[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

hmm... KP/Willy look a little different with some guys who defend
Author Thread
fishmike
Posts: 53902
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
4/1/2017  1:12 PM
Last night you start Sasha/Lee/Baker 3 guys who came out and set the tone defensively. Suddenly Willy/KP dont look so horrific.

Amazing and telling the quotes from last night's game:

KP:

“I think we came out way better than the first game against the Heat [Wednesday],” Porzingis said. “They kind of punked us the first game. We came out with a different mentality, playing strong, defense the whole game and offensively we shared the ball. It was the defense that made us win the game.”

Lee:

We competed the whole game

Baker:

Everyone was playing together

Hornacek:

Defense was played for 48 minutes

Melo:

“Honestly I don’t know my role at this point,”


This squad is a long way away from being a good team but there are some pieces that work and others that do not.

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
AUTOADVERT
crzymdups
Posts: 52018
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/1/2004
Member: #671
USA
4/1/2017  1:23 PM
We've heard for over three years now about how Phil was going to go and get two-way players who compete, defend, play team basketball.

I honestly can't wait til he actually does it.

Seems like it's a lot easier to say that over and over again than to actually do it.

I really really would love it if he could go out and get the players he keeps saying he will.

Time to do it. $30M in cap space again, for the third off-season in a row. 3 draft picks, one of which is a top ten selection. Let's do it.

¿ △ ?
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
4/1/2017  1:29 PM
crzymdups wrote:We've heard for over three years now about how Phil was going to go and get two-way players who compete, defend, play team basketball.

I honestly can't wait til he actually does it.

Seems like it's a lot easier to say that over and over again than to actually do it.

I really really would love it if he could go out and get the players he keeps saying he will.

Time to do it. $30M in cap space again, for the third off-season in a row. 3 draft picks, one of which is a top ten selection. Let's do it.

Lets hope if he tries again they are under 30, aren't on the decline, coming off of injuries, etc and that getting them doesn't involve losing guys that are under 30, signed to good contracts and fit with the team.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/1/2017  1:37 PM
Yeah it didn't really surprise me that they played harder on D. The younger guys always had that kind of effort, but the more they play minus Melo and Rose the better they should get. This doesn't mean that suddenly they're a good team. We still need upgrades in Talent but the role players we're developing can provide good minutes.

Also have to remember that many of these players have very little NBA experience and haven't played this much yet in their brief careers. They need more time to get adjusted to each other and this level of play. This is all part of the process for these guys.

Love KP and Willy when they can stay home and not have to constantly be out of position. Loved the execution on both ends. Loved Jeff going smaller. Love Baker's toughness. Love how Sasha stays ready. Love Randle staying within himself and not forcing things. Love Holiday's overall game. Love how CLee was being a leader and talking to the guys when they messed up.

Moonangie
Posts: 24767
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 7/9/2009
Member: #2788

4/1/2017  2:49 PM
Other then the win, it was a terrific game. If only we lost by 1.
HofstraBBall
Posts: 28100
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

4/1/2017  3:01 PM    LAST EDITED: 4/1/2017  3:05 PM
fishmike wrote:Last night you start Sasha/Lee/Baker 3 guys who came out and set the tone defensively. Suddenly Willy/KP dont look so horrific.

Amazing and telling the quotes from last night's game:

KP:

“I think we came out way better than the first game against the Heat [Wednesday],” Porzingis said. “They kind of punked us the first game. We came out with a different mentality, playing strong, defense the whole game and offensively we shared the ball. It was the defense that made us win the game.”

Lee:

We competed the whole game

Baker:

Everyone was playing together

Hornacek:

Defense was played for 48 minutes

Melo:

“Honestly I don’t know my role at this point,”


This squad is a long way away from being a good team but there are some pieces that work and others that do not.

