isles and Blue -
I don't want to be coined the Isiah apologist here, because I am not defending his mistakes which we know are many.
I'm just asking if this is as bad as we are making it out to be in terms of actual harm to the future, or is it our own anger and desire for revenge as fans at a team that has been in a terrible situation for years, with which Isiah has become possibly the biggest lightning rod.
Dolan is paying him big bucks + good relationship with he and Walsh + looking to find some way for him to earn that salary given all of the promises Isiah's made to improve the team = Isiah stays in a lesser non decision making role.
"I value Isiah's knowledge of the game and his opinions, so I will use him as a resource. Isiah will be reporting to me. There will be nobody reporting to Isiah."
This may not help much, but I think that Isiah can offer something as a scout, consultant, whatever, to find a way to earn his pay. To me he is not a complete slouch in terms of b-ball, and if Walsh can tap into those strengths then good for him. If he doesn't like Isiah's view, then he doesn't have to agree. Differing opinions are good anyway when making decisions.
Isiah is not the sole individual responsible for our team's plight. He's a major figure and as GM/Prez/Coach he's done a lot of damage, but it's been cumulative and multi-partied in terms of who's responsible.
If the team keeps sucking then you all will be right, sure, but none of us will be any happier. I have some faith in Walsh and see/hear some distinctive differences in approach.
I'm sorry some are very disappointed. Can't say I blame you either. We've all clearly suffered and just want to feel that we are being heard. I do feel that there is very legit anger for feeling that some die hard fans are not being respected. I'm fortunate enough to not feel that way, but I can empathize as a Knick fan, for sure.
Let's just hope things work out for us all down the road with improvement and success.
[Edited by - PresIke on 04-18-2008 6:06 PM]
Forum Po Po and #33 for a reason...