We are not winning any playoff series with this kind of guard play, and that is IF we make the playoffs.
Phil and Fisher have to see this.
If they have resigned themselves to let Melo's contract run out, then letting Galloway and Grant continue stumble and learn makes sense. If they want to do something worthwhile during Melo's tenure here, then we need a point guard who distributes better than ThisMelo at point forward and is able to defend.

Unless Fisher and Phil have their eye on some college prospect for next year that will immmediately reap dividends, the Gallo-Grant point guard experiment does not make sense.
They have to decide if they are trying to win now and realize that we need to trade for a more proven commodity.
Honestly...we would have to give up someone like DWill or LT for that.

We have no assets to deal that will get us anything back. Derrick Williams, with an opt out, isn't going to get us anything much.

If we can sell and build for the future at the deadline, do it. Otherwise, do our best to make the play offs this year, then take it next year and try to add another talent with our draft pick.

Still has to work on his explosiveness under the rim.

Knicks1969 wrote:I want Rondo, Lavine and Noah

Of course you do.
Rondo can't shoot well and will do it his way. Not the Knicks way.
Lavine is an athlete but clueless and Noah breaks easy.

If Lavine can shake loose he could be a worthy project.

reub wrote:Ricky Ledo is lighting up the D league recently. Shooting threes too. Has that ship sailed?

You keep bringing him up in every thread but do you not remember when we had him here and how he looked?? D-League and NBA.....two different levels.

Knicks1969 wrote:

Nalod wrote:

Knicks1969 wrote:I want Rondo, Lavine and Noah

Of course you do.
Rondo can't shoot well and will do it his way. Not the Knicks way.
Lavine is an athlete but clueless and Noah breaks easy.

If Lavine can shake loose he could be a worthy project.

Rondo can't shoot? He sure as hell is not getting his points by dunking http://m.espn.go.com/nba/playercard?playerId=3026&src=desktop

Don't care. The long armed brilliant mind with borderline personality disorder can stay with Boogie and Karl and drive each other crazy in SAC.
Don't confuse talent with improvement. This guy plays a certain way which is fine but our team runs a certain type of offense. If he is compatable with our culture I say go for it. I don't see this, so I say no.

Lavine is a great athlete but from what I have read he is driving his coach crazy with a lack of fundamentals and sort of poster child for AAU and whats wrong.
He would be a project in my view but one worthy of a gamble. Question is at what price?

Its why I like what we are doing with Derek Williams, sort of his "second coming". He had to wash out and be unrestricted to get him.

newyorker4ever wrote:

reub wrote:Ricky Ledo is lighting up the D league recently. Shooting threes too. Has that ship sailed?

You keep bringing him up in every thread but do you not remember when we had him here and how he looked?? D-League and NBA.....two different levels.

Ricky had his shot and he wasn't even in shape. There's a charecter issue with the guy.

newyorker4ever wrote:

Cartman718 wrote:Jose - good on offense when he's looking for his shot, allows him to create better for others. terrible on defense - old and slow.
Arron - sometimes mamba on offense, sometimes invisible...no consistency, and on defense....just OK. poorer than advertised.
Galloway - inconsistent on offense, probably our best guard in transition, inconsistent on defense as well, nights where he can defend anyone and times where he cannot stop anyone.
Grant - terrible on offense, has one move...drive to the right of the basket trying to bank the shot. one of our better guards on defense, but still inconsistent.
Sasha - understands triangle offense more than any other guard on the team, but inconsistent on shooting (better as of late). inconsistent on defense as well, again better effort overall as of late.

We are not winning any playoff series with this kind of guard play, and that is IF we make the playoffs.
Phil and Fisher have to see this.
If they have resigned themselves to let Melo's contract run out, then letting Galloway and Grant continue stumble and learn makes sense. If they want to do something worthwhile during Melo's tenure here, then we need a point guard who distributes better than ThisMelo at point forward and is able to defend.

Unless Fisher and Phil have their eye on some college prospect for next year that will immmediately reap dividends, the Gallo-Grant point guard experiment does not make sense.
They have to decide if they are trying to win now and realize that we need to trade for a more proven commodity.
Honestly...we would have to give up someone like DWill or LT for that.

Breaking News.......Knicks guards suck.

speaking of trolling.... you are doing a fantastic job of it yourself, considering you are calling out others in other threads for it.

Cartman718 wrote:

newyorker4ever wrote:

Cartman718 wrote:Jose - good on offense when he's looking for his shot, allows him to create better for others. terrible on defense - old and slow.
Arron - sometimes mamba on offense, sometimes invisible...no consistency, and on defense....just OK. poorer than advertised.
Galloway - inconsistent on offense, probably our best guard in transition, inconsistent on defense as well, nights where he can defend anyone and times where he cannot stop anyone.
Grant - terrible on offense, has one move...drive to the right of the basket trying to bank the shot. one of our better guards on defense, but still inconsistent.
Sasha - understands triangle offense more than any other guard on the team, but inconsistent on shooting (better as of late). inconsistent on defense as well, again better effort overall as of late.

We are not winning any playoff series with this kind of guard play, and that is IF we make the playoffs.
Phil and Fisher have to see this.
If they have resigned themselves to let Melo's contract run out, then letting Galloway and Grant continue stumble and learn makes sense. If they want to do something worthwhile during Melo's tenure here, then we need a point guard who distributes better than ThisMelo at point forward and is able to defend.

Unless Fisher and Phil have their eye on some college prospect for next year that will immmediately reap dividends, the Gallo-Grant point guard experiment does not make sense.
They have to decide if they are trying to win now and realize that we need to trade for a more proven commodity.
Honestly...we would have to give up someone like DWill or LT for that.

Breaking News.......Knicks guards suck.

speaking of trolling.... you are doing a fantastic job of it yourself, considering you are calling out others in other threads for it.