Posted by fishmike:
so his shortcomings we can overlook because he's ok for an AVERAGE ROOKIE.
BUT
He's going to be an allstar.
Which is it? Is Channing an average rookie or an all star? All star bigs like Amare, Josh Howard, Elton Brand, etc were good rebounders as rookies. Frye's below average rebounding is just a carry over from his below average rebounding for 4 years in college.
He trys hard but has no idea what to do when the ball goes up in the air.
I like Channing a lot. Glad we have him. Not my first choice but a good choice.
He's a gifted scorer. I mean he's really a superior set of offensive skills, but he's far from a complete player. Guys saying he's a good rebounder or defender are just taking happy pills.
Pass me some.
Okay, fishmike, I guess you are looking for some action, so you are intentionally ignoring what I actually wrote, and making it into something else.
That's cool.
Let me restate the title: "Channing Frye threatens to make all-star team..." The operative word is THREATEN. Which means he does really well, gets consideration, but probably falls short.
Sorry if you think that is not possible, I do. But you should just come right out and say it so we can have an intelligent discussion rather than a sarcasm war.
I think it is unlikely that Sweetney will average 18/12 and 3 blks this season though. (

) How about you?
Channing Frye was ABOVE THE AVERAGE ROOKIE AT EVERYTHING! Including rebounding and defense.
Compared to the league at large I would say he is an average rebounder and defensive player. BUT THAT IS PRETTY DAMN GOOOD FOR A ROOKIE.
The thing is Fish, rookies improve. Starting out average is not bad. It's good. And average for the league is better than the average rookie. I wish he was a perfect player too, but he isn't.
However he showed much promise, including as a defensive player (Nice shot-blocking), and as a rebounder. As pointed out in another thread, Frye rebounds at the same rate as Dirk and Bosh, who are not great rebounders, but they are good rebounders. And he did that asa rookie who was jerked around.
Some things are good fish. Some things are good.
oohah