[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

If you could start your team off with one of these players who would you start with in their prime?
Forum Index  ›  NY Knicks Forum


Author Poll
BRIGGS
Posts: 33275
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
A Carmelo Anthony
B John Stockton
C Vince Carter
D Kevin McHale
2 votes
9.52%
Carmelo Anthony
12 votes
57.14%
John Stockton
1 votes
4.76%
Vince Carter
6 votes
28.57%
Kevin Mchale


Page 1 of 2  1  2 Next ›
« Reply To Topic
Author Thread
BRIGGS
Posts: 53275
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
5/6/2015  11:47 PM
I have Stockton slightly in front of Mchale with Carmelo third and Vince 4th.
RIP Crushalot😞
AUTOADVERT
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/6/2015  11:50 PM
anthony, vince - no defense just scoring/losers
stockton - i only saw the end of his career and he wasnt too impressive/but i appreciate a passer who makes their teams better
mchale = im only picking kevin cuz i wasnt around to know his ups and downs/i only know that he won 3 rings/barkley calls him the best big man hes ever played

slight edge of McHale over stockton simply due to the myth

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
NardDogNation
Posts: 27405
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 5/7/2013
Member: #5555
5/6/2015  11:51 PM
Depends on the era and venue but I'd go with Stockton. This is a PG dominated era and the fact is that he had the kind of character and leadership abilities to hone his craft in spite of the distractions that New York has to offer.

Meanwhile Vince Carter had no leadership abilities to speak of and was a well known flake, which I don't think would've bode well in this environment. Carmelo means well but is more of a Sonny Corlene than a Michael and his style of play doesn't exactly entice others to want to play with him. McHale was a hell of a player but I think Stockton's personality made him more of a preferable candidate; anyone would want to play with a John Stockton, especially since he was an iron-man that never missed games and could always be counted on.
franco12
Posts: 34069
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 2/19/2004
Member: #599
USA
5/6/2015  11:53 PM
BRIGGS wrote:I have Stockton slightly in front of Mchale with Carmelo third and Vince 4th.

I got to rank them?

Stockton, McHale and then honestly, I might go Vince over Carmelo, simply because Vince is still playing, and not sure Carmelo will have that kind of longevity.
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/6/2015  11:53 PM
i just remember a slow slow stockton getting schooled by payton. but yes ideally a passer to distribute is ideal. but i appreciate hall of fame WINNERS like kevin
Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
BRIGGS
Posts: 53275
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
5/6/2015  11:53 PM
callmened wrote:anthony, vince - no defense just scoring/losers
stockton - i only saw the end of his career and he wasnt too impressive/but i appreciate a passer who makes their teams better
mchale = im only picking kevin cuz i wasnt around to know his ups and downs/i only know that he won 3 rings/barkley calls him the best big man hes ever played

slight edge of McHale over stockton simply due to the myth

wow no myth--Kevin Mchale was great--he mightve been better on a different team--he couldve easily averaged 25-30 points elsewhere. When people say great footwork in the post--they are not talking about Tim Duncan--they are talking to the master Kevin Mchale. The only guy who was better than Mchale in the post was Hakeem.

RIP Crushalot😞
BRIGGS
Posts: 53275
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
5/6/2015  11:55 PM
callmened wrote:i just remember a slow slow stockton getting schooled by payton. but yes ideally a passer to distribute is ideal. but i appreciate hall of fame WINNERS like kevin

-->slow slow stockton???? Stockton was one of the quickest players in NBA history maybe you were thinking of Dwayne Poolee.

RIP Crushalot😞
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/6/2015  11:57 PM
BRIGGS wrote:
callmened wrote:i just remember a slow slow stockton getting schooled by payton. but yes ideally a passer to distribute is ideal. but i appreciate hall of fame WINNERS like kevin

-->slow slow stockton???? Stockton was one of the quickest players in NBA history maybe you were thinking of Dwayne Poolee.

hahahahah...no i remember watching a 40 yr old PG..at that point he was slow...im sure in his prime he was quick

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
BRIGGS
Posts: 53275
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
5/6/2015  11:59 PM
callmened wrote:
BRIGGS wrote:
callmened wrote:i just remember a slow slow stockton getting schooled by payton. but yes ideally a passer to distribute is ideal. but i appreciate hall of fame WINNERS like kevin

-->slow slow stockton???? Stockton was one of the quickest players in NBA history maybe you were thinking of Dwayne Poolee.

hahahahah...no i remember watching a 40 yr old PG..at that point he was slow...im sure in his prime he was quick

John Stockton is probably quicker now than many guards.

