Poster’s note: This post is long, and full of finance and CBA stuff. If that doesn’t appeal to you, don’t read on. Just take this conclusion to heart: Bosh won’t likely sign a five year deal with another team, which means he has to work with the Raptors, either agreeing to stay, or insisting his new team provide some decent compensation to Toronto for a sign and trade. The consequences of not getting the six year/$133 million deal are far too onerous.
That’s why Bosh and Wade have laughed at the idea of giving a discount to play together. There will be no discounts.
For this summer’s free agent fest, it will be imperative for players to get the biggest, longest possible contract – more so than in other years.
First the background and it applies to all players on all teams, but especially those with the ability to hammer out a max or near max deal for their years of service. Chris Bosh can sign a three year extension with the Raptors (unlikely), or he can opt out of his deal and sign a five year contract with 8% raises with any team with cap space, or he can agree to a six year contract with 10.5% raises with the Raptors, either to remain here, or to be traded to another team. The difference is about $35 million dollars between the five year and six year deals.
However, several factors make it imperative for Bosh, Wade, Johnson, etc – any player who can reasonably be expected to perform for six years ¬– to get that full six-year $133 million deal, because where you account for each of the following, the deal won’t be worth anything like $133 million in take home pay.
1. Escrow. 8% of a player’s salary is withheld to make sure the owners get 43% of all basketball revenues, and if they don’t, that money is forfeited to the owners. In good times, the players get some or all of that back, but not this year. In fact, if the 8% isn’t enough, whatever else is owing is taken from the following season’s pay on top of the 8% escrow for that season. I'd guess that given the economy, that will happen and next year's escrow combined with the short-fall from this season will exceed 10%, possibly even 12%.
2. Taxes. With the expiration of the Bush tax cuts, all American millionaires can expect to pay more US taxes (about 39.5% in Florida/Texas/Arizona versus 35% now, more in states like NY and California).
Here's the financial reality for these guys: Between escrow, escrow carryover and higher taxes, I’d be surprised if a player will clear 48% of their next contract. And that doesn’t account for third party local income taxes – like those on visiting teams in some cities, and it doesn’t include Bosh’s child support. It also doesn’t account for a possible US Health Care tax on the rich.
But it doesn’t stop there.
There’s the next CBA, to be negotiated by the start of the 2011-12 season. There isn’t anyone who doesn’t expect the owners to play hardball, looking for shorter, smaller contracts, which makes that sixth year Bosh and other free agents can sign GOLDEN.
And there is the not inconsequential issue of a lockout. If the NBA locks out the players for half a season, or a full season, then all existing deals are shortened accordingly, which makes the larger increases and sixth year even more precious. (Any contract already signed before a lockout begins, or new CBA is signed, will be grandfathered. They always are.)
So in short, it’s a no-brainer that Bosh, Wade and all the others will put a really, really high premium on that six year deal. It’s why Bosh, Wade and LeBron signed three year deals in the first place – to be able to sign a third contract prior to the next CBA. It's also why BC has a couple of bullets in his revolver - he's not taking the terrible risk some people assume by waiting this out to the summer.
That gives BC as much leverage in the summer, and maybe more, than he would have dealing Bosh at the trade deadline. Unless some team makes a Hail Mary attempt to change his mind with an offer he can’t reasonably ignore, BC will not trade Bosh now. He will likely get comparable or better in the summer, and that’s also why Bosh is in no way closing the door on staying in Toronto. He can always sign a new deal, stay here, and after a new CBA takes effect, assuming the team hasn’t made the progress he wants, can quietly ask for a trade. That can be arranged informally during the coming negotiations, with a handshake. It’s a third option the media doesn’t talk about either because it’s too complicated to explain and would ruin their simple-minded theories and make-believe scenarios.
----
that was posted on a raptors forum by a financial guy with ties to the nba.
edit: BC = bryan colangelo