Ultimateknicks.com Forums: Grade Walsh

Grade Walsh

Forum Index › NY Knicks Forum

Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next ›

« Reply To Topic

Author

Thread

VCoug
Posts: 24935
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/28/2007
Member: #1406

4/8/2012 9:12 AM

Reply with quote

Gave him a B+. Couldn't give him an A because of the Jordan Hill pick and because of the chance that the rumored Jeffries + Nate to Sacramento might have been real and we could've kept our draft pick.

Now the joy of my world is in Zion How beautiful if nothing more Than to wait at Zion's door I've never been in love like this before Now let me pray to keep you from The perils that will surely come

AUTOADVERT

Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA

4/8/2012 9:30 AM LAST EDITED: 4/8/2012 9:31 AM

Reply with quote

I had a feeling he'd be rated much higher here than I thought he deserved. The Melo trade has been discussed already and that supposedly was Dolan anyway. So really the biggest moves Walsh did were to give away picks and clear cap space so that we could offer Amare $100 mil. The Chandler signing was the next biggest decision and that definitely partly helps to off-set the loss of picks and Amare signing but only partly. I don't see anything great that he did. He didn't do anything terrible either. He got us back up to the middle of the league (.500) at least. So I gave him a C.

smackeddog
Posts: 38390
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/30/2005
Member: #883

4/8/2012 10:56 AM

Reply with quote

Bonn1997 wrote:I had a feeling he'd be rated much higher here than I thought he deserved. The Melo trade has been discussed already and that supposedly was Dolan anyway. So really the biggest moves Walsh did were to give away picks and clear cap space so that we could offer Amare $100 mil. The Chandler signing was the next biggest decision and that definitely partly helps to off-set the loss of picks and Amare signing but only partly. I don't see anything great that he did. He didn't do anything terrible either. He got us back up to the middle of the league (.500) at least. So I gave him a C.

Walsh gets a B+ from me, simply because for a couple of years he changed the culture of the Knicks, from laughing stock and joke of a franchise, to an actual professional team, with a clear strategy and plan in place. Before he came here we were an absolute disaster- the worst organization in sports. He fired IT, and brought in a level head, treated the media well, protected his coach and made classy moves like bringing back Allan Houston and John Starks- actually reconnecting us with our successful past.

Sure I didn't agree with some of his moves, but I could always see the reasoning behind them, and he was always the first to admit a mistake. Even the hiring of D'Antoni made sense- I never liked him as a coach and thought he was the wrong coach for NY, but he did help inflate our players values, and make us a more desirable team for free agents.

He was a really classy guy, and helped right our sinking ship.

crzymdups
Posts: 52018
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/1/2004
Member: #671
USA

4/8/2012 11:59 AM LAST EDITED: 4/8/2012 12:00 PM

Reply with quote

i give him a B+ for being a breath of fresh air and changing the culture from isiah's time. getting rid of the bad contracts, cleaning up the cap, drafting some solid young players: gallo, fields, mozgov, shumpert, toney, jorts, jerome jordan.

the jordan hill pick is the big blemish on his record. that led to the jeffries/hill for mcgrady trade.

otherwise, i was happy with walsh. part of me still wants to see how he would've handled the melo deal and kept rebuilding the team. the other part of me is ready to move on.

¿ △ ?

Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA

4/8/2012 12:18 PM

Reply with quote

smackeddog wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:I had a feeling he'd be rated much higher here than I thought he deserved. The Melo trade has been discussed already and that supposedly was Dolan anyway. So really the biggest moves Walsh did were to give away picks and clear cap space so that we could offer Amare $100 mil. The Chandler signing was the next biggest decision and that definitely partly helps to off-set the loss of picks and Amare signing but only partly. I don't see anything great that he did. He didn't do anything terrible either. He got us back up to the middle of the league (.500) at least. So I gave him a C.
Walsh gets a B+ from me, simply because for a couple of years he changed the culture of the Knicks, from laughing stock and joke of a franchise, to an actual professional team, with a clear strategy and plan in place. Before he came here we were an absolute disaster- the worst organization in sports. He fired IT, and brought in a level head, treated the media well, protected his coach and made classy moves like bringing back Allan Houston and John Starks- actually reconnecting us with our successful past.
Sure I didn't agree with some of his moves, but I could always see the reasoning behind them, and he was always the first to admit a mistake. Even the hiring of D'Antoni made sense- I never liked him as a coach and thought he was the wrong coach for NY, but he did help inflate our players values, and make us a more desirable team for free agents.
He was a really classy guy, and helped right our sinking ship.

I don't disagree with that but I don't think that warrants a B+. Don't wins and losses have to count too?

Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA

4/8/2012 12:18 PM

Reply with quote

Wow, one person gave an F!

MarburyAnd1Crossover
Posts: 23120
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 10/24/2011
Member: #3650

4/8/2012 12:21 PM

Reply with quote

A+, hands down, man down

Carmelo Anthony is ANTI-BASKETBALL

MarburyAnd1Crossover
Posts: 23120
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 10/24/2011
Member: #3650

4/8/2012 12:26 PM

Reply with quote

WTF are you doing? Knocking him down to B+ because of a Jordan Hill pick??

You don't remember what this franchise was like before he came?? You don't remember???

Carmelo Anthony is ANTI-BASKETBALL

MarburyAnd1Crossover
Posts: 23120
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 10/24/2011
Member: #3650

4/8/2012 12:27 PM

Reply with quote

Bonn1997 wrote:Wow, one person gave an F!

Probably Anji or ActionJackson

Carmelo Anthony is ANTI-BASKETBALL

nycisgreat
Posts: 20872
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 2/7/2012
Member: #3894

4/8/2012 1:42 PM

Reply with quote

Walsh is a stud GM. Dolan is just to hands on with this team. He remembers me so much of Jerry Jones. This team will have a hard time winning Champions if this continues. The Knicks front office before Walsh's arrival was like a secret society. I am not even sure if J West would've survived the Dolan.

nycisgreat
Posts: 20872
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 2/7/2012
Member: #3894

4/8/2012 1:43 PM

Reply with quote

A+ for Walsh. The previous 7+ years were dreadful. We're relevant again.

loweyecue
Posts: 27468
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 11/20/2005
Member: #1037

4/8/2012 1:45 PM

Reply with quote

I have him an A. I think he played the Melo trade correctly till Dolan got involved. I have no issues about trading scrubs like Jordan Hill. Only issue I had was giving Amare all that money. Should have offered him $75MM guaranteed for 5 and dated him to take less guaranteed money from the other teams.

TKF on Melo ::....he is a punk, a jerk, a self absorbed out of shape, self aggrandizing, unprofessional, volume chucking coach killing playoff loser!!

SupremeCommander
Posts: 34057
Alba Posts: 35
Joined: 4/28/2006
Member: #1127

4/8/2012 1:51 PM

Reply with quote

I gave him an A. Just minor stuff for why he fell... namely letting Pringles gush freely about Westbrook and Curry.

smackeddog nailed why he gets an A from me. A+ and A are both 4.0s so whatever.

DLeethal wrote: Lol Rick needs a safe space

knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582

4/8/2012 2:19 PM

Reply with quote

I gave him a B-. The few things I din't like, Not reaching out to the Jazz for D will, Not handling the Steph and MDA situation, jordan Hill pick...other than that, he did a pretty decent job..

One thing i have to say..He redeem himself for the hill pick by drafting shump

skeng
Posts: 22090
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 10/27/2009
Member: #2959
Denmark

4/8/2012 2:21 PM

Reply with quote

I gave him a B+ because I don't like Amare all too much

Legalize di NBA

JamesKPolk
Posts: 21204
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/15/2012
Member: #4093

4/8/2012 5:50 PM

Reply with quote

Iman Shumpert ‏ @I_Am_Iman Reply Retweet Favorite · Open
Dear Donny Walsh...thank you for giving me a chance!! #NYKAllday

"Peace, plenty, and contentment reign throughout our borders, and our beloved country presents a sublime moral spectacle to the world." - James K Polk

gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA

4/8/2012 6:12 PM

Reply with quote

F would've been a C or B but he hired Dantoni

Nalod
Posts: 71181
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA

4/8/2012 6:18 PM

Reply with quote

All GM's make mistakes. Dude got an A cuz he set the franchise right.

ITs not like he wiffed on a top 5 pick on Jordan Hill.

JamesKPolk
Posts: 21204
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/15/2012
Member: #4093

4/8/2012 6:19 PM

Reply with quote

gunsnewing wrote:F would've been a C or B but he hired Dantoni

Please man...there is no way you can rationalize giving the man an F.

"Peace, plenty, and contentment reign throughout our borders, and our beloved country presents a sublime moral spectacle to the world." - James K Polk

nyshakespeare
Posts: 20527
Alba Posts: 13
Joined: 6/23/2003
Member: #420
USA

4/8/2012 6:26 PM

Reply with quote

Would hate for him to be named the new GM of the Brooklyn Nets.

It Is Solved By Walking

Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next ›

« Reply To Topic

Grade Walsh

Forum Index › NY Knicks Forum

Author	Poll
Bonn1997 Posts: 38654 Joined: 2/2/2004 Member: #581 USA	How good a GM was Walsh for the Knicks? A+ A A- B+ B B- C+ C C- D F View Results