Isiah needs to be gone completely. I don't want him making another decision with the Knicks, unless it's a decision on the settlement of the remainder of his contract after he's fired.

Of course not, removing him as coach and not as GM actually makes things worse because then Isiah will be free to hire and fire coaches every season like he was before, and the nightmare will continue.

Isiah needs to be uninvolved in any coaching or managerial decisions because he isn't competent enough to make either well. Personally I want him gone completely but if Dolan wants to keep him around to earn more of his extension with a meaningless role like Cosmic suggested then I'd be ok with that too, but at least that much has to happen for things to change.

no. in fact if I had to pick only one, clearly Isiah the GM has done more damage than Isiah the coach.

YOU FORGOT the other catergory: if isiah is gone do you want to keep the same players

Posted by Solace:

Posted by playa2:

YOU FORGOT the other catergory: if isiah is gone do you want to keep the same players

Do you really think any fan wants this roster? I would be shocked if anyone on this board could name more than 5 players on the team they'd actually want to keep.

I still wish LB were here with a GM who knew what he was doing. WIth that type of tough-nose backdrop I would keep Lee, Nate, Jamal (sixthman), Balk, Chandler. Dang that's not a lot.

Posted by EnySpree:

Yo man it feels like we are stranded on an island waiting for someone to rescue us.....

Anybody seen nixluva's last rant? He is officially on the darkside now! Lmao!

Man I can't believe this has happened. Im a huge homer and I myself was standing right next to nixluva and I had his back on a lot of fights here. Wow man what a waste that was!

we are all standing side by side just waiting for Dolan to drop the ax on Isiah. Never thought I'd see the day. Everyone is on the darkside.

I suppose its hard to stay positive when every losing streak almost equals your win total for the season.

Posted by martin:

Posted by Solace:

Posted by playa2:

YOU FORGOT the other catergory: if isiah is gone do you want to keep the same players

Do you really think any fan wants this roster? I would be shocked if anyone on this board could name more than 5 players on the team they'd actually want to keep.

I still wish LB were here with a GM who knew what he was doing. WIth that type of tough-nose backdrop I would keep Lee, Nate, Jamal (sixthman), Balk, Chandler. Dang that's not a lot.

I would keep:

Lee - He can be a serviceable starter or a nice piece off the bench.
Jamal - I think he's coachable and you can use him as a 6th man when he's on. A Vinnie Johnson type.
Balkman - As an 8th or 9th man to come in for 10-15 a game and let him cause havoc. No basketball to speak of but still useful in spurts.
Chandler - Who the hell knows with him at this point? Can't really judge him.

That's it. How pathetic that after 4 years, spending hundreds of millions of dollars, trading away multiple lottery picks and all this roster turnover, you barely have 1 starter to show for it. It's mindboggling.

I bet even the former CBA owners are laughing at us, that Isiah managed to screw us over more than he did them.

Posted by islesfan:

Posted by martin:

Posted by Solace:

Posted by playa2:

YOU FORGOT the other catergory: if isiah is gone do you want to keep the same players

Do you really think any fan wants this roster? I would be shocked if anyone on this board could name more than 5 players on the team they'd actually want to keep.

I still wish LB were here with a GM who knew what he was doing. WIth that type of tough-nose backdrop I would keep Lee, Nate, Jamal (sixthman), Balk, Chandler. Dang that's not a lot.

I would keep:

Lee - He can be a serviceable starter or a nice piece off the bench.
Jamal - I think he's coachable and you can use him as a 6th man when he's on. A Vinnie Johnson type.
Balkman - As an 8th or 9th man to come in for 10-15 a game and let him cause havoc. No basketball to speak of but still useful in spurts.
Chandler - Who the hell knows with him at this point? Can't really judge him.

That's it. How pathetic that after 4 years, spending hundreds of millions of dollars, trading away multiple lottery picks and all this roster turnover, you barely have 1 starter to show for it. It's mindboggling.

I bet even the former CBA owners are laughing at us, that Isiah managed to screw us over more than he did them.

I'd add Nate to that list, maybe drop chandler off, maybe expand the list to five... because, you're right, who knows with Chandler? As for Nate, I'm not a fan, but he seems to play hard when given the chance.

I voted choice 3. I want to I SAY UGH in a new role as Concrete Foreman.