes melo out of genuine contention. kidd is the glue to this team not melo. is melo scoring more efficiently and making more effort on defense? yes. is he in better shape, finally? yes. would the team implode if he were not playing? i don't think so. but kidd goes down and the knicks implode.

the difference is that kidd makes everyone else better and melo doesn't.

knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA
12/13/2012  8:00 PM
I don't know. Melo goes down for an extended period of time with Amare's injury history the Knicks are a lottery team. Melo is certainly the mvp of the Knicks
OGkush121
Posts: 21145
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/17/2012
Member: #4392

12/13/2012  8:02 PM
dk7th wrote:
gunsnewing wrote:Boy this MVP discussion really took a turn for the worst

from what i have learned from others here, apparently the standard is merely being the "best" player on the team with the best record. by that dubious standard he most certainly is in the running for mvp, although there is a great deal of doubt what that has to do with being the most valuable player. since the team relies on jason kidd so much, an argument can be made that kidd's presence takes melo out of genuine contention. kidd is the glue to this team not melo. is melo scoring more efficiently and making more effort on defense? yes. is he in better shape, finally? yes. would the team implode if he were not playing? i don't think so. but kidd goes down and the knicks implode.

the difference is that kidd makes everyone else better and melo doesn't.


3-1 without Kidd.
1-1 without Melo.
your argument is invalid.
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
12/13/2012  8:05 PM
OGkush121 wrote:
dk7th wrote:
gunsnewing wrote:Boy this MVP discussion really took a turn for the worst

from what i have learned from others here, apparently the standard is merely being the "best" player on the team with the best record. by that dubious standard he most certainly is in the running for mvp, although there is a great deal of doubt what that has to do with being the most valuable player. since the team relies on jason kidd so much, an argument can be made that kidd's presence takes melo out of genuine contention. kidd is the glue to this team not melo. is melo scoring more efficiently and making more effort on defense? yes. is he in better shape, finally? yes. would the team implode if he were not playing? i don't think so. but kidd goes down and the knicks implode.

the difference is that kidd makes everyone else better and melo doesn't.


3-1 without Kidd.
1-1 without Melo.
your argument is invalid.
18-6 last spring once D'Antoni left. Player of the month. Recovered enough ground to make the playoffs. Kidd is a nice addition. Melo is in contention for the mvp.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA
12/13/2012  8:07 PM
In contention but he won't win. You need numbers. You need more than 1 stat to actually win MVP. Melo only has the scoring. Lebron or Durant have better all around stats
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
12/13/2012  8:12 PM
gunsnewing wrote:In contention but he won't win. You need numbers. You need more than 1 stat to actually win MVP. Melo only has the scoring. Lebron or Durant have better all around stats
I agree that he probably doesn't get it but Melo always averages close to 7 boards a game.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
Kobe talks about Melo

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy