Yeah, loving what the Knicks did this year. Free agency couldn't have turned out much better, and there weren't a lot of ways the Knicks could have done better. Say what you want about Jaden Ivey's upside, I don't think he was a refined PG (more of a combo guard) - certainly not what Morant was coming out of college. Even if we had gotten him (and given up some additional assets), I would have expected some growing pains and would not have expected us to win right away. I might be wrong, but I see him along the lines of Chauncey Billups - he might take 5 years to run a team - and by then you'll have worked with him for years and then he'd be ready for his own $25m+/yr contract extension.
So what we got in FA:
Brunson: a legit, young, healthy PG with upside, with a sweet eFG. As much as I like giving Quickley and McBridge a chance at starter mins, I feel dramatically more confident with Brunson on board. Worst case, Quickley keeps doing his 25mpg thing and McBride continues to be deep depth.
Mitch: Glad to have him back, glad the guy got paid. He did the Knicks a favor these past years with his original way-below-market $6.5m/4yr deal. That now looks like an $8yr/$66.5m deal.
Hartenstein - a center with a little bit of range, toughness, and upside to replace an injury prone Noel. His shooting really gives the Knicks a different look compared to what Mitch/Noel/Taj/Sims provided over the past few years.
Gained more 1st round picks (albeit protected) - either we'll get low 1st rounders OR we'll get unprotected picks like 5 years from now. Assets for the future are a good thing.
The Knicks seem pretty complete and have some extra minutes for the youths to compete for.
Outgoing:
Kemba: I wish it worked out, and I'm still shocked at how little he was able to provide.
Noel: He was absolutely great in 2020-2021, but his history and propensity to miss long stretches of seasons returned. In theory, your backup players play limited minutes so you sort of expect them to be ready to play minutes. But somehow he was hobbled all year. I'll miss the healthy version of him, but everyone won here - the Knicks got a good backup center in Hartenstein with offensive upside, and Noel ultimately got a pretty beefy 2-year contract from the Knicks so no bad blood should we re-acquire him in the future. :)
Burks: Kobe Bryant 1/4 of the time. His role was completely redundant with RJ and Fournier on the team. I think of this as akin to the Celtics losing Gordon Hayward - giving folks like Tatum/Brown/Smart more responsibility and room to grow. Burks was a really good player for us, but I think he was a little too good and was impeding the other guys long term.
I think it'll be interesting how Obi/Grimes/Fournier/Reddish/Quickley/Rose are deployed. The funny outlier on the team is Rose - much like Noel he was phenomenal in 2020-2021 before giving us close to nothing this past season. Indications are he's a good mentor for some of the young guys, but ideally we get more than than, we get a bit of the 2020-2021 magic back from him.