[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

NOAH Lands at #1
Author Thread
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
8/3/2018  10:31 AM    LAST EDITED: 8/3/2018  10:32 AM
Thanks Phil...the worst contract currently in the NBA.

So i just wanted to know, who on this list would you trade NOAH for if they don't stretch him. I mean they are all obviously bad, but considering NOAH is sitting on a BEACH not earning a cent of his $$$..

Noah avg 16.6 miss games per yr since he join the league...the scary and disappointment part is KP is right on pace for that #.. Then i also think about MCdyess after the acl, and that dude was an athletic beast.

When a player signs a contract with an NBA team, their salary is almost always guaranteed for the life of the deal - whether they exceed or fall well short of expectations.

In the latter case, certain bloated contracts end up handcuffing the teams that signed them for years to come.

With that in mind, here are the 20 worst contracts in the NBA today, with regards to the remaining terms of the deal. Consideration was given to the age of the player, their current abilities, their injury history, and of course, the length and dollar amount of their deal. Contracts that expire next summer were generally not included, as even the worst among them have some value in the form of soon-to-be available cap space - which some teams will inevitably use to sign yet another bad deal.

20. Pau Gasol, Spurs
AGE YEAR SALARY
38 2018-19 $16M
39 2019-20 $16M*
* Partially guaranteed for $6.7M

Unless Gasol submits an all-time great season for a 38-year-old in 2018-19, the Spurs will likely cut bait before the following campaign, effectively making this deal a one-year, $22.7-million contract - slightly more palatable overall.

19. Gorgui Dieng, Timberwolves
AGE YEAR SALARY
28 2018-19 $15.2M
29 2019-20 $16.2M
30 2020-21 $17.2M
Before signing this deal, Dieng performed like an above-average two-way power forward - and got paid like one. However, the Timberwolves also decided to make 32-year-old Taj Gibson the starter with a two-year, $28-million contract, relegating Dieng to the status of overpaid backup power forward.

18. John Wall, Wizards

AGE YEAR SALARY
28 2018-19 $19.2M
29 2019-20 $37.8M
30 2020-21 $40.8M
31 2021-22 $43.8M
32 2022-23 $46.9M*
* Player option

Of everyone on this list, Wall stands out as the best player in terms of present-day ability, but there are reasons to be concerned if you're a Wizards fan:

He missed half of last season due to injury
Much of his game is predicated on speed, a trait that hasn't aged well historically
He's shot 34 percent on threes over the past five years in a league that practically demands elite shooting from backcourt stalwarts
His contract is set to skyrocket after 2018-19
Of course, the Wizards' hands were tied when they signed Wall to this deal, as losing him would've signaled a return to the draft lottery. On the other hand, an annual salary above $40 million could make sense for a handful of players who can keep any team in contention, but there's little indication Wall is capable of that on his own.

17. Hassan Whiteside, Heat
AGE YEAR SALARY
29 2018-19 $25.4M
30 2019-20 $27.1M*
* Player option

Whiteside's player option means that if he underperforms this coming season, the Heat will be locked into a massive financial commitment to the cantankerous big man. But if Whiteside lives up to his star-level contract, there's a possibility he declines his option and aims for a lucrative long-term deal instead. Neither situation is great for the Heat.

16. Tyler Johnson, Heat
AGE YEAR SALARY
25 2018-19 $19.2M
26 2019-20 $19.2M
After paying Johnson just $5.7 million on average over the first half of this contract, that average salary will nearly quadruple in Year 3 - a product of a "poison pill" that the Brooklyn Nets put into an offer sheet for Johnson when he was a restricted free agent.

15. Serge Ibaka, Raptors

AGE YEAR SALARY
29 2018-19 $21.7M
30 2019-20 $23.3M
The Raptors took a calculated risk when this deal was signed before last season - specifically, overpaying Ibaka on an annual basis, but being able to get out from under the deal in just three years. Regardless, it's still a bad contract for a player who's regressed significantly from the shot-blocking defender he once was.

14. Andrew Wiggins, Timberwolves
AGE YEAR SALARY
23 2018-19 $25.3M
24 2019-20 $27.3M
25 2020-21 $29.3M
26 2021-22 $31.3M
27 2022-23 $33.4M
Wiggins has averaged 19.7 points, 4.1 rebounds, and 2.1 assists through four seasons, but hasn't lived up to his pre-draft billing as an elite two-way player. Tying the next half-decade to a player whose game seems to have plateaued could prove costly for Minnesota, especially because having both Karl-Anthony Towns and Jimmy Butler in the fold should give the team a window of contention right now.