RIP Crushalot😞
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/6/2015  11:59 PM
BRIGGS wrote:
callmened wrote:anthony, vince - no defense just scoring/losers
stockton - i only saw the end of his career and he wasnt too impressive/but i appreciate a passer who makes their teams better
mchale = im only picking kevin cuz i wasnt around to know his ups and downs/i only know that he won 3 rings/barkley calls him the best big man hes ever played

slight edge of McHale over stockton simply due to the myth

wow no myth--Kevin Mchale was great--he mightve been better on a different team--he couldve easily averaged 25-30 points elsewhere. When people say great footwork in the post--they are not talking about Tim Duncan--they are talking to the master Kevin Mchale. The only guy who was better than Mchale in the post was Hakeem.

by myth i meant mystique..ive seen old footage of mchale and he was AMAZING. im was just saying that even though stockton or any hall of fame pg would be ideal for starting a team, id pick mchale cuz of his mythological pedigree (aka he was a LEGEND)

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/6/2015  11:59 PM
BRIGGS wrote:
callmened wrote:i just remember a slow slow stockton getting schooled by payton. but yes ideally a passer to distribute is ideal. but i appreciate hall of fame WINNERS like kevin

-->slow slow stockton???? Stockton was one of the quickest players in NBA history maybe you were thinking of Dwayne Poolee.

"maybe you were thinking of Dwayne Poolee." dig noted...u really hate when people disagree with you huh

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/7/2015  12:04 AM
to put vince and meo in the same conversations mchale and stockton is insulting to them..thats a joke

to me i never saw stockton or mchale in their prime (the only thing i remember was a washed up old 40yr old stockton). so to me, im picking based on reputation, accomplishments and old tv footage ive seen. my logic says you always start a team with a hall of fame PG. but then i also respect and value players that have WON. so i give a slight edge to Mchale

i hope thats ok with you BRIGGS

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/7/2015  12:04 AM
to put vince and meo in the same conversations mchale and stockton is insulting to them..thats a joke

to me i never saw stockton or mchale in their prime (the only thing i remember was a washed up old 40yr old stockton). so to me, im picking based on reputation, accomplishments and old tv footage ive seen. my logic says you always start a team with a hall of fame PG. but then i also respect and value players that have WON. so i give a slight edge to Mchale

i hope thats ok with you BRIGGS

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
BRIGGS
Posts: 53275
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
5/7/2015  12:11 AM    LAST EDITED: 5/7/2015  12:11 AM
callmened wrote:to put vince and meo in the same conversations mchale and stockton is insulting to them..thats a joke

to me i never saw stockton or mchale in their prime (the only thing i remember was a washed up old 40yr old stockton). so to me, im picking based on reputation, accomplishments and old tv footage ive seen. my logic says you always start a team with a hall of fame PG. but then i also respect and value players that have WON. so i give a slight edge to Mchale

i hope thats ok with you BRIGGS

I wouldnt say that that at all--come on carmelo and vince are multi all stars. Id say they are not top 50 all timers. the thing about stockton that some people dont remember but he was almost unstoppable going to where he wanted to go--how tough he was and how much of gamer he was---and easily a top 50 defender.

RIP Crushalot😞
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234
5/7/2015  12:19 AM
i think so much has value has been placed on one dimensional players who can score. great for sportscenter highlights but im never impressed. melo and vince fit that category. talented all stars who havent won much. theyll both make the hall of fame but i dont value their overall games. but no way in hell id start a franchise around them (even though denver did and became a playoff team once melo arrived)

in regards to stockton: i remember his short shorts and i think i have his basketball cards. i always wondered who benefitted more: mailman or stockton?kinda like amare or nash? was mailman great cuz stockton set him up? or did stockton pile up assists cuz of malone? i dont know.its probably 50-50. i wasnt old enough to observe critically

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
Swishfm3
Posts: 23312
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/28/2003
Member: #392
5/7/2015  12:21 AM
J.Stockton made players like Shandon Anderson, D. Benoit and B.Russell look good. That should tell you something right there.
mreinman
Posts: 37827
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/14/2010
Member: #3189
5/7/2015  9:59 AM
Stockton by a mile.

How did Melo and Vince get on this list?

so here is what phil is thinking ....
jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
5/7/2015  10:15 AM
Interesting.

McHale plays almost his entire career with Bird, and also gets to be a "legend". I saw him play regularly. Nothing incredible.
Stockton played his entire career with Malone. Tough, dirty, gritty guard. If he's not playing with an all time great PF, what separates him from Scott
Skiles?

Nice list, BRIGGS. What exactly was the agenda here?
Bonn1997
Posts: 58654
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 2/2/2004
Member: #581
USA
5/7/2015  10:24 AM
mreinman wrote:Stockton by a mile.

How did Melo and Vince get on this list?


because we have Melo and there needed to be at least one person who wasn't vastly better than him?
gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA
5/7/2015  10:38 AM
Mchale. Melo last
Page 1 of 2  1  2 Next ›
« Reply To Topic
If you could start your team off with one of these players who would you start with in their prime?
Forum Index  ›  NY Knicks Forum

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy