I believe if you can trade a draft pick for 2 lottery picks and a starter, which is what the Knicks were getting for KP, then the future would be Ntlikina, Gomez, 2 lottery picks and a young starter on top of whatever you could get for a Melo trade.
I don't think Phil has done great, but our future is better today than it was 3 years ago. It's probably been the healthiest this franchise has been in a long time. Consistent drafting. Consistent application in getting talent from the draft.
Porzingis (valued at 2 lottery picks and a young starter right now)
Ntilikina (lottery pick but lets see his value in a year)
Hernangomez (valued in my opinion as a late lottery pick, top 15 draft pick)
All draft picks 2018 onward.
We've got some projects/development players like Ron Baker, Randle, Dotson, Kuzminskas. Some may make it for good, others may not. This process helped us make guys like Lance and Gallo as fringe NBA players who wound up being regular rotation NBA players who got multi-year multi million dollar contracts. That's similar to what the Spurs do, they bring no names, and develop them in their system and style of play and you all of a sudden see them become NBA players who get multi-year contracts. We basically have done that with a few players now such as Ron Baker, Langston Galloway, Lance Thomas.
We're struggling with attracting free agents. We're struggling with making good veteran moves. This has KILLED Phil. I thought he would be able to have enough connection in the league with the veteran players that he would be able to sign a star by now. He hasn't. However you look around the league not many teams are winning free agency. It's just the contenders clearing last minute or pre-planned capspace and adding stars to an already loaded team. The Knicks can't compete with that for a long time. Not until Kristaps' prime, Willy, Nti and whomever else we have in 2 years from now. Or if we trade KP because he doesn't want to get on page with the team, then the young core post-trade a few years from now. We're FAR from the situation Boston, Cleveland, Golden State or San Antonio are in. Those teams have a player like Kris in their primes, peaking and having MVP level year. While then still having more all-star level players next to them and free agency.
We are years away from that. And there was no way any other management plan with the Knicks was getting us that way. Melo, good vets and a playoff team with no young players gets us where? One year good 50 wins 2nd round. Next year lottery, 35 wins. The team wasn't going to be a powerhouse even if Phil just stuck with Woodson, Tyson and the same plan. We brought Phil in to change, to rebuild and to install a different way of thinking.
He hasn't done enough, but I'm glad we have a farm system now. We have a real patience within the organization to develop draft picks. To not give up on them. To keep supporting youth and to value the draft and capspace. I think in two years we will be in a strong spot IF Kristaps becomes the player he wants to be, OR if we make an outstanding KP trade. I hope we keep KP and he becomes the star he is working towards becoming. If he does, Ntilikina becomes a solid guard that is a lockdown defender, with Willy's great post skills, we have a real foundation there. Keep adding good draft picks and young players through farm system, In 2 years, you will be able to sign a veteran that is actually good.