Author | Thread |
AUTOADVERT |
Uptown
Posts: 30878 Alba Posts: 3 Joined: 4/1/2008 Member: #1883 |
12/3/2018 7:12 PM
BigDaddyG wrote:fishmike wrote:BigDaddyG wrote:why? I mean why specifically that?fishmike wrote:CrushAlot wrote:totally agree. This is about the team, about the Knicks.meloshouldgo wrote:If you click on the tweet you can link to the article. I watch the games. I am amazed at the criticism of the coach and the attacking of guys not named Frank in the game thread. I don't participate as much because I would rather watch and root for the team. It has to suck to hate guys on the team you root for because you think they are taking your favorite players job. It the only guy on the roster that might have a complaint about effort/performance translating to minutes has been Dotson. I think Fiz has done a really good job so far. I think the front office and the coach are invested in Frank and Mudiay being successful.CrushAlot wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:The Knicks have played 21 games not 25. Frank has started 9 games at the point. That is more than any other young lottery point guard on the team.newyorknewyork wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:knicks1248 wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:Mudiay has 14 combined assists and 7 TOs over the last 5 games where he supposedly "broke out" as PG. He also has a net +/- of -9 over the same period. Why would you assume an coach who has been coaching in the NBA for over a decade, would just throw line ups to together on a whim?! Perhaps, Mario has been playing well in practice, outplaying the other SF's and earned the right to start. Same with Mudiay out playing the other pg's and Kanter outplaying the foul prone Robinson. As far as the different line ups are concerned, I speculated in another thread that perhaps we are in the evaluation stage of the rebuild. We have a bunch of guys who contracts expire at the end of the season (Mudiay, Vonleh, Mario, Burke, etc) and its important to figure out who is a part of the long term plans and who aint....I believe there is a method to the madness...Rebuilds aint pretty but I think it will all make sense next year.... |
PresIke
Posts: 27640 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 7/26/2001 Member: #33 USA |
12/3/2018 8:00 PM LAST EDITED: 12/3/2018 8:04 PM
Meanwhile some of our esteemed fans have thing like this to say:
Tweet was deleted or there was problem with the URL: Dumb? lol Love the genius of some of our fans. And Knicks Film School folks consider this dude a smart one worth following/listening to? (I heard that on the last podcast). Right, so Fiz should just play Frank no matter what he does and Mudiay always on the bench. Is Fiz a coach or a jukebox for fans who see "development" as one where the coach exclusively plays all young players with more than 1 year on their contract or who we already expect to keep? How is he supposed to hold players accountable if he can't bench them when they don't perform well? If not, that's beyond ridiculous and no sane manager in any job would accept that as normal. Having players you have to compete with for playing time can be a good thing for development rather than just an easy path where you can get complacent knowing you're always going to play. It's affecting some players who know they need to perform to get minutes/be in the rotation or start (Kanter) clearly, so the criticism of Fiz is very foolhardy if you ask me. I know...Mudiay has a 8m cap hold, but seems early to decide he can't play when he's done well. What kind of madness would it be to drop him for Frank right now? Plus I expect Frank to get back into the rotation as Fiz has shown a propensity to do this already after players get DNP's. Seems like we could include Mudiay in some kind of trade as well if he keeps it up as his value would increase from pretty much almost zilch a few months ago. Forum Po Po and #33 for a reason...
|
BigDaddyG
Posts: 37500 Alba Posts: 9 Joined: 1/22/2010 Member: #3049 |
12/3/2018 10:29 PM
Uptown wrote:BigDaddyG wrote:fishmike wrote:BigDaddyG wrote:why? I mean why specifically that?fishmike wrote:CrushAlot wrote:totally agree. This is about the team, about the Knicks.meloshouldgo wrote:If you click on the tweet you can link to the article. I watch the games. I am amazed at the criticism of the coach and the attacking of guys not named Frank in the game thread. I don't participate as much because I would rather watch and root for the team. It has to suck to hate guys on the team you root for because you think they are taking your favorite players job. It the only guy on the roster that might have a complaint about effort/performance translating to minutes has been Dotson. I think Fiz has done a really good job so far. I think the front office and the coach are invested in Frank and Mudiay being successful.CrushAlot wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:The Knicks have played 21 games not 25. Frank has started 9 games at the point. That is more than any other young lottery point guard on the team.newyorknewyork wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:knicks1248 wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:Mudiay has 14 combined assists and 7 TOs over the last 5 games where he supposedly "broke out" as PG. He also has a net +/- of -9 over the same period. We have a guy who's been a headcoach for over a decade? Fiz is nearly a rookie as far as headcoaches go. That's why I'm not calling for his head, yet. You gotta take the good with the bad. Maybe Mario has been killing it in practice? But I doubt it. Even if he has, he did not do it enough times on the court to take time away from Dot. Even now, with Dot coming off the bench, it's clear who the more impactful player is. It's odd. The Kanter /Robinson thing is also weird. Of course Kanter would be more NBA ready than Mitch. Heck, I thought Mitch would start off in the G-League. Wasn't the point of starting Mitchell to get our future center more reps and minutes. No one should be surprised Robinson struggled with fouls. If you're gonna take him out of the starting lineup, I gotta ask, what was the point of starting him in the first place. If we're evaluating, there's no need to waste time on Kanter, Burke, Thomas in the first place. It makes sense if we're competing for the 8th spot of the playoffs. I don't what direction we're going. If we're going full player development, then cool. If we're going for the 8th playoff spot that's cool. We suck too much from stopping this tank from moving forward. Just pick one. Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right.
- The Tick
|
Welpee
Posts: 23162 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 1/22/2016 Member: #6239 |
12/4/2018 9:32 AM
BigDaddyG wrote:I think all of this is mental. I think Fiz thought Mario (who sees himself as a starter) would produce better in that role and Dot would be good either way (starting or coming off the bench). It just hasn't worked. So maybe Fiz thinks if he returns Mario to the bench he loses him entirely. I don't know. Sometimes starters aren't based on the five best but the scenario to maximize everybody. So far it's not yielding any meaningful results so I agree that maybe it's time to hitch our wagon to Dot.Uptown wrote:BigDaddyG wrote:fishmike wrote:BigDaddyG wrote:why? I mean why specifically that?fishmike wrote:CrushAlot wrote:totally agree. This is about the team, about the Knicks.meloshouldgo wrote:If you click on the tweet you can link to the article. I watch the games. I am amazed at the criticism of the coach and the attacking of guys not named Frank in the game thread. I don't participate as much because I would rather watch and root for the team. It has to suck to hate guys on the team you root for because you think they are taking your favorite players job. It the only guy on the roster that might have a complaint about effort/performance translating to minutes has been Dotson. I think Fiz has done a really good job so far. I think the front office and the coach are invested in Frank and Mudiay being successful.CrushAlot wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:The Knicks have played 21 games not 25. Frank has started 9 games at the point. That is more than any other young lottery point guard on the team.newyorknewyork wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:knicks1248 wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:Mudiay has 14 combined assists and 7 TOs over the last 5 games where he supposedly "broke out" as PG. He also has a net +/- of -9 over the same period. |
Chandler
Posts: 25988 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 11/26/2015 Member: #6197 |
12/4/2018 10:05 AM
PresIke wrote:Meanwhile some of our esteemed fans have thing like this to say:Tweet was deleted or there was problem with the URL: I read the tweets differently. KFS is saying that Mudiay should start (Mudiay over Frank). I'm a Frank fan too, and I can agree with that as well. Mud is playing better than Frank right now; There's something off with Frank Of course the huge irony is that all we keep hearing is that Fizzdale got Mudiay's confidence up by playing him. If I were to speculate on Frank, I'd say it's a confidence thing too. (His shot mechanics are far superior to Mudiay's -- no hitch, stays on his feet etc). Yet Fizzdale's approach to Frank is glue him to the bench. That to me is at least highly puzzling -- specially since Frank can contribute on defense more than any other guard on the team
(5)(5)
|
Chandler
Posts: 25988 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 11/26/2015 Member: #6197 |
12/4/2018 10:17 AM
Uptown wrote:BigDaddyG wrote:fishmike wrote:BigDaddyG wrote:why? I mean why specifically that?fishmike wrote:CrushAlot wrote:totally agree. This is about the team, about the Knicks.meloshouldgo wrote:If you click on the tweet you can link to the article. I watch the games. I am amazed at the criticism of the coach and the attacking of guys not named Frank in the game thread. I don't participate as much because I would rather watch and root for the team. It has to suck to hate guys on the team you root for because you think they are taking your favorite players job. It the only guy on the roster that might have a complaint about effort/performance translating to minutes has been Dotson. I think Fiz has done a really good job so far. I think the front office and the coach are invested in Frank and Mudiay being successful.CrushAlot wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:The Knicks have played 21 games not 25. Frank has started 9 games at the point. That is more than any other young lottery point guard on the team.newyorknewyork wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:knicks1248 wrote:meloshouldgo wrote:Mudiay has 14 combined assists and 7 TOs over the last 5 games where he supposedly "broke out" as PG. He also has a net +/- of -9 over the same period. As an assistant coach for a decade. As a head coach he was a little over .500 one year, and in his second year alienated his best player, and the GM said he couldn't close games. We can agree there's madness, but disagree if there's a method to it. Perhaps some deep regression analysis on statistics proves Hezonja should start and Frank shouldn't be guarding Beal or Wall (5)(5)
|
Marv
Posts: 35540 Alba Posts: 69 Joined: 9/2/2002 Member: #315 |
12/4/2018 9:43 PM
frank is urkel right now. he’s not ready for 2nd base.
i don’t think he’s feelin’ fiz either. |