CLASSIC!! As your the first to make fun of Briggs for knee jerk threads. Yes the yoots had great energy. What did Miami shoot from 3 though? What stretch 4's does Miami have? Fact of the matter is, as bad as they shot we almost lost the game if not for Dragic missing layup. Your right though, Was good to see the efforr level. But kinda Funny how your celebrating a meaningless win. As your a tank guy. Lets keep this lineup for next few years the same as last night. Will love how quickly people turn on them. Baker, all of a sudden is starting grade. Smh. But don't worry, I will save this thread for next year when the yoots are getting mauled without true talent.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/1/2017  3:15 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
fishmike wrote:Last night you start Sasha/Lee/Baker 3 guys who came out and set the tone defensively. Suddenly Willy/KP dont look so horrific.

Amazing and telling the quotes from last night's game:

KP:

“I think we came out way better than the first game against the Heat [Wednesday],” Porzingis said. “They kind of punked us the first game. We came out with a different mentality, playing strong, defense the whole game and offensively we shared the ball. It was the defense that made us win the game.”

Lee:

We competed the whole game

Baker:

Everyone was playing together

Hornacek:

Defense was played for 48 minutes

Melo:

“Honestly I don’t know my role at this point,”


This squad is a long way away from being a good team but there are some pieces that work and others that do not.

CLASSIC!! As your the first to make fun of Briggs for knee jerk threads. Yes the yoots had great energy. What did Miami shoot from 3 though? What stretch 4's does Miami have? Fact of the matter is, as bad as they shot we almost lost the game if not for Dragic missing layup. Your right though, Was good to see the efforr level. But kinda Funny how your celebrating a meaningless win. As your a tank guy. Lets keep this lineup for next few years the same as last night. Will love how quickly people turn on them. Baker, all of a sudden is starting grade. Smh. But don't worry, I will save this thread for next year when the yoots are getting mauled without true talent.

This post makes me laugh. You seem to have missed the point of the thread. We all know the team still needs Frontline talent! Hopefully we add more in the draft and FA! The thing is we see that as the kids play more minus Melo and Rose they're adjusting and stepping up.

They still need TIME to develop which you seem to be reluctant to accept. As a FAN you should appreciate when our young prospects show signs of development. It's the only way forward for this franchise.

Knixkik
Posts: 35754
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #11
USA
4/1/2017  3:48 PM
The concept of surrounding KP and Willy with defensive minded players is spot on. Baker, randle, and vujacic aren't the answer, but the idea is right. An elite pg from this class and some shooter/defender wings is the recipe to success longterm.
Swishfm3
Posts: 23342
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/28/2003
Member: #392
4/1/2017  4:06 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
fishmike wrote:Last night you start Sasha/Lee/Baker 3 guys who came out and set the tone defensively. Suddenly Willy/KP dont look so horrific.

Amazing and telling the quotes from last night's game:

KP:

“I think we came out way better than the first game against the Heat [Wednesday],” Porzingis said. “They kind of punked us the first game. We came out with a different mentality, playing strong, defense the whole game and offensively we shared the ball. It was the defense that made us win the game.”

Lee:

We competed the whole game

Baker:

Everyone was playing together

Hornacek:

Defense was played for 48 minutes

Melo:

“Honestly I don’t know my role at this point,”


This squad is a long way away from being a good team but there are some pieces that work and others that do not.

CLASSIC!! As your the first to make fun of Briggs for knee jerk threads. Yes the yoots had great energy. What did Miami shoot from 3 though? What stretch 4's does Miami have? Fact of the matter is, as bad as they shot we almost lost the game if not for Dragic missing layup. Your right though, Was good to see the efforr level. But kinda Funny how your celebrating a meaningless win. As your a tank guy. Lets keep this lineup for next few years the same as last night. Will love how quickly people turn on them. Baker, all of a sudden is starting grade. Smh. But don't worry, I will save this thread for next year when the yoots are getting mauled without true talent.

You don't get it. Its a win WITHOUT Melo, THAT is what matters

RonSanity!!!!

yellowboy90
Posts: 33942
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 4/23/2011
Member: #3538

4/1/2017  4:15 PM
This is similar to the threads that were made when the team won when Melo was playing the 4 and KP was out or the threads when Rose was out and BJ started, or the ones after a win when K.P. was at the 5 and Melo was at the 4. It all means nothing. A few years ago when the Sixers were super duper bad they even managed to win games. It happens in the NBA especially when two bad teams play each other twice within a week.


Most smart posters know that Rose and Melo need to go. Other smart posters know that Phil needs to go. Really smart posters know all 3 should go but only one has a NTC that the president have him. Smh.


Anway, KP and Willy are young and still need to put in work. I am still not sure if the best thing going forward would be to split them up so both can be the 5 when they play.

Vmart
Posts: 31800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/23/2002
Member: #247
USA
4/1/2017  4:35 PM
Swishfm3 wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
fishmike wrote:Last night you start Sasha/Lee/Baker 3 guys who came out and set the tone defensively. Suddenly Willy/KP dont look so horrific.

Amazing and telling the quotes from last night's game:

KP:

“I think we came out way better than the first game against the Heat [Wednesday],” Porzingis said. “They kind of punked us the first game. We came out with a different mentality, playing strong, defense the whole game and offensively we shared the ball. It was the defense that made us win the game.”

Lee:

We competed the whole game

Baker:

Everyone was playing together

Hornacek:

Defense was played for 48 minutes

Melo:

“Honestly I don’t know my role at this point,”


This squad is a long way away from being a good team but there are some pieces that work and others that do not.

CLASSIC!! As your the first to make fun of Briggs for knee jerk threads. Yes the yoots had great energy. What did Miami shoot from 3 though? What stretch 4's does Miami have? Fact of the matter is, as bad as they shot we almost lost the game if not for Dragic missing layup. Your right though, Was good to see the efforr level. But kinda Funny how your celebrating a meaningless win. As your a tank guy. Lets keep this lineup for next few years the same as last night. Will love how quickly people turn on them. Baker, all of a sudden is starting grade. Smh. But don't worry, I will save this thread for next year when the yoots are getting mauled without true talent.

You don't get it. Its a win WITHOUT Melo, THAT is what matters

RonSanity!!!!

That is the last thing a Melo fan would want to hear.

Zebo13
Posts: 20376
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/31/2017
Member: #6434
USA
4/1/2017  5:02 PM
fishmike wrote:Last night you start Sasha/Lee/Baker 3 guys who came out and set the tone defensively. Suddenly Willy/KP dont look so horrific.

Amazing and telling the quotes from last night's game:

KP:

“I think we came out way better than the first game against the Heat [Wednesday],” Porzingis said. “They kind of punked us the first game. We came out with a different mentality, playing strong, defense the whole game and offensively we shared the ball. It was the defense that made us win the game.”

Lee:

We competed the whole game

Baker:

Everyone was playing together

Hornacek:

Defense was played for 48 minutes

Melo:

“Honestly I don’t know my role at this point,”


This squad is a long way away from being a good team but there are some pieces that work and others that do not.

I loved everything I saw last night but one thing remains, Willy had a long way to go defensively. Pretty much clueless in many situations. Defensive rebounding as well. Now he's a euro rookie against guys bigger and more athletic than he's ever seen, so a learning curve is to be expected.

nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/1/2017  5:30 PM
yellowboy90 wrote:This is similar to the threads that were made when the team won when Melo was playing the 4 and KP was out or the threads when Rose was out and BJ started, or the ones after a win when K.P. was at the 5 and Melo was at the 4. It all means nothing. A few years ago when the Sixers were super duper bad they even managed to win games. It happens in the NBA especially when two bad teams play each other twice within a week.


Most smart posters know that Rose and Melo need to go. Other smart posters know that Phil needs to go. Really smart posters know all 3 should go but only one has a NTC that the president have him. Smh.


Anway, KP and Willy are young and still need to put in work. I am still not sure if the best thing going forward would be to split them up so both can be the 5 when they play.

I'm not really concerned about Phil. I know he knows what it takes to win and he's not had much success getting the kind of talent he needs in Free Agency nor any success convincing guys like Melo and Rose to PASS THE DAMN BALL! Still I think his basic concepts are right.

I think KP and Willy are good together when surrounded by mobile defenders. I don't see any serious problems but I do think we need more athletic ability at guard and wing spots. KP and Willy starting should be fine.

yellowboy90
Posts: 33942
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 4/23/2011
Member: #3538

4/1/2017  6:06 PM
nixluva wrote:
yellowboy90 wrote:This is similar to the threads that were made when the team won when Melo was playing the 4 and KP was out or the threads when Rose was out and BJ started, or the ones after a win when K.P. was at the 5 and Melo was at the 4. It all means nothing. A few years ago when the Sixers were super duper bad they even managed to win games. It happens in the NBA especially when two bad teams play each other twice within a week.


Most smart posters know that Rose and Melo need to go. Other smart posters know that Phil needs to go. Really smart posters know all 3 should go but only one has a NTC that the president have him. Smh.


Anway, KP and Willy are young and still need to put in work. I am still not sure if the best thing going forward would be to split them up so both can be the 5 when they play.

I'm not really concerned about Phil. I know he knows what it takes to win and he's not had much success getting the kind of talent he needs in Free Agency nor any success convincing guys like Melo and Rose to PASS THE DAMN BALL! Still I think his basic concepts are right.

I think KP and Willy are good together when surrounded by mobile defenders. I don't see any serious problems but I do think we need more athletic ability at guard and wing spots. KP and Willy starting should be fine.

First of all there is zero evidence that shows Phil knows what it takes to win as Team President so how do you know.

Starting Willy and KP may be fine but it might not lead to greatness. The more I see KP playing with a 5 the more I see how many opportunities he misses as the high PnR big. He could be getting 4 - 8 pts easy points at the basket at the 5. Also, separating them gives each unit a potential star to run the offense through assuming both of them can improve.

Knixkik
Posts: 35754
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #11
USA
4/1/2017  6:58 PM
yellowboy90 wrote:This is similar to the threads that were made when the team won when Melo was playing the 4 and KP was out or the threads when Rose was out and BJ started, or the ones after a win when K.P. was at the 5 and Melo was at the 4. It all means nothing. A few years ago when the Sixers were super duper bad they even managed to win games. It happens in the NBA especially when two bad teams play each other twice within a week.


Most smart posters know that Rose and Melo need to go. Other smart posters know that Phil needs to go. Really smart posters know all 3 should go but only one has a NTC that the president have him. Smh.


Anway, KP and Willy are young and still need to put in work. I am still not sure if the best thing going forward would be to split them up so both can be the 5 when they play.

In regards to playing KP and Willy together, I think they will share the court for some time, but should be split up for some time as well. They should combined for a majority of the center minutes going forward, with Noah seeing spot minutes. If KP plays 34 mpg and Willy plays 30, they probably share the floor for about 18-20 mpg.

nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/1/2017  7:40 PM
yellowboy90 wrote:
nixluva wrote:
yellowboy90 wrote:This is similar to the threads that were made when the team won when Melo was playing the 4 and KP was out or the threads when Rose was out and BJ started, or the ones after a win when K.P. was at the 5 and Melo was at the 4. It all means nothing. A few years ago when the Sixers were super duper bad they even managed to win games. It happens in the NBA especially when two bad teams play each other twice within a week.


Most smart posters know that Rose and Melo need to go. Other smart posters know that Phil needs to go. Really smart posters know all 3 should go but only one has a NTC that the president have him. Smh.


Anway, KP and Willy are young and still need to put in work. I am still not sure if the best thing going forward would be to split them up so both can be the 5 when they play.

I'm not really concerned about Phil. I know he knows what it takes to win and he's not had much success getting the kind of talent he needs in Free Agency nor any success convincing guys like Melo and Rose to PASS THE DAMN BALL! Still I think his basic concepts are right.

I think KP and Willy are good together when surrounded by mobile defenders. I don't see any serious problems but I do think we need more athletic ability at guard and wing spots. KP and Willy starting should be fine.

First of all there is zero evidence that shows Phil knows what it takes to win as Team President so how do you know.

Starting Willy and KP may be fine but it might not lead to greatness. The more I see KP playing with a 5 the more I see how many opportunities he misses as the high PnR big. He could be getting 4 - 8 pts easy points at the basket at the 5. Also, separating them gives each unit a potential star to run the offense through assuming both of them can improve.

I'm POSITIVE that Phil does understand what is needed to win PERIOD. Now what have his options been to actually get the best players??? Show me the players he had a legit shot of adding given the situation he inherited. We all watched the last 2 offseasons and there weren't a lot of great options.

Now drafting and developing is probably the best option left. Hopefully we can add another STUD this summer. Keep developing role players. Then when it's the right time add a key FA!

Obviously KP and Willy will spend time on the floor without each other. That's just logical use of talent in a typical rotation. I see them playing well together as they complement each other and have good chemistry that should only get better. I'd like to add a different type of big. A really athletic PF/C that hits the boards.

mendoza1906
Posts: 20031
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/13/2017
Member: #6464

4/1/2017  7:56 PM
Neither Willy or KP can guard or close out the perimeter! I think the best thing is for Willy to lose weight and become a 4. They can switch positions on defense and offense. For example on offense KP will play PF and Willy will play C and on defense KP will play C and Willy will play PF.
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/1/2017  8:08 PM
mendoza1906 wrote:Neither Willy or KP can guard or close out the perimeter! I think the best thing is for Willy to lose weight and become a 4. They can switch positions on defense and offense. For example on offense KP will play PF and Willy will play C and on defense KP will play C and Willy will play PF.

I think they will eventually be fairly interchangeable as they mature. We should look to add an athletic and long PF to the mix who is more quick and agile than either KP or Willy. Someone like Nigel Hayes.

WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/28/2014
Member: #5843

4/1/2017  9:37 PM
Some of us have talked about this before. The basic idea that you want perimeter defenders and that not having them affects you interior D can't be debated, even if guys like Baker or Sasha are not the final answer.

If KP is guarding good stretch 4s and opposition guards are getting into the paint his man will get an open 3 on the kickout or KP will get beat when his man takes the pass, gives him a shot fake, and drives. He's been conditioned to look to the interior, and opponents seem to penetrate at will against us, and he gets hurt in these situations. Besides the points you also have to worry about the fouls he or Willy pick up

This is why I'd be looking at Fox and Ntilikina if one of them is available. If we can't get a PG with a rep for D, I might look to another position...

I have not seen much on Isaac, but he might be someone to consider as a future replacement for Melo if the two PGs I prefer are gone, assuming that he can play the 3 in the NBA. Needs to get stronger, but he seems to have a nice skill set. If he can play D at the 3 he might be a potential pick for us.

EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
fishmike
Posts: 53902
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
4/1/2017  11:56 PM
Zebo13 wrote:
fishmike wrote:Last night you start Sasha/Lee/Baker 3 guys who came out and set the tone defensively. Suddenly Willy/KP dont look so horrific.

Amazing and telling the quotes from last night's game:

KP:

“I think we came out way better than the first game against the Heat [Wednesday],” Porzingis said. “They kind of punked us the first game. We came out with a different mentality, playing strong, defense the whole game and offensively we shared the ball. It was the defense that made us win the game.”

Lee:

We competed the whole game

Baker:

Everyone was playing together

Hornacek:

Defense was played for 48 minutes

Melo:

“Honestly I don’t know my role at this point,”


This squad is a long way away from being a good team but there are some pieces that work and others that do not.

I loved everything I saw last night but one thing remains, Willy had a long way to go defensively. Pretty much clueless in many situations. Defensive rebounding as well. Now he's a euro rookie against guys bigger and more athletic than he's ever seen, so a learning curve is to be expected.

He stinks defensively. But there is plenty of effort there and good physical tools. He's a very strong, very quick and very long player (wingspan). Maybe he's an average rotation guy. Maybe he's a hall of famer. Time will tell but they both looked much better playing in behind a much better defensive effort.
"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
hmm... KP/Willy look a little different with some guys who defend

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy