Solace wrote:Obviously, you can just list the best player we passed up. In general, though, can you imagine if we don't trade for McDyess and draft Amar'e? Camby, Amar'e, Van Horn or Sprewell, Houston, on the same team. Would've been a good franchise for all these terrible years we've had.

The curse of the Fat Boy - Michael Jack Sweetney [shudder]

Solace wrote:Obviously, you can just list the best player we passed up. In general, though, can you imagine if we don't trade for McDyess and draft Amar'e? Camby, Amar'e, Van Horn or Sprewell, Houston, on the same team. Would've been a good franchise for all these terrible years we've had.

If they didn't trade for Dice I wondered if we would've still drafted Nene to play with Camby. The Knicks never get anything right. I know for a fact Amare was problably not even in their radar. Maybe the next Frederic Weis was tho

BigDaddyG wrote:Artest over the French dude that got teabagged by Vinsanity.

+1
Almost nothing can compare to the waste that was Frederick Weis.

I know we all love Willis Reed by default, but exchanging Larry Bird for Michael Ray Richardson would be top priority setting for the time machine. Although with Larry Legend, we are most likely not in the lottery come Ewing time...still...

The best credit that I can think of was the back to back with Strickland and Mark Jackson. While it did not work out for the Knicks--those were awesome back to back picks in the draft.

ChuckBuck wrote:My top 3 botches:

1)Frederic Weis over Ron Artest
2)Channing Frye over Andrew Bynum
3)Jordan Hill with Stephen Curry if GS didn't cokblock us. Or we could've drafted any of these point guards instead: Brandon Jennings, Jrue Holiday, Ty Lawson, Jeff Teague, Eric Maynor

1. Fred "Tapscott" Weis was awful. I can understand why we did not pick Ron-Ron as he might have imploded faster and larger had he stayed in NYC. Migranes and elbows, suspensions and fights would have been on the knicks watch? ON paper we needed a center to replace Ewing. Reality was I don't think Ed Tapscott ever saw this dude play! If anyting he was victom to the greatest dunk ever! Vinsanity nut jump dunk in the olympics!

The reaction from vince was perhaps a great reason for refs world wide to help temper down the celebrations. First of all he nearly destroys Kevin Garnetts face with his exuberance! Then the two of them are woofing it up pretty good. Why was Vince so mad? Why the angry preening? What a douchebag! Garnnet was that kind of manic doucheback himself!

2. NO doubt in hindsight Bynum the better pick and we should have developed him. But think about the words "Develope" and "Knicks" and you realize its not used in a sentence often. I understood where Isiah was going with Frye and he did have a good rookie year. But then his knee bent the wrong way and it never got "Straight" after that.

3. Jennings over Hill was the right call. Jennings was an arrogant prick who had not shown much in europe but Donnie admits this was a bad read. HIll proved to be a bit lazy and found himself in the MDA outhouse. HOliday and Lawson still needed time to mature as do most points. Teague and Maynor might not have gotten much play. Hill would be a nice player for us now off the bench. I think MDA would have either ruined Jennings or he'd be even better with a "LinTense" touches. By now Melo would have run him off.