13. James Johnson, Heat
AGE YEAR SALARY
31 2018-19 $14.7M
32 2019-20 $15.3M
33 2020-21 $16M*
* Player option

Like they did with so many players who were instrumental to their 30-11 finish to the 2016-17 season, the Heat rewarded Johnson's career year with a big deal last summer. The $16-million player option for the final season only adds further uncertainty to Miami's outlook, as the team's books are crammed with multi-year, eight-digit contracts.

12. Bismack Biyombo, Hornets

AGE YEAR SALARY
26 2018-19 $17M
27 2019-20 $17M*
* Player option

Biyombo's whopping four-year, $68-million contract is only half over, while the team that signed it (Orlando) has already cut bait. And unless he miraculously extends his shooting range beyond the length of his arm, it's almost certain the defensive center will exercise his 2019-20 player option.

11. Tristan Thompson, Cavaliers
AGE YEAR SALARY
27 2018-19 $17.5M
28 2019-20 $18.5M
Thompson played a pivotal role in the Cavaliers' run to their first NBA title in 2016. Years 4 and 5 of his original $82-million contract are steep, but it's still a relatively small price to pay as collateral for the strongest period in team history.

10. Brandon Knight, Suns
AGE YEAR SALARY
26 2018-19 $14.6M
27 2019-20 $15.6M
Still just 26, Knight has some work to do after missing all of last season due to an ACL tear. At his best, he might be able to provide the bench-scoring spark of a prototypical sixth man.

Of course, the Suns can't feel great about Knight's contract after watching two-time Sixth Man of the Year Lou Williams sign a three-year extension with the Clippers for just $24 million total - with only $1.5 million partially guaranteed for the final year.

9. Timofey Mozgov, Magic
AGE YEAR SALARY
32 2018-19 $16M
33 2019-20 $16.7M
Having been traded from the Lakers to the Nets to the Hornets to the Magic since last June, Mozgov is living proof that no contract - no matter how onerous - is truly untradeable.

8. Blake Griffin, Pistons

AGE YEAR SALARY
29 2018-19 $32.1M
30 2019-20 $34.5M
31 2020-21 $36.8M
32 2021-22 $39M*
* Player option

Griffin comes with the same concerns as Wall. The Pistons forward is past his car-hopping, above-the-rim athletic prime, and has missed 107 regular-season games over the past four years.

You can justify Detroit's investment given the franchise's struggles to lure stars, but the final years of Griffin's deal could prove catastrophic if his health or on-court production continues to slip. He even has a $39-million player option for his age-32 season.

7. Evan Turner, Trail Blazers
AGE YEAR SALARY
29 2018-19 $17.9M
30 2019-20 $18.6M
The Trail Blazers' chances of winning a title while playing in the same conference as the Golden State Warriors have always been slim, but a four-year, $70-million contract for Turner has not helped their cause.

6. Ryan Anderson, Rockets

AGE YEAR SALARY
30 2018-19 $20.4M
31 2019-20 $21.3M
It should be noted that Anderson averaged 26.1 minutes per game across 66 appearances for a Rockets team that led the league with 65 wins last season. That said, floor-spacing big men (who struggle defensively) aren't as difficult to find as they used to be. For example, Anthony Tolliver, who shot 43.6 percent on 4.6 attempts per game from deep in 2017-18, just signed a one-year, $5.7-million contract with Minnesota.

5. Ian Mahinmi, Wizards
AGE YEAR SALARY
31 2018-19 $15.9M
32 2019-20 $15.5M
Mahinmi has averaged five points and 4.3 rebounds in 15.7 minutes per game since joining the Wizards two seasons ago. His remaining contract is bad on its own, but since Washington is currently $12.6 million over the luxury-tax threshold for 2018-19, it's also a huge reason why the team is set to pay a $22.9-million tax bill.

4. Danilo Gallinari, Clippers
AGE YEAR SALARY
30 2018-19 $21.6M
31 2019-20 $22.6M
Gallinari has already lost 322 regular-season games to injury in his career, and hasn't suited up at least 70 times in a season since 2012-13. The Clippers will have to ride out the final two years of his deal with minimal expectations that he'll ever be able to stay healthy.

3. Chandler Parsons, Grizzlies

AGE YEAR SALARY
29 2018-19 $24.1M
30 2019-20 $25.1M
Though lingering injuries were a concern during Parsons' time with the Rockets and Mavericks, the Grizzlies were willing to back up the Brinks truck in an attempt to maximize the waning primes of Marc Gasol and Mike Conley. However, Parsons has played only 70 games - and just 19.5 minutes per night when he's taken the court - through the first half of his lucrative deal. His body just can't take the pounding of a full season

2. Luol Deng, Lakers
AGE YEAR SALARY
33 2018-19 $18M
34 2019-20 $18.8M
We're going to assume that you - yes, you - did not play in the NBA last season. That means you played just 13 fewer minutes than Deng, who's now more likely to appear on the side of a milk cartoon under the headline "Missing" than in a Lakers uniform.

Leading the league in minutes per game in 2011-12 and 2012-13 with the Bulls - a product of Tom Thibodeau's ludicrously short rotations - seems to have finally caught up to Deng.

Speaking of Thibs ...

1. Joakim Noah, Knicks

AGE YEAR SALARY
33 2018-19 $18.5M
34 2019-20 $19.3M
What were the Knicks thinking? There were red flags everywhere.

Prior to New York signing Noah to four-year, $72-million contract, the former Defensive Player of the Year had missed an average of 16.6 games per season during a nine-year run with Chicago. In his final year with the Bulls as a 30-year-old, Noah was held to 21.9 minutes per game while making just 29 regular-season appearances. Regardless, the Knicks offered him a contract in line with his prior performance - and now they're stuck paying for his present and future.

ES
AUTOADVERT
Nalod
Posts: 68632
Alba Posts: 154
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
8/3/2018  11:40 AM    LAST EDITED: 8/3/2018  11:41 AM
Good article.
Bad write up 1248. Its like your a chicken and every day is new. Regurgitation the same thing over and over.
If not bad enough, you extrapolate all the bad of the past and assume it to be forward.
Then when being called a buzzkill kind of guy you think we are all just ignoring the past.
All teams have bad deals and bad stories. Not just knicks. The really successful ones avoided them.
The thing you must ask yourself is what are we doing different that might not have those conclusions?
Obviously KP situation has you worried. Its valid. At the same time your over doing it too.
back in the day knicks had a few in that top 20 bad list. Its also subjective. Noah still might have talent. SOme never did or like Deng have been cooked for a few years.
I have one thing to say: "Biyombo".
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
8/3/2018  12:05 PM
Two recently signed Super Max deals on that list. I thought Mike Conley and Allen Crabbe would be on the list. At least there is only one Knick contract on there. Getting away from the Amare/Bargs/Tyson type contracts is definitely a positive.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
8/3/2018  12:19 PM
There will always be a bad contract on your roster, because players get paid based on pass and future performances, the key is to do your homework, and phil didn't when it came to Noah. It's no wonder mills and perry can't find a deal look at this list. The only concern I have with KP is his health, and i think that's a very legitimate concern for everybody.


To me, the way to go is 2 to 3 yr deals regardless to who you are, You can't go wrong.

ES
Nalod
Posts: 68632
Alba Posts: 154
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
8/3/2018  1:19 PM
knicks1248 wrote:There will always be a bad contract on your roster, because players get paid based on pass and future performances, the key is to do your homework, and phil didn't when it came to Noah. It's no wonder mills and perry can't find a deal look at this list. The only concern I have with KP is his health, and i think that's a very legitimate concern for everybody.


To me, the way to go is 2 to 3 yr deals regardless to who you are, You can't go wrong.

Paid on past and future performance. That's the kind of higher level of thinking that is missing from most of us.
Go pay top talent 2-3 year deals and watch them walk or hang up the phone. Another open concept by our resident hindsight GM!
Only concern anyone has with KP is his health. I wonder why? Anemic?, height?, that knee thing? Your very astute.
Im mocking what you think is insight is rather obvious to even the most oblivious knick fans!

GustavBahler
Posts: 41138
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

8/3/2018  9:25 PM
The sad thing is that Phil was more or less on the same course as Perry, until Rose/Noah. Phil got playoff fever.
doomed
Posts: 20222
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/13/2006
Member: #1078
USA
8/3/2018  10:50 PM
Why are you insisting on trading assets away just to rid the Knicks of two years of some dead money? Who cares now? So it’s a bad contract... get over it already. If the Knicks have a shot next summer to get two max players in here cross that bridge when it comes. Why trade anything away right now? Relax. Enjoy the rebuild this year with literally nothing to lose and worry about cap room when it’s actually needed.

Knicks will basically have room for at least one max next summer and more room the year after. That’s worst case. It could be a whole lot worse. We’re fine right now.

arkrud
Posts: 32217
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 8/31/2005
Member: #995
USA
8/3/2018  11:35 PM
GustavBahler wrote:The sad thing is that Phil was more or less on the same course as Perry, until Rose/Noah. Phil got playoff fever.

Melo needed some sudo-supper-friends to stay in NY on top of NTC and max.
Not sure why Phil believed that Melo is second coming of the GOAT.
In reality Melo was just the goat eating somebody else cabbage.
Phil created the most funny caricature on Supper-teams.
Was not funny for NY fans.

"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." Hamlet
TLover
Posts: 21038
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 2/12/2003
Member: #381
USA
8/4/2018  8:47 AM
Gorgui Deing for Noah could work bc Deing has one more year than Noah. At least Deing can shoot the ball and play in a Fizdale system. Noah goes back to his old coach that drove him into the ground.
Bc we are taking on the extra year on Deing’s contract, would like an asset back like Tyus Jones or a draft pick.
Jmpasq
Posts: 25242
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 4/10/2012
Member: #4182

8/4/2018  9:31 AM
In the current NBA? Pshhh That's nothing. Is Noah the worst contract in NY Knicks history? Now that is the true measure of ineptitude.
Check out My NFL Draft Prospect Videos at Youtube User Pages Jmpasq,JPdraftjedi,Jmpasqdraftjedi. www.Draftbreakdown.com
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27186
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

8/4/2018  1:47 PM
arkrud wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:The sad thing is that Phil was more or less on the same course as Perry, until Rose/Noah. Phil got playoff fever.

Melo needed some sudo-supper-friends to stay in NY on top of NTC and max.
Not sure why Phil believed that Melo is second coming of the GOAT.
In reality Melo was just the goat eating somebody else cabbage.
Phil created the most funny caricature on Supper-teams.
Was not funny for NY fans.

Yep. Melo made Phil give him a max and sign Rose and the cripple.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27186
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

8/4/2018  1:51 PM    LAST EDITED: 8/4/2018  1:58 PM
TripleThreat wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:There will always be a bad contract on your roster, because players get paid based on pass and future performances, the key is to do your homework, and phil didn't when it came to Noah. It's no wonder mills and perry can't find a deal look at this list. The only concern I have with KP is his health, and i think that's a very legitimate concern for everybody.


To me, the way to go is 2 to 3 yr deals regardless to who you are, You can't go wrong.


This is incorrect on every level of basic resource management.

Noah versus Robin Lopez

Lopez's contract

- Was a value to the current marketplace at the time and had present and future value
- He had positional value
- His age and health profile meant the contract would not encompass his standard decline phase
- He had no off the court issues
- He had no lockerroom issues with his previous teams
- He was not elite in any area, but no deficient in any single area
- He was very durable
- For what he could do, he was very consistent
- He did not have an extensive injury history
- He had no PEDS issue

Everything about Lopez above doesn't apply to Noah.

If Lopez busts up his knees and can't play, that's just bad luck. It was a good market decision that didn't work out.

Noah was just a bad decision period. He was a bad bet that predictably blew up in people's faces.

The goal is to make good market based decisions that have odds of working out for you. If they don't, that's the cost of doing business. That is far different from a bad contract.

Phil Jackson had no training or experience

- With the salary cap and CBA structure
- Dealing with agents
- Rapport with other non Knicks front office people
- Dealing with other owners
- Dealing with brands/endorsement companies, who heavily influence many of these players
- Scouting
- Analytics
- Lower level player development

"Homework" would have meant spending a decade learning to do the job and building the relationships needed to do the job.

People will say, but he did this and that with the Bulls and Lakers. Which is not true. The job of head coach is vastly different from running a front office.

You can't hire a baker from a bakery to fix the engine in your car.

This. From day ONE. Phil had no clue. Fisher, unloading most of the 54 win team for NO assets. Insisting on his beloved Triangle. Signing cripples. How anyone thought a 70 year old coach with no FO experience, running a system NO other team in NBA ran exclusively, and who the Lakers would not even higher in the FO, would be a good long term plan?

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27186
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

8/4/2018  2:06 PM
GustavBahler wrote:The sad thing is that Phil was more or less on the same course as Perry, until Rose/Noah. Phil got playoff fever.

Did Phil choose an experienced coach as his first hire? Did he sign former lottery picks on cheap one year contracts? Did he unload players with assets in return? Did he have an understanding of the current NBA? Did he have a true plan for a proper rebuild?

Fact is Phil did nothing. Last year was our first true year of rebuild. We could have probably done more with a monkey in the FO (Not Dolan). At least the monkey would have tanked the same way, not given any contracts to guys like Noah or maxed a guy that was not in a plan to rebuild.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27186
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

8/4/2018  2:25 PM    LAST EDITED: 8/4/2018  2:26 PM
NOT FOR LONG!

https://dailyknicks.com/2018/08/03/new-york-knicks-joakim-noah-adding-three-point-shot/

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
Nalod
Posts: 68632
Alba Posts: 154
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
8/4/2018  2:51 PM
Not defending the signing at all. ALl I said was he might still have talent. Health is another issue.
What I know is what was. What I hope is what can be.
I hope a healthy Noah for the knicks. Nothing too argue.
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
8/4/2018  2:58 PM    LAST EDITED: 8/4/2018  2:59 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
TripleThreat wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:There will always be a bad contract on your roster, because players get paid based on pass and future performances, the key is to do your homework, and phil didn't when it came to Noah. It's no wonder mills and perry can't find a deal look at this list. The only concern I have with KP is his health, and i think that's a very legitimate concern for everybody.


To me, the way to go is 2 to 3 yr deals regardless to who you are, You can't go wrong.


This is incorrect on every level of basic resource management.

Noah versus Robin Lopez

Lopez's contract

- Was a value to the current marketplace at the time and had present and future value
- He had positional value
- His age and health profile meant the contract would not encompass his standard decline phase
- He had no off the court issues
- He had no lockerroom issues with his previous teams
- He was not elite in any area, but no deficient in any single area
- He was very durable
- For what he could do, he was very consistent
- He did not have an extensive injury history
- He had no PEDS issue

Everything about Lopez above doesn't apply to Noah.

If Lopez busts up his knees and can't play, that's just bad luck. It was a good market decision that didn't work out.

Noah was just a bad decision period. He was a bad bet that predictably blew up in people's faces.

The goal is to make good market based decisions that have odds of working out for you. If they don't, that's the cost of doing business. That is far different from a bad contract.

Phil Jackson had no training or experience

- With the salary cap and CBA structure
- Dealing with agents
- Rapport with other non Knicks front office people
- Dealing with other owners
- Dealing with brands/endorsement companies, who heavily influence many of these players
- Scouting
- Analytics
- Lower level player development

"Homework" would have meant spending a decade learning to do the job and building the relationships needed to do the job.

People will say, but he did this and that with the Bulls and Lakers. Which is not true. The job of head coach is vastly different from running a front office.

You can't hire a baker from a bakery to fix the engine in your car.

This. From day ONE. Phil had no clue. Fisher, unloading most of the 54 win team for NO assets. Insisting on his beloved Triangle. Signing cripples. How anyone thought a 70 year old coach with no FO experience, running a system NO other team in NBA ran exclusively, and who the Lakers would not even higher in the FO, would be a good long term plan?


Is it safe to say that Mills was responsible for negotiating contracts, trades, and FA signings (as the GM working for a totally in experience President) and all phil did was sign off on them. We already confirm phil doesn't talk to agents.

The contracts of Noah, Baker, Lance and THJ seems like it was negotiated by the same person.

ES
Nalod
Posts: 68632
Alba Posts: 154
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
8/4/2018  3:04 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
TripleThreat wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:There will always be a bad contract on your roster, because players get paid based on pass and future performances, the key is to do your homework, and phil didn't when it came to Noah. It's no wonder mills and perry can't find a deal look at this list. The only concern I have with KP is his health, and i think that's a very legitimate concern for everybody.


To me, the way to go is 2 to 3 yr deals regardless to who you are, You can't go wrong.


This is incorrect on every level of basic resource management.

Noah versus Robin Lopez

Lopez's contract

- Was a value to the current marketplace at the time and had present and future value
- He had positional value
- His age and health profile meant the contract would not encompass his standard decline phase
- He had no off the court issues
- He had no lockerroom issues with his previous teams
- He was not elite in any area, but no deficient in any single area
- He was very durable
- For what he could do, he was very consistent
- He did not have an extensive injury history
- He had no PEDS issue

Everything about Lopez above doesn't apply to Noah.

If Lopez busts up his knees and can't play, that's just bad luck. It was a good market decision that didn't work out.

Noah was just a bad decision period. He was a bad bet that predictably blew up in people's faces.

The goal is to make good market based decisions that have odds of working out for you. If they don't, that's the cost of doing business. That is far different from a bad contract.

Phil Jackson had no training or experience

- With the salary cap and CBA structure
- Dealing with agents
- Rapport with other non Knicks front office people
- Dealing with other owners
- Dealing with brands/endorsement companies, who heavily influence many of these players
- Scouting
- Analytics
- Lower level player development

"Homework" would have meant spending a decade learning to do the job and building the relationships needed to do the job.

People will say, but he did this and that with the Bulls and Lakers. Which is not true. The job of head coach is vastly different from running a front office.

You can't hire a baker from a bakery to fix the engine in your car.

This. From day ONE. Phil had no clue. Fisher, unloading most of the 54 win team for NO assets. Insisting on his beloved Triangle. Signing cripples. How anyone thought a 70 year old coach with no FO experience, running a system NO other team in NBA ran exclusively, and who the Lakers would not even higher in the FO, would be a good long term plan?


Is it safe to say that Mills was responsible for negotiating contracts, trades, and FA signings (as the GM working for a totally in experience President) and all phil did was sign off on them. We already confirm phil doesn't talk to agents.

The contracts of Noah, Baker, Lance and THJ seems like it was negotiated by the same person.

Your making shyt up again. Phil had full control about all basketball decisions. YOu won’t to hate mills so much your laying everything you can on him.
since Phil is gone have you not noticed a Change? Apparently your blind to it.

GustavBahler
Posts: 41138
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

8/4/2018  4:13 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:The sad thing is that Phil was more or less on the same course as Perry, until Rose/Noah. Phil got playoff fever.

Did Phil choose an experienced coach as his first hire? Did he sign former lottery picks on cheap one year contracts? Did he unload players with assets in return? Did he have an understanding of the current NBA? Did he have a true plan for a proper rebuild?

Fact is Phil did nothing. Last year was our first true year of rebuild. We could have probably done more with a monkey in the FO (Not Dolan). At least the monkey would have tanked the same way, not given any contracts to guys like Noah or maxed a guy that was not in a plan to rebuild.

Lets not get all messianic here. Phil stayed away from quick fixes, was mostly looking to build with youth, not hand out big contracts outside of Melo (which I was against)

He was doing a gradual rebuild around KP, not Melo. Said repeatedly that they werent going for the quick fix. Went looking for young, cheap, talent, overseas, as well as here.

Phil watched GS/Cavs dominating the news, the playoffs, with him on the sidelines, and his negative comments about GS and LeBron.

Phil got playoff fever, and scrapped the plan. There was a rebuilding plan until Rose/Noah. Would it have been successful? With that system, doubt it, but he was on the right track as far as building gradually.

Hornacek might have worked out better if he had full autonomy from day one. He had similar success as Fizdale out of the gate, before he ran into some problems with players/mgmt.

arkrud
Posts: 32217
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 8/31/2005
Member: #995
USA
8/5/2018  7:56 AM
HofstraBBall wrote:
arkrud wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:The sad thing is that Phil was more or less on the same course as Perry, until Rose/Noah. Phil got playoff fever.

Melo needed some sudo-supper-friends to stay in NY on top of NTC and max.
Not sure why Phil believed that Melo is second coming of the GOAT.
In reality Melo was just the goat eating somebody else cabbage.
Phil created the most funny caricature on Supper-teams.
Was not funny for NY fans.

Yep. Melo made Phil give him a max and sign Rose and the cripple.

Yep - by fact of his existence on Knicks roster.
Melo was like expensive car with no use but to show of.
Phil decided that this car can also drive him places.
Delusional he was.

"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." Hamlet
Vmart
Posts: 31800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/23/2002
Member: #247
USA
8/5/2018  12:57 PM
Let’s be honest here the worst contract was Kawahi. Dude didn’t even want to play.
NOAH Lands at #1

©2001-2012 